Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this couple's attitude has no place in modern society?

618 replies

Georama · 20/01/2022 18:35

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10419543/Christian-couple-ban-gay-man-partner-buying-dream-650-000-sexuality.html

A church-going wife who banned a gay man and his ITV producer partner from buying her £650,000 Surrey home has hit back in the row and insisted they are just sticking to their beliefs.

Luke Whitehouse and Lachlan Mantell were stunned when they were told that they could not buy the three-bedroom home because the Christian owners didn't want to sell to 'two men in a partnership.'

Honestly, they should be ashamed of that text. I hope no estate agent will work with them ever again.

OP posts:
thedancingbear · 20/01/2022 21:34

@Cultish

but not active discrimination against protected characteristics.

The couple also have a protected characteristic: religious belief. Forcing them to sell the house to someone who goes against their religious beliefs would not be acceptable or possible either. It's not dissimilar to the baker / gay couple case. They couple haven't gone out of their way to seek trouble. They've refused to do something because the principles of their religion. They haven't made a big thing of it, they haven't gone to the papers to express their disgust. They just don't want to sell the house to this couple. They are allowed to do that.

And we’re allowed to call them bigoted cunts.

No law against that either. Western democracy is brilliant innit?

Please keep posting - we much prefer you out in the open

lightisnotwhite · 20/01/2022 21:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

woodhill · 20/01/2022 21:34

@BIWI

Why not?! You were the one to take issue with the word I used! Explain what you meant by your comment.
No thanks
Cultish · 20/01/2022 21:34

Still, this doesn't answer the question Who decides what's acceptable? And how to they do that? Are we all obliged to changes our beliefs according to "progress"?

Well that is the big question isn't it. And one person's idea of progress isn't another persons.
But really, at the very least, it just needs to fall in line with the law. I would say that the gay couple may be moving outside of that position and into another one of inviting a public pile on and inciting religious hatred.

CorneliusVetch · 20/01/2022 21:34

@Cultish

but not active discrimination against protected characteristics.

The couple also have a protected characteristic: religious belief. Forcing them to sell the house to someone who goes against their religious beliefs would not be acceptable or possible either. It's not dissimilar to the baker / gay couple case. They couple haven't gone out of their way to seek trouble. They've refused to do something because the principles of their religion. They haven't made a big thing of it, they haven't gone to the papers to express their disgust. They just don't want to sell the house to this couple. They are allowed to do that.

It’s not like the Ashers Bakery case at all. In that case, they weren’t refusing to make a cake for Mr Lee because he was gay. That would be the equivalent to the actions of these bigots.
evilharpy · 20/01/2022 21:33

@FitAt50

Shocked that 21% of mumsnetter's agree with the homophobic couple.
Maybe they don't, maybe they voted YABU because they assumed it meant the vendors' actions were unreasonable?
BIWI · 20/01/2022 21:33

Why not?! You were the one to take issue with the word I used! Explain what you meant by your comment.

woodhill · 20/01/2022 21:32

[quote BIWI]@Woodhill

Your point being ... ?[/quote]
I'm not getting into this

Cheekypeach · 20/01/2022 21:31

Yanbu it’s mad people have views like this in 2022.

I mean did they really have to send the bloody letter & tell them why?! Just decline to sell them the house if you’re that worked up about it.

Omicrone · 20/01/2022 21:30

@mordinvasnormandy

I wonder if people would be so eager to defend them if they discriminated based on someone's race.
I still wouldn't think it was right to plaster very personal details all over a national newspaper. But then I never have been one for 'trial by media'.
BIWI · 20/01/2022 21:30

@Woodhill

Your point being ... ?

AgathaMystery · 20/01/2022 21:30

@5128gap whose rights are paramount though?

I don’t agree with the couple at all. I think they’re mental.

But. We did decided not to sell our last house to a person we didn’t like. It was our choice. It was our home, we decide who comes inside it, who views it & who buys it. No one else.

Cultish · 20/01/2022 21:30

but not active discrimination against protected characteristics.

The couple also have a protected characteristic: religious belief. Forcing them to sell the house to someone who goes against their religious beliefs would not be acceptable or possible either. It's not dissimilar to the baker / gay couple case. They couple haven't gone out of their way to seek trouble. They've refused to do something because the principles of their religion. They haven't made a big thing of it, they haven't gone to the papers to express their disgust. They just don't want to sell the house to this couple. They are allowed to do that.

Bitofachinwag · 20/01/2022 21:28

@Elsiebear90

“Fair enough. But you can't expect everyone to keep changing their opinion according to what's "deemed acceptable to modern society " . Regardless as to what year it is people always live in modern society. People who lived in 1865 also lived in modern society. Who decides what's acceptable?”

Yes you can, it’s called progress, or do you also think there’s nothing wrong with a man thinking his wife is his property that he can rape and beat when he likes? After all, this was morally acceptable not so long ago, and is still morally acceptable in many parts of the world. Should we not expect him to change his opinion? Would you defend him too?

In your example someone is getting hurt. I did say in a previous post that that isn't ok. I would say that the man in your example can have that opinion if he wants, but he can't hurr others. There is a big difference.

Still, this doesn't answer the question Who decides what's acceptable? And how to they do that? Are we all obliged to changes our beliefs according to "progress"?

Maze76 · 20/01/2022 21:28

I’d like to say I’m shocked- but I’m not

mordinvasnormandy · 20/01/2022 21:27

I wonder if people would be so eager to defend them if they discriminated based on someone's race.

Innocenta · 20/01/2022 21:26

It's not the 'belief', it's the discriminatory behaviour. Really shocking that so many are okay with active, hateful homophobic behaviour... @BoredZelda @Unsure33 @Cultish @Bluebluemoon39

5128gap · 20/01/2022 21:25

@AgathaMystery

It’s a weird one.

In my opinion they ANBU in the act of wanting to decide who to sell their house to. But I feel they ABU in the reason behind their refusal.

Interesting times when 2 protected characteristics of the EA clash as well.

If rights arising from one protected characteristic cause discrimination on the grounds of another protected characteristic, they should no longer be rights, so there shouldn't be a conflict.
lightnesspixie · 20/01/2022 21:25

Organised religion is just another cover for bigots to hide behind. I've always found ironically that so-called 'religious' ppl (often of any denomination) are the nastiest ppl around. They can just fuck off.

Lockheart · 20/01/2022 21:25

@Cultish

But they've crossed the line by refusing a house viewing because this couple is gay.

Not really, because they are under no obligation to sell their house to anyone for any reason that they want. Even if other people don't like that reason.

But it is discrimination, because they're refusing to treat this couple like anyone else. It's not just the Christian couple holding the private belief that homosexuality is a sin anymore. They're actively discriminating.
Omicrone · 20/01/2022 21:25

@Lockheart

I think people are getting freedom of thought confused with discrimination.

You can hold whatever beliefs you like. You can believe that Jews are evil and gays are sinful and that anyone who isn't white is dirty and that disabled people should be euthanised. You can think and believe whatever horrible atrocious things you wish.

What you can't do is treat people differently because of it.

And this is where they've crossed the line.

They can think this gay couple is sinful as much as they want. They can pray for their souls and say whatever hateful things they like between themselves. But they've crossed the line by refusing a house viewing because this couple is gay.

Technically, according to the law, I think they can do this.

For starters it's (currently) their house and therefore they are allowed to choose who they do and do not allow inside for a viewing, and presumably are allowed to tell those people why.

Fatarseflanagan09 · 20/01/2022 21:24

I hope they can’t sell it and it falls down around their nasty homophobic ears.

Cultish · 20/01/2022 21:23

But they've crossed the line by refusing a house viewing because this couple is gay.

Not really, because they are under no obligation to sell their house to anyone for any reason that they want. Even if other people don't like that reason.

woodhill · 20/01/2022 21:23

@BIWI

21%, so 84 people, voted that YABU. Who are these bigots? None of whom have come on to the thread to say why they voted that way.
Isn't the term bigot subjective
Innocenta · 20/01/2022 21:22

@Artichokeleaves @DoubleYouOhEmAyEn This potentially was an actual hate crime, though. I agree that varying views should be tolerated, but not active discrimination against protected characteristics.

(DOI: am a lesbian.)