Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this couple's attitude has no place in modern society?

618 replies

Georama · 20/01/2022 18:35

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10419543/Christian-couple-ban-gay-man-partner-buying-dream-650-000-sexuality.html

A church-going wife who banned a gay man and his ITV producer partner from buying her £650,000 Surrey home has hit back in the row and insisted they are just sticking to their beliefs.

Luke Whitehouse and Lachlan Mantell were stunned when they were told that they could not buy the three-bedroom home because the Christian owners didn't want to sell to 'two men in a partnership.'

Honestly, they should be ashamed of that text. I hope no estate agent will work with them ever again.

OP posts:
InvalidCrumb · 20/01/2022 23:00

^^ sorry forgot the first subsection from the legislation
"(1)A person (A) who has the right to dispose of premises must not discriminate against another (B)—

(a)as to the terms on which A offers to dispose of the premises to B;

(b)by not disposing of the premises to B;

(c)in A's treatment of B with respect to things done in relation to persons seeking premises."

Omicrone · 20/01/2022 23:00

Re write that but remove the bit about the law. They did act unlawfully.

If they acted unlawfully, then they can be arrested, charged, taken to court, and it can be up to the authorities to release their personal details to the public. Not the Daily Mail.

InvalidCrumb · 20/01/2022 22:59

@BashStreetKid

They may have caused offence & outrage but they didn’t do any harm to the couple & therefore they can’t be accused of anything other than religious zealotry, which is exactly what they are; religious zealots who hold the word of the Bible in truth - & expect it to also be upheld in practice.

No. Under the Equality Act 2010 a person who has the right to dispose of premises must not discriminate against another by, amongst other matters, not disposing of the premises to that person due to, amongst other matters, the person's sexual orientation. So they clearly can be accused of unlawful discrimination.

That's really interesting, thanks for quoting that - here's the link for anyone else who's interested. I didn't realise that that was actually in the EA2010 - BUT I see at the end 'sexual orientation' is not protected here.... any legal bods shed any light?

From the notes:
126.This section makes it unlawful for a person who has the authority to dispose of premises (for example, by selling, letting or subletting a property) to discriminate against or victimise someone else in a number of ways including by offering the premises to them on less favourable terms; by not letting or selling the premises to them or by treating them less favourably.

127.It also makes it unlawful for a person with authority to dispose of premises to harass someone who occupies or applies for them. The Act does not however make it unlawful to harass someone because of sexual orientation or religion or belief when disposing of premises.

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/notes/division/3/4?view=plain

The legislation:

"(3)A person who has the right to dispose of premises must not, in connection with anything done in relation to their occupation or disposal, harass—

(a)a person who occupies them;

(b)a person who applies for them."

"(6)In the application of section 26 for the purposes of subsection (3), neither of the following is a relevant protected characteristic—

(a)religion or belief;

(b)sexual orientation."
www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/section/33

skintasabint · 20/01/2022 22:57

They're completely vile.

YoBeaches · 20/01/2022 22:56

@Omicrone

I don't believe that anyone who has acted perfectly within the law should have their name, age, close up photograph, fairly easy to find address and employment history detailed in a national newspaper. Particularly off the back of a private message. I don't believe in trial by media. I think the couple were right to go to the papers, but I don't think it was right that the home owners were identified. It doesn't achieve anything, it won't achieve change.

If that makes me a 'homophobic cunt' or whatever else has been slung about on this thread then, whatever.

It's not actually clear whether it was the couple who provided all that identifying info or whether they just went to the Mail with the story and the newspaper found the photos, YouTube video etc.

Re write that but remove the bit about the law. They did act unlawfully.
BashStreetKid · 20/01/2022 22:56

@LadyNell

Don't agree with it but they are entitled to their opinion
Not when it results in breaching equality duties. And I doubt that any reputable Christian church would like to defend their opinions.
InvalidCrumb · 20/01/2022 22:55

But then aren’t we heading back to the time it was fine for B&Bs, landlords and shop owners to stick signs up saying no blacks, no Irish, no Jews?

I think if that were the case then this story wouldn't be news at all?

WhatScratch · 20/01/2022 22:52

Where’s the bit in the bible that says you can’t sell your house to a gay couple? It’s really creepy and disturbing that they’re trying to police the morality of whoever buys their house. I’d imagine that’s why they were selling though an internet agency, that has now dropped them - no high street agent would touch them.

Omicrone · 20/01/2022 22:52

I don't believe that anyone who has acted perfectly within the law should have their name, age, close up photograph, fairly easy to find address and employment history detailed in a national newspaper. Particularly off the back of a private message. I don't believe in trial by media. I think the couple were right to go to the papers, but I don't think it was right that the home owners were identified. It doesn't achieve anything, it won't achieve change.

If that makes me a 'homophobic cunt' or whatever else has been slung about on this thread then, whatever.

It's not actually clear whether it was the couple who provided all that identifying info or whether they just went to the Mail with the story and the newspaper found the photos, YouTube video etc.

BashStreetKid · 20/01/2022 22:52

They may have caused offence & outrage but they didn’t do any harm to the couple & therefore they can’t be accused of anything other than religious zealotry, which is exactly what they are; religious zealots who hold the word of the Bible in truth - & expect it to also be upheld in practice.

No. Under the Equality Act 2010 a person who has the right to dispose of premises must not discriminate against another by, amongst other matters, not disposing of the premises to that person due to, amongst other matters, the person's sexual orientation. So they clearly can be accused of unlawful discrimination.

Leonthelobster · 20/01/2022 22:45

As usual Artichoke you've articulate a thought that was only half formed in my head. Whilst i completely abhor the views of this couple I think we need to be able to tolerate people with opinions that are different from our own. These people haven't killed anyone, they've acted in line with their own beliefs in a way that is not criminal. It's shit but there it is. Some people have views that other people find abhorrent. Reacting in the same manner just perpetuates polarisation

But then aren’t we heading back to the time it was fine for B&Bs, landlords and shop owners to stick signs up saying no blacks, no Irish, no Jews? And is it ok to pass this off as people who have beliefs that others find abhorrent and let it stand on that basis? So if I don’t want to sell my house to someone of Pakistani, Jewish, African or Irish heritage should prospective buyers of any of those ethnicities just shut up and go away?

BashStreetKid · 20/01/2022 22:45

@ConsuelaHammock

Meh ! People can sell their house to whoever they want. I don’t agree with their views but lots of people will agree with them. We cannot police anyone’s own belief system.
People can't refuse to sell their house when it's against the law. Which this is.
liliainterfrutices · 20/01/2022 22:44

I’m Christian. One of the things I most love Desmond Turu for is saying that he'd have no interest in a homophobic God and would rather go to hell than hang out in a homophobic heaven. That’s how I feel too.

BashStreetKid · 20/01/2022 22:40

Having introduced buyers who were willing and able to proceed, I guess the estate agents' fee is payable. If I were them I'd take the fee and then bail out.

OneTC · 20/01/2022 22:34

Not the same thing at all. But, saying either of these things would make many people think that you’re a backward, bigoted fuckwit from the boondocks.
Just as someone saying I don't want black people in my home, I don’t want to sell my house to black people - then maybe add in some batshit crazy religious quote to keep it interesting - would make many people think they’re backward, racist fuckwits.
And in either of those cases I think it’s absolutely fine if the people being discriminated against decided to go public with the story.

Agree with all of this 👍

Isaw3ships · 20/01/2022 22:32

And I wouldn’t for one second feel sorry for the bigots or the attention that they have brought upon themselves.

YoBeaches · 20/01/2022 22:31

@timshortfforthalia quite!

" I'd rather not interact with that potential buyer" - end of story

" I'd rather not interact with that potential buyer, because they are gay" - unlawful discrimination

Isaw3ships · 20/01/2022 22:31

‘ But you can, if you like, say I don’t want gay people in my home. Or I don’t want to sell them my home.’

Not the same thing at all. But, saying either of these things would make many people think that you’re a backward, bigoted fuckwit from the boondocks.
Just as someone saying I don't want black people in my home, I don’t want to sell my house to black people - then maybe add in some batshit crazy religious quote to keep it interesting - would make many people think they’re backward, racist fuckwits.
And in either of those cases I think it’s absolutely fine if the people being discriminated against decided to go public with the story.

5128gap · 20/01/2022 22:31

@Cultish

I’m just ignoring *@Cultish* from here on in. He’s a nasty bit of work (you’ll see up thread he called me a ‘thick cunt’ presumably because certain other slurs have been rightly criminalised)

😂 I didnt call you a thick cunt. I simply said that people might call you a thick cunt, in response to you calling the couple bigoted cunts. You seem to be quite at home refering to other people as cunts. You've said it plenty of times on this thread. Or is that ok in your mind, until it gets directed back at you 😉

Anyone who thinks that calling someone bigoted based on their behaviour is the same as calling someone thick as an insult, is probably deserving of one of those adjectives being ascribed to them. (Clue: it's not bigoted. On this occasion.)
timshortfforthalia · 20/01/2022 22:27

Why all the talk of the gay couple taking it to the papers? Its 2022. I imagine they tweeted about it (as you would) and then press got in touch with them.

One poster was suggesting that they went to the papers with photos of the Christians and the house Confused

What amazes me is how stupid the sellers were. Surely they could have just quietly pulled out of viewings without a reason. That way, they stick to their religious principles. Instead they not only told the buyers why, but quoted the bible. So much unecessary theatrics and escalation. They just had to be right. And that makes me have very limited sympathy for those claiming that we should protect them by not talking about their actions.

Cultish · 20/01/2022 22:21

I’m just ignoring @Cultish from here on in. He’s a nasty bit of work (you’ll see up thread he called me a ‘thick cunt’ presumably because certain other slurs have been rightly criminalised)

😂 I didnt call you a thick cunt. I simply said that people might call you a thick cunt, in response to you calling the couple bigoted cunts. You seem to be quite at home refering to other people as cunts. You've said it plenty of times on this thread. Or is that ok in your mind, until it gets directed back at you 😉

Ozanj · 20/01/2022 22:21

Discrimination on religious or cultural terms does happen and I know of many houses where EAs will ensure a property in a popular Hindu / Jewish / Muslim / Christian area is available to view by a customer on their books who is the right background first & so by the time the rest know about it or it goes on RM it’s sold. Never known other types of discrimination tho

Bitofachinwag · 20/01/2022 22:19

@Isaw3ships

‘ Yes the gay couple could have criticised them for it, in private, face to face. No need to "call people out" in the newspapers/internet all the time.

Will no one stand up for bigotry! How dare those gays go and shame the poor homophobes in public

Your comment is not relevant to what I said.
RobotValkyrie · 20/01/2022 22:17

But you can, if you like, say I don’t want gay people in my home. Or I don’t want to sell them my home.

Not a lawyer, but not convinced at all these two things are equivalent in the eye of the law.
Selling something (or not) is a commercial activity, a kind of service being provided. Even if it's not your main job/source of income, that kind of activity tends to be quite heavily regulated. Anything involving money generally is.
Inviting (or not) someone into your home isn't.

Isaw3ships · 20/01/2022 22:15

‘ Yes the gay couple could have criticised them for it, in private, face to face. No need to "call people out" in the newspapers/internet all the time.

Will no one stand up for bigotry! How dare those gays go and shame the poor homophobes in public