Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that assisted deliveries are more dangerous than we are led to believe

166 replies

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 17:20

Last September I suffered severe injuries as the result of a ventouse delivery that I did not consent to. I am still in recovery. Since the incident, I have sought out other women who have had similar experiences and I'm coming to the conclusion that assisted deliveries are more dangerous than we are led to believe. AIBU to feel this? Have any mumsnet users suffered similarly?

OP posts:
TearifficTaz · 20/01/2022 19:16

YANBU

We are one of the few 1st world countries to still use forceps for example

In countries with better health care most would be straight in for a C-section the second anything looked like it might end up with an assisted delivery

One of the many reasons I went for an elective C section for mine.

The NHS does it to save money, not for womens health

Staryflight445 · 20/01/2022 19:14

Lulu1027

@AppleBlueberryPie You are absolutely right. As women, it's essential that we speak openly about birth experienceseven traumatic onesso that we can make informed choices. If I ever have another child I will be having an elcs.

Why op? I think a c section has 3 x the risk of a natural birth?
I lost just over 2 litres of blood due to an episiotomy with my first child, I had a perfectly normal delivery with no assistance for my second.

Unless a doctor is seriously recommending you have a section, I’m not sure it’s the right choice to make statistically?

monfuseds · 20/01/2022 19:12

thinkchildbirthis more dangerous than we are led to believe tbh.

I agree

I had a semi elective CS & they used a ventouse, very common apparently.

Staryflight445 · 20/01/2022 19:11

I agree with what you’ve said @AppleBlueberryPie it concerns me that people romanticise their birth experience, like it’s a happy event like a wedding or proposal or something.

I’ve noticed many women feel so angry over their birth trauma they fail to realise it was either that or losing their babies or their life. That is the risk. Giving birth is a means to an end, the issue is peoples attitude towards birth and their values to it, instead of realising how dangerous it is and actually, how important it is to be fully informed before giving birth.

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 19:10

@AppleBlueberryPie You are absolutely right. As women, it's essential that we speak openly about birth experienceseven traumatic onesso that we can make informed choices. If I ever have another child I will be having an elcs.

@Chasingaftermidnight Agreed!

@LashesZ "Also NO one tells you about assisted births beforehand. I had to Google it." They don't! In fact, when I took the hospital's prenatal course they glossed over ventouse deliveries because "you'd never have one."

@madmomma That's wonderful. You see, my doctor clearly did not have the skill to perform the assisted delivery. My injuries are not normal, even for an assisted delivery. If it were only the 3rd degree tear I wouldn't be complaining. I also suffered an internal tear of some description (which he mentioned briefly at the time but is not recorded in my medical records) and I can plainly see that I was torn all the way up either side of my labia minora (also not recorded). I'm grateful that I've healed well and none of the stitches came undone, but it looks like I received a labiaplasty, which is incredibly violating.

@UnderTheMoonlightWeDanced That level of communication and compassion would make all the difference.

OP posts:
Scotabroad24 · 20/01/2022 19:06

Yes. I gave birth in 2020 overseas where i live. Dh wasnt allowed in at any point so i was totally alone, i do speak the language here but not fluently. I had long painful labour, failed epidural. I was exhausted and had 2 previous nights of no sleep.
Was snapped at by a nurse who asked me 'why I seemed to be giving up'... after 16 hours strapped to the ctg machine on my back I had no strength left and was in so much pain.
Doctor came in just before midnight and forced my feet into the stirrups (I had previously asked please not to have to put my feet in as my spine felt like it was splitting and I couldn't breathe through the pain) then a nurse came and was holding my arms down to the side of the bed, I had absolutely no idea what they were doing to me and think I was crying hysterically by this point, I heard the word episiotomy in other language and asked them to please explain to me in English which they didn't. I can barely remember what happened next nor ds being placed on me... they gave me an episiotomy which I didn't consent to, ventouse delivery, and I had also torn. Ds was then taken away to be weighed and dressed and I was left on the bed with my legs in stirrups, blood everywhere for around 20 minutes until the doctor came back to stitch me.

The entire thing was inhumane and disgraceful. It took me months to recover and I still struggle to think about it all.

JustWonderingIfYou · 20/01/2022 18:55

I don't think they are more dangerous than we are led to believe. There are risks, anyone whos done any kind of antenatal class is aware of them. Everyone i know has tried to avoid instrumental deliveries. Sometimes its too late to though of baby's head is too far down the birth canal. They haven't smudged the stats or anything.

I would actually say c sections are far more dangerous than we are led to believe. Alwasy treated as routine and an easy option. I've met women with permanent spinal injuries from c sections.

ItsSnowJokes · 20/01/2022 18:43

I had in my birth plan that I would want a CS rather than an instrumental delivery and I drummed it in to husband that I do not consent to an instrumental delivery at all. A good friend was severely injured from her birth and I just didn't want the same.

madmomma · 20/01/2022 18:27

I had a forceps delivery due to maternal exhaustion. The wonderful female doctor asked if she could perform an episiotomy and I said no so she didn't. She got him out with no blood loss, no tears, not even a graze. Amazing woman. Still felt like I'd had a bus driven out of me for weeks, and it took years to get proper tone back. It was way more traumatic than the planned section I had with the next baby. That was bloody brilliant, and much nicer for the baby I expect!

LashesZ · 20/01/2022 18:16

Forceps here. It was only on day 2 I realise I had an episiotomy when I was having a sneaky read of my notes. I suppose as it was an emergency, there was no time for informed consent (buzzer to birth in 9 minutes) but yknow.. maybe something afterwards would have helped.

Also NO one tells you about assisted births beforehand. I had to Google it.

SummerHouse · 20/01/2022 18:12

Third degree tear and ventouse for me.

I was out of it and don't remember it all clearly. I know they were very apologetic and I since think that this was a delay in putting in a catheter (so pushing onto a full bladder).

I think mistakes were made but they are human. And certainly where the NHS is concerned, they are constrained by resources and hindered by a system that is very far from a tight ship.

For a long time it felt like my innards were going to fall out but I was lucky to heal well and I think running helped (although felt very wrong for a long time).

The difference for me was, each and every medical professional was really decent, kind, caring and just brilliant at their job. It sounds like you had the opposite - dismissive, belittling and mean.

Mistakes happened, better medical choices could have been made, I think someone acknowledging that to you would have made a very big difference.

UnderTheMoonlightWeDanced · 20/01/2022 18:09

Forceps, bad 3rd degree tear and episiotomy over here!
It was very traumatising but the next day the surgeon came and saw me and walked me through each second from the moment he came in the room. He showed me on a heart rate print out where my babies heart beat practically disappeared, each action he took at each point and why he had to make a snap decision not to do c section as he thought she wouldn’t make it while they prepped for it.
I have to say without the debrief I would have been a lot more traumatised by how quick and scary it all was. I now have the strength of knowledge that even though it left me in a state down there my baby is alive because of their quick actions and I’m grateful. The doctor was so conscientious and kind when talking to me the next day and acknowledged it was a very traumatising thing to go through and put my feelings about it very central so I do think he was focussed on me but during the birth his main priority was getting my baby out alive which I agree with.
My husband had a bit more knowledge “in the moment” because he had watched along with the midwife the heartbeat getting more and more in distress.

RasputinsPickledPenis · 20/01/2022 18:05

I had a ventouse delivery but it wasn't until I was pregnant again five years later that I found out I'd lost a lot of blood, and my placenta had disintegrated so had to be removed manually, and I should have been offered counselling due to it being traumatic.

I opted for a caesarean this time.

Chasingaftermidnight · 20/01/2022 18:05

No but then women should be aware of the facts before they give birth, not misled on the different modes of delivery as I believe they currently are, and if a woman wants an ELCS, she should get one without having to fight for it and be able to make an informed choice.

Exactly. A lot of information is withheld from women, or at least not presented to us upfront - for example, the age-related risks of needing an instrumental delivery, and the risks associated with instrumental delivery. I can’t remember the exact figures but I remember being staggered at the chances of instrumental delivery if giving birth for the first time aged 35+.

And this information is presumably kept from women in order to stop them from requesting ELCSs. It’s better to cut them and drag babies out of them with salad tongs round the head.

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 18:01

@JaneTheVirgin "Also remember though that at the time it may have been the only way to save your baby."

I came home from the hospital thinking this, but as I slowly began to understand the gravity of my injuries I wondered if I had been properly cared for. Then I ordered my medical records and realized that my doctor stated that I gave informed consent (I did not). Also, he only recorded my 3rd-degree perineal tear (when I had additional external and internal injuries). To this day I don't fully understand what repairs were made to my body. This is wrong. If there were no other option why didn't he just tell me so, inform me of my injuries, and help me with after care? My uncle, who is the head of obstetrics at a large university hospital, reviewed my medical records and, even before I told him of the additional injuries he said they were strangely brief. He's advised me to see a urogynecologist and a lawyer.

OP posts:
DSGR · 20/01/2022 18:01

There are studies looking at this. Speaking to other mothers is not a controlled study.
For what it’s worth I had a ventouse delivery and it was fine and got out my floppy baby, who then needed oxygen. I was so grateful.
I’ve also had epidurals and drugs with no issues.

AppleBlueberryPie · 20/01/2022 18:01

The vast majority of women are all co-conspirators in normalising a hugely fucking risky experience that is natural birth. The risk of birth injury is 40% and the risk of needing an emergency section is around 30%. I'm forever grateful to MN for reading honest, anonymous accounts from women about their birth choices because every single person in my real life touted natural birth like there's no tomorrow.

A happy, natural birth needs to be seen as an incredibly fortunate gift, not the norm that everyone person in labour should expect. Most women have no idea how quickly things can go wrong and suffer in silence with birth injuries, mental trauma etc. Pregnant women are given the impression that you will have a memorable natural birth 90% of the time, and maybe 10% risk of complications. The real stats are extremely different.

My logic is that if I went into a situation with a one in THREE chance of ending up with major surgery then I would rather just choose the elective surgery and get it done with. Exactly what I did and had a wonderfully peaceful ELCS. Zero pain, in-and-out within 25 minutes and no problems BF afterwards. Interestingly, I was allowed the ELCS on the basis that I have a medical condition that increases the possibility of needing ventouse delivery. So for the OP, yes, assisted delivery is dangerous and a proven link is sufficient grounds for ELCS.

MilduraS · 20/01/2022 17:59

I think generally if a childbirth reaches the point of requiring assisted delivery it's because it's already more dangerous than an uneventful birth. I didn't know I had an episiotomy at the time but had pre-agreed with my consultant that if it was needed I didn't want to be told. I had an epidural and didn't feel much. DD came out on her own but my placenta got stuck and I felt all the tugging then. I ended up in surgery due to bleeding. It turned out I had mild placenta accreta that was missed on ultrasounds so I feel quite lucky. Severe cases can require a c section and hysterectomy at the same time.

LumosSolem · 20/01/2022 17:58

@plantathon

All birth is more dangerous than 21st century women in think.

Elective C sections are not the simple procedure everyone thinks it is.

No but then women should be aware of the facts before they give birth, not misled on the different modes of delivery as I believe they currently are, and if a woman wants an ELCS, she should get one without having to fight for it and be able to make an informed choice.

Have had two ELCS and it was fantastic both times. Painful for a couple of days yes but I recovered quickly both times with no ill effects at all. Would never have wanted anything different and feel very lucky.

ELCS is very different from an EMCS. Especially if you are choosing it when there is perhaps not a physical medical indication for it. Of course there will be a small number of people who have a different experience to me. But there are high numbers of women who have dreadful, traumatic experiences of vaginal deliveries. Who have very difficult recoveries and longlasting injuries.

Chasingaftermidnight · 20/01/2022 17:56

I agree with you. And I think the risks of instrumental deliveries (to both mother and baby) are underplayed in comparison to the risks associated with caesareans.

yourestandingonmyneck · 20/01/2022 17:55

@LalaMelyn

I think childbirth is more dangerous than we are led to believe tbh.

Have you had a birth debrief type thing? Its sounds very traumatic Sad

I agree with this.

Childbirth can be terrifying.

I had an assisted delivery. It wasn't pleasant, but the baby wasn't coming out. There was no other option and it was incredibly scary.

It was the best (only) option available.

plantathon · 20/01/2022 17:52

All birth is more dangerous than 21st century women in think.

Elective C sections are not the simple procedure everyone thinks it is.

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 17:51

@SoftPillow "I believe that the medical professional in inherently biased to cause woman worse outcomes then men, and that in childbirth we are often treated with such disrespect and inhumanity that I wonder why we put up with it."

Couldn't have put it better myself. Thank you @ SoftPillow

OP posts:
SilverontheTree · 20/01/2022 17:51

I did a lot of research and came to the contact that I would only have an ELCS. I would urge anyone who is at all worried to do the same in the same circumstances (first baby at 35, history of multiple losses, ICSI baby, only wanted one.)

JaneTheVirgin · 20/01/2022 17:49

I agree that it's CHILDBIRTH that's more risky than women are ever told, not necessarily instrumental delivery. Usually they're used in a situation where it may very well be babies life or death, and a CS would be more risky due to birth canal positioning.

Have you spoken to your medical professional yet? Asked for a debrief?

Medical staff can and do get it wrong, so ask your questions. Educate yourself with everything you may need to ask those questions effectively and understand their answers so you know what to ask as follow ups. Also remember though that at the time it may have been the only way to save your baby. It may not be the case, but it's a strong possibility.