Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to leave a 2 year old with a babysitter they dont know?

61 replies

OfstedOffred · 20/01/2022 11:23

Friend thinks IABU to not ever want to leave 2 year old with a babysitter who is a complete stranger to them. Eg an agency sitter etc, gym creche with random staff. Friend thinks I am being a "martyr".

AIBU?

FWIW 2 yr old in question reasonably often wakes around 10 or 11pm. Settles quickly but would be terrified if there was only a stranger there.

To avoid drip feed:
I have an older DC aged 5 and in recent months have felt they are old enough to be on with this - as they dont wake at night and in any case are used to going to swimming lessons etc without a parent, and would understand what was going on if it was explained to them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CamomileTeabag · 20/01/2022 18:26

You need to do your research not just assume all strangers are ‘bad’

It's nothing to do with not trusting the carer and everything to do with it being traumatic for a young child to wake up and find mummy and daddy missing and a stranger in the house.

There is NO WAY I would ever have done this. Grandparents, trusted friend or neighbour, keyworker or nursery staff - fine, but not agency staff or some random unknown babysitter.

UglyModernWindows · 20/01/2022 14:08

@OfstedOffred Yes it's different if it's only an odd situation you can't get the childcare you like. It happens, you can't always go to all the outings you want to. But in many people case, they can never go anywhere because there is no family near by at all.

My DC went to both nursery and preschool but in neither case, the staff was unable to babysit. So that option was out. I didn't know any local teens and in any case preferred to have a full vetted adult rather than a teen when DC were small. We later had two teen boys when ours had gotten older and they were great. Very occasionally we did a babysitting swap with friends but I always felt obliged to get back home fairly quickly, when you pay for the service, I felt more relaxed and able to enjoy my night. Just a different point of view.

OfstedOffred · 20/01/2022 13:59

I mean, you could invite the babysitter round for half an hour before you go out.

I just think even having met someone for a half hour, when my 2 yr wakes half asleep and a bit distressed (definitely will wake) they will be so scared that it's someone they barely know standing over their bed

OP posts:
OfstedOffred · 20/01/2022 13:56

I simply refused to become a recluse just because my DC might be upset for five minutes.

I guess because I've always had options my kids are familiar with it's not like I've had to be a recluse. I can only think of a handful of occasions where I've had to skip something because my regular babysitting options have fallen through.

OP posts:
ChiefWiggumsBoy · 20/01/2022 13:56

I mean, you could invite the babysitter round for half an hour before you go out. That’s what most parents did back in the day when I was babysitting.

But obviously it’s completely up to you and what you’re comfortable with.

RedCandyApple · 20/01/2022 13:54

I think a crèche/holiday club is totally different to someone you barely know in your house alone with your child, sorry but it’s not even close to them same thing.

Camomila · 20/01/2022 13:52

I would be fine in the day time with a gym creche/holiday kids club etc. as neither of my DC are shy and are used to nursery/school.

For night time I would only leave them with grandparents/my brother though as they would just get too upset if they woke up to find someone they didn't know well.

LakeShoreD · 20/01/2022 13:48

I’m pretty lax, am all about the holiday kid clubs, love the gym crèche, find sitters on Bubble etc but even I wouldn’t leave a child that is guaranteed to wake with someone they don’t know. If it’s evening babysitting then I think they need to be old enough understand they’re being left, know the sitter, or be 110% reliable so that you’re certain they won’t wake up. In your situation there’s no way I’d go. Being a martyr would mean not leaving them ever but you have a trusted regular sitter so friend is being rude and unfair. But I do think you’re being a bit precious about about stuff like the gym crèche. Its one thing to think twice if they’re clinging to your leg crying at drop off but if they’re happy to get stuck in with the toys then what can possibly happen in an hour whilst you work out and in the unlikely event that there was an issue they would contact you and you’d be there in minutes!

elbea · 20/01/2022 13:47

We only use our daughters nursery key worker for babysitting, if she’s not available we don’t go!

UglyModernWindows · 20/01/2022 13:46

This thread is dripping in judgement and it's not from the OP.

I would have been stuck at home for years if we haven't had the option to use various sitter services and OMG use STRANGERS!!!! I simply refused to become a recluse just because my DC might be upset for five minutes. Tbh they never were upset because they were used to meeting new people (STRANGERS!!!) and always had fun with them. I don't think our marriage had survived either if we'd never had a moment to ourselves.

We have no family near by at all. We used The Sitters for 10 years and met so many lovely women through them. At one point we had a regular babysitter, an older lady through them. My DC built a wonderful relationship with her and were always excited to have her to come. We also had another lady who was a Norland Nanny, she was great. Another one was a young 20 something woman who had a great energy and my DS took such a shine on her, it was very cute.

To me this is a weird MN thing. Where we live, all the holiday camps, creches etc are always fully booked. Most of the kids going into these have never met the staff before.

OfstedOffred · 20/01/2022 13:30

I've had situations of babies / toddlers waking up and being absolutely distraught that im a stranger. It's not nice.

It's this, this is what I dont like. I'm totally fine with using a sitter but have made the effort to have a regular one or use a friend so that my kids actually know the person and it's not scary. To me it's not worth getting a random person in on one occasion because DH's friend Bob wants EVERYONE over for drinks because you don't turn 37 every day....

OP posts:
LaBelleSausage · 20/01/2022 13:29

I think you're being totally reasonable and sensible. You know your child best and how they will react.

I will only go out for the evening if I can leave my kids (2 and 4) with family or the staff they know well from nursery, as if they did wake in the night it's because something is wrong - and if that's the case they would want a familiar face.

OfstedOffred · 20/01/2022 13:26

Are you complaining about it? Why is your friend saying you are a martyr?

Nope not complaining! I have a regular babysitter, neighbours daughter who is a student, kids love her. Friend is wife of DH friend. Is complaining because her DH has moved his birthday drinks, we had had usual sitter booked but now its short notice on a different date, sitter isnt free and havent got any other friends the kids know or family free. I'm not willing to use an agency sitter they've never met, so i'll stay home with them. DH still going but friend thinks I'm being ridiculous and should just ring and get whoever from sitters.

OP posts:
JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 20/01/2022 13:24

I never did it. I know plenty of people who did. They were happy to leave their child with people at gym and IKEA crèche facilities, or use local teenagers looking for cash for babysitting and were always happy to drop and run at parties. That's up to them. It wasn't something I was happy doing. I didn't judge them. I actually don't care if they judged me. I was just doing what I felt comfortable with and more importantly what my DD felt comfortable with.

Stick to your guns. If you don't want to leave your 2-year old with anyone then don't. Your friend is being very rude to call you a martyr.

OfstedOffred · 20/01/2022 13:20

Ozanj

Sorry I think you've misunderstood me. No concerns with the safety/responsibility of the sitter, my concern is over my child being scared/upset by being left with someone they have never met.

I understand this happens when they first start in any childcare but usually its isolated to the initial settling period and within a few days they are settled with that childcare and it's no longer strange to them.

I'm talking about things like a sitters service or hotel babysitter where your child hasnt met the person before/barely knows them.

OP posts:
UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 20/01/2022 13:15

Momicrone there is no reason to think the OP is complaining about not being able to go out though. She's complaining about being told she's a martyr.

Actually being a martyr would be making yourself and your children miserable/ anxious/ unhappy or messing up your sleep in order to meet demands made by another adult, or prove something (how relaxed you are, how you haven't changed since having children, how "in charge" or no nonsense you are) to that adult.

Sometimes it does matter psychologically to people what others do because they feel judged or undermined unless others make the same decisions as them.

On a more everyday level friends and acquaintances often want things their way and feel put out when others don't play along, whether that means getting a babysitter to go out like you did pre kids, or bringing grandchildren to late evening restaurant meal, or declining to visit someone who smokes in the house or has nippy, poorly trained dogs, or whatever else.

RedCandyApple · 20/01/2022 13:12

Well I’ve seen some parents asking for babysitters on local Facebook groups so honestly I’m not surprised some parents aren’t fussed if the child has met the person before..

HeadToToesNo · 20/01/2022 13:09

This is really interesting as I'm in a similar but I'm getting pressure from my family to leave my children with a stranger babysitting them while we are on holiday next month.
I have never left them with someone they don't know, and I am absolutely not comfortable doing it, but they are all behaving like I'm crazy and it's a totally fine and normal thing to do.
Glad to read everyone else's attitude seems to match my own!

MrsGHarrison87 · 20/01/2022 13:08

I would never do that. The only people I've left my children with are family members who I trust can look after them properly or that can deal with watching them for half an hour in an emergency. I would never leave my kids with a babysitter off a website no matter what qualifications or checks they've had. It's often sneered at on here if you're not willing to leave your child with a stranger and you're called paranoid. Sorry but no fucking way.

saraclara · 20/01/2022 13:08

In the daytime is different. The child either knows they're somewhere different (creche/gym) or they've met the person caring for them before they go down for a nap, and when they wake it's not new. I didn't hesitate to do that

But I wouldn't ask someone they didn't know to babysit at night. Waking up in the dark to find a stranger over their cot/bed? that's going to be pretty terrifying. Fortunately my mum friends and I would sit for each other when mine were small. So they were known to my kids.

RowanAlong · 20/01/2022 13:07

Not at 2, I wouldn’t have. But each to their own!

Landof · 20/01/2022 12:59

As a professional nanny I do occasional babysitting for new families. You wouldn't believe how many of them aren't bothered about me meeting the children beforehand. I always make it known that I'm happy to meet them beforehand (with no cost to the family) not least because the child will have seen my face at least once. I've had situations of babies / toddlers waking up and being absolutely distraught that im a stranger. It's not nice. I obviously call parents but I've had some not want to come back because they are enjoying and I've eventually managed to get them back off. I'm obviously trained for all sorts of scenarios and 99% of the time it all goes smoothly but no matter what training you have, some children aren't OK with strangers.

Opus17 · 20/01/2022 12:58

I have an 18 month old. I'd never do it either.

HopefulProcrastinator · 20/01/2022 12:55

It's personal preference, but I wouldn't do it either.

The only time I'd consider a qualified stranger to look after one of my children when that young would have been for an emergency, not for me to have a 'night off'.

Applefruitcake · 20/01/2022 12:54

YANBU if that's not your thing, but YABU to judge others who think differently. Lots of parents don't any family support for childcare, this might be their only chance to take a little break every once in a while.

I work in an agency as an emergency nanny / ad hoc babysitter, I've worked with literally hundreds of children. Some are super friendly with new people and don't care at all that their parents are leaving, others need a bit more time to get used to the idea. Ultimately, parents will know best how their children will react. You could for example, start the sit earlier so the child can meet the b.sitter beforehand then put them to bed yourself and leave. Or you could build up with a few sessions, so they're not complete strangers. I've found most children actually really enjoy having babysitters. I mean, how often would they get an adult to play whatever they want with them? and rules are usually much more relaxed than normal!