Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I want to stop buying my kids so much stuff for Xmas... how do you do it?!

56 replies

Zara198 · 20/01/2022 14:35

To give context.. my dc are 5 and 3.
5yo asked specifically for a few things, mostly Thomas trackmaster and some bath bombs.
My 3yo asked for nothing but they were both extremely excited for Xmas and opening the presents.
We work full time and the boys do 3 clubs during early evenings so the week days are a write-off pretty much
Then weekends are often spent out, at parks, on walks, visiting friends etc.
It pained me knowing that I was spending all this money on toys which were unlikely to be played with, based on the fact that we are rarely here!
It doesn't help that its my eldests birthday 2 weeks after Xmas.
Also family and close friends always ask what they can buy, and everyone's always reluctant to give money as they're young and they say it's boring, same with clothes.
I'm working at home today and went in the playroom, looking at mounds and mounds of boxes full of unopened games, lego, playability, craft stuff. I know it will never get played with and I feel so guilty that people have wasted their money (me included) but also that its so bad for the environment.
However, I also distinctly remember many Xmas and birthdays as a little girl being so excited for the big day, and feeling very deflated that I got barely anything. I was from a very poor family. I never want mine to feel that sadness that I did but how do you balance it!
Please help!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Caspianberg · 21/01/2022 11:33

I think less is a good idea, and maybe move family gifts into smaller token gift, then money towards football class for example if they want that.

But even out a lot, then must have time at home sometimes, you can’t be out 8am-8pm every day. What do they use the most at home during downtime? Drawing? Garden stuff? Puzzles? Board games?
Watch what they use the most over the next year, before Next Christmas for ideas.

00100001 · 21/01/2022 08:09

I only ever got my lad 1 gift for birthdays. People thought I was miserable twat.

It he'd get gifts from around a dozen or more other people, so I really didn't see the point of buying stuff "just to open" which is what a lot of people recommend here...(and then will complain about consumerism 3 minutes later on another thread!)

converseandjeans · 21/01/2022 07:35

They aren't fussed by toys. Neither of them have ever been bothered by them and I just don't know how to get them engaged

Not all children play with toys. All DS wanted to do was play footie so he never bothered with Lego, play mobil, play doh etc - I used to get loads of stuff out on rotation & he would go back to kicking a ball. So we did end up putting all the toy stuff away when he was about 8.

Can you ask for footie club membership as gift & new boots & kit? It sounds like they would prefer that to presents.

Now DS is older he likes Xbox & his phone - so maybe save some cash for in a few years.

Mine had a switch as joint gift when they were younger - they might like something like that instead of more traditional toys.

GinTonic123 · 20/01/2022 19:39

My kids don’t play with their toys either much preferring to be outdoors.
Depending on the child we go for books, pj’s/onesie, the eldest has now decided to get into to Playmobil aged 11!, one likes craft stuff, and one Lego technics. The 18th old likes sand toys and told me he wanted a floor puzzle. The eldest had ice skates, the youngest a scooter. We try to only get one toy each which needs playing with as such. It seems ok. Granny pays for a weeks horse riding lessons in the summer holiday as the Christmas present. I think it’s a question of looking at what they enjoy rather than what you perceive they should be playing with.

NameChange30 · 20/01/2022 19:06

Mine are 4 and 1.
For Christmas I give them one big present (or one or two medium presents if there's nothing big they want/need), stocking presents, and maybe some books or audiobooks.
For birthday it's the same, one big present or a few small/medium ones.
I try and get things they need and will use a lot, such as a bike, scooter or trike. DC1 got a scooter for his second birthday, balance bike the following Christmas, pedal bike the Christmas after that, and will get a bigger bike for his 5th birthday. Good quality kids' bikes are expensive so I don't go mad apart from that.
Anything he asks for or any other ideas I have, I keep a list and will make suggestions to the grandparents when they ask.

I think in your case if you have memories of being disappointed at Christmas, it's understandable to overcompensate a bit. Just remember all they need is one very exciting present and they will be delighted!

jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey · 20/01/2022 18:53

What about gifts to use out and about
Camera
Backpack
Binoculars
Flasks
That kind of thing

grey12 · 20/01/2022 18:46

Have you tried toy rotation? I have 4/5 small shopper bags (nice ones from smyths) and I bring one into the living room for the day. At the end of the day everything gets thrown back in and bag goes away

Contents:

  • train set
  • tea/cooking set
  • construction blocks
  • small figures
  • dress up stuff
  • puzzles

They have more toys but these are in the bags and it works really well Smile

HairyScaryMonster · 20/01/2022 18:30

We've had season tickets to the farm and zoo in previous years paid by family for Xmas.

I would like to recommend magnatiles as a great Xmas gift, expensive but doesn't take up much space, easy to dip into and play with independently.

Darbs76 · 20/01/2022 18:17

Get them out at the weekends

grey12 · 20/01/2022 18:10

I ask for GP to give experiences. Not always successfully but I try Grin One of the GM gaves us a year pass to the Zoo Wink

About opening xmas presents, I actually remember the opposite experience: receiving so many gifts that it got really awkward as they were pilling around me..... Blush so a really nice, big gift is amazing and then maybe a couple of small things like books.

Your children are the same age as mine. They probably have loads of toys and don't need anything more! Do give away toys that they don't play and that you know aren't the best for them.

Sartre · 20/01/2022 16:38

You don’t need to go out all of the time to have fun, maybe stay at home sometimes and play with the unloved toys.

busyeatingbiscuits · 20/01/2022 16:33

Mine get a present and a book from Santa
A stocking with mostly consumables like bath bombs, chocolate, stickers, bubbles and things they need like socks and hairclips

They get a present (toy) under the tree from us and then to be honest I get lots of things they will need anyway!
But fancy/character stuff - Paw Patrol t-shirts and glittery trainers, character bedding.
Things for their hobbies like a kit bag but with their name embroidered on it or character swimming costume instead of a plain one.

Kids like lots of things to open, but a couple of very well chosen toys is better than piles of toys that won't get played with.

Nevermakeit · 20/01/2022 16:25

I have the same thing OP, mine don't actually play with most of their toys at all. I remember when my DD was about 4 she had to bring a picture of her favourite toy to school and I had to give her a picture of her bouncing on the trampoline in the garden as she didn't really engage with anything else.
I think you are in the worst age, it gets a bit easier as they get older.
My solutions have been:

  1. Most of the presents are books (which can get read over and over and take up less space),
  2. Things like nice swimsuit, or in your case football kit / football shoes / football equipment of some sort (eg nice drinking bottle, goalie gloves, an actual football, a popup goal for the garden) which they will use! For girls, you can get things like nice pencil case, fountain pens etc, which also do get used.
  3. Clothes, like a winter coat - maybe not super exciting, but can be if it is a nice one!
  4. A family board game, IF you don't have many or you think you will find the time to play with them in the evening, eg just before they go to bed. Otherwise don't bother, they are too young to play that on their own.
  5. I don't buy them Xmas presents - they get loads from other people, and I will spend that money on things they need or treats through the year, as they will notice a new toy a lot more in say June than they do at Xmas with all the other presents.
  6. buy toys which work with your lifestyle. Eg mine love those water pump things from places like Tiger, which you can use in paddling pools to splash everyone. So not 'at home' toys, but 'days out' toys, if you see what I mean.
olivehater · 20/01/2022 16:20

I go for one big present each. Then something to wear, to read, something to play with, something to eat. Food treats and stationary to fill the stocking and a key ring for their book bag. Vouchers for days out from family and pyjamas are an easy one for them to get. Or practical things for their hobbies. Ie.personalized Boot bag.
One tip I saw was fill the floor with balloons to make it look more exciting.

seekinglondonlife · 20/01/2022 16:13

When mine were small and we were trying to cut back on stuff we would ask grandparents to give a voucher or trip to food/dessert places. One of their favourites was a frozen yoghurt place that we wouldn't have ordinarily gone to, and now they are bigger they said that was one of their best presents.

WellTidy · 20/01/2022 16:09

Ds1 really enjoyed the birthday where we got him new bedding, a lamp, light shade and a soft toy (all the same theme) - I think he was about 6yo.

As he has got older, I’ve done the bedding thing again, lights, desk, name for his door, wall decals, canvases (more lately) - stuff like that. He has always been given far too many toys, most of whaling he has never asked for and unsurprisingly had no interest in. He wasn’t ungrateful, it’s just that he never played with them because he didn’t want them in the first place. Which led to huge amounts of money being wasted and space being taken up. Time and time again.

Membership of something would be great, like a petting farm, soft play, activity centre type thing (like go ape). If it’s too expensive, then just a visit there. Or cinema tickets.

Ds also once really appreciated a £10 sainsburys voicher. We went and he chose a tub of ice cream or two, wafers, toppings, sauces etc. and then we took it all home and played ice cream parlour.

Or maybe go with consumable toys like play doh or paints or Melissa and Doug sticker pads, magic paints (you just add water), scratch art or shrinkles.

Keladrythesaviour · 20/01/2022 16:09

Ask your family to pay for outings through the year, especially if one has a birthday near Christmas. That way it's not 'boring' and it's spreading stuff through the year. They'll get so much more our of activities than a toy they play with once.

emuloc · 20/01/2022 16:06

@bluechilli47

For main stuff follow the rhyme: Something they want Something they need Something to wear Something to read

Bulk it out with loads of cheap stuff that will get used up. Hot chocolate bombs, bath bombs, crayons, chocolate.

The last thing it sounds like you need is loads more stuff, just for the sake of it.
Cocomarine · 20/01/2022 16:01

Stop projecting your own childhood feelings.
They are not you.
They don’t have your context of a poor family.

1 present in a poor family? Could make you sad that you didn’t get what others seem to. 1 present when you’re surrounded by other things - both physical things and trips out, clubs… can be a different feeling.

Just cut the presents down.

My tip is not to rush into a present opening frenzy. Let them play with the just opened present for a while. This makes even a small number of presents into a lengthy “present opening” occasion.

As they get older, I find more and more need (but desirable) items make good presents. Like the football club you mention - new boots are a good present!

myyellowcar · 20/01/2022 16:00

Watching with interest OP as we are overwhelmed and I’m trying to sort out what to sell and what to keep

JustKeepSwimmingJust · 20/01/2022 15:59

Ask family to take them out for a treat. Doesn’t have to be complicated: bowling then a hot dog is utterly thrilling for a 6yo. Plus side: instead of it being an anonymous box, it’s spending from that family member that they will remember being treated by, and strengthens their relationship.

Slingingcontest · 20/01/2022 15:52

I would take the craft stuff and Lego and put it away for a rainy day. It will come in useful when they can't go out for some reason.

And give away any toys that your dc won't play with to a less fortunate family and involve your dc in the process. (Where I live (not UK) there is a good scheme where you can sign up to give a child living in a refuge centre birthday and Christmas presents.)

And while it is fantastic that your dc get to go out so much and have loads of fun with you at weekends, I would personally ask family to share the cost of a toy farm or similar, so that your dc learn how to play on their own and development their imagination, while you do something else, which could be good for them to be more autonomous, and useful for you when they are bigger!

Or, could you ask friends and family to fund a hobby for six months or a year: uniforms, equipment, lessons?

Or impose a budget on presents? Or ask for half of cost to be added to a savings account?

Good luck op Flowers. My mother grew up during the war and our presents were lovely but they were were not numerous or lavish! And we were thrilled to receive them! So I know exactly how you feel!

DaisyTheUnicorn · 20/01/2022 15:48

Its easy to fall into responding to the "where are we going today" trap. But they will ask that if going out is all they've known.

Do you play with them? Set up craft/baking/giant train tracks?

Mayvb go out for the morning and encourage some creative play at home in the afternoon. Play is so important to their development and to learn how to handle down time and not be scheduled the whole time. Time to just "be" and draw/read/etc as rhey get older is so good and is a skill thats hard if they haven't learnt to "be bored" when younger. You dont want to be always having to entertain them or "go out" when "going out" becomes expensive as they get older.

Aside from that in general reducing overload of toys is great. It just jumps out thay yours don't get time to play at home!

RealBecca · 20/01/2022 15:43

Gift essentials luke toothbrushes and consumables.

Charity or sell food quality items so the people who actually want it can have it without driving further demand from shops. Look at LEGO- tons of it available second hand and yet there is still demand for new bricks, its mad.

You aren't responsible for someone else's spending.

Dixiechickonhols · 20/01/2022 15:38

I’d be honest and ask if family would pay for football, beavers etc or pass to zoo etc or buy hobby related items.