Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Think my husband has a lovechild

507 replies

Claire14467 · 20/01/2022 13:37

I am in shock and I don’t know what to do. I have just been contacted by a young man who has done an ancestry.com DNA test. He says the site indicates that there is a parental match to my husband. I know we have done these so they have our DNA on the system but I must say my husband was not keen on it at all at the time.
I am absolutely in shock. He is at work right now and I don’t know how I will face him later. Could this be wrong? Could this man be lying to get money?
Has anyone had a similar experience and got to the bottom of this?! I’m literally shaking with worry and anger.

OP posts:
OVienna · 21/01/2022 10:45

@givememykeys

The Ancestry results are categorised. Mine says 'Parent/child' and then lists my birth father.

The next category is 'Close Family' then 'Extended Family.'

So, I guess if this person's match is coming up under 'Close Family' they could be confused for that reason.

OVienna · 21/01/2022 10:41

@Mommabear20

My uncle had some contact him through this site claiming to be his son, checked the app, yes all matched, definitely his son, uncle very confused as was adamant he hadn't cheated on his wife, got an official paternity test done and turns out he wasn't the guys dad. I don't trust ancestry or any of those sites as there's so many times they've ruined peoples life's and turned out to be wrong
Can I just check you are seriously saying that Ancestry showed that this individual shared 50% DNA with your uncle but they did an external paternity test and it wasn't the case?

Or was the scenario something else and they read the results wrong?

I have matched with my birth father on two separate sites. In my case, I do have other 'evidence' but ime for something as categoric as a parent there is no chance the findings are wrong. I think there is something missing in the story here, they probably didn't match that accurately.

givememykeys · 21/01/2022 10:40

@OVienna

Most people who are given an Ancestry kit for Christmas have never heard the word "Centimorgan". When their results come in they leap to conclusions without the facts, or assume that a "paternal relation" is their father.

This is all very bizarre. I am on several DNA type pages on FB with thousands of members in some cases. People come on every day to discuss their results and what they mean.

I have never encountered someone quite as confused as the person who contacted the OP is at least being presented as. "Paternal vs Parental" - really? It's not even just being confused about the words, it's the huge psychological step it takes to finally reach out to a parent, let alone the SPOUSE of the parent as a first port of call. This is a really 'niche' approach, to say the least.

@Claire14467 take things VERY slowly here.

I can totally see how someone who is trying to find their father and signs up to one of these type of sites without knowing much about it or maybe doesn't have great literacy skills and confuses paternal with parental. That seems like a really easy mistake to make in what is probably a very emotional time

The way the contact has been explained it sounds like you send a message via the site with no personal details so all you know is that you are contacting your match. I could be wrong but you don't know who is actually the person that will read your message in the first instance.

I'm guessing it's along the lines of "I think you might be my father" rather than "Your husband is my dad"

givememykeys · 21/01/2022 10:36

@LadyEloise1

I'm still wondering why they contacted *@Claire14467* instead of their "father". Very odd.
It isn't odd though @LadyEloise1, many posters have explained how it works and the way they are set up on the site. Which part makes you still wonder?
UniversalAunt · 21/01/2022 10:34

Nailed it again @MarshmallowFondant

‘Ancestry is not dodgy. People's understanding of Ancestry, centimorgans and interpreting DNA results most definitely can be. Ancestry kits are heavily marketed as a perfect Christmas gift and are often taken by people who have zero experience in family history research and who, when confronted with a pile of matches, have no clue where to start with it all and make basic errors like assuming paternal matches are their father. Or misreading "paternal" as "parental". ‘

catandcandle · 21/01/2022 10:04

I am on the other side of the scenario, except in my case the man IS my biological father. I knew the likely name decades ago, but Ancestry confirmed it (he had not tested but his sister had). I have not contacted him directly (through Ancestry, anyway, I did write to him about 10 years ago but he never replied and i left it at that). I have contacted some of his cousins and they have been very interested and welcoming. But they were a bit suspicious of my motives at first, understandably.

MarshmallowFondant · 21/01/2022 09:56

If you're doing DNA, paternity tests etc done then you do them correctly, not just through an app via Ancestry which as can be seen from this thread is a bit dodgy.

But Ancestry does not market itself as a paternity testing company and never has done. That is a totally different kettle of fish.

Ancestry is not dodgy. People's understanding of Ancestry, centimorgans and interpreting DNA results most definitely can be. Ancestry kits are heavily marketed as a perfect Christmas gift and are often taken by people who have zero experience in family history research and who, when confronted with a pile of matches, have no clue where to start with it all and make basic errors like assuming paternal matches are their father. Or misreading "paternal" as "parental".

Loads of people don't even understand what terms like third cousin or second cousin once removed mean.

UniversalAunt · 21/01/2022 09:51

A helpful post above from @MarshmallowFondant about why Ancestry is a good starting point.

Ancestry has the largest repository of DNA testers & this is a is a good base for first set of matching. There are loads (!) of people in the US, Australia & beyond searching on Ancestry & other sites for their forebears who migrated through the recurring diasporas to the ‘new’ countries. Hence the prevalence of 3- 5th cousins where people with shared matches at this level can be link back to multiplied Greats of GreatGrandparents.

YouTube hosts load of quality bloggers about Ancestry & DNA genealogy - top tips & how to avoid being sidetracked down rabbit holes.
Always do your own research through records to confirm matches. Some family trees online are built by meticulous research & the owners usually quote their sources, e.g. birth records, census records etc, & these may help you on your way, but always double check.

As *@MarshmallowFondant describes the file that contains the DNA data is literally a list of numbers, & it is Ancestry DNA data files that can be easily exported to the other mainstream consumer DNA genealogy sites * e.g. Family Tree DNA, My Heritage & GEDmatch (a meta analysis site) where you will find new or overlapping records of DNA test results loaded up by their owners, which expands your search base at no extra or little cost. The reverse is not so, Ancestry does not accept DNA data files from other test sites.

Gonnagetgoing · 21/01/2022 09:49

@Mommabear20

My uncle had some contact him through this site claiming to be his son, checked the app, yes all matched, definitely his son, uncle very confused as was adamant he hadn't cheated on his wife, got an official paternity test done and turns out he wasn't the guys dad. I don't trust ancestry or any of those sites as there's so many times they've ruined peoples life's and turned out to be wrong
@Mommabear20 - that is seriously messed up and if Ancestry are doing this I'd be slightly concerned if I were them because someone with money may well sue their site.

If you're doing DNA, paternity tests etc done then you do them correctly, not just through an app via Ancestry which as can be seen from this thread is a bit dodgy.

MarshmallowFondant · 21/01/2022 09:48

@LadyEloise1

I'm still wondering why they contacted *@Claire14467* instead of their "father". Very odd.
Maybe try reading the thread? Hmm
Gonnagetgoing · 21/01/2022 09:47

@StopStartStop

I have this on ancestry. Every line leads back to aristocracy. And so many of my ancestors seem to have migrated to America in the sixteenth century, leaving their children behind in the UK. Er, no, don't think so mate. Not in such numbers. So, you trace back to the error and start again... takes ages. Great hobby.
@StopStartStop - we've got a cousin in USA through my great aunt who emigrated to Canada (great aunt long since dead) who was looking into family history on Ancestry.

He seemed determined to be able to prove us right re certain aspects of my nana's (GA's sister) heritage/lineage and wanted to go onto Ancestry and pay for this (my DM was reluctant to spend so much money), so we were quite happy to say no to him.

LadyEloise1 · 21/01/2022 09:44

I'm still wondering why they contacted @Claire14467 instead of their "father".
Very odd.

Mommabear20 · 21/01/2022 09:37

My uncle had some contact him through this site claiming to be his son, checked the app, yes all matched, definitely his son, uncle very confused as was adamant he hadn't cheated on his wife, got an official paternity test done and turns out he wasn't the guys dad. I don't trust ancestry or any of those sites as there's so many times they've ruined peoples life's and turned out to be wrong

MarshmallowFondant · 21/01/2022 09:34

Agree there is a lot of rubbish on Ancestry.

The site is designed to make it as easy as possible to create your tree and get started - and that's great. But the downside is that the "click and collect" genealogists will just accept every single hint and never stop to think whether it's really possible that John SMITH born in Birmingham, England in 1850 was the father of Jean SMITH born in Birmingham, Alabama in 1860. Click click click - look how massive my tree is! Look how far I've got back! I'm related to William the Conqueror or Anne Boleyn!

Some trees are great, my advice is always to look at the sources/records which the user has attached to the individual and go for there. Never ever accept someone else's research without verifying it first.

Rubysocold · 21/01/2022 09:28

Yes, you have be careful and check dates properly; not just make the evidence fit with what you want.

UniversalAunt · 21/01/2022 09:23

Hi @knittingaddict our paths may have crossed at the London Record Centre. Assume you busy with 1921 😀

UniversalAunt · 21/01/2022 09:21

Hi @Claire14467 it’s good to see your post late last night with the update.

So a connection on the young man’s paternal line & traced back could turn out to be very interesting - could be you’ve struck some Ancestry gold 😀.

Once you have established the shared cM link between your DH & ‘new’ cousin, you may find the table I posted up yesterday of interest.

knittingaddict · 21/01/2022 09:19

But don't trust the family trees on Ancestry. Every single one I've looked at have errors, some of them obviously so. Ancestry gives you hints as to possible relevant records and some/most people seem to just add that to their tree without thinking about it. Always do your own research and check everything.

knittingaddict · 21/01/2022 09:08

@TracyMosby

I dont get it. Ive looked at ancestry And it is £14 a month. What is there to gain from paying that?
Where to start.

I spend literally hours a day on there at the moment, as well as Find My Past. There are all sorts of records on there - baptisms, marriages, census, coroners reports, newspaper articles. The list is endless.

When I first started it was a case of going to London and local archive offices. You can imagine how expensive that was. It's a luxury to sit at home and be able to research with a cup of coffee and a biscuit next to you. It's my main hobby at the moment and I love it.

OVienna · 21/01/2022 08:57

@nitsandwormsdodger

I’ve done 24 and me and found cousins all over the world The health info is intense Brac1 and brac2 breast cancer and Parkinson’s and dementia genes as as as 50 other diseases I’ve never heard of also my muscles are not elite athletic!
When people say these tests 'aren't reliable' what they are talking about is often the medical screening part (and the ethnicity.)

You're cross checking whatever they've reported with your doctor, right?

nitsandwormsdodger · 21/01/2022 08:51

I’ve done 24 and me and found cousins all over the world
The health info is intense Brac1 and brac2 breast cancer and Parkinson’s and dementia genes as as as 50 other diseases I’ve never heard of also my muscles are not elite athletic!

Grasping · 21/01/2022 08:43

I considered buying one of these for my DBros birthday but decided that was a can of worms that didn’t need opening Grin

Coffeepot72 · 21/01/2022 08:41

It's a bit shocking though that people can misinterpret relationships via these sites and potentially cause havoc in families because of it!

Absolutely!

MarshmallowFondant · 21/01/2022 08:26

Ancestry would tell you how much of a match you are and also your link (father, cousin etc). Me and my DF did it and he appears on it as my father. His cousin also appears as my second cousin. Then there's loads of 5th and 5th cousins I've never heard of but it does tell me if its on my father's line or mother's line.

Only because your Dad has tested and you have (presumably) linked to him on your tree as your Dad.

For people (like me) whose parents haven't tested through Ancestry, you will still get the suggested relationship between you and the other person, but it can't tell you whether it's on the maternal or paternal side. You can "tag" matches with maternal/paternal to help the site suggest where other people might fit in.

OVienna · 21/01/2022 08:25

Most people who are given an Ancestry kit for Christmas have never heard the word "Centimorgan". When their results come in they leap to conclusions without the facts, or assume that a "paternal relation" is their father.

This is all very bizarre. I am on several DNA type pages on FB with thousands of members in some cases. People come on every day to discuss their results and what they mean.

I have never encountered someone quite as confused as the person who contacted the OP is at least being presented as. "Paternal vs Parental" - really? It's not even just being confused about the words, it's the huge psychological step it takes to finally reach out to a parent, let alone the SPOUSE of the parent as a first port of call. This is a really 'niche' approach, to say the least.

@Claire14467 take things VERY slowly here.