Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Think my husband has a lovechild

507 replies

Claire14467 · 20/01/2022 13:37

I am in shock and I don’t know what to do. I have just been contacted by a young man who has done an ancestry.com DNA test. He says the site indicates that there is a parental match to my husband. I know we have done these so they have our DNA on the system but I must say my husband was not keen on it at all at the time.
I am absolutely in shock. He is at work right now and I don’t know how I will face him later. Could this be wrong? Could this man be lying to get money?
Has anyone had a similar experience and got to the bottom of this?! I’m literally shaking with worry and anger.

OP posts:
heelforheelandtoefortoe · 21/01/2022 08:19

Hi OP

I am on ancestry and quite active on it regarding DNA and family tree.

It appears the person who made contact is a DNA match on your DH's paternal line. So he's related on that line rather than your DH being his parent. I suspect that is where the confusion lay.

Ancestry would tell you how much of a match you are and also your link (father, cousin etc). Me and my DF did it and he appears on it as my father. His cousin also appears as my second cousin. Then there's loads of 5th and 5th cousins I've never heard of but it does tell me if its on my father's line or mother's line.

HTH

MarshmallowFondant · 21/01/2022 08:06

@NewModelArmyMayhem18

It's a bit shocking though that people can misinterpret relationships via these sites and potentially cause havoc in families because of it!
It's not surprising given a lot of the responses on this thread.

Most people who are given an Ancestry kit for Christmas have never heard the word "Centimorgan". When their results come in they leap to conclusions without the facts, or assume that a "paternal relation" is their father.

MarshmallowFondant · 21/01/2022 08:02

m thinking of doing my sisters dna for a birthday or Christmas present. Do you mind if I ask if could you tell me which of those 2 sites gave you the best/most information? And do you have to have a subscription to either of them to review the date? Thanks ever so much.

Personally, I would always go for Ancestry.

It's not really "information" though, especially when you are looking at DNA. Your DNA is just a list of numbers, it's a statement rather than information. What the sites like Ancestry are doing is looking for matches in your long string of DNA numbers with other people's string of DNA numbers.

23 and Me started off more as a health testing company - do I have the gene which creates a greater risk of a certain type of cancer? They have a predominantly North American database, never really took off here in the same way.

Ancestry are in a totally different market, it's nothing about health testing at all. They are all about matching you with people who share your DNA. They have the biggest database and many more people from the UK/Ireland in it. You are more likely to get closer matches through Ancestry. Plus there is the whole other side of Ancestry where you can create your family tree and search for records to help you figure out where people fit in.

23 and Me is pure DNA testing, no records whatsoever. So you're still going to need Ancestry, FindMyPast, FamilySearch (and probably a combination of all three) to research too.

LakieLady · 21/01/2022 07:59

Thanks for the update, OP, and really sorry you had such a shock over something that was a complete misunderstanding.

These DNA organisations really should explain things in simple language to prevent this sort of misunderstanding.

Esspee · 21/01/2022 07:43

What a great last post OP. I felt for you.
Hopefully you will be able to help the young man after your adrenaline levels get back to normal.

Tracing my family tree got me through lockdown. I am on 23 and me and ancestry and now have contact with distant relatives abroad and locally whom I had no idea existed. Having lived in New Zealand, the US and the Caribbean I discovered I now live within one mile of where my great and great grandparents were born and died. I have lots of mysteries still to uncover but so far it has brought much joy.

52andblue · 21/01/2022 07:36

A huge relief for the OP no doubt.
Thank you for posting, it has created a very interesting chat & I have learned about the main DNA sites, what they can offer & some pitfalls too.
Also about bullying- that it still exists writ large re the pejorative terms (still used in 2022!) for children born outside of wedlock, & writ small on the thread.

Callingallskeletons · 21/01/2022 07:34

Brilliant news OP, what a stressful evening you must have had! Hope you’re DH was ok as well

NewModelArmyMayhem18 · 21/01/2022 07:34

It's a bit shocking though that people can misinterpret relationships via these sites and potentially cause havoc in families because of it!

Grasping · 21/01/2022 07:18

I hope you get some answers today OP.

zoopigi · 21/01/2022 07:05

Op I hope it all gets cleared up soon. When my husband did his DNA test he found a half sister. The message said it may be a half sister or a niece (his brothers child) turns out it was indeed a half sister and my FIL had been playing away with a 3 year affair starting when my husband was 3.

OVienna · 21/01/2022 07:04

Ancestry has access to research databases. 23andme only gives DNA info- people often select it for the health screening. And in terms of relative relationships both are equally accurate.

TolkiensFallow · 21/01/2022 06:51

I’m glad for you OP. I am also totally put off dna testing by your thread!

Vapeyvapevape · 21/01/2022 06:43

@MyrtlethePurpleTurtle this poster has apologised for the comment a million times over.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 21/01/2022 06:31

@elelel

A love child?

You mean 'a child' ?

What a not helpful response
Ellowyn · 21/01/2022 06:04

I'm thinking of doing my sisters dna for a birthday or Christmas present. Do you mind if I ask if could you tell me which of those 2 sites gave you the best/most information? And do you have to have a subscription to either of them to review the date? Thanks ever so much

23&Me gives you more scientific information and you can take part in studies, but it's more expensive.

With both of them, you pay for the DNA kit, send it back with your sample and several weeks later you can see the results, which includes all your DNA relatives who are also on there. I find 23&Me has better results with the genetic traits and health etc. It's updated as new research is completed. I have been with them for ten years and never paid for a subscription - just my initial cost for the DNA kit. They ask me to take part in research, which is just answering a lot of questions about my health/traits. They use it for research as they have my DNA raw data on file. You can opt out of this.

Ancestry.com can be a bit scammy. It appears I can look at my DNA info without paying additional costs, but you have to subscribe to do family tree research. I subscribed for 6 months to research my family tree only to discover I could only see US records which are no good to me as I'm British - all my family has been British going back hundreds of years. They wanted quite a bit more money for me to see the British records. I don't think much of one of their spin-off companies, Newspapers.com. There was a newspaper article I wanted to read, so I paid the fee for a month to read newspapers and went immediately back to read the article only to be told I had to upgrade $$ to read it. IT WAS THE SAME ARTICLE I JUST PAID FOR. I'm so mad about it.

I think more British people use the Ancestry DNA because I have uncles, Aunts and first cousins on Ancestry DNA but only very, very distant cousins on 23&Me. In other words, my British family don't seem to use it, maybe because it's more expensive. (I did put my sons and my fathers DNA on 23&Me).

I get frequent emails from 23&Me informing me I have new (distant) relatives or asking me to take part in research, and also informing me of new research results. I don't seem to get updates like that from the Ancestry DNA.

Hydrate · 21/01/2022 01:19

Glad it was not a parent child match, sorry for the dna match still not knowing the answers they seek. Was he a high match?

LemonSwan · 21/01/2022 00:51

It turns out that there is a link in the paternal line and we are not sure where, but clearly there has been a misunderstanding somewhere here.

Well thank god for that! What a stress for you OP

AcrossthePond55 · 21/01/2022 00:37

Well, that's a relief.

Although I know it's been upsetting to you, I do feel for the young man a bit. He's obviously searching for his father and thought he'd found him, even if he did handle it 'a bit clumsily'.

If there is 'close enough' paternal link do you think your DH would be willing to help him figure who that link is? If it were me, I'd have to think very carefully. On one hand you have a child wanting to locate a parent. On the other hand you may have a person who has either been longing for reunion or who lives in fear of having his life blown apart. As an adoptee, I think it's a real double-edged sword.

JazzyBBG · 20/01/2022 23:58

Pleased for you what a relief. This poor chap is still looking for his dad though!

madisonbridges · 20/01/2022 23:46

@Ellowyn

I have my DNA at both 23&Me and Ancestry. 23&Me is far better. If they told you someone was your father he actually would be.
I'm thinking of doing my sisters dna for a birthday or Christmas present. Do you mind if I ask if could you tell me which of those 2 sites gave you the best/most information? And do you have to have a subscription to either of them to review the date? Thanks ever so much.
blyn72 · 20/01/2022 23:41

I'm glad you have talked to your husband and are reassured.

PrincessFiorimonde · 20/01/2022 23:38

Thanks for updating, OP. What a relief to find that (as some pp suggested) the young man appears to have confused a paternal link with a parental link.

Flowers for you for the worry you must have felt before realising that.

StopStartStop · 20/01/2022 23:14

I have this on ancestry. Every line leads back to aristocracy. And so many of my ancestors seem to have migrated to America in the sixteenth century, leaving their children behind in the UK. Er, no, don't think so mate. Not in such numbers. So, you trace back to the error and start again... takes ages. Great hobby.

MarshmallowFondant · 20/01/2022 23:13

Unlike people who are lacking in the ability to read the thread??

UserBot999 · 20/01/2022 23:11

@2022success

Why has he contacted you rather than your DH? Confused
Yes this is odd. He must be lacking in basic diplomacy, sensitivity and judgment to contact the spouse of his biological parent.