Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this couple's attitude has no place in modern society?

618 replies

Georama · 20/01/2022 18:35

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10419543/Christian-couple-ban-gay-man-partner-buying-dream-650-000-sexuality.html

A church-going wife who banned a gay man and his ITV producer partner from buying her £650,000 Surrey home has hit back in the row and insisted they are just sticking to their beliefs.

Luke Whitehouse and Lachlan Mantell were stunned when they were told that they could not buy the three-bedroom home because the Christian owners didn't want to sell to 'two men in a partnership.'

Honestly, they should be ashamed of that text. I hope no estate agent will work with them ever again.

OP posts:
Innocenta · 21/01/2022 12:44

@BoredZelda

As a lesbian I have every right to call people homophobic when they say homophobic things.

At the moment you do (albeit your opinion can also be way off mark) You should be glad that people fought for your right to do that and be very wary of ever suggesting someone who has an opposing opinion isn't allowed to say that too. I remember in my lifetime your freedom of expression wasn't what it was today. Aren't you glad people fought for that to be ok?

This isn't a freedom of expression issue. But if you're so keen to focus on that, then by all means keep telling me that I'm unreasonable to say you're being homophobic (even though, actually, you are being...), and I shall assert my freedom to repeatedly tell you that attacking a lesbian for commenting on homophobia is in itself pretty disgusting.
BoredZelda · 21/01/2022 12:39

It annoys me when straight people try to tell gay people when they should and shouldn’t find something homophobic

It annoys me when people jump straight to a -phobia or -ism, when they have no idea who they are talking to.

BoredZelda · 21/01/2022 12:38

As a lesbian I have every right to call people homophobic when they say homophobic things.

At the moment you do (albeit your opinion can also be way off mark) You should be glad that people fought for your right to do that and be very wary of ever suggesting someone who has an opposing opinion isn't allowed to say that too. I remember in my lifetime your freedom of expression wasn't what it was today. Aren't you glad people fought for that to be ok?

Innocenta · 21/01/2022 12:36

I've thought about it plenty, thanks, @SantaClawsServiette - haven't changed my mind about all the bigotry being spewed in this thread. Your justification is no better than anyone else's.

Trainbear · 21/01/2022 12:35

Is the reason for the outrage the some fact that the declined buyers were gay, or that the sellers were not willing to sell to people whose situation was against their principles?

If you are a Remainder would you sell to a Brexiteer?
If you are a liberal and a potential buyer turned up in a Boris is best t-shirt would you decline their offer?

Isaw3ships · 21/01/2022 12:34

@Innocenta yup! To totally agree. It annoys me when straight people try to tell gay people when they should and shouldn’t find something homophobic.

Innocenta · 21/01/2022 12:33

@BoredZelda As a lesbian I have every right to call people homophobic when they say homophobic things.

Isaw3ships · 21/01/2022 12:29

‘ It's quite rude to call religion "fairy tales". Tolerance goes both ways’

Perhaps, but I’ve always loved a good bible story, they have some right ripping yarns. Floods, plagues, pillars of salt, men sacrificing their own children, raping their own children, cheating on their wives…
Still, the difference is, although my opinion is that it is all fiction and no man was ever thousands of years old and no-one ever spoke from a burning bush I wouldn’t come front a Christian and tell them that.
I respect their right to believe. And I wouldn’t ever tell them that their belief was wrong, as they are opposite to mine, and then refuse them any kind of service.

Isaw3ships · 21/01/2022 12:25

The homophobes got their chance to have their say in the Mail and have just gone with no regrets, we were right so IMHO have waived any right to sympathy.

StoatMilk · 21/01/2022 12:25

@Migrainesbythedozen

I think this needed to be called out, and the homophobic couple needed and deserved to be publicly shamed and held up to public ridicule.
Would you like to bring back the ‘stocks’ as well Hmm
BoredZelda · 21/01/2022 12:07

Mostly I'm going to expect people to comply with the relevant law, which is referenced above, and which does indeed affect how people dispose of their property

Except it actually doesn't.

BoredZelda · 21/01/2022 12:07

You're disturbingly willing to tolerate discrimination against gay men and lesbians. Giving lip service to it not being what you really think actually doesn't mean anything to us, you know. I notice that you use exactly the same tired homophobic trope that others on this thread have been using - claiming that gay and lesbian posters don't understand / are stupid / can't read / can't grasp matters. You couldn't be more wrong; indeed, it is you who comes to this with not only a shallow mindset but a failure of empathy. I would encourage you to meditate on what it's like to experience homophobia, but I fear such exhortations would be useless.

Nothing homophobic about any of my comments. And you have absolutely no idea what my experiences are so the attempted condescension and supposed insult is entirely misplaced.

What I do know is, regardless of how abhorrent I find someone's views, I will always defend their right to say it. And so should you, because next time, it might be people coming along to silence you on something you firmly believe. For example, someone might come along and tell you that calling people homophobic (especially when they aren't) is actually really problematic and you should be very careful about doing it and in fact refusing to sell your home to a homophobic person is unlawful. I'm going to guess you wouldn't be happy with that.

Once again because you really do seem to struggle with the concept, defending the action is not the same as defending the act.

BashStreetKid · 21/01/2022 12:07

Think through the implications here. What are you going to do? Tell people they have to sell their belongings to anyone, that they can't choose how to dispose of their own property? What are the implications there for the existence of private property?

Mostly I'm going to expect people to comply with the relevant law, which is referenced above, and which does indeed affect how people dispose of their property.

Bitofachinwag · 21/01/2022 12:06

@Isaw3ships

‘ So are you saying that you live by every single rule in the Old Testament, without exception?shock’ *@AlexaShutUp*

I don’t live by ANY rule of any religion as I’m an Atheist who believes in science and not fairytales.
I’m not sure how you got I follow any Testament from what I’ve been posting!
Even as a child going to a church school and going to church I could see the hypocrisy and contradictions and nonsense in religion, and do t get me started on the misogyny and paedophilia in so many faiths.

It's quite rude to call religion "fairy tales". Tolerance goes both ways
fuckyourpronouns · 21/01/2022 12:06

@Artichokeleaves

Well obviously they do have a place in modern society, they're living in it and it's ridiculous to pretend that society doesn't include people with these beliefs. It does. Those beliefs don't get changed by tutting and reporting to the police for wrong think, that just makes the divide of belief harder and them angrier. Having beliefs you may not agree with is not a crime.

If you discover that your seller is prejudiced and has incompatible views and doesn't want to sell to you - you shrug and go buy from someone else, because life is too short. You might think your seller is an unpleasant twit: that's not against the law. This whole punish and silence the wrongthinkers and be prejudiced against them really doesn't help anyone or solve anything. It's just prejudice in a different form.

I'm LGBT btw.

Yep. This.

People have different views. We don't live in a communist state where we are told what we just think and how we must act. Also worth understanding that this a private couple making decisions about their property. If it was a business actively promoting that they don't sell to gay people that would be completely different and unlawful.

Not all Christian's hold the same beliefs as this couple. I certainly don't. It wouldn't matter a jot to me if a gay couple purchased our house. I have refused to sell a previous house to someone before who was rude to me and exceptionally arrogant. I'm entitled to do that. My house. My decision.

BashStreetKid · 21/01/2022 12:03

@MummyWoodentop

I think people are saying it is the bigotry that is bad - so - should we ban bigotry, surely one man's bigoted comment is another person's truth.
Does that work universally? If I were to say that, say, all members of a particular race or religion are subhuman and don't deserve to live, would there be any circumstances where that could be true?
SantaClawsServiette · 21/01/2022 11:58

[quote Innocenta]@SantaClawsServiette It's not a failure to "Act like a grown up" to be distressed or angered by homophobia, and to want to respond to it actively. The very fact that you're this willing to dismiss it in such terms is disturbing.

@BoredZelda You're disturbingly willing to tolerate discrimination against gay men and lesbians. Giving lip service to it not being what you really think actually doesn't mean anything to us, you know. I notice that you use exactly the same tired homophobic trope that others on this thread have been using - claiming that gay and lesbian posters don't understand / are stupid / can't read / can't grasp matters. You couldn't be more wrong; indeed, it is you who comes to this with not only a shallow mindset but a failure of empathy. I would encourage you to meditate on what it's like to experience homophobia, but I fear such exhortations would be useless.

@WindInTheWillows7 So do you think society should tolerate the implementation of such views? What about, say, an attempt to reintroduce legal slavery? For any disturbing view, you can find someone who sincerely holds it. Society rightly limits how people can act on their views. [/quote]
I think you'll find there are plenty of gay and lesbian adults who agree with me.

Think through the implications here. What are you going to do? Tell people they have to sell their belongings to anyone, that they can't choose how to dispose of their own property? What are the implications there for the existence of private property? Tell people they are only allowed to think certain things, or only allowed to express certain ideas? How do you think that is compatible with liberal democracy? Don't you see that kind of attitude could very easily be used to suppress any view that isn't mainstream?

OneTC · 21/01/2022 11:52

And yet plenty of Christians manage not to act like these people.

While all still bowing their heads to the book that contains the offending homophobia

Isaw3ships · 21/01/2022 11:51

‘ So are you saying that you live by every single rule in the Old Testament, without exception?shock’ @AlexaShutUp

I don’t live by ANY rule of any religion as I’m an Atheist who believes in science and not fairytales.
I’m not sure how you got I follow any Testament from what I’ve been posting!
Even as a child going to a church school and going to church I could see the hypocrisy and contradictions and nonsense in religion, and do t get me started on the misogyny and paedophilia in so many faiths.

Georama · 21/01/2022 11:50

Homosexuality is not only referenced in the Old Testament, though. It is also referenced in the New Testament. And this is why it affects Christians.

And yet plenty of Christians manage not to act like these people.

OP posts:
Bitofachinwag · 21/01/2022 11:31

@loislovesstewie

Do they eat pork, or rabbit, or shellfish? Do they wear clothing of mixed fibres? Do they mix meat and dairy? Do they abide by all the other dietary laws? Or all of the other rules, commonly called Mosaic laws on hygiene and purity matters? I bet my arse they don't.
Probably not, those are Jewish laws, from the Old Testament.
5128gap · 21/01/2022 11:22

@MummyWoodentop

I think people are saying it is the bigotry that is bad - so - should we ban bigotry, surely one man's bigoted comment is another person's truth.
One persons 'truth' should not be allowed to harm, hurt or remove the rights and equalities of another person; and where it does, the protection of the second person's rights is more important than the rights of the first person to infringe them. Its really very simple.
Flutterflybutterby · 21/01/2022 11:21

@loislovesstewie

Do they eat pork, or rabbit, or shellfish? Do they wear clothing of mixed fibres? Do they mix meat and dairy? Do they abide by all the other dietary laws? Or all of the other rules, commonly called Mosaic laws on hygiene and purity matters? I bet my arse they don't.
Of course they don't, they're Christians. Christians are not required to follow Mosaic law. I thought this was common knowledge?!

Homosexuality is not only referenced in the Old Testament, though. It is also referenced in the New Testament. And this is why it affects Christians.

OneTC · 21/01/2022 11:18

So are you saying that you live by every single rule in the Old Testament, without exception?shock

😭

loislovesstewie · 21/01/2022 11:18

Do they eat pork, or rabbit, or shellfish?
Do they wear clothing of mixed fibres?
Do they mix meat and dairy?
Do they abide by all the other dietary laws?
Or all of the other rules, commonly called Mosaic laws on hygiene and purity matters?
I bet my arse they don't.

Swipe left for the next trending thread