Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this couple's attitude has no place in modern society?

618 replies

Georama · 20/01/2022 18:35

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10419543/Christian-couple-ban-gay-man-partner-buying-dream-650-000-sexuality.html

A church-going wife who banned a gay man and his ITV producer partner from buying her £650,000 Surrey home has hit back in the row and insisted they are just sticking to their beliefs.

Luke Whitehouse and Lachlan Mantell were stunned when they were told that they could not buy the three-bedroom home because the Christian owners didn't want to sell to 'two men in a partnership.'

Honestly, they should be ashamed of that text. I hope no estate agent will work with them ever again.

OP posts:
Youarefakenews · 21/01/2022 14:37

@WindInTheWillows7

I don't think the comparisons to bans on black/Irish/traveller people hold up, because it is not the fact that the buyers are gay and have this protected characteristic which is the issue for the sellers, it is the fact that they are in a gay relationship, which is a lifestyle choice, not a characteristic. They weren't discriminating against them because because they were same-sex attracted, but rather because they didn't want to sell their house to people who would be actively practicing their homosexuality in that building. That's very different to refusing to sell to someone because of their sexuality. It was more about what the building would be used for (a home for two people in a gay relationship).
A very similar thing happened years ago to Irish travellers in a town called Rathkeale. When the sellers refused to sell to travellers, the travelling community started buying up the houses round about it. As I recall the original house was sold for far less than they wanted because they were the ones left feeling like outcasts.
Isaw3ships · 21/01/2022 14:37

The woman has a PHD - it’s mind boggling that someone allegedly so educated can act in such an ignorant manner. They’ll have kids too no doubt, and poison their minds with the same bigotry

Innocenta · 21/01/2022 14:35

@Flutterflybutterby You're condoning homophobia.

Innocenta · 21/01/2022 14:34

Some people don't seem to understand that being homophobic isn't a neutral position. It's not like preferring apples to oranges. If you think it's okay to behave like the couple in question, then yes, actually, you are condoning not different private beliefs (abhorrent ones, but sure - freedom of ideas), but hatred. Good old fashioned hatred.

So don't dress it up in the language of pluralism and respect, and call gay people stupid and childish for challenging you. We know exactly what you're saying, we see right through it, and we'll continue to call it out.

Flutterflybutterby · 21/01/2022 14:29

@OneTC

the Christians in question would argue that they ARE loving these men by saying what they said

bollocks

... well, they would!
OneTC · 21/01/2022 14:25

the Christians in question would argue that they ARE loving these men by saying what they said

bollocks

Flutterflybutterby · 21/01/2022 14:21

@loislovesstewie

BTW Jesus said (if we believe it) 'Do not think that I came to destroy the Law or the Prophets. I did not come to destroy but to fulfil.' I was taught at my school which was a very religious establishment that it meant the Jewish laws were NOT to be changed.
But they're not being changed. Jesus fulfilled the Old Testament laws when he was crucified and died. That's what the temple veil being torn in two when Jesus died symbolised. That's why his final words were, "It is finished." That's why Christians don't need to abide my the Mosaic laws anymore. There seems to be so much misunderstanding about this. If we are going to discuss Christianity we might as well be accurate.

Also, the Christians in question would argue that they ARE loving these men by saying what they said. I suppose it's an unpopular view if you're not a Christian, but telling people the word of God is an act of love for their own benefit, not to be judgey or cruel, but to save them - although unfortunately it might come across as judgey and cruel. Well, I suppose it would be very difficult to tell someone that their behavior is sinful without offending them!

OneTC · 21/01/2022 14:19

I wonder if RL would show the same thing?

If it was an anonymous voting box maybe, but in conversation, no of course not

TheWomandestroyed · 21/01/2022 14:18

It's incredible that educated people can have that attitude. They sound like they are in a cult. I wonder what their religious background is?

Thelnebriati · 21/01/2022 14:15

In real life I can only think of a couple people who have outed themselves as homophobic, so that 25% is always a wake up call.

loislovesstewie · 21/01/2022 14:13

BTW Jesus said (if we believe it) 'Do not think that I came to destroy the Law or the Prophets. I did not come to destroy but to fulfil.' I was taught at my school which was a very religious establishment that it meant the Jewish laws were NOT to be changed.

TimBoothseyes · 21/01/2022 14:09

Ah good old Christianity (and other religions), "Love thy fellow man.....unless they also love their fellow man, in which case, do everything you can to make their lives more difficult".

Isaw3ships · 21/01/2022 14:09

That 25% seems pretty constant on MN- you can get people calling out homophobia and about a quarter of MN comments will be from people saying it’s not homophobic, everyone is entitled to their views, or saying sexuality is irrelevant here etc when it’s clearly the whole point
I wonder if RL would show the same thing? Be interesting to know…

Elsiebear90 · 21/01/2022 14:03

I think what gets me on here is the constant minimisation of homophobia by referring to it as just a difference of opinion or a belief. I’ve not come across this with racism or sexism, seems like to many people homophobia is still acceptable whether they agree with it or not.

Isaw3ships · 21/01/2022 13:58

@LoveMae
It is endless, isn’t it. I genuinely do think our lives are better than 20/30 years ago but there will always be those who would happily excuse homophobia because of their own prejudices.

LoveMae · 21/01/2022 13:52

Oh and 24% saying YABU? Sigh.

I try to avoid threads about LGBT issues like this one on MN because it hurts.my.heart and also does.my.head.in seeing people discuss my life, my marriage, my family like we don't actually exist in real life.

LoveMae · 21/01/2022 13:51

@NightmareSlashDelightful

I think what a lot of people don't get or are refusing to see is that expressing prejudice through religion is just one framework through which we as gay people find ourselves on the receiving end of homophobia. (Which, when you strip everything else away, is basically fear and weak-mindedness, in my opinion.)

It comes in many forms. Religion 'it's against God's will, the Bible forbids it', etc. Medical 'gay people spread HIV'. Statistical 'well there's only a tiny percentage of you, you don't matter'. Societal 'I don't want my children exposed to that'. And so on it goes.

Some people will find whatever convenient framework that works for them to justify it, but the end result is the same: alienation, prejudice, rejection, hatred and sometimes violence.

That's why this situation is shit. Because Luke and Lachlan have probably experienced bits of shit chucked at them like this their whole lives, but with varying justifications.

Oh, THIS!!! Sad

If you've never been on the end of homophobia, then don't think you can even begin to imagine how it feels.

To the poster who said "obviously homophobia is upsetting, but...." there is no but Angry if this couple said they weren't willing to sell to a black couple, would you say "obviously racism is upsetting, but..."

Sad
BIWI · 21/01/2022 13:49
Grin
EeeICouldRipATissue · 21/01/2022 13:49

I'm saddened that there's so many homophobic views still around on this, but also sadly not surprised.
What people always fail to grasp is that you are allowed to think what you like, but what you CAN'T do, rightly, is discriminate against people for protected characteristics such as being gay.
Like this couple have.

If you are a Remainder would you sell to a Brexiteer?
I voted Remain, and yes I would.

If you are a liberal and a potential buyer turned up in a Boris is best t-shirt would you decline their offer?
No, but I'd reserve the right to think you must be a massive knob Grin

Innocenta · 21/01/2022 13:26

@SantaClawsServiette I'm not trying to restrict anyone's thinking. Stop strawmanning.

Isaw3ships · 21/01/2022 13:18

‘ It annoys me when straight people try to tell gay people when they should and shouldn’t find something homophobic

It annoys me when people jump straight to a -phobia or -ism, when they have no idea who they are talking to.’

If you don’t think this couple are homophobic for refusing to allow a gay couple to even view the house they’re selling while referring the potential buyers to offensive bible passages telling them that they have given into ‘shameful lusts’ and have ‘depraved’ minds then I guess that’s your look out.
But as they are quite literally quoting homophobic bible passages at a gay couple, I think it’s fine to call them homophobic bigots.

Elsiebear90 · 21/01/2022 13:13

@BoredZelda

As a lesbian I have every right to call people homophobic when they say homophobic things.

At the moment you do (albeit your opinion can also be way off mark) You should be glad that people fought for your right to do that and be very wary of ever suggesting someone who has an opposing opinion isn't allowed to say that too. I remember in my lifetime your freedom of expression wasn't what it was today. Aren't you glad people fought for that to be ok?

Are you really trying to tell gay people we should be fighting for people’s rights to be homophobic towards us? And you’re comparing their so called right to do that to our fight for equality and to not be discriminated against? Do you have any idea how offensive that is?

Stop equating homophobia to a mere difference of opinion or free speech, it’s minimising it and it’s effects.

OneTC · 21/01/2022 13:12

It annoys me when straight people try to tell gay people when they should and shouldn’t find something homophobic.

I don't think there's many people itt who are saying this isn't homophobia though. They refused to sell them their house cos they're gay. Of course it's homophobic. Their homophobia is couched in hundreds of years of discrimination and brainwashing. It's an abhorrent way to think but I'm simultaneously revolted by, and ever so slightly sympathetic to people who have fallen for this nonsense and I accept that the church has had about 2000 years worth of experience on having one over on people's logical processes.

I'm not defending these people or their views. I don't care if people give them shit they invited it upon themselves. If no-one thought like this the world would be a far superior place to live

SantaClawsServiette · 21/01/2022 13:10

[quote Isaw3ships]@Innocenta yup! To totally agree. It annoys me when straight people try to tell gay people when they should and shouldn’t find something homophobic.[/quote]
This sounds nice, but it's pretty easy to see that the principle is ultimatly kind of bullshit.

There are women who claim certain things are sexism, and they are objectively wrong. There are non-white people who claim certain things are racism, and they are objectively wrong.

There are gay people who claim that certain things are homophobic, and they are objectively wrong.

And there are all kinds of reasons people can be wrong about these things. Sometimes it's because they have experienced those things and assume a situation is the same, but are incorrect. Sometimes it's just because they've misunderstood the situation. Sometimes it's because they have an over-broad definition. And then there are legitimate disagreements about what constitutes such things, someone like Robin DiAngelo thinks pretty much everyone who disagrees with her is a racist, many people disagree with her views including many (most?) non-white people.

INterestingly no one in the thread has really said their views aren't homophobic, what's been said again and again is that society can't and shouldn't try and restrict people's thinking and also that it's important to make a fair bit of room to allow people to live according to their views, with a light hand restricting that.

Given the relative youth of the gay rights movement you'd think the importance of that would be understood, as it would never have got off the ground otherwise.

SantaClawsServiette · 21/01/2022 12:54

The received theological wisdom is that the bit in Romans they cited means 'don't have an orgy' and not 'homosexuality is wrong'.

Even if this wisdom is incorrect, it's certainly the case that Jesus never said anything on the topic.

Well, no, it isn't the received theological wisdom. Even among people who aren't evangelicals. There are some people who think that, which is a different thing all together.

The idea that what Jesus said is valid and anything else isn't, or even that only what is explicitly stated is important, is also not the received wisdom.

Christian teachings on sexuality are part of a larger set of beliefs around the purpose of sex, and even the body in general. Historically they are quite strict, for everyone, ideally people are only meant to have sex if they are willing that a pregnancy could result, only with one spouse, and no sex during times like fast days, lent, and so on. Celibacy being the rule for anyone who, for whatever reason, doesn't marry, being the expectation.

Not to say that people have ever been very good at all that, but it's a coherent perspective that fits together with a lot of different teachings about the body rooted in both the Bible and also the philosophical tradition Christianity comes out of.

Evangelicals can have an odd tendency to pick and choose from that, but it's just not accurate to say that the real theological understanding is what you'd expect to hear from some of the Jesus seminar type people.