Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that assisted deliveries are more dangerous than we are led to believe

166 replies

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 17:20

Last September I suffered severe injuries as the result of a ventouse delivery that I did not consent to. I am still in recovery. Since the incident, I have sought out other women who have had similar experiences and I'm coming to the conclusion that assisted deliveries are more dangerous than we are led to believe. AIBU to feel this? Have any mumsnet users suffered similarly?

OP posts:
PiesNotGuys · 20/01/2022 22:36

I refused consent for any touching in labour, I was not to be touched by anyone, even dh, unless I actually, specifically asked to be.

It did confuse the midwives at first and more than once they pestered me with requests for touching eg an examination, even though I’d said no. They kept saying it would be easier for them if I consented to touch but it would not have been easier for me. I do wonder if this request led to more watchfulness, and more listening to my actual words, than if I’d consented to touch. I do wonder if there might be a bit of a conveyor belt mentality to birth for some medical professionals. Habits, too. And probably a large side of misogyny, even from the women (you just wait, you’ll be screaming, leave your dignity at the door blah blah blah, all shit misogynistic tropes)

As it is, with lots of luck and good fortune I have actually been through all my births without touch from a medical professional (and from DH either as I’ve can bugger right off when I’m in labour).

The system is broken if we have women coming through it so traumatised. I’m so sorry for those struggling with birth injuries.

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 22:32

@Tmwtgg Thank you. Exactly. Men would never stand for this kind of treatment.

OP posts:
Spudbitch · 20/01/2022 22:28

I'm sorry for your trauma sounds like the issue is them Not fully informing you of everything. It has taken me years to get over giving birth to my 1st child and am currently waiting to have an operation to fix things caused by that. My baby was in severe distress with heart rate dropping and it was an emergency situation suddenly the room was full of people my feet were in stirrups and a doctor was using a ventouse that didn't work so forceps came out don't think i even noticed what they used all I could think was oh my god baby is goona die and so am I (dangerously low blood pressure or so I thought) the doc and midwife had a disagreement with her telling him off and that he needs to wait for a contraction before pulling, him telling her he's getting baby out now and doesn't need to wait for contraction. Felt like he was pulling my whole body inside out anyway much blood n gore n stitches later baby comes out without a noise is whisked off to be resuscitated then all is fine except for bruising to his eye that lasted 15 years and suction marks on his head and face, I was in a lot of pain couldn't walk for a week or so and then had prolapse however I am grateful they saved my child and don't really care about injuries as if they hadn't done that baby could have died and what's worse? Pretty sure they didnt tell me what they were doing as they were too busy getting baby out there was no debriefing and I am sure I did have some sort of post traumatic shock but I understand childbirth is risky and don't blame anyone for it. Perhaps you need to see your records again to understand what went wrong and why they did what they did. I hope you get the answers you need.

Atla · 20/01/2022 22:27

I was supposed to have elcs with ds2 but he scuppered that plan by arriving 6 weeks early.

Atla · 20/01/2022 22:26

Not to be devil's advocate, but without a high forceps (keilands) delivery ds1 and I could both have died, because he was stuck in the birth canal and I was haemorrhaging.

Was it traumatic? Yes, very. Did I want it? No I did not. But, it was an emergency, too late for a cs and they had to get him out. Both of us are alive and well, 10 years later. Without medical intervention this story would not have had a happy ending.

Jathro · 20/01/2022 22:25

A family members baby died due to excessive force used a forceps delivery. They have been heavily affected by PTSD and flashbacks of seeing the damage to the skull of their newborn baby. It ruined a lot of lives. I am electing for a caesarean out of fear of what she went through.

Pbbananabagel · 20/01/2022 22:23

My first baby was showing very big for dates so after researching the implications of shoulder dysplasia etc I specifically wrote in my birth plan that I did not consent to forceps and in the event of difficulty would want to speak with a consultant prior to use of ventouse or episiotomy. As it happens after multiple attempts to induce me and then having my waters broken but baby still not coming, the consultant fully agreed and we moved to c section. I was then recommended a second c section with my next very large baby and I have no regrets whatsoever. If you write in your notes what you and do not consent to or state explicitly that you expect to be informed every step of the way then that is what they have to do.

axillarytailofspence · 20/01/2022 22:20

I had an assisted delivery in 1985. My daughter was in the occipital posterior position ie back to back. It was Christmas Eve. I often wonder if her birth was induced because it was Christmas. I later trained to be a midwife. I spent my career advocating for women to try to prevent such birth trauma and its' lasting consequences.

Midwife.

3cats4poniesandababy · 20/01/2022 22:20

Form my experience intervention would be needed a lot less if we had attentive midwives who listened to patients. Almost everyone I know who had birth trauma had one common theme- midwives didn't listen, I said I was I active labour but midwives didn't listen, I asked for pain relief but midwives didn't listen. I asked for support on the postnatal ward but was ignored.

Why aren't woman being listen too? Why do midwives ignore woman, you know the patient who is actually giving birth?

WhiteJellycat · 20/01/2022 22:11

I had vontose but it was all made very clear why it was needed. Ds was back to back presenting with his head tilted to the side and the cord to short to move down the birth canal because it was wrapped around his neck ( didnt know that until he was born).

The midwife who delivered him told me on the ward the next day I could have pushed forever, it was impossible for him to come down.

Because of that I dont have any bad feelings about it. I'd be dead without intervention at so many points in that pregnancy. I had pre eclampsia.

I think you need to find out as much as you can so you find some peace. For me, no amount of me doing anything could have prevented pre eclampsia or vontose. Therefore I can look back and be ok. Mind you that took time. It took about three months to hit me ( more about the PE but in turn induction, very fast birth, vontose) a good two years to even think about having another. But the alternative was not getting out of the hospital.

Dont dismiss your feelings. But do think about steps to process it by finding out all you can.

LumosSolem · 20/01/2022 22:10

@randomsabreuse I think the focus should be on listening to women and ensuring that they are able to make properly informed choices right from the beginning of pregnancy. And they feel in control of their choices and are respected.

I can't comment on what is easier to recover from- CS or a vaginal delivery, because I have only had ELCS. I had pain afterwards but I recovered really quickly and really well with no lasting effects at all. The truth is it is really does seem to be a lottery- can have a really rough recovery from a VB or very easy, and vice versa for CS.

giggly · 20/01/2022 22:08

@Lulu1027

Last September I suffered severe injuries as the result of a ventouse delivery that I did not consent to. I am still in recovery. Since the incident, I have sought out other women who have had similar experiences and I'm coming to the conclusion that assisted deliveries are more dangerous than we are led to believe. AIBU to feel this? Have any mumsnet users suffered similarly?
If you are actively seeking out woman who have had similar experience that is going to give you a bias. I had ventouse which I didn’t consent to however my baby was stuck and I had complete faith in my delivery team to make the right decision for the safe delivery of my baby. Any harm to me I would see as incidental in the safe delivery.
BiscuitLover3678 · 20/01/2022 22:08

@LumosSolem I’m considering an elective next time for this reason. I have very mixed feelings about it though. The aftercare isn’t great and if I recover worse I don’t want to be stuck in hospital any longer than I have to.

BiscuitLover3678 · 20/01/2022 22:07

I still remember the doctor, male and very young, not understanding why I wanted to avoid forceps. He couldn’t fathom why I might be scared of having an assisted delivery. “ just have an epidural it doesn’t matter. C section is way worse”. He had no fucking idea.

LumosSolem · 20/01/2022 22:06

[quote BiscuitLover3678]@LumosSolem and most women just come out saying “at least we’re both ok” ie alive. Rarely anyone does anything about it. It’s a very vulnerable situation to be in.[/quote]
Agreed @BiscuitLover3678- its an incredibly vulnerable position to be in.

It's bizarre really isn't it- I actively chose the biggest medical intervention possible, an ELCS under GA- I was completely passive. But at the same time I knew all the steps that would happen and I therefore felt completely in control. It made a real difference I think. But that is what was best for me.

Tmwtgg · 20/01/2022 22:06

There is also a tendency in the medical profession to dismiss thing like prolapse, pelvic floor trauma, incontinence as minor issues. Fine, they don’t kill you. But for so many women they are desperately traumatic and distressing injuries to live with. I don’t think I’ve seen many studies accounting for that.

But god forbid that a man should have to put up with erectile dysfunction. That doesn't kill you either, yet funnily enough the health profession isn't telling men to put up and shut up. Meanwhile women with life changing birth injuries are being told that it's an inevitable side-effect of having a baby and to get on with it.

Houseofvelour · 20/01/2022 22:05

YANBU I've heard so many horror stories that on my birth plan, in red print I had:

I DO NOT CONSENT TO THE USE OF FORCEPS OR VENTUOSE. IN THE EVENT THAT ASSISTANCE IS NEEDED, I WOULD LIKE TO OPT FOR AN URGENT C SECTION.

When you put the word consent in, they usually take it seriously.

One of my friend's sons had a forceps birth and had brain damage as a result.

BiscuitLover3678 · 20/01/2022 22:05

I’m still angry about my birth experience. Pretty much every woman I know who gave birth in a hospital is.

Hopefully this is something that we look back on and think fuck that! Women really didn’t mean much did they? (Look back because it’s changed).

randomsabreuse · 20/01/2022 22:03

I'm honestly not convinced that a C-section is so much easier than a vaginal birth. I've not had a C-section and my only experience of abdominal surgery was a laparoscopic appendectomy but I much preferred dealing with my (admittedly only 2nd degree) tears/stitches than the recovery from the appendix.

I'd be more focused on improving post birth care, ensuring decent natural light in all post natal locations, putting in a routine physio assessment for pelvic floor function instead of the box ticking based 6 week check.

I'd also like to see a lot more help available on post natal wards - so you have someone to pass you the baby, help you get food etc, regular pain relief etc when you need it rather than being made to feel inconvenient. The contrast between the medical ward with my appendix where they happily helped me to the toilet etc as I was a bit dizzy and post natal where it was basically your baby, your problem...

BiscuitLover3678 · 20/01/2022 22:02

@LumosSolem and most women just come out saying “at least we’re both ok” ie alive. Rarely anyone does anything about it. It’s a very vulnerable situation to be in.

Philandbill · 20/01/2022 21:59

@BiscuitLover3678 totally agree. The book "Why human rights on childbirth matters" is a good read. And @Stopsnowing that is an eye opening film. The iatrogenic risks of the hospital environment are not well understood. I opted out with my second child, after a grim instrumental birth with my first, and birthed her at home with an independent midwife.

CookieCrunch123 · 20/01/2022 21:58

The thing that strikes me is where are the stats on this? You shouldn’t need to come to mumsnet to get anecdotal evidence there should be research into this, but there appears to be very little. We don’t know if assisted deliveries are safe if no one follows up with women and babies to see how they recover long term from different delivery types. It’s a disgusting neglect of women and their medical needs.

cafenoirbiscuit · 20/01/2022 21:57

My DM had an assisted delivery with me, her 1st child. She said it was so horrific she’d never do it again. I missed out on siblings and my DM had problems with her mental and physical health for years - throughout my whole childhood. It had a pretty brutal effect on my parents’ relationship too.

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 21:55

@TaketheTrain I'm glad to hear that! I'm also livid about being treated like a piece of meat (rather than a sentient human being) in the delivery room. Congrats on your recovery, which is due to your strength and determination! I'm on the mend but it's been a long road. I spent the first month lying on my side while DH cared for me and the baby. My uncle (an obgyn) told me to stop pumping because I need my estrogen to rebound to heal. That has helped enormously. Prolapse symptoms are 90% gone and now doing physio to strengthen my pelvic floor. I still struggle with the memories and feeling disfigured. I'm also a stubborn cow and this SOB messed with the wrong vagina. One way or another he will suffer some consequences from this because I firmly believe he's a danger to other women.

OP posts:
LumosSolem · 20/01/2022 21:46

@BiscuitLover3678

It would help if women weren’t treated like pieces of meat, made to lie on the bed, given involuntary internal examinations which are obviously going to stop natural labour. All comes back to poor NHS funding.
Agree funding isn't good enough but I don't think it's just about money- it's sexism and misogyny which is rife in medicine.