Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want to stop buying my kids so much stuff for Xmas... how do you do it?!

56 replies

Zara198 · 20/01/2022 14:35

To give context.. my dc are 5 and 3.
5yo asked specifically for a few things, mostly Thomas trackmaster and some bath bombs.
My 3yo asked for nothing but they were both extremely excited for Xmas and opening the presents.
We work full time and the boys do 3 clubs during early evenings so the week days are a write-off pretty much
Then weekends are often spent out, at parks, on walks, visiting friends etc.
It pained me knowing that I was spending all this money on toys which were unlikely to be played with, based on the fact that we are rarely here!
It doesn't help that its my eldests birthday 2 weeks after Xmas.
Also family and close friends always ask what they can buy, and everyone's always reluctant to give money as they're young and they say it's boring, same with clothes.
I'm working at home today and went in the playroom, looking at mounds and mounds of boxes full of unopened games, lego, playability, craft stuff. I know it will never get played with and I feel so guilty that people have wasted their money (me included) but also that its so bad for the environment.
However, I also distinctly remember many Xmas and birthdays as a little girl being so excited for the big day, and feeling very deflated that I got barely anything. I was from a very poor family. I never want mine to feel that sadness that I did but how do you balance it!
Please help!

OP posts:
CrimbleCrumble1 · 20/01/2022 15:37

Just buy them one or two gifts if you know they’ll get lots from relatives.
It sounds like your DC are very sociable and love the fresh air which is lovely to hear.

Peanutbuttercupisyum · 20/01/2022 15:32

I think you need to get your kids into playing! We go out every weekend day too, but the dc still spend a good few hours holed up in the playroom every weekend! And what about the school holidays? Surely they have time then? Or early morning when you are having a lie in and they go downstairs to the playroom? Or the couple of hours before bed on a Saturday? I can’t believe they have no opportunities to muck about at home!

irregularegular · 20/01/2022 15:29

Please don't stop getting out for walks and the park and seeing friends at weekends just because you think you "should" get some use out of toys you have bought! That would be crazy!! It sounds like you have a happy and healthy life with your kids. If you feel the toys are going to waste, then pass some of them onto a charity etc or sell them. Much better than forcing everyone to stay in and play when they show no interest.

For next year, are you sure they would be less excited about Christmas with a smaller number of gifts to unwrap. My kids only every had a handful of gifts, plus genuinely tiny stocking fillers (we use an actual pair of hiking socks of DH). There is still plenty of excitement. And as other people have suggested, replace some of the gifts with things you might buy anyway such as clothes. Consider asking relatives who want to buy larger gifts for "experiences", though bear in mind they won't mean much to small children on opening. Plus more outdoor toys and equipment.

MotherWol · 20/01/2022 15:26

If they’re genuinely not bothered by toys, just reduce the number of things you buy. Try to stick to, say, three or four things each - a book, a toy, some pyjamas. Ask family for books/clothes/tickets to something/a magazine subscription. If you’re worried about it not feeling enough on the day, do an activity after the unwrapping, so they can put their new wellies/hat on and take their new kite/football to the park. That way you’re moving the focus away from the number of gifts to the function of them IYSWIM

bluechilli47 · 20/01/2022 15:25

For main stuff follow the rhyme:
Something they want
Something they need
Something to wear
Something to read

Bulk it out with loads of cheap stuff that will get used up. Hot chocolate bombs, bath bombs, crayons, chocolate.

Blurp · 20/01/2022 15:25

If they're not interested in toys, you don't have to buy them more just because it's Christmas/birthday. Do they actually enjoy opening tons of stuff? Or is it just because you want to give them lots of stuff? I would just dial it down, get a couple of toys, then maybe some bike gear, trainers, tracksuit bottoms etc.

BackAwayFatty · 20/01/2022 15:23

What about days out for Xmas? You could print off pictures of where you are going to go?

I always set a budget & stick to it. Sons bday is a week after Xmas & this year although I spent the same on the 3 kids, he had loads more gift wise so I kept some back for bday.

Try not to feel guilty. I was comparing what I got thinking the kids don't have enough & my daughter was so grateful for what she got so no need to try keeping up with the Jones'

I also do a stocking with sweets but could do other consumables like art & crafts.

If I wanted to cut back more I would do the something they can wear, want, need, read. Good concept

gogohm · 20/01/2022 15:21

How about reducing the quantity by thinking about longevity of the items (if it will be suitable for 4 years it's different than 1 year) and asking different family members to buy items towards a larger gift

Zara198 · 20/01/2022 15:20

I realise I said my dc are 5 and 3 in opening thread... my 5yo was 6 last week 🤭

OP posts:
Zara198 · 20/01/2022 15:19

Thanks all, some really good advice here and I do think trying to get family to club together for a bigger gift or tickets to somewhere is a really good idea.
As is the ideq of stocking fillers which aren't toys.
I appreciate what you say about downtime - honestly though they just prefer being out.
3yo only does 1 after preschool activity which is swimming, the (just) 6yo does beavers and a kids club run at a church as well as swimming and enjoys them all.
Weekends, as soon as we wake up it's 'where can we go today?'. They both keep asking to join the football club on a Saturday morning over the road where their friends go, but it's at 9am and despite how they are, I'm exhausted! And it's the cost.
But they love bike rides and scooter rides, even just popping to the pub on a Sunday afternoon where we bump into friends with their dc etc.
They aren't fussed by toys. Neither of them have ever been bothered by them and I just don't know how to get them engaged

OP posts:
user1471548941 · 20/01/2022 15:18

My SIL often says they get too much stuff for my 3YO nephew- large family but the only grandchild.

We happily buy them an “experience” gift i.e family ticket to an attraction or put money is his savings account with a token gift like a book for him to open on the day!

rosiebl · 20/01/2022 15:17

I let my little boy (6) create his Christmas list (usually using the Smyths catalogue and add anything he mentions in passing). I keep the list in my phone notes then whenever a family member asks what to buy, I select something from his list and assign it to them, putting their name next to the item. Or give them a choice of a few items, if you don't know the budget but ask them to confirm which they get as it's from his list. Keep that going then just buy whatever is leftover yourself. These might be the more expensive items or things you want to buy. I found it so much easier this year and it meant we didn't have ridiculous amounts of stuff. Just the stuff he asked for plus a few bits and bobs extra from people that didn't ask what to buy or bits I saw myself that I thought he would like.

Danikm151 · 20/01/2022 15:14

Ask family to get vouchers for a day out

Calennig · 20/01/2022 15:09

We work full time and the boys do 3 clubs during early evenings so the week days are a write-off pretty much
Then weekends are often spent out, at parks, on walks, visiting friends etc.
It pained me knowing that I was spending all this money on toys which were unlikely to be played with, based on the fact that we are rarely here!

That does seem pretty full on - but portable toys/crayons/books/audio books - toys in carry cases/art cases - stuff that they can take with then and play while traveling or bath toys.

I think we've been lucky mine do seem to excited by clothes.

Having said that mine at now teens and this last chirtsmas was first I did manage to rein it in - clothes, chololate, books, hobby things, audio books - enough so there was pleanty to open. I think I managed this year as they aren't as exicited by it all.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 20/01/2022 15:06

I'd just start factoring in some playtime at home.

Bring a small box of toys through to the living room, a couple of jigsaws and a couple of books - they are more likely to dip into them if they are right there

Clutterbugsmum · 20/01/2022 15:06

Could you get a family season ticket to a local attraction.
My children have had season tickets to the local zoo when they were the age of your children. Now they are older we’ve had tickets to theatre shows. The Harry Potter films at the Albert Hall with the orchestra playing the music.

converseandjeans · 20/01/2022 15:06

Don't buy as much stuff. They can also have bits to open that they need anyway like PJs, trainers, socks.

What about things like trampoline, scooter - my DS rarely played with actual toys. He had no interest. But would enjoy those things.

There's nothing wrong with money - say you're saving for a bike/scooter/trampoline. Or put into savings for summer.

Also we used to have family pass sometimes as a gift. So you can have nice days out all year.

Books would make a good gift too.

Hungry625f · 20/01/2022 15:04

I think its a balance - unstructured play is really beneficial developmentally, and 3 after school activities sounds a lot for their ages. I'd cut back a bit personally.

Then re Xmas we do a few things:

  • commit to a couple of ranges of toys they particularly enjoy and look out for secondhand add ons to those ranged throughout the year. So we are a lego household rather than playmobil, loads of lego sets come up throughout the year
  • buy consumables for Xmas like Bath bombs, pyjamas, treat food, vouchers for days out/events etc
Footnote · 20/01/2022 15:03

I wrap up lots of things that aren’t toys. Cake mix, biscuit cutters, toothbrush, unusual toothpaste, cereal they aren’t usually allowed, mini pack of ferrero rocher, pens, stickers.

Bananalanacake · 20/01/2022 15:02

I do car boot sales and toys in good condition sell well, better than throwing them away.

SleepingStandingUp · 20/01/2022 15:02

I'm sure they do have too many toys, like most kids do. But I think the real issue is that they have no down time. You both work so they in childcare / school full time, plus three night of activities and then weekends out the house. They have no time that's just free for them to fill themselves, to get out the lego or craft stuff for a few hours a d see what they make. They really don't need every hour of their life managed so much

Blurp · 20/01/2022 14:58

Yeah, anything unopened can be regifted or sold on Marketplace if you don't think it will get used. Or donate to a toy appeal - there are loads of places that do them in the run-up to Christmas, but I'm sure some are year-round.

Spend less time on clubs and outings so that the kids actually have time at home. Let them be bored sometimes, it's good for them.

Stop trying to buy your kids happiness - they won't be happy just because they get a ton of presents; in fact they may well get overwhelmed. If people are buying for them, suggest vouchers for days out, or a pass for somewhere that you go regularly.

Don't buy toys as stocking fillers - buy things like bath bombs, books, pyjamas etc instead. Even things like duvet covers can go in a stocking (if it's one they will especially like).

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 20/01/2022 14:58

We ask for experience gifts... so last year they got zoo season tickets for example (we live 10 minutes walk away!). Or people club together for bigger stuff like trampolines.

thewhatsit · 20/01/2022 14:56

For purely environmental reasons I try to buy Christmas presents for my kids second hand where possible. I suppose this limits it as I have an idea of the presents I want (about 6 each) and each one I have to source on eBay or wherever so the effort is bigger .. because of this there isn’t time to buy loads of presents and I don’t just buy on a whim.

IDontHaveThePelvisForAFuton · 20/01/2022 14:55

I didn't get a lot as a child either do I've done the Christmas madness and regretted it.

You could sell or donate the stuff you definitely know won't get played with so at least it's not wasted. Alternatively put sone of it away out of sight for rainy days.

Going forward think about more practical gifts. Books, pjs, clothes, towel, flannel, bedding, bubble bath, lunch box, drink bottle, plant pot and seeds, gardening bits etc. These things are still gifts and are exciting to receive but not so wasteful.

It's more difficult with family who want to spoil the children. I'd hint at money for treats as pp has said, but if they want to give gifts and have asked for ideas that's good as you can make sure it's something the dc actually want.