Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask my MIL to stop making fat comments around my son?

91 replies

Charl881 · 20/01/2022 09:49

Two weeks in a row now my MIL has told my 19 month old son that he’ll get fat if he keeps eating.

He’s not fat, nowhere near it, but even if he was I don’t think that she should be making such comments to someone at such a young age.

I want to ask her to stop but not sure how well it will go down or if I’m just being unreasonable.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 20/01/2022 15:36

FIL is bad in a different direction. He's really happy all his GCs are 'skinny'. He tries to comment on it constantly. DD eats like someone is going to take it away, she's just tall so it has somewhere to go.

When he started it, when DD was a similar age, I said through pursed lips, "food is not a battleground in this house". He still tries it every now and again and I shut him down. "Well if you want your GC to develop eating disorders, go right ahead". Just one of the ways his lack of filters and self-obsession leak though. I really miss MIL at these times.

FreshHeaven · 20/01/2022 15:26

Yanbu.

Sweep89 · 20/01/2022 15:25

@Stellaris22

YANBU. My father makes comments to my 8 year old DD about 'getting a tummy' and says it as a joke, I hate it.
That seems incredibly mean spirited. If I were you I'd tell your daughter that your dad is it a bit of a nob and she probably shouldn't listen to him 😅.
luckyleeds · 20/01/2022 14:43

My MIL does this. I've told her a few times to stop. Last week we went for a meal and she was still non stop talking to dd about her meal and nitpicking about what she was eating in the wrong order,total rubbish. So I asked her to butt out again, and then started doing to her, what she had done to my dd. "Oooo MIL, why haven't you eaten your carrots? Too hard? That's very fussy. Go on, eat them....go on eat them. You've eaten a lot of meat haven't you? " she wasn't amused but I think it got my point across

billy1966 · 20/01/2022 14:24

@RedRobyn2021

I don't think she should be saying that to anyone let alone a toddler
This.

Most people with eating disorders can trace back their issues to the rude, tackless remark of someone about their weight.

You are completely correct to not tolerate this.

monotonousmum · 20/01/2022 14:00

My Mum is always making odd comments too, like 'you don't want to be fat like Nanny'.
I've asked her to stop and it did improve for a while. But it's like she doesn't realise she's doing it, or thinks if she's only putting herself down it doesn't matter.

I'll continue telling her to stop. Maybe one day she'll understand.

IggyAce · 20/01/2022 13:42

My mum pulled that with my dcs and didn’t listen to my requests to stop. She started when my dcs were older so when she didn’t stop after my request I taught my children to respond with “have you looked in the mirror nanna”. She soon stopped, she tried to make out they were cheeky/disrespectful but I pointed out that she it was her that was and that my dcs were only speaking the truth. Yes she is a larger lady.

Mandy8888 · 20/01/2022 13:38

I agree it's not nice, definitely say something or respond with something positive to the child to make her think twice

MzHz · 20/01/2022 13:38

“MIL, stfu… that’s enough and if you don’t stop, we’ll leave and won’t be back. I won’t have you making ridiculous comments like that to my son.”

That is the simplest way to resolve this.

Why on earth haven’t you put her in he place before now?

dangerrabbit · 20/01/2022 13:36

Awful comments from your MIL! Glad to see you are addressing it. Some good advice on this thread about how to talk back. Also shocked at some of the stories in this thread. To the one who's granny said she was still fat after not seeing her for 10 years, I'd be inclined to say "I see you still have the same personality."

Sedai · 20/01/2022 13:30

Totally agree with the comments about nipping it in the bud as and when it happens.
To those saying you're being sensitive- my beautiful 21 year old sister died from an eating disorder so f away off with those comments please and thank you.

Charl881 · 20/01/2022 13:00

@Coyoacan exactly that!

OP posts:
Stellaris22 · 20/01/2022 12:50

YANBU. My father makes comments to my 8 year old DD about 'getting a tummy' and says it as a joke, I hate it.

Coyoacan · 20/01/2022 12:48

Even if a child were morbidly obese, any comments about their food intake should be made to the person responsible for feeding them, not to the child

HelloFrostyMorning · 20/01/2022 12:30

YANBU, she sounds rude! Some MILs are like that (and grandparents too,) and mothers! Why do they think it's acceptable? Fucks me right off!

Charl881 · 20/01/2022 12:14

@Tal45 thanks… he has a perfectly balanced diet. No chocolate, very little processed food. I think he’s had chips about three times in his life and had no real interest in them.

Even if he was chubby, the point is that I don’t want him growing up with negative body image.

OP posts:
Charl881 · 20/01/2022 12:06

Thanks everyone, sorry only just checked back here now and seen all these comments! Good to know I’m not being unreasonable and sorry some of you have experienced this personally.

@AliasGrape I really like that suggestion, I think I’ll definitely wait until she does it again and mention it there and then rather than making it a big awkward conversation.

The stupid thing is he’s not even a chubby toddler, most he’s ever been is on the 25th percentile. So it’s very much a case of her putting her own body image issues onto him rather than her saying it out of any concern for his health. She genuinely doesn’t mean anything nasty by it, I just don’t think she’s considered the impact her words could have.

OP posts:
Tal45 · 20/01/2022 11:34

While the comments need to stop I'd also look at what you're feeding him to have the comments arise. Just because he's not fat to your eyes doesn't mean it's ok for him to be snacking on processed, high fat, high salt, high sugar food - or that he's not actually over weight. It can be hard for people to tell especially with young children. If you're feeding him healthy, nutritious food then no problem but he's hardly more than a baby and so it's really important for him to have a healthy diet.

BashStreetKid · 20/01/2022 11:34

Absolutely say something. It doesn't have to be confrontational, just a simple statement that you really don't want your child to grow with eating issues and you'd rather she didn't say that sort of thing to him. It may be best if it comes from your partner, though, as otherwise you will be cast as the villain.

If she ignores it, you're going to have to think about cutting down contact.

IntermittentParps · 20/01/2022 11:33

Absolutely YANBU, except you need to tell her, not ask.
Personal comment about anyone's appearance are not OK.

Hollywolly1 · 20/01/2022 11:32

And by the way I'm not being sensitive

Hollywolly1 · 20/01/2022 11:31

Is there something badly wrong with her?? Like wtf I definitely wouldn't be leaving her to mind mind my baby as I'd be afraid she wouldn't feed the child.some people think they can say what they like and get away with it,this is your very precious baby and how dare she be so horrible. I get the feeling its you she wants to get at and not the baby.She could be very jealous of you and you may not have realised it

Sally872 · 20/01/2022 11:30

It's not acceptable to say that to any child. I would definitely say something.

Maybe as it happens
"Gran, we don't comment on anyone's size it can be hurtful" or "please don't use the word fat, we would be mortified if he said that to someone who is fat and I want to encourage him to eat not discourage it "

If that doesn't work then proper chat. Ideally dh says "Mum I don't agree with commenting on food or size. We want dc to have healthy attitude to food and body image. I realise you don't mean any harm I don't need you to understand or agree but I do need you to respect our choices on this"

minimadgirl · 20/01/2022 11:28

My mil does the same with my 20 month old. I need to nip it in the bud as she did it with my Sil's daughters and still now at 16 and 18 they won't eat in front of her. They are so skinny bordering on too thin.
She also calls my husband fat, he's 9 stone wet.

However this is the woman that gave me a weight loss leaflet 5 days after I had given birth.

Lancssss · 20/01/2022 11:27

@PAFMO

Babies are supposed to be "fat". Though at 19 months and presumably mobile it'll be redistributing now. Unless your Health Visitor has noted that he is, in fact, unhealthily big, then she should be told to stop commenting on her grandchild's weight.
In my opinion even if he was overweight and the health visitor had discussed it, I’d still think that she shouldn’t be saying anything and definitely not using the word fat to a child. It would be up to the parents to deal with sensitively. OP I think you should definitely ask her to stop, or better still get his Dad to tell her.