Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this couple's attitude has no place in modern society?

618 replies

Georama · 20/01/2022 18:35

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10419543/Christian-couple-ban-gay-man-partner-buying-dream-650-000-sexuality.html

A church-going wife who banned a gay man and his ITV producer partner from buying her £650,000 Surrey home has hit back in the row and insisted they are just sticking to their beliefs.

Luke Whitehouse and Lachlan Mantell were stunned when they were told that they could not buy the three-bedroom home because the Christian owners didn't want to sell to 'two men in a partnership.'

Honestly, they should be ashamed of that text. I hope no estate agent will work with them ever again.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 23/01/2022 21:50

Absolutely nuts.

depremesnil · 23/01/2022 21:42

@Alayalaya

Everyone is protesting about this, yet the Catholic Church is homophobic on a daily basis and nobody says a word. These people wouldn’t have that attitude if the church hadn’t taught it to them.
Not sure where you got the impression that nobody ever talks about the Catholic church's attitude to homosexuality.
Alayalaya · 23/01/2022 21:12

Everyone is protesting about this, yet the Catholic Church is homophobic on a daily basis and nobody says a word. These people wouldn’t have that attitude if the church hadn’t taught it to them.

depremesnil · 23/01/2022 21:10

@WindInTheWillows7

Just look at some of the ways Christians are described on this thread. I even saw one comment despairing that this couple might breed, and pass their beliefs onto their children. Sure, people are free to be Christians in the UK without harassment or discrimination, as long as they don't actually live out their faith in society or express their beliefs in the workplace or in public. christianconcern.com/cccases/the-bristol-four/ christianconcern.com/cccases/seyi-omooba/ christianconcern.com/cccases/andrew-sathiyavan/ christianconcern.com/cccases/hatun-tash/ christianconcern.com/cccases/hazel-lewis/

As long as you're one of those nice Christians that doesn't actually take the Bible seriously, or talk about your faith, you're perfectly safe.

That website promotes conversion therapy. It's sick.
MummyWoodentop · 23/01/2022 13:06

A civilised society has laws against the above list of behaviours.

Innocenta · 23/01/2022 12:45

@thedancingbear I couldn't agree with you more. 👏🏻

thedancingbear · 23/01/2022 12:25

I'm not entirely sure that they are. Some men believe they are entitled to sex with women, through force if necessary. Some people feel that women who have sex outside of marriage should be stoned to death. Some people believe that children are capable of consenting to and enjoying sex with adults. A civilised society doesn't just shrug its shoulders and say these people are entitled to their beliefs. A civilised society challenges and educates, and if that fails, it monitors and controls, to protect people who would otherwise be harmed. The reality is, people with very strong beliefs don't typically keep them in the privacy of their own minds. They share them, seek out like minded people to confirm and perpetuate them, and eventually often act upon them, as this couple has done.

Quite. And some people think that gay people shouldn't be allowed to own a home.

Which is why we need to keep shouting and protesting about these fucking bigoted cunts.

5128gap · 23/01/2022 10:09

@Alayalaya

At the end of the day people are entitled to their beliefs even if we don’t agree with them. Some religions have beliefs that I strongly disagree with but still they have the right to hold those beliefs. I personally have beliefs that some people disagree with and the same applies.
I'm not entirely sure that they are. Some men believe they are entitled to sex with women, through force if necessary. Some people feel that women who have sex outside of marriage should be stoned to death. Some people believe that children are capable of consenting to and enjoying sex with adults. A civilised society doesn't just shrug its shoulders and say these people are entitled to their beliefs. A civilised society challenges and educates, and if that fails, it monitors and controls, to protect people who would otherwise be harmed. The reality is, people with very strong beliefs don't typically keep them in the privacy of their own minds. They share them, seek out like minded people to confirm and perpetuate them, and eventually often act upon them, as this couple has done.
Trilley · 23/01/2022 09:07

If the house still on the market, which is doubtful, I suspect they may well get lots of people viewing the house out of sheer curiosity. I must say, it's quite tempting to go round with a female friend wearing stereotype butch lesbian gear.

Isaw3ships · 23/01/2022 07:59

I wish there was some kind of karma that would kick in re: seeing the house but the fact is the publicity has probably helped

Innocenta · 22/01/2022 22:44

@wishtotravel The focus of the thread is homophobia. Like it or not, that's what you're defending.

I hope you're more honest with yourself than you are in what you say on the internet.

wishtotravel · 22/01/2022 20:19

[quote Innocenta]@wishtotravel Why are you so eager to speak up for the homophobes?

No one is saying that varied views are inherently wrong. We are talking about this example, which is an instance of homophobia. [/quote]
I am not defending anyone. You have made the focus of your discussion homosexuality, which is fine. I have made my focus whether or not modern society includes unpopular views, and in my opinion it does, independently to whether or not I agree with them.

bustersword · 22/01/2022 18:55

@WindInTheWillows7

Homosexuality between men was only decriminalised in the sixties - the eighties in Scotland and NI. It was only in 2001 that gay people could serve in the military and the age of consent was equalised, and section 28 was in force until less than 20 years ago (although judging from your posts you probably think it should still be there). Same-sex marriage has only been legal throughout the UK for two years.

When was the last time that Christianity was illegal, and that Christians were legally prevented from getting married, having children or serving in the armed forces? I seem to forget.

Innocenta · 22/01/2022 17:54

@Byebyeboris Very well said. Wine

Byebyeboris · 22/01/2022 17:41

@Artichokeleaves

Well obviously they do have a place in modern society, they're living in it and it's ridiculous to pretend that society doesn't include people with these beliefs. It does. Those beliefs don't get changed by tutting and reporting to the police for wrong think, that just makes the divide of belief harder and them angrier. Having beliefs you may not agree with is not a crime.

If you discover that your seller is prejudiced and has incompatible views and doesn't want to sell to you - you shrug and go buy from someone else, because life is too short. You might think your seller is an unpleasant twit: that's not against the law. This whole punish and silence the wrongthinkers and be prejudiced against them really doesn't help anyone or solve anything. It's just prejudice in a different form.

I'm LGBT btw.

You’re absolutely right. We should allow people to marginalise people with protected characteristics 🤔

You’re attitude is hardly pro lgbt. Backwards people with these attitudes should be called out every single time. By doing nothing, shrugging and walking away, we condone them.

Innocenta · 22/01/2022 17:33

@wishtotravel Why are you so eager to speak up for the homophobes?

No one is saying that varied views are inherently wrong. We are talking about this example, which is an instance of homophobia.

wishtotravel · 22/01/2022 17:18

[quote Innocenta]@wishtotravel No, it is not acceptable to behave in a hateful and discriminatory way. Stop excusing homophobia. You may give lip service to not really agreeing, but you're still ultimately justifying those views.

Nobody is saying people can't have their own private opinions. But this goes beyond that - they didn't have to behave in the way that they did, which plainly crossed over from a mere belief into active, hateful discrimination. At minimum it's a hate incident, even if not meeting the threshold for the CPS to pursue prosecution. [/quote]
I agree that these views and behaviour were hurtful and hateful but I was simply replying to the idea that they shouldn't belong in modern society. Modern society is simply a reflection of everyone's views, there is no should or shouldn't about it. All we can do is say whether or not we agree with a view, and until the law, on the behalf of the people, makes various actions illegal, then those actions are made according to one's own moral compass.
If the OP had said, should it be illegal to do this, or how hateful it was, then that is a different discussion.
My other point was that everyone discriminates in their private lives because we all make decisions based on our own views. My point was that we can't presume that all views different to our own are wrong and therefore need silencing immediately.

Trilley · 22/01/2022 17:07

Legally, they’ve done nothing wrong

I think they have.

Section 33 Equality Act 2010:

(1) A person (A) who has the right to dispose of premises must not discriminate against another (B)—
(a). as to the terms on which A offers to dispose of the premises to B;
(b). by not disposing of the premises to B
(c) in A's treatment of B with respect to things done in relation to persons seeking premises.

I see upthread that it's been suggested that this doesn't apply, but the person who says so has never come back to explain it, and there's nothing in the section suggesting that there are any limitations to how it's applied.

Trilley · 22/01/2022 17:00

@Alayalaya

At the end of the day people are entitled to their beliefs even if we don’t agree with them. Some religions have beliefs that I strongly disagree with but still they have the right to hold those beliefs. I personally have beliefs that some people disagree with and the same applies.
The issue here is how they express those beliefs. If they do so in a way that discriminates against groups with protected characteristics, they are breaking the law.
BashStreetKid · 22/01/2022 16:53

[quote fuckyourpronouns]@BashStreetKid
" Oh, I know, they have a terrible time, don't they? What with the Queen being the head of the Church of England, compulsory Christian worship in schools, church schools funded by the state, the state broadcaster regularly broadcasting Christian services and hymns - the persecution is absolutely horrendous."

Wtf are you on about?! [/quote]
WTF is your problem with understanding that, @fuckyourpronouns? Have you come across sarcasm before?

kmblark · 22/01/2022 13:53

Again, people are not saying that they agree with this couple's opinions

@WindInTheWillows7 seems to be.

Isaw3ships · 22/01/2022 13:45

Morally they’re a couple of shits. But other than being in the papers for being a couple of shits this will soon blow over and there’ll be little or no repercussions for them.
Other than some of their colleagues, particularly hers at a university I would imagine, thinking that they’re bigots of the lowest order.

Innocenta · 22/01/2022 13:32

@wishtotravel No, it is not acceptable to behave in a hateful and discriminatory way. Stop excusing homophobia. You may give lip service to not really agreeing, but you're still ultimately justifying those views.

Nobody is saying people can't have their own private opinions. But this goes beyond that - they didn't have to behave in the way that they did, which plainly crossed over from a mere belief into active, hateful discrimination. At minimum it's a hate incident, even if not meeting the threshold for the CPS to pursue prosecution.

wishtotravel · 22/01/2022 13:18

Again, people are not saying that they agree with this couple's opinions, just that they are within their rights to think as they wish. People are also commenting on the OP's post which says that this attitude has no right in modern society, when all modern society is, is the attitude of all people alive at the present moment.
I feel that because people feel strongly about this issue they do not wish to hear an apposing view in any way, and when they hear of one being expressed, wish to suppress this view more harshly than the law would permit. If we wish to live in a tolerant society, we have to accept that other people have differing opinions. We have ways of making sure that people are not discriminated against by t he state, because the state should represent the majority view, but we can't force individuals to privately not discriminate, even if it hurts to hear these views when they touch us as individuals. Personally I was upset to hear a friend wouldn't consider viewing a house next to a disabled living community home. It changed my opinion of her, but I wouldn't say she should be forced to view that house because by not doing so she would be discriminating!

burnoutbabe · 22/01/2022 13:10

@Isaw3ships

‘ Freedom of speech isn't only for people who say nice things.’

Indeed. Which is why a newspaper gets to publish this story and publicise them without repercussions a d I get to say I think they are outdated,homophobic bigots.
Freedom of speech doesn’t, of course , cover hate crime but their backward opinions in their case doesn’t constitute hate speech.

yep. i agree. I have just done a course on freedom of speech including of course restrictions for hate crimes.

So this fits into that. Legally nothing wrong with it (morally probably but they were at least truthful and said what they thought which they probably think its better than just lying about a change of mind over the sale which most people would do)

I may choose not to sell my house to someone's who views i disagree with but i'd not get castigated in the daily mail as my views are probably "the right ones" per the daily mail.