Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this couple's attitude has no place in modern society?

618 replies

Georama · 20/01/2022 18:35

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10419543/Christian-couple-ban-gay-man-partner-buying-dream-650-000-sexuality.html

A church-going wife who banned a gay man and his ITV producer partner from buying her £650,000 Surrey home has hit back in the row and insisted they are just sticking to their beliefs.

Luke Whitehouse and Lachlan Mantell were stunned when they were told that they could not buy the three-bedroom home because the Christian owners didn't want to sell to 'two men in a partnership.'

Honestly, they should be ashamed of that text. I hope no estate agent will work with them ever again.

OP posts:
OneTC · 21/01/2022 09:28

I don't think the comparisons to bans on black/Irish/traveller people hold up, because it is not the fact that the buyers are gay and have this protected characteristic which is the issue for the sellers, it is the fact that they are in a gay relationship, which is a lifestyle choice, not a characteristic.

odfod

handroid2049 · 21/01/2022 09:26

@WindInTheWillows7 ‘ The issue is whether in law, there is a distinction between protected characteristics and lifestyle.’

I’m not a legal professional but my understanding of the EA is that there is no distinction. Certainly the guidance around it I read states that ‘ In the Equality Act, sexual orientation includes how you choose to express your sexual orientation.’ It also gives discrimination following the mention of a partner as an example of direct discrimination.

Also on a side note, that view is rather naive - not all single LGB people are celibate. Therefore, there is no guarantee that a single gay person would have ‘practiced their homosexuality’ any less in that house. Moreover, there is no guarantee that two people in a same-sex partnership are not celibate.

whatkatydid2013 · 21/01/2022 09:24

The couple selling the house could, if they really felt that strongly about not selling to someone who didn’t follow the teaching of their religion, have chosen to exclusively advertise their property privately via their church. It would have limited the pool of possible buyers and likely reduced the offers they might get but would have avoided the possibility of having all manner of “unsuitable” people viewing the house. They chose to list it openly with an agent and could reasonably have expected to have many, many people who don’t follow the same religious teachings as them wanting to view/buy it. They then chose not only to deny a viewing to someone but to send them a message insulting them with quotes from the bible. They are free to do that and I wouldn’t support prosecuting them for it. Equally they chose to do it and have to live with the consequence that a large portion of people think their behaviour was rude, bigoted, discriminatory, unchristian etc. It may have their employer calling into question their ability to leave aside their personal prejudices when dealing with colleagues in the future & it may put a lot of people off buying their home/selling to them. It serves them right really as they had no need to be so nasty.
They could easily have quietly exercised their beliefs by selling a different way but they instead chose to be very hurtful to someone else. Living in a society with lots of different views doesn’t require we find those who disagree with us and then insult them.

Elsiebear90 · 21/01/2022 09:23

Being gay or being in a same sex relationship*

Elsiebear90 · 21/01/2022 09:21

[quote WindInTheWillows7]@thedancingbear what you or I think about it is irrelevant. The issue is whether in law, there is a distinction between protected characteristics and lifestyle.[/quote]
I’ve heard this “it’s a lifestyle choice to engage in your sinful homosexual desires, so the consequences of that are on you”, before and people seem to think it’s nice little get out of jail free card to justify their homophobia. It’s not and it isn’t a legally valid defence either. If I go to a hotel and ask for a room with my fiancée and they say “are you two in a relationship? Yes? Well we can’t let you stay here because you will be practicing your gayness under our roof” that’s still discrimination and is illegal. Now in this case as it’s a private sale I don’t know if that applies, but either way there is no legal difference between discriminating against someone for being or being in a same sex relationship.

etulosba · 21/01/2022 09:20

Romans bit they cited

King James version as specified

The understanding of ancient languages has improved in the 400 years since the King James Version was translated. As has the English language.

Isaw3ships · 21/01/2022 09:15

‘ Naming and photographing the Christian couple is awful. Everyone is entitled to their views and beliefs.’

Beliefs and views are one thing, however disgusting. Refusing someone a service or affecting their lives adversely because of those views - another thing entirely.
I think Evangelical Christians are batshit and dangerous in many cases, would I ever refuse
to sell them a house, rent them a room, give them a table in restaurant?
No, because I’m not. Bigot and discrimination is discrimination.
Anyone defending them because of their ‘beliefs’ need to have a good hard look at themselves. Racists believe that they are superior in some way to people of color - but refusing to sell a
house to a black couple would cause outrage and wouldn’t be defended as okay because of the sellers ‘beliefs’.
They’d be called out just like these homophobes are being called out.
If you want to quote bible verses at gay people telling them they’re ‘sinful’ then expect some comeback.

OneTC · 21/01/2022 09:13

And the NT says literally nothing about homosexuality

Except the bit the homophobes quoted to them I guess?

Innocenta · 21/01/2022 09:10

[quote WindInTheWillows7]@thedancingbear what you or I think about it is irrelevant. The issue is whether in law, there is a distinction between protected characteristics and lifestyle.[/quote]
It's not irrelevant when you are posting on a public forum defending homophobic bigotry.

WindInTheWillows7 · 21/01/2022 09:09

@thedancingbear what you or I think about it is irrelevant. The issue is whether in law, there is a distinction between protected characteristics and lifestyle.

thedancingbear · 21/01/2022 09:07

[quote WindInTheWillows7]@thedancingbear there is a distinction between same-sex attraction and same-sex practice... I personally know several Christians who are gay and celibate. They are open about the fact that they are same-sex attracted, it's who they are, they've never been attracted to the opposite sex and probably never will, but they make a firm distinction between attraction and actions. The point isn't whether you find that wrong/sad/offensive, but that there is a distinction which some gay people themselves even make.[/quote]
Ah, you're one of them. 'I've got gay friends, you know, and they manage not to bum each other, so why can't you?'.

Okay, fine. I'll leave you to it.

WindInTheWillows7 · 21/01/2022 09:07

@Bitofachinwag

dancingbear most Christians follow guidance in the New Testament, not the Old Testament (Leviticus is).
Massive over simplification. Christians believe that the God who gave the Isaraelites the Mosaic law in the wilderness is the very same God who came to die on a cross for the people's sins. The whole of the Old Testament points to the New.
handroid2049 · 21/01/2022 09:06

@WindInTheWillows7 so I guess it’s perfectly fine to discriminate against any gay or lesbian person in a relationship then? Please enlighten me as to why this is acceptable?

WindInTheWillows7 · 21/01/2022 09:05

@thedancingbear there is a distinction between same-sex attraction and same-sex practice... I personally know several Christians who are gay and celibate. They are open about the fact that they are same-sex attracted, it's who they are, they've never been attracted to the opposite sex and probably never will, but they make a firm distinction between attraction and actions. The point isn't whether you find that wrong/sad/offensive, but that there is a distinction which some gay people themselves even make.

thedancingbear · 21/01/2022 08:57

@Bitofachinwag

dancingbear most Christians follow guidance in the New Testament, not the Old Testament (Leviticus is).
I agree absolutely. And the NT says literally nothing about homosexuality. Anywhere. Jesus never mentioned the subject.

The only reference to homosexuality in the Bible is in the OT, in Leviticus, the rest of which is batshit crazy too.

thedancingbear · 21/01/2022 08:55

@burnoutbabe

Has it been discussed what people would do if a clearly homophobic couple wanted to buy your house? Or clearly racist? (And even more so if you have neighbours who may then be targeted)

Would you want to sell to them.

Plenty of people decide not to sell to people who are just downright rude to them during a viewing.

So yes I think anyone should be allowed not to sell if they don't want to.

There's a good reason why the equalities act protects gay people; people of colour; disabled people etc. and not homophobes and racists.

Can you take a guess as to what that might be? Go on, try.

AlexaShutUp · 21/01/2022 08:54

@burnoutbabe

Has it been discussed what people would do if a clearly homophobic couple wanted to buy your house? Or clearly racist? (And even more so if you have neighbours who may then be targeted)

Would you want to sell to them.

Plenty of people decide not to sell to people who are just downright rude to them during a viewing.

So yes I think anyone should be allowed not to sell if they don't want to.

But you can't compare being gay to being homophobic! One is a protected characteristic, the other is just a bigot!
Bitofachinwag · 21/01/2022 08:54

dancingbear most Christians follow guidance in the New Testament, not the Old Testament (Leviticus is).

BashStreetKid · 21/01/2022 08:54

@Nutsohazelnuts

Of course this is all kinds of wrong, and I’m not for a moment in favour of discriminating against anyone. But:
  • It does point-blank say in the Bible that homosexuality is wrong.
  • People do believe the Bible and adhere to its teachings.
  • We live in a society where we are, thankfully, still able to say what we think and live according to our own beliefs.
  • Therefore, you have to argue that the vendors are within their rights to refuse this sale.
No, you don't have to argue it, because what the Bible says doesn't override the law. If this was correct, people would be free to bar gay people from shops, restaurants, hotels, schools etc; and fortunately, they aren't.
thedancingbear · 21/01/2022 08:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post.

burnoutbabe · 21/01/2022 08:52

Has it been discussed what people would do if a clearly homophobic couple wanted to buy your house? Or clearly racist? (And even more so if you have neighbours who may then be targeted)

Would you want to sell to them.

Plenty of people decide not to sell to people who are just downright rude to them during a viewing.

So yes I think anyone should be allowed not to sell if they don't want to.

BashStreetKid · 21/01/2022 08:50

@OneTC

It’s good to know it’s against the equalities act. Can they be prosecuted?

It's a bit less clear cut than bash Street kid is presenting. It seems to be important that you've involved an estate agent, which purple bricks technically aren't

There's nothing in the Act that says it only applies if you're selling through an estate agent. The significance of doing so is presumably that an estate agent who follows instructions to screen out certain buyers with protected characteristics will also be acting in breach of the Act.
WindInTheWillows7 · 21/01/2022 08:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

thedancingbear · 21/01/2022 08:48

- It does point-blank say in the Bible that homosexuality is wrong.

It also says not to wear mixed fibre textiles; that people with physical deformities cannot go to church; that if a man's brother dies, he has to shag his wife; and that swearing at your parents is punishable by death (mainly, but not only, Leviticus, which is where the single reference to homosexuality resides).

At no point did Jesus say a word about gay people.

When the sellers here also refuse to sell their house to someone wearing a cotton/lycra blend top, then I will, at least, applaud them for their consistency and rigour. But until that point, I will work on the presumption that they are using their religion as a smokescreen for bigotry. They can fuck off to the far side of fuck.

And before anyone misrepresents me again, I recognise that what they have done is legal, and I don't think the law should be changed.

BashStreetKid · 21/01/2022 08:47

@Omicrone

If what the Christian couple has done is indeed illegal, then why have the other couple gone to the Daily Mail instead of to court?

Let the courts deal with it, and let the authorities be the one to release any personal information that they deem to be in the public interest.

There are all sorts of perfectly sensible reasons for choosing not to go to court, starting with the expense.