Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be delighted DS wasted all his Christmas money?

234 replies

newnamenewyear · 20/01/2022 15:21

13yo DS had £70 of Christmas money from various relatives.

Given the last two years we've had with Covid he's not had a lot of experience of hanging about with his mates outside in the world - they just seem to want to be on the computer all the time, so I'm keen to encourage him to be independent and get out and do stuff.

Last weekend, he and a couple of friends went into town. I didn't realise he'd taken ALL his Christmas money with him. He spent it all on absolute crap, moatly for his friends and now has nothing to show for it. I know he wanted to buy a bit of kit for his hobby with it.

He's asked a couple of times if I'll replace it and the answer is no, of course (even though I want to!)

He's annoyed with himself, sad his money is gone and that he can't buy the bit of kit he wanted. He'll have to save up his pocket money now if he wants it.

I'm really hope he's learnt an important lesson - if you waste your money it's gone!

I hope he learns this lesson now, if so it'll be £70 well spent. I was shit with money as a young woman, I don't want him to be like I was.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 09:34

But if I swoop in and start suggesting a programme of jobs for him to earn it back, that's still fixing it for him IMO.

Oh FFS. Feck off with your 'not understanding'! I understand fine. You keep changing position

Saying to DS, 'you can do some jobs, as you know, for agreed amounts to earn back your money' is not swooping in

Why are you point-scoring with your son? If he doesn't want to do it, then absolutely you've done all you can.

But making a point that he knows he can ask, without suggesting it again to him, as if it was some key parenting point, is just so silly.

Anyway I see that you really just want to argue & justify your position to the apparently hard-of-thinking like me. I'll leave you to it now.

newnamenewyear · 21/01/2022 09:33

Earings, please either read all my posts and try to understand them in good faith or stop trying to pick holes in them, it's a waste of your time and mine, and exactly why I didn't post a lot of detail in the OP.

The "contradictions" you mention come from you either misinterpreting what I've said, assuming bad faith, or ignoring posts where I've clarified exactly the thing you are misunderstanding.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 09:30

he was trying to encourage them to play the game he likes, so he can play it with them.

It's a really odd dynamic that a 13 yo is happy to spend £60 on other boys, in the hope they'll like this game as much as he does.

It's also not good that they accepted this. My DC similar ages would know this isn't ok. A pal buying you a treat or a hot drink - grand & you'll get them back. Spending £60 (I know not just on one person) - no way anyone should think this is right.

Anyway, good luck to your DS. I think he sounds really lovely.

newnamenewyear · 21/01/2022 09:28

@EarringsandLipstick

OP, you are the one contradicting yourself.

A poster wrote:
I think it's fine to have a nice day in town with friends and fritter his money and as long as you spin it to him as 'Well yes, you can only spend your money once but if you had fun then that's also OK. Would you like me to give you some jobs to earn some money?

And you replied
No, this is still fixing it for him!

So apparently giving him the option to earn money by doing jobs is not something you are willing to do. And you regard it as 'fixing it'.

Now you say, no that's not the case at all, and this option is open to him

Which is it? I mean we cab only go on your posts & can't be expected to factor in your contradictions.

You're obviously not reading all my posts, or having trouble understanding them, though.

I explained, already, upthread, that this option is always open to him, he knows that, I've suggested it to him enough times in the past but he chooses not to.

What I'm not going ot do is smooth the way for him. If he wants to come to me and ask for jobs to get the money back, brilliant. But if I swoop in and start suggesting a programme of jobs for him to earn it back, that's still fixing it for him IMO.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 09:27

I don't see not fixing things for your teenage child as being automatically unsupportive. It may be more beneficial to be sympathetic about mistakes and very supportive of their efforts to find solutions without handing the solutions out yourself!

I agree entirely. OP's earlier posts gave no indication of this. Latterly she's suggested this actually is her approach.

Eg

I'm not going to offer him a way to make it better - then it becomes my problem not his.

In response to a poster saying could she offer him jobs to do to earn some money; however she's since clarified this is an option

Then

Reckon I'll leave it a week or so as I don't want to be swooping in to fix it for him, but yes I think it's a good time to start talking to him about budgetting.

But later, she has had supportive conversations already.

Anyway OP is happy with her approach so that's fine. I'm not sure why she posted I that case.

newnamenewyear · 21/01/2022 09:24

@Imworkingonit

I'm finding some of these responses really bizarre.

Those of you that say to contact parents and negotiate the return of items/payment. Do you really think it's a good thing to model to a teen if you regret spending on a gift it's ok to ask for it back?

People saying he is kind - maybe he does do kind things but let's be honest, his reasons for spending weren't purely altruistic in this instance. He wants his friends to play the game with him and saw it as a reasonable cost to buy the kits in the hope they do. It may come off or it may not. That's life. He lost a bit of Christmas money for goodness sake which is a fortune when your a kid but not enough for a months electric in the real world. He's not given away a house or a kidney! I think some people may benefit from a bit of perspective.

let's be honest, his reasons for spending weren't purely altruistic in this instance. He wants his friends to play the game with him and saw it as a reasonable cost to buy the kits in the hope they do. It may come off or it may not. That's life.

Yes, this! He is a kind boy, he has a lovely nature. But in this instance, he wasn't being taken advantage of, or trying to buy his friends (they would certainly have prefered he spent it all on sweets, McDonalds or credit for computer games) - he was trying to encourage them to play the game he likes, so he can play it with them.

And, if they do get into it, then it'll be money well spent, in the end. (Another reason for not forcing them to give it back!). It's a gamble.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 09:22

It's possible to say no with kindness and empathy, you don't have to be an arsehole about it!

That's absolutely true. But it's not coming across from your posts.

Imworkingonit · 21/01/2022 09:22

@EarringsandLipstick

Do you really think it's a good thing to model to a teen if you regret spending on a gift it's ok to ask for it back?

Hardly a gift. It's not like he consciously bought his pal a planned birthday present.

He went into town with a group & spent his cash buying several of them some kit

(Tho I agree asking for it back may not be possible or practicable)

But it was a gift, when you give something to someone else without expectation of payment, conditions etc, it's a gift! It might be inappropriate but it's still a gift.

The OP has said there will be discussions and I infer what she's said It's quite clear these things will be addressed.

In addition, I can't see anything that she's written that suggests she's not sympathetic and he won't feel supported. I thought I read his solution was to ask her to replace it and she said no. Which I'm sure we both agree is reasonable. If he comes up with an alternative solution that works for her maybe she'll consider it and say yes.

I don't see not fixing things for your teenage child as being automatically unsupportive. It may be more beneficial to be sympathetic about mistakes and very supportive of their efforts to find solutions without handing the solutions out yourself!

EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 09:21

OP, you are the one contradicting yourself.

A poster wrote:
I think it's fine to have a nice day in town with friends and fritter his money and as long as you spin it to him as 'Well yes, you can only spend your money once but if you had fun then that's also OK. Would you like me to give you some jobs to earn some money?

And you replied
No, this is still fixing it for him!

So apparently giving him the option to earn money by doing jobs is not something you are willing to do. And you regard it as 'fixing it'.

Now you say, no that's not the case at all, and this option is open to him

Which is it? I mean we cab only go on your posts & can't be expected to factor in your contradictions.

EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 09:19

See, you're just making things up to then have a go at me about!

I'm not. I'm responding to your posts & information you provided.

You seem much more interested in objecting to any counter-view than taking points on board. Which is fine. Your son, and you're the parent.

Just if you post asking AIBU, maybe consider alternative POV.

newnamenewyear · 21/01/2022 09:14

@catwomando

This happened to my DD when she was younger. She was so upset. We sat down and did a breakdown of what she had spent and on what. I 'refunded' some of it (where she had bought food for example) and she took the rest of the hit. Fast forward 10years and she is financially astute, a keen saver and financial planner and puts it down to that early intervention and learning the value of money.

It's a hard lesson, but I'd encourage you to have the detailed discussion to analyse what he's spent and to help him work out a plan/ schedule to save for his hobby purchase going forward. He will learn so much from it.

Good luck.

Yes, that's a good idea. I'll have a chat with home about thinking through how long it will take to save up from his pocket money, and suggest he puts some money aside each week.
OP posts:
newnamenewyear · 21/01/2022 09:13

@EarringsandLipstick

Where did I say I'm not intending to provide him with guidance and support?

That was what I suggested in my post. That you quoted & then disagreed with.

From your description I don't see any evidence of you providing support.

You've told him 'tough', you won't allow him earn it back, you're not bothered thad he spent it all on his pals, not himself.

You are being so harsh in my view. He didn't just fritter it away. Also, he didn't make just a foolish choice. It's really unusual for a 13yo or any child really, to spend all their money on stuff for someone else and they let him. I would absolutely be having conversations with him about why he did this & what the nature of their friendship is.

I take your point re contacting the parents. That's your call & if it would be humiliating or upsetting, I agree, maybe not.

But I would then not expect your poor DS to suck up the loss of £60 with your 'delight'. I really don't think he's going to learn the lesson you think he will. I think there are other lessons - about friendship & self-esteem - that you are missing here.

See, you're just making things up to then have a go at me about!

From your description I don't see any evidence of you providing support.

The whole point of this is about supporting him, to learn how to deal with money. I've spoken to him kindly, and will continue to, about how to handle with his money and about his friendships.

You've told him 'tough', you won't allow him earn it back, you're not bothered thad he spent it all on his pals, not himself.

I've not told him tough, where did you get that from? I've simply said no, when asked to refund it.

I've not said I won't allow him to earn that back, again where are you getting this from? If you actually read my posts, you'll see that earning money from chores is an option that's always been open to him, and he chooses not to. He gets pocket money and can use that to save if he wants to.

Yes, I am bothered about what he spends his money on, which is exactly why I'm not going to enable him frittering it by fixing it for him if he fucks up.

I think it's interesting that posters are confusing saying no to a child's request to give him money, with being mean! It's possible to say no with kindness and empathy, you don't have to be an arsehole about it!

And of course I'm not running about telling him I'm delighted he's lost money! But yes if he spends £70, after I've told him he needs to keep his Christmas money safe not walk around with it all in his pocket - well yes, he needs to own that.

Much harsher IMO to humiliate him by making his friends give it back and getting them in trouble with their parents than let him experience the regret of spending money.

OP posts:
catwomando · 21/01/2022 08:33

This happened to my DD when she was younger. She was so upset. We sat down and did a breakdown of what she had spent and on what. I 'refunded' some of it (where she had bought food for example) and she took the rest of the hit. Fast forward 10years and she is financially astute, a keen saver and financial planner and puts it down to that early intervention and learning the value of money.

It's a hard lesson, but I'd encourage you to have the detailed discussion to analyse what he's spent and to help him work out a plan/ schedule to save for his hobby purchase going forward. He will learn so much from it.

Good luck.

LookItsMeAgain · 21/01/2022 08:31

@newnamenewyear

It's hard to resist the urge to want to fix it for him!

But I know I need to, don't I?!

Surely the way to 'fix' this is to get him to do chores and pay him per chore so that he can earn the money back sooner than just pocket money alone.

loading/unloading the dishwasher
changing the sheets on his bed (including duvet cover)
sweeping the floor
walking the dog (if you have one)
Keeping his room tidy

That sort of thing....

EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 08:31

He's not given away a house or a kidney

I guess we all have our own perspective but I can't get on board with your view

By OP's own description, her DS has had limited opportunity for friendship building & socialisation. He thought this was a route to that.

Misplaced and wrong but from good intentions. I just couldn't take this harsh stance & focus on lessons learnt.

He can still learn these lessons while getting some cash by cleaning the car, tidying the garden or washing windows, and is deserving of some sympathy from his mum in the process

EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 08:27

Do you really think it's a good thing to model to a teen if you regret spending on a gift it's ok to ask for it back?

Hardly a gift. It's not like he consciously bought his pal a planned birthday present.

He went into town with a group & spent his cash buying several of them some kit

(Tho I agree asking for it back may not be possible or practicable)

EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 08:26

Where did I say I'm not intending to provide him with guidance and support?

That was what I suggested in my post. That you quoted & then disagreed with.

From your description I don't see any evidence of you providing support.

You've told him 'tough', you won't allow him earn it back, you're not bothered thad he spent it all on his pals, not himself.

You are being so harsh in my view. He didn't just fritter it away. Also, he didn't make just a foolish choice. It's really unusual for a 13yo or any child really, to spend all their money on stuff for someone else and they let him. I would absolutely be having conversations with him about why he did this & what the nature of their friendship is.

I take your point re contacting the parents. That's your call & if it would be humiliating or upsetting, I agree, maybe not.

But I would then not expect your poor DS to suck up the loss of £60 with your 'delight'. I really don't think he's going to learn the lesson you think he will. I think there are other lessons - about friendship & self-esteem - that you are missing here.

Imworkingonit · 21/01/2022 08:23

I'm finding some of these responses really bizarre.

Those of you that say to contact parents and negotiate the return of items/payment. Do you really think it's a good thing to model to a teen if you regret spending on a gift it's ok to ask for it back?

People saying he is kind - maybe he does do kind things but let's be honest, his reasons for spending weren't purely altruistic in this instance. He wants his friends to play the game with him and saw it as a reasonable cost to buy the kits in the hope they do. It may come off or it may not. That's life. He lost a bit of Christmas money for goodness sake which is a fortune when your a kid but not enough for a months electric in the real world. He's not given away a house or a kidney! I think some people may benefit from a bit of perspective.

newnamenewyear · 21/01/2022 07:59

Eh? Where did I say I'm not intending to provide him with guidance and support?

I was responding to the suggestion of contacting the other children's parents and making them return the kits to him.

That would be absolutely humiliating for him. The natural consequence of spending money is you don't have money any more.

What life lesson dors it teach him if I go to the parents and make his friends give the kits back or give him money for them?

It's not teaching him responsibility or that there are consequences to his actions. It's massively controlling and punishing him by humiliating him in front of his friends and getting their families involved.

Would people really do this at 13?!

(FWIW I know one set of parents well, but never met the other ones).

At primary, sure, but at secondary I don't even know what half his mates look like. Would you really track down their parents to do this?! What if their parents are arseholes and the friends get in loads of trouble and blame DS? The drama and upset of that would override any lesson about spending money.

OP posts:
EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 07:49

Support! I provide them with support & guidance. Supper too tho.

EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 07:48

No way! He's 13 not 7!

So what? My eldest is 14. I've a 12 and 10 yo. Of course I still provide them with supper & guidance. You sound really unkind.

How's he going to learn to manage money if I swoop in and fix it for him?

Jesus, you're not swooping in & fixing it! You are talking through what happened, ensuring he makes better decisions in future, and being supportive. Like a parent.

OP, I am just amazed you don't see more of an issue with your immature 13 yo (by your description of socialisation he's missed out on) spending almost all his Christmas money on other people. Nothing for himself. And you're essentially saying 'tough. Life lesson. Don't do it again'.

I feel really sorry for him. He made a really poor call, but from a good place. I really think you should have a proper chat & at least give him a route to earning some back. And that's not 'fixing it' either - in grown up life, adults have a choice like that, to work more for extra money.

Oh and university in 4.5 years 🙄 4.5 years is huge at this stage. He will be unrecognisable by nearly 18, a lot will change between now & then. Stop acting like he's off to university in the morning.

newnamenewyear · 21/01/2022 07:40

@EarringsandLipstick

DS spent £60 on starter kits for his main hobby obsession, but not for himself, for his friends.

I disagree so much with you. This really is a drip feed.

It matters hugely that he spent most of his Christmas money on his friends, not himself, and not just rubbish.

He sounds lovely & kind.

However, this isn't ok. I'd be mortified if any of my DS's friends did this.

You really need to talk to the boys' parents and work this out. Return the kit, get the money back or whatever.

Then you do need to talk to DS about why he did it, good intentions but not sensible etc

And yes, give him a chance to earn back what he ends up losing.

He's still young. You said yourself he's only learning to navigate his new-found independence. Support him.

He really really doesn't sound like a kid just wasting his money carelessly. He did a kind albeit misplaced thing. Give him a bit of support & guidance

No way! He's 13 not 7!

As I said above, he could be off to university in just 4.5 years. How's he going to learn to manage money if I swoop in and fix it for him?

Also he'd be absolutely humiliated by this, it's babying him and extremely controlling! It'd be appropriate for a primary aged kid, but not a teenager!

I told him not to take all his money out with him, in general terms. He's decided to ignore that and it's all gone now. That's a valuable lesson. He's not in trouble - but he is having to understand the natural consequences of spending money. What's he going to learn if I override his decision and bring the money back to him?

OP posts:
Cstring · 21/01/2022 07:34

In my last post I was completely supportive of you, but I think what he spent this on changes it quite a lot plus the fact he’s On the spectrum.
Yes it’s a bad choice, but it’s very different than frittering it on shite for himself. However there is still a lesson to be learned I think. I feel quite sorry for him now, is he quite Immature? I have a 13 year old snd I know lockdown has affected her maturity and development so no judgement meant from that comment !
However, even bearing this in mind I don’t think replacing it is the right thing to do.
Maybe a structured plan of chores and spending money to earn it back?

AlecTrevelyan006 · 21/01/2022 07:20

@sadpapercourtesan

I think it's a bit mean to be delighted tbh. I agree that he'll learn a much-needed lesson from it, but I'd be sympathetic rather than gleeful. He's a young teenager and it's for you to support and scaffold him in learning to make good choices, not laugh at him when he fucks up Sad
This.
EarringsandLipstick · 21/01/2022 07:07

DS spent £60 on starter kits for his main hobby obsession, but not for himself, for his friends.

I disagree so much with you. This really is a drip feed.

It matters hugely that he spent most of his Christmas money on his friends, not himself, and not just rubbish.

He sounds lovely & kind.

However, this isn't ok. I'd be mortified if any of my DS's friends did this.

You really need to talk to the boys' parents and work this out. Return the kit, get the money back or whatever.

Then you do need to talk to DS about why he did it, good intentions but not sensible etc

And yes, give him a chance to earn back what he ends up losing.

He's still young. You said yourself he's only learning to navigate his new-found independence. Support him.

He really really doesn't sound like a kid just wasting his money carelessly. He did a kind albeit misplaced thing. Give him a bit of support & guidance