Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this couple's attitude has no place in modern society?

618 replies

Georama · 20/01/2022 18:35

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10419543/Christian-couple-ban-gay-man-partner-buying-dream-650-000-sexuality.html

A church-going wife who banned a gay man and his ITV producer partner from buying her £650,000 Surrey home has hit back in the row and insisted they are just sticking to their beliefs.

Luke Whitehouse and Lachlan Mantell were stunned when they were told that they could not buy the three-bedroom home because the Christian owners didn't want to sell to 'two men in a partnership.'

Honestly, they should be ashamed of that text. I hope no estate agent will work with them ever again.

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 02:18

There's having beliefs,
Expressing beliefs
But also
Being a dick about it.

IMO.

CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 02:15

Examples.

  1. 6th form a boy of a v strict group local to the area. Telling my goth mate all the body time. That she was a witch. Evil. Should repent. She was dangerous, an agent of Satan etc.
Humph. (I worried about his brother's future, he wasn't a good fit for that group. And leaving/being expelled vvv big deal for person who goes).
  1. Same group actually! When child. Group out high street weekends. Maybe 15 people in line.

Have to spread the word of God. Slight issue. Closed, no one allowed to join.

Answer? Inform passers by they are sinners, they are evil, they deserve to burn, they are headed for hell etc.

Yay? They were where walked past from my house. Holding mums hand age 4 to get bread. Burn, sinner!

CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 02:07

I have NEVER had any of that attitude from any other faith. Ever.

And I have no beef in general it's specifically those who can't help themselves from telling you they're better than anyone else.

What does that say?

CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 02:04

Having beliefs isn't the same aas-

Choosing to express them, in no uncertain terms, to random individuals. They could have said loads of other things to say sorry house not available.

But no.

They chose to, well. In my honest opinion, given what they wrote.

Grab the opportunity to put the boot in as hard as they could. I've come across, and no it's not that common. The sort of smug self righteousness a fair few times. I think you're SHIT and you can't argue because I'm simply a much better person.

What they wrote screams that attitude.

If someone is a total arsehole to you and uses excuse of faith. Then why on earth not act?

They did NOT need to write that at all. Their CHOICE. They can now see if there are any consequences.

Arnia · 21/01/2022 01:54

Deeply unpleasant and rather foolish if people are offering you good money but I somewhat disagree with you. I think there's a place for most unpleasant views in society even though I disagree with many. The absolutist part of me would love to shut them down but realistically I would rather their hateful views were free to be aired than everyone being policed for "wrongthink".

SantaClawsServiette · 21/01/2022 01:41

It's an odd approach, I think even for very orthodox Christians, but I think the reaction and newspaper story is inappropriate.

People will believe different things that you do, some of them you will not like. Other people sometimes really won't like the things you believe either.

We don't put their pictures in the paper, that achieves nothing. Act like a grown up and move on. Private sellers don't have to sell you their house, car, dog, vase, etc, for any reason. It doesn't have to be fair.

People talk about the value in diversity and pluralism. Well, that's what this is. A society where people have diverse worldviews and beliefs. That's what it looks like when you have multiple cultures. Having that means you can't be expecting validation from everyone.

CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 01:25

I have zero interest personally in seeing them prosecuted.

It would be entirely counter productive.

There is at least one Christian org who fund legal fees etc for cases that they think will in some way help their goal of getting various laws changed here.

A really bad idea.

I hope the gay couple find awesome home.

The couple who told the men they would not engage in a transaction with them because they were sinners.

The couple who said no can't sell house.

The physicist I'm guessing will find at work various things. Colleagues not impressed. Employer not impressed. Maybe others saying not prepared to work with her.

They did NOT need to behave this way. Sorry off market we got offer etc. Done.

Their decision to say you're sinners, look Bible reference, etc etc.

They brought this on themselves.

I can't understand anyone who says the MEN did wrong thing going to press! I mean FFS. The homosexuality is a sin couple brought this whole thing on themselves. Because they couldn't resist laying it on thick about just how disgusting the men were.

Lalliella · 21/01/2022 01:19

There is no clash here under the EA. Being a Christian does not mean being prejudiced against people for their sexual orientation. Having a weird and wrong interpretation of Christianity does. True Christians follow the teachings of Jesus, not the various hangers-on (mainly Paul in the New Testament) who wrote some of the bible. Jesus taught tolerance, acceptance, love, inclusion and non-judgementalism (is that a word?). I don’t believe he would have taught that being gay is wrong. Who cares who loves who in a consenting relationship? Why does it matter to anyone else?

Quit judging others, Surrey couple. Jesus told you not to, after all.

CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 00:58

For those supporting views similar to the above.

There are logical endpoints to consider here.

No not likely to happen. But it's always instructive to look at extremes to see if there's anything that could present a problem.

So extreme endpoints-

Christian couple are completely unable to sell their house, and when hunting anything they want to look at are told no. Don't agree with couples beliefs.

That's ok to those supporting right to express beliefs?

Couple go on holiday wherever without realising it's totally populated by a different religion. This religion has rule not to transact with Christians.

Hotel booked turns them away when arrive on I dunno. Bible t-shirts, crosses, striking up convo about Christian values as soon as arrive. Not unlikely, this couple seem pretty keen to let others know about their beliefs. At length.

Only one ferry a week to get away. Stuck there. No one will let them stay, sell them food, anything.

That's fine right? Yes pretty unlikely. But. Logically that would be fine.

And another more general question.

Christian couple gets knock on door. Panicked gay couple are being chased by gang of men with baseball bats, can see coming down road. Maybe add some of those flame stick bundles. Think terrifying middle ages type scene, and obviously after the blokes.

They beg to come in to shelter and call police etc.

What a bind!

Let them in house?
Blokes getting close they won't make it to another house knock wait etc.
They ARE sinners though.
If they decide no. And close door. The thugs aren't their fault. Maybe could tell themselves well don't want to get involved. Yes that's why.
Or just. Not going to help sinners.

That IS ok, right? I mean beliefs are beliefs.

Yes extremes.
The point is. A blanket adhere to beliefs everyone. Worth thinking what that approach actually allows.

CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 00:42

@WindInTheWillows7

YABU, because surely a modern society should be tolerant to all views and beliefs, and allow people to practise their religion freely, even where people find it offensive.
Hmm.
BashStreetKid · 21/01/2022 00:30

@WindInTheWillows7

YABU, because surely a modern society should be tolerant to all views and beliefs, and allow people to practise their religion freely, even where people find it offensive.
Why should we tolerate the expression of views and beliefs in ways that are against the law? Is it really acceptable for people to send religious texts telling another person that they're shameful and depraved?
Bucanarab · 21/01/2022 00:22

YABU, because surely a modern society should be tolerant to all views and beliefs, and allow people to practise their religion freely, even where people find it offensive.

So you believe that the radical Jihadi Islam that ISIS practice should be tolerated and that we should allow those who wish to follow it here in the UK to do so freely? An extreme example I grant you but what about those who wish to follow Salafism or Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh ideologies? Is it OK for them or is freedom of religous expression only ok for Christians?

handroid2049 · 21/01/2022 00:16

Well said @Elsiebear90 (sorry got a bit trigger happy with the post button before tagging)

handroid2049 · 21/01/2022 00:13

Well said

handroid2049 · 21/01/2022 00:11

Is it sad that I’m not remotely surprised? Unfortunately there are still a lot of people in society that think that way; some are just more vocal than others. Maybe I’m a bad gay and just not politically-minded enough nowadays, but I usually just let these comments slide because life is too short and I’d rather take my money elsewhere. For those without any experience of homophobia or similar discrimination, please try to understand that it can be a truly awful and humiliating experience. Free speech is a wonderful thing, but surely it shouldn’t come at the cost of someone’s rights or make them feel like a second-class citizen. Everyone should be entitled to their views but it’s another matter to use said views to actively discriminate against somebody. This has always been an emotive issue, but I do think that people on both sides of such conversations could often learn to be kinder and more tolerant though.

Elsiebear90 · 21/01/2022 00:01

No one is trying to police thoughts and opinions, they’re objecting to the couples actions. They may have some kind of legal loophole to discriminate because it’s a private sale, but that doesn’t mean they’re beyond criticism and the couple shouldn’t talk about the way they’ve been treated. If you don’t want people to expose you as a bigot don’t act like one in the first place.

CheeseMmmm · 20/01/2022 23:59

And having read it I think

Massive point

They didn't need to do that at all. They could have just assumed couple (I mean v safe bet surely). And said oh sorry we in negotiations had offer so sorry taking off market for a bit. Or something.

But they had to go all out to tell them they were sinners etc.

THAT'S for me a BIG thing.

Beliefs can be stuck to without being a bastard about it.

Smug horrible bastards.

CheeseMmmm · 20/01/2022 23:57

Christian man has 13 siblings!!!

V unusual here these days. Assume family follows pretty fundamental Christian beliefs as well.

I personally can't even begin to imagine carrying birthing caring for 14 kids. Each to their own obv i just couldn't deal with that at all.

DH would have had 3, my perinatal MH got worse each time and we knew that doing again could have severe long term consequences for me (if got through it).

I always wonder about MH in societies, religious groups, before contraception. How women who got MH issues Pg etc carried on tbh.

Sorry side track!

Migrainesbythedozen · 20/01/2022 23:56

I think this needed to be called out, and the homophobic couple needed and deserved to be publicly shamed and held up to public ridicule.

BoredZelda · 20/01/2022 23:50

But then aren’t we heading back to the time it was fine for B&Bs, landlords and shop owners to stick signs up saying no blacks, no Irish, no Jews?

No, because B&Bs are business and in that situation there are laws that prevent that.

If we want to start policing the views and opinions of others, maybe think about what would happen if something you firmly believed it became something you could no longer talk about.

ZuleikaDobson · 20/01/2022 23:48

@BoredZelda

I disagree. The gay couple were treated differently because of their sexual Orientation as a protected characteristic. They were unlawfully discriminated against.

Then you don't really understand the laws about discrimination.

So why do you say they weren't discriminated against, given the legal provisions quoted in this thread?
CheeseMmmm · 20/01/2022 23:47

Couple making point thinking will get to press and they can open some kind of 'debate'?

I mean it's bizarre. Why would anyone care what sort of people buy their house?

Unless they needed to cohabit with the buyers for a while Grin

I mean FFS.

I assume they don't car boot, sell anything on eBay etc!

Who do they work for? Anything that has any part in anything to do with general people (IE pretty much everything!) then they're betraying their beliefs every day!

Even day working for an oil company. No doubt some of the energy, petrol, plastics etc produced might well end up in the hands of homosexuals.

Silly fuckers.

What if they move somewhere and turns out neighbours same sex couples? What if local shops for milk etc have Gay Connections. Avoid the shifts when that man who looks a bit, well suspicious, is working? I mean. Those shirts he wears are a bit flamboyant aren't they. The milk will probably have gone off due to presence of sinner.

Etc etc.

FFS.

And omg how can they carry on at work? HR time surely. Things public reflecting badly on company gets you sacked...

I should read it prob so many questions!

BoredZelda · 20/01/2022 23:47

Not the same thing at all. But, saying either of these things would make many people think that you’re a backward, bigoted fuckwit from the boondocks.

It is exactly the same thing. A person has the right to do whatever they like with their home whether it be selling it or inviting people in.

A reminder that these people were using the exact same freedom of expression as you are using to insult them. You might want to reflect on that.

PickAChew · 20/01/2022 23:46

I hope they get dozens of people showing an interest and offering no more than half the asking price.

WhatScratch · 20/01/2022 23:46

Freedom of speech, which we don’t have, should not and does not equal the right to refuse to do business with someone because of their colour, religion or sexuality. If I had a shop near that couple it wouldn’t be acceptable for me to refuse to sell them milk and bread because they’re (allegedly) Christians.

Swipe left for the next trending thread