Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that assisted deliveries are more dangerous than we are led to believe

166 replies

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 17:20

Last September I suffered severe injuries as the result of a ventouse delivery that I did not consent to. I am still in recovery. Since the incident, I have sought out other women who have had similar experiences and I'm coming to the conclusion that assisted deliveries are more dangerous than we are led to believe. AIBU to feel this? Have any mumsnet users suffered similarly?

OP posts:
PissedOffNeighbour22 · 21/01/2022 07:16

@LumosSolem yes I'm in the UK. I know they shouldn't have refused, but they did and I only have 3wks until my due date.
I was given a variety of excuses including it's too late to book an ELCS, it's not medically necessary, unless ELCS is discussed at the beginning of care it can't be an option, my previous experience doesn't impact this pregnancy, high BMI means I'll recover badly from an ELCS, my medical issue means I'm more likely to bleed heavily and my personal favourite - my medical condition doesn't cause pain. The whole reason my first birth went so badly was that they refused to believe I was in so much pain from an issue I have. The pain masked all contractions and because I couldn't feel them they denied I was in labour. I was also hospitalised during my first pregnancy from the pain at this point in my first pregnancy.

I'm using a different trust this time and obviously they promised the world. The reality is they have no midwife appointments (supposed to be seen every two weeks and it's been 8wks), there's no beds - last time I was in to be seen they were telling women they needed to come in for induction immediately but there were several days wait for beds and it's impossible to get anything dealt with.

It was a female consultant I saw and she was completely dismissive of both my previous problems and issues that other medical professionals have raised about this current baby.
Luckily I have someone who is trying to get me in to see another consultant but I've heard nothing since the beginning of the week. I was supposed to be re-scanned by today but there's no appointments available.
The whole situation has been a joke from start to finish and I really do despair of what might happen.
I'm still waiting for the promised physio for the damage caused by the first birth 2yrs ago but this was all on hold with the usual 'cos of Covid' excuse. Whereas my DP called about a vasectomy a few days ago and has already been referred to speak to someone and be booked in. If that was a woman's issue he'd have been waiting years.

Antsgomarching · 21/01/2022 04:34

globalnews.ca/news/7828769/planned-c-sections-less-risky-mom-baby/

www.theguardian.com/education/2019/dec/18/women-have-been-woefully-neglected-does-medical-science-have-a-gender-problem

Found this interesting. When I had DD EMCS and ELCS were lumped together in studies vs natural birth. It was hard to find actual statistics that would be useful to me.

I think the UK is barbaric when it comes to womens healthcare. I moved abroad where I had DD by ELCS, I had no arguing or shaming from my OBGYN, she set out the options and consequences and said “it’s up to you”. There was an acknowledgment that childbirth is painful however you do it and that it is possible to ease that. My CS recovery was fine, took me a week to be fully functional with some twinges, I just had to amend how I got out of bed etc. it was nice to be spoken to like I wasn’t a complete moron.

LumosSolem · 21/01/2022 04:06

@PissedOffNeighbour22 your experience sounds awful, I'm so so sorry to read what happened. Are you in the UK? You shouldn't be refused an ELCS.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 21/01/2022 03:16

In February 2020 I had an assisted delivery. We were under the impression we were going for a CS.
I was in my 4th day of labour, having been induced as a medical emergency. If it was an emergency, why was I still in labour 4 days later with every consultant I saw pushing the case onto the next shift? No one would take responsibility. Eventually my DD almost died and someone finally realised they should do something and I was taken down to theatre. I'd not eaten for 4 days and had been on an epidural for a couple of days plus lots of medication before that (codeine, morphine etc) when I got a piece of paper shoved under my nose and told to sign it without being allowed to read it (not that I was in a fit state to).
I was then subjected to a forceps delivery with an episiotomy plus tearing. I was discharged the following morning with no checks done. I was ill for approx 6mths afterwards and my DD was readmitted within a couple of weeks too.
Every single person I spoke to while I was at hospital had been subjected to a forceps delivery. And every one of them had suffered nasty consequences.
To rub salt in the wound, when my DD was readmitted to hospital we were accused of abusing her because of the state of her face. The damage THEY caused with the forceps.

My second baby is due in a few weeks. I've been refused an ELCS despite the trauma of the first birth (I have a trauma birth plan and have PTSD according to a specialist I have seen. I can see this birth following the first and being too similar. I don't think I could cope with another induction and instrumental delivery.

KittyKel · 21/01/2022 00:37

YANBU, the risks aren’t explained. My undercarriage is certainly not what it was but more importantly my DD has multiple consequences of the birth injuries she received from forceps.

MogsBestestFurball · 21/01/2022 00:31

Yanbu, I will never be fully continent again after ventouse, forceps and third degree tear. Obstetric anal sphincter injuries are not as uncommon as people think, it's just taboo to talk about them and nobody wants to hear about the ongoing after effects.

coraka · 21/01/2022 00:30

I had one "textbook" birth which left me with PTSD. My second birth my baby ended up in NICU and I had a PPH. However I have no trauma and positive memories of it. The difference was my medical caregiver and the relationship we had. I felt the love, care, the emotional connection she had to me, the profound respect she held me in, how she honoured my decisions and my emotions.

I'm so sorry you were not held in this way during your experience OP, and like so many other women.

I found thus book very helpful: howtohealabadbirth.com

HauntedDishcloth · 21/01/2022 00:29

I was at high risk of bleeding and had a mechanically unassisted birth with DC1 but still had retained placenta and 3litre PPH. The actual PPH increased my risk of bleeding further for subsequent births. For DC2 I was under the care of a teaching hospital due to being higher risk and was advised that a CS would actually increase the risk of bleeding even more so they are not always a straightforward alternative.

With DC1's labour I remember the fear of forceps somehow helping me through it even though it was a tortuous nightmare, but with DC2 I was asking for them to be used as I just wanted him out and for it to end!

Lulu1027 · 21/01/2022 00:07

@BiscuitLover3678 Agreed. My uncle, the obgyn, was appalled by what I suffered.

OP posts:
Lulu1027 · 21/01/2022 00:07

When I asked him why I wasn't given a c-section earlier he didn't say it was never an option, he only replied that I'd have a better recovery this way. A feeble excuse at best and totally untrue. I was unable to walk properly for weeks and ultimately discovered that he had refashioned my labia minora and clitoral hood and that I had a prolapse. I have an appointment with him in a month to ask him again why he made the choices he did.

OP posts:
BiscuitLover3678 · 21/01/2022 00:01

No one is trying to bash doctors here. They do an incredible very important job. They are also people, not Gods. Some of them are awful. I have doctors in my family and they don’t all think that every doctor is wonderful. Patient care is actually a really big part of the process.
Of course they don’t do it all just for fun, but something they make the wrong decision and their behaviour is not ethical.

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 23:55

@Focus126 This doctor was definitely crappy. If he had no choice why didn't he simply explain that to be--at the time or subsequently? And why did he falsify my medical records and offer me no after care?

OP posts:
Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 23:53

@Tigger85 "the c-sec was better than the instrumental delivery and the induced Labour."

This is my belief. I was also induced for low amniotic fluid and I'm not sure if I needed to be. I was assessed for low fluid multiple times, sometimes twice in the course of an hour with different results (one low fluid, one normal). It seemed subjective based upon the practitioner. I was made to feel the baby was in danger so I agreed. In retrospect, I wish I had requested a c-section then and there. The induction was very aggressive (membrane sweep, balloon, cytotec, and pitocin) and set me on a course of mounting interventions. I struggled through without an epidural for over eight hours but was subjected to rough cervical exams every hour or two, which I just couldn't tolerate anymore. They hurt more than the pitocin induced contractions. I had had a perfect pregnancy and at my 39 week appointment, I was suddenly a medical emergency. Incidentally, at the same appointment, they told me they were too busy to schedule my 40 week check up...I've wondered if they were just trying to get me off the dockett.

OP posts:
Focus126 · 20/01/2022 23:39

@Staryflight445

I agree with what you’ve said *@AppleBlueberryPie* it concerns me that people romanticise their birth experience, like it’s a happy event like a wedding or proposal or something.

I’ve noticed many women feel so angry over their birth trauma they fail to realise it was either that or losing their babies or their life. That is the risk. Giving birth is a means to an end, the issue is peoples attitude towards birth and their values to it, instead of realising how dangerous it is and actually, how important it is to be fully informed before giving birth.

Yeah. Some women seem to think doctors do instrumental deliveries just for fun. No they are trying to get the baby out alive and not brain-damaged. Crappy doctors do exist, but the majority are just trying to do their job.
Notcontent · 20/01/2022 23:38

@randomsabreuse

I'm honestly not convinced that a C-section is so much easier than a vaginal birth. I've not had a C-section and my only experience of abdominal surgery was a laparoscopic appendectomy but I much preferred dealing with my (admittedly only 2nd degree) tears/stitches than the recovery from the appendix.

I'd be more focused on improving post birth care, ensuring decent natural light in all post natal locations, putting in a routine physio assessment for pelvic floor function instead of the box ticking based 6 week check.

I'd also like to see a lot more help available on post natal wards - so you have someone to pass you the baby, help you get food etc, regular pain relief etc when you need it rather than being made to feel inconvenient. The contrast between the medical ward with my appendix where they happily helped me to the toilet etc as I was a bit dizzy and post natal where it was basically your baby, your problem...

My elective c-section was a breeze. No issues. You can’t even see the scar.
Notcontent · 20/01/2022 23:26

@LalaMelyn

I think childbirth is more dangerous than we are led to believe tbh.

Have you had a birth debrief type thing? Its sounds very traumatic Sad

Yes - and it’s still a taboo subject.
Justkeeppedaling · 20/01/2022 23:22

I had a ventouse. No episiotomy, no trauma, no issues

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 23:21

@Tigger85 I'm so sorry you have suffered so terribly. Why didn't they give you an elcs in the first place if they knew his placement/head size! Wishing you all the best. You are so strong!

OP posts:
Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 23:17

@Mountaingoat12 I got the same attitude. When I asked the doctor the next day why I wasn't given a section he said you'll see you'll heal so much better. Yeah right. I'm still recovering four months on and have permanent injuries. Was also told my injuries weren't severe because I wasn't given an episiotomy. In what universe is a third-degree tear plus inner and labial tears not severe? I was sent home with a motrin (otc pain reliever like paracetemol). If I had suffered such a severe injury in any other context I would have been given prescription pain killers.

OP posts:
Tigger85 · 20/01/2022 23:12

I had a failed ventous followed by forceps delivery for ds1. I did consent, I had been in labour for several hours and he was stuck sideways and in distress. He has congenital neuro abnormalities which they knew about and a 99th centile head which they also knew about as I had scans every 2 weeks due to his conditions. They told me he would possibly die if I didn't consent so of course I wasn't going to say no. I had no analgesia at all for the venous attempts, the first cap they tried came unstuck and came flying out of me. I felt like I was being tortured when they were putting it in and on to his head, it was by far the most physically painful thing I have ever been subjected to. I had a spinal block in theatres for the forceps so at least there was no pain. It gave me a severe rectocele and moderate cystocele. I have been urine incontinent and cannot open my bowels unless using a water irrigation system or manually evacuating my bowels due to my injuries. My second living ds was recently born by elective c-section to prevent worsening of the prolapses and also for mental health reasons (middle ds was a tfmr which involved being induced to deliver him as a stillborn) but I have bad luck with babies and births and had a major haemorrhage losing 33% of my total blood volume, asides from nearly bleeding to death the c-sec was better than the instrumental delivery and the induced Labour.

MummyGummy · 20/01/2022 23:11

There should be much more information given at midwife appointments about various interventions and the potential consequences.

Unfortunately there are increasing numbers of complicated pregnancies and inductions which can lead to a cascade of interventions.

I think there needs to be a lot more research and education on how to prevent this, from before women even become pregnant up to being in labour.

Obviously there will always be cases where emergency interventions are required. But things like being a healthy weight at conception, being active during pregnancy, and trying to help move the baby into the optimal position in the final trimester, hypnobirthing etc could have a big impact.

The aim should be for mother and child to come though it all happy and healthy. The effects of a traumatic birth can have a devastating impact on mental health.

Hellokittyninja · 20/01/2022 22:54

I also had a kiellands delivery that saved my baby and I. We both have permanent damage but are alive. My repairs were extensive and very well done but I was lucky to be at St Thomas’ with the best obstetricians. No pregnancy and birth is ever safe really. Sorry for all those that have suffered.

BogRollBOGOF · 20/01/2022 22:49

I had two spontaneous labours that both ended up in theatre. One an EMCS, the other intended on being EMCS but ended up being rather rough forceps as baby was just on the point of no return.
The second birth while incurring the worse birth injuries was less traumatic because communication was generally better with more explanation of what was happening or coming next. Interestingly it did have a 12 week hospital check-up. Nothing after the emergency surgery.

Informed consent is a huge issue.
Debriefing is another huge issue.

I wish I'd been offered a epidural with DS1. I'd had over 24 hours of regular contractions before being admitted and about 5 hours into the labour room the MW sweetly popped my waters to speed things up. No warning that I was about to explode with pain. Then she says "I know you didn't want pethadine". I'd have sold the baby at that point if it was going to help. Unfortunately pethadine did not relieve the pain, it locked me in with it. The pain relief discussion should have come first.

My babies were 11 & 8 years ago. Staffing was a major part of the baggage with DS1's birth both labour and on main ward. DS2 was born at a quieter time. I had a MW in the labour room at all times and staff had enough time to care. With DS1 staff dipped in and out until the late stages. Main ward was awful, dumped on there at midnight and left to fend for myself with no information (I hadn't walked for over 48 hours by then).

There is a huge amount of underplaying around birth and a huge lack of follow-up when things have had complications. The 6-8wk GP check doesn't present an opportunity to bridge with hospital care. It's more of a "stitches healed, thought about contraception?" agenda. Often issues haven't even surfaced at that point and there needs to be a door open within the first year to give women the chance to recognise issues and respond.

Mountaingoat12 · 20/01/2022 22:46

Emergency c section for first child - just fine, they urged to try naturally for the second child. The baby’s heart stopped though just before full dilation, they brutally yanked it out and took it to resus (worked, phew). Horrendous. Just so horrendously traumatic. Nightmares for months. Problems bonding. PND. What really really annoys me though is that midwives afterwards we’re going on and on about how great it was that I didn’t have to have another emergency section. WHAT!!!!! WTF!!!!! A woman is left ripped apart by unnecessary trauma and that is done sort of success??? It’s a sick attitude these obstetricians and midwives have, a really sick attitude.

Ajl46 · 20/01/2022 22:43

@gogohm

Yabu they do not undertake assisted deliveries unless necessary. They will have informed you it was necessary.

Unfortunately epidurals increase the likelihood of needing an assisted delivery, I'm not sure whether this is clearly communicated before labour

I was offered the choice of forceps or emcs without any discussion of the risks of either. In the end I opted for forceps which badly bruised my baby's head (to the point she couldn't feed due to the pain) and have left her with a permanent scar on her cheek. The forceps didn't work so we ended up with an emcs anyway. Had I been informed of the risks of forcep use i'd never have let them anywhere near DD. I was in hospital for three days for an induction - surely in that time someone could have explained the risks of the various interventions that were quite likely to be required.