Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that assisted deliveries are more dangerous than we are led to believe

166 replies

Lulu1027 · 20/01/2022 17:20

Last September I suffered severe injuries as the result of a ventouse delivery that I did not consent to. I am still in recovery. Since the incident, I have sought out other women who have had similar experiences and I'm coming to the conclusion that assisted deliveries are more dangerous than we are led to believe. AIBU to feel this? Have any mumsnet users suffered similarly?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Spudbitch · 21/01/2022 17:40

It's all very well making birthplans about what you do and don't want but when it comes down to it you don't know what is going to happen. There was no time for a caesarian in my case, that would have wasted time that was critical in a life or death situation it was a better choice to opt for invasive damaging assisted delivery. You may think everything is going well when suddenly something changes noone knows that is going to happen I stated I wanted a waterbirth but oh well no chance of that. That's life I'm afraid. Caesarians are not risk free either and have long recovery times and complications plenty of women have suffered because of them. I think the issue is people do think birth is going to be a lovely happy thing and sometimes it is but if that's what you expect and you end up damaged it is a massive shock and you question everything. Sometimes birth injuries happen and can't be helped it's how it has been since the start of time with some Improvements obviously. When midwives nurses and doctors deal with it all the time they see episiotomies and tears and other injuries all day every day it is not a major thing for them or horrific they just get on with it but when you are not aware of what can happen you might think things are a hell of a lot worse than what they actually are.

Lulu1027 · 21/01/2022 16:37

@Lightswitch123 @JaneTheVirgin Thanks for the advice on preparing for the conversation I'll have with him next month. I did ask him the next morning why he chose the vacuum and not a c-section and all he said was that my recovery would be so much better, which, of course, it has not been. He said nothing about danger to the baby, which was odd to me at the time. At my six-week check-up I told him the baby was healthy and he was totally uninterested just said "ok".

OP posts:
Lulu1027 · 21/01/2022 16:09

@itsstillhotinperth Thank you. I'm so sorry for all you've suffered. I also believe these injuries can be prevented. You are so brave! How did you get to a place where you felt comfortable getting pregnant again? Did carrying the pregnancy worsen your prolapses?

OP posts:
Lulu1027 · 21/01/2022 16:05

@Lightswitch123 Yes, thank god. He's great. He spent two days in the nicu as a precaution but he's healthy as a horse. He was a pound larger than the doctor predicted (I told him so...) and is still a big boy. 99th percentile for height. Initially, I had assumed there was no choice but the doctor's behavior made me suspicious ie. dismissive aftercare, falsifying my medical records etc. Surely if there was no choice he'd just tell me so directly and feel perfectly justified in his actions-whatever my injuries.

OP posts:
Lightswitch123 · 21/01/2022 15:16

@JaneTheVirgin

I agree that it's CHILDBIRTH that's more risky than women are ever told, not necessarily instrumental delivery. Usually they're used in a situation where it may very well be babies life or death, and a CS would be more risky due to birth canal positioning.

Have you spoken to your medical professional yet? Asked for a debrief?

Medical staff can and do get it wrong, so ask your questions. Educate yourself with everything you may need to ask those questions effectively and understand their answers so you know what to ask as follow ups. Also remember though that at the time it may have been the only way to save your baby. It may not be the case, but it's a strong possibility.

This 👆

Is your baby OK?

RedHelenB · 21/01/2022 15:14

How did you not know? They need you to work qith them re pushing for a ventouse delivery?

LumosSolem · 21/01/2022 14:51

I think what I'm trying to say is I agree with posters that sometimes there is no choice but to opt for instrumental but I think women need to understand the likelihood of needing this, the risks and the potential long term effects, BEFORE they even attempt a vaginal birth. And if they prefer to take their chances with the associated risks of a c-section, then that it what they should be entitled to.

Lulu1027 · 21/01/2022 14:46

@ LumosSolem Precisely. Well said. It is a matter of bodily autonomy. Mine was absolutely violated.

OP posts:
LumosSolem · 21/01/2022 14:41

I think from this thread it's clear that if a woman attempts a 'natural' birth, there are occasions when there is no choice but to proceed with an assisted delivery- and it's actually good to see some positive stories of when this has been handled really well and with care from HCP's (apologies I can't remember the name of the particular PP who sounded like she had a difficult birth but good care in the circumstances).

But it's the fact that women aren't being given full and accurate facts on the risks and benefits of different modes of delivery, that they are being pushed towards 'natural' birth without accurate information, without proper freedom of choice about how they would prefer to give birth, that feels wrong to me. If women were give full information about the risks of instrumental deliveries, they might not want to attempt a vaginal birth and that should be their decision to make. Women need to know the risks of an instrumental delivery- and if the risk of needing these kind of interventions means that a woman would prefer to have a c-section (with full knowledge of the potential risks in that situation too), she should be able to choose it instead. It's about full bodily autonomy and being able to make a properly informed choice.

Lavender24 · 21/01/2022 14:31

I had a ventouse delivery and I have a lot of scar tissue but that's from the episiotomy. I begged them not to cut me but I know they only did it because it was necessary and it would have been more dangerous for me to keep pointlessly trying to push her out when her heart rate was dropping.

Sorry you suffered birth injury OP, I know it can be hard to come to terms with when the birth doesn't go the way you wanted.

CornishGem1975 · 21/01/2022 14:25

@Igneo

Mmm I’m not sure if i’d lay the blame for my difficult birth at the foot direcly of misogyny. I felt that the medics were following the treatment protocols to the letter and had no ability to respond to the effects of the treatment and to adapt accordingly. Was it really necessary to double the dose of syntocin every 30 mins, when I was very quickly unable to cope with the pain, but contractions were already building steadily?

Arriving at 6am, would it not have been wise to allow me to breakfast quickly befor starting the drips, so that I wasn’t hungry throughout?

The lack of ability to respond to women as they progress can make medics treat them in an inhumane way.

I know, the doubling of syntocin is mental. I demanded that they turn it right down at one point. There weren't even seconds between the contractions, they never came back down. I was about to rip it out of my arm if they hadn't listened to me!
itsstillhotinperth · 21/01/2022 14:07

@Lulu1027 - I am so sorry for what you have endured - and the many other women on this thread who have endured similar. I am 22 years on from my 4 day obstructed, non dilating labour, and resulting brutal intervention at at very late stage that left me with life changing injuries, and PTSD for which I am still having treatment.

A large, 10 day overdue OP baby, which after labouring for 3 1/2 days was in distress, meconium present upon rupture of membranes, further induced with pitocin, I had an epidural, pushed for 3 hours when fully dilated and when baby's heart rate was through the roof in distress, and the midwife repeatedly calling and begging the doctor to come and assess - he was unable to as performing an EMCS -when he eventually arrived, he performed episiotomy, and used the vacuum multiple times to pull the baby out telling me that i had to push with everything I had, too late for a section. Baby was delivered, cord round his neck, and me left with severe anterior, uterine and posterior vaginal wall prolapses and significant pudendal nerve damage.

It took months to recover physically - and that was just the episiotomy. The prolapses were something else entirely. I had IVF to conceive my second child because the damage was so severe and an elective section second time around. The recovery from that was a dream! Since then I have had multiple prolapse repair surgeries, amputation of my severely damaged elongated cervix, a hysterectomy, severe chronic pelvic pain and now have an implanted neuromodulator device to help with pudendal and deep pelvic pain. It has completely changed every aspect of my life and how I am able to function in my life. And it is devastating to see that nothing has changed - that women are still suffering terrible birth injuries that can be prevented.

Childbirth education classes skirted over and around assisted deliveries - I thought I had done loads of reading and was well prepared. I didn't have a clue. I was up and around, mostly pain free after my section - I couldn't believe the difference in how I felt both physically and emotionally. After my first delivery, one of the younger doctors and a midwife came to see me the day after and said that was not a normal delivery - do you want to talk about it? I couldn't even think about it, let alone talk about it - it was so traumatising.

Lulu1027 · 21/01/2022 14:06

@FinallySomeNormality "Not saying everyone should demand ELCS but the medical profession needs to be far more realistic and transparent about comparing the risks of CS against vaginal birth because the comparisons are always made against a very uncomplicated VB, which sadly isn't the reality for a hell of a lot of VB's."

This. A million times. I knew my baby was trending large and I'm a smaller person. I asked a million questions about possible complications and I was told by my doctor time and again about how "natural' vaginal birth was. Then I was induced and had an assisted delivery.

@GrendelsGrandma Very true. However, I'm in the US and supposedly had the best of the best care. Best hospital in the area (suburbs of nyc) and chief obstetrician of a top practice. I have good insurance that paid a fortune for my care. And I had to pay the doctor $5000 cash on top of the $25,000 the insurance company paid out. So funding wasn't an issue in my case.

@Nameisjustaname "I ask why scans are not done if the woman is in labour? Surely a quick hand scan to determine baby's position would prevent many injuries."

I have wondered this too. Of the scant info I received a nurse told me my injuries were so severe in part because the baby's head was cocked to one side. Surely this can't be so uncommon and they must have a way to asssess the baby's position.

OP posts:
FinallySomeNormality · 21/01/2022 13:11

Couldn't agree more. Also agree that all childbirth is much more dangerous than we are informed of. Yes it's a natural process that women have been doing for thousands of years.... but it's not without risks and it wasn't so long ago in history that many women died during childbirth of course.

Anecdotally - I had a vaginal delivery with DS1. No instruments etc and very natural and hypnobirthing in the birthing pool. Minor tearing. Thought I'd managed to come aaay from birth with very little damage. I was wrong and still suffer to this day (he's 5.5yrs) with issues that were caused during a prolonged pushing stage.

For DS2 I researched like a woman possessed. Ended up demanding ELCS and it was 100% best decision. Bit uncomfortable for first week and mobility was lacking for about 3 weeks but I recovered brilliantly and much faster than my "textbook" birth for DS1. Not saying everyone should demand ELCS but the medical profession needs to be far more realistic and transparent about comparing the risks of CS against vaginal birth because the comparisons are always made against a very uncomplicated VB, which sadly isn't the reality for a hell of a lot of VB's.

GrendelsGrandma · 21/01/2022 12:58

Birth would be safer if maternity services had heaps more funding so staff weren't overstretched and there was time for the human touches that can make a huge difference to trauma.

I'm sure there are targets for clinical elements of birth, it would be good if there were targets for women coming through without feeling traumatised as well. It seems like women's experience gets lost in it all.

Let's face it, it doesn't help that mothers tend to be older, fatter and less fit than we used to be as well.

Nameisjustaname · 21/01/2022 12:35

I ask why scans are not done if the woman is in labour? Surely a quick hand scan to determine baby's position would prevent many injuries.
I had a 4th degree tear, shoulder dystopia with hand to face presentation.
The only way that could be foretold is with a scan i presume?
I am just grateful I escaped without the need for a colostomy bag.
Another baby would never exit my vagina again and a gynecologist has written a letter to verify that.

Igneo · 21/01/2022 11:54

Mmm I’m not sure if i’d lay the blame for my difficult birth at the foot direcly of misogyny.
I felt that the medics were following the treatment protocols to the letter and had no ability to respond to the effects of the treatment and to adapt accordingly. Was it really necessary to double the dose of syntocin every 30 mins, when I was very quickly unable to cope with the pain, but contractions were already building steadily?

Arriving at 6am, would it not have been wise to allow me to breakfast quickly befor starting the drips, so that I wasn’t hungry throughout?

The lack of ability to respond to women as they progress can make medics treat them in an inhumane way.

Focus126 · 21/01/2022 10:11

[quote CorneliusVetch]@Focus126 not at all. I have no criticism at all of the doctors and midwife who delivered my baby with forceps. I sent them a thank you card.

The issue is whether or not instrumental deliveries are more dangerous than women are told.

Also every single one of these birth injuries could be avoided by an elective caesarean. Lots of women don’t want that, and prefer a vaginal birth - which is fine. All birth choices should be supported. But lots of women who want a section are pushed into a vaginal birth on the false promise of it being the better option, without being fully informed of the risks. That’s unacceptable. This thread is about honesty and being upfront about how awful instrumental deliveries are for so many women.[/quote]
I do agree that not much info is given about the risks of vaginal birth and instrumental deliveries.
I was given leaflets with the risks of a C-section and risks of an induction, but not risks of a "natural" or assisted birth.
So improvements can be made here.

And at the same time, I feel like there is a certain level of demonisation of medical profession in threads like this. In this thread there were assumptions that certain things happened because of "misogyny" or lack of respect or care for women, when we don't know if that was the case.

We need to distinguish between genuine cases of medical malpractice and cases where doctors did the best they could in a difficult situation.

Demonisation of medical profession leads to dangerous things like freebirths and vaccine refusals.

LibrariesGiveUsPower · 21/01/2022 10:02

I voted YABU purely because childbirth is much more dangerous that we are led to believe.

We all get sold the story of spontaneous Labour which hurts but few complications. So many women don’t have that. Assisted delivery has its risks, but they are massively less than a stuck baby.

It does very much seem that some interventions are given too quickly, however one would assume in the vast majority of cases the primary concern is keeping mother and baby alive.

I had a great delivery with my first, total mess with my second. I’m too scared to have another to be honest, I’m incredibly lucky that both myself and DC2 are alive. It is thanks to rapid intervention of the doctors that we are both here. If I did have another I’d insist on scheduled section.

Quantity5 · 21/01/2022 09:52

I agree OP. The posters who trust that docs are always making the right choices for the baby in the moment are naively thinking the system works. There are huge statistical variations between the birth outcomes of women with very similar profiles. Different hospitals, different staff within hospitals have different stats. Knowing where or who you see makes a difference to your delivery. If we look globally there are counties with better outcomes and massively reduced assisted births.

There isn’t enough respect for the mother and too many decisions made as a consequence of poor practice, funding and training.

The failures in communication is often a whole other disaster.

CornishGem1975 · 21/01/2022 09:51

I researched before my births and had it written into my notes that I would accept ventouse, not forceps. If that was the case they should go to c-section.

I had two ventouse deliveries, no episiotomies, minor tears and no lasting damage, and then one emergency c-section because baby was too high to be able to yank out.

I never particularly worried about birth injuries and I've been lucky that I'm unaffected but I do have a friend who suffered a terrible prolapse following a birth injury caused by an assisted delivery and years later she's still struggling with surgeries to correct her issues.

Scotabroad24 · 21/01/2022 09:45

@BiscuitLover3678

It would help if women weren’t treated like pieces of meat, made to lie on the bed, given involuntary internal examinations which are obviously going to stop natural labour. All comes back to poor NHS funding.

Absolutely this 100 times! Im overseas and its the exact same here

CorneliusVetch · 21/01/2022 07:50

On debriefs - I had a debrief and it is helpful. It hasn’t repaired the irreparable damage the forceps did to me though. The only way to do that is not to have the instrumental delivery in the first place.

CorneliusVetch · 21/01/2022 07:50

@Focus126 not at all. I have no criticism at all of the doctors and midwife who delivered my baby with forceps. I sent them a thank you card.

The issue is whether or not instrumental deliveries are more dangerous than women are told.

Also every single one of these birth injuries could be avoided by an elective caesarean. Lots of women don’t want that, and prefer a vaginal birth - which is fine. All birth choices should be supported. But lots of women who want a section are pushed into a vaginal birth on the false promise of it being the better option, without being fully informed of the risks. That’s unacceptable. This thread is about honesty and being upfront about how awful instrumental deliveries are for so many women.

Bunnycat101 · 21/01/2022 07:44

I had a similar birth and it took me a long time to recover. I would definitely recommend a debrief. I had mine much later when I was pregnant with my second and it helped.

Essentially birth is still quite a dangerous thing. Medical advances mean that the experience might not be pleasant but you and the baby will survive when you might not have otherwise. 100 years ago one or both of us would have most likely died (me from infection/blood loss and my daughter from being stuck and in distress.

My second birth was much better and a completely different experience. I didn’t need pain relief, had a water birth and quick recovery.

Part of the problem is high expectations of what the experience should be and I do think some of that expectation has come from the way NCT teaches. I remember at our catch post birth our teacher was so delighted by the water birth one of our group had and was so disappointed by mine and my inability to breastfeed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread