Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you have an infectious disease, you should stay home?

177 replies

Notcontent · 20/01/2022 09:17

So apparently the need to isolate if you have COVID will end in March. To me that seems to be sending an odd message… I am all for COVID restrictions being lifted - but surely if someone knows they have a virus, they should just stay at home??

I always thought it was pretty selfish for people with the flu or a stomach virus etc to just go out and spread their virus on public transport, to colleagues at work, etc.

I thought that a positive to come out of COVID might be that people will be more mindful about not spreading illness but it seems the message being given is that it’s fine to expose others!

OP posts:
OniferousWasp · 20/01/2022 11:48

@Ilikewinter

Maybe its time to rethink phoning in work sick. Yes I and many of my colleagues have been in work full of cold and coughing everywhere, we dose ourselves up on cold medication and crack on. Inevitably then everyone else catches the cold and no one thanks the first person for passing it round. Ive gone into work through feeling guilty of taking time off, in future if I had covid or felt truly ill I would probably take a couple of days off now.
I completely agree with you. I hope it continues to be acceptable for people who have symptoms of coughing and sneezing everywhere to work from home, if they can. I worked from home for a while before getting a job in an office a few years ago. I was always baffled by the fact that people would still come in, cough and sneeze throughout the day, when they could’ve worked from home. Almost everyone would then up catching it.
PartyOnKale · 20/01/2022 11:46

The reason UK kids have a government flu vaccine programme is to stop spread among the older folk who are far more likely to end up in hospital.
I read about a study (done in Eton I think (close contacts, controlled environment!) which showed just how much flu was circulating among the teens. Much showing little to no symptoms.

thewhatsit · 20/01/2022 11:44

By the way, I would agree with you if it was simple. If we all had some kind of switch on us that flicked on every time we were incubating some kind of virus, either knowingly or unknowingly, and it switched off when we were no longer infectious. But life isn’t like that.

We’ve all had colds where the cough drags on and on for weeks and weeks. Presumably we were not infectious after the first few days but of course if you go out with a hacking cough that you’ve had for 2 weeks you’ll still get glared at. Often we don’t know we have a cold (or Covid etc!) until it’s too late.

teaandchocolate1 · 20/01/2022 11:43

The economy does a lot for a lot of people. Gives people jobs that enable them to pay mortgage or rent, put a roof over their head, feed their children for example!

hugr · 20/01/2022 11:42

If I was back at work, I would have had to take the 3.5 weeks off to look after my son unpaid.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/01/2022 11:42

@hugr people can't just take time off for a cold. Do you honestly want people to lose their jobs? Or go without pay?!

TheMoth · 20/01/2022 11:42

I thought flu, proper flu was v different to a cold. I've had plenty of proper horrible colds over the years, but think I've only had flu about 4 or 5 times over my life. I remember those times, because I could barely get out of bed and it took months to get properly right. Bar covid, think it's 5 years since my last flu. And by 'mild', don't they just mean 'not severe enough to go to hospital '?

Whereas I get kids who've been off school for 2 days, bounce back in and tell me they've been off with flu.Hmm

Bakewelltart987 · 20/01/2022 11:41

You cough and sneeze at people? Personally I have always covered my mouth or used a tissue when coughing/sneezing if you can't do that then yes you should stay home.

hugr · 20/01/2022 11:39

@Colderthanever

I honestly think people should stay off work with a cold

This is such a privileged view point and has no concept of the hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people who would lose their jobs or not get paid if they stayed off for a cold.

It would be lovely if everyone could stay at home if the had a cold, get paid, be able to pay their bills, not risk their jobs, but that’s not the real world.

The sentance should read everyone should be able to stay home if they have the cold, collect their full wage and not risk unemployment.

I think it's privileged to think that it's not going to significantly impact someone if you spread a cold to them. My 8 month old son was very poorly in hospital for 3.5 weeks over Christmas with a cold that my husband picked up from someone at work.
justasking111 · 20/01/2022 11:38

When I had staff state that they have flu, norovirus I asked them to stay home I've sent staff home. Better one person short I thought other staff agreed

PartyOnKale · 20/01/2022 11:38

Primary age is not a bad time to get exposure.

OfstedOffred · 20/01/2022 11:32

People are also forgetting that exposure to mild viruses makes our immune system stronger.

Many viruses you are incubating and spreading before symptoms emerge, this makes it nigh on impossible to stop them. If we are all regularly exposed our immune system builds up and we are typically mildly affected. Absent that regular exposure, when we do catch these things our immune system hasnt got a clue and they can be deadly.

Never being exposed to anything is like playing Russian roulette. When you do catch something you could be a goner.

BurntO · 20/01/2022 11:32

I wouldn’t socialise but if I couldn’t work from home I’d have to go in…I’d still be taking my kids to school and getting my shopping. You can’t stay home for every infectious illness.

thewhatsit · 20/01/2022 11:32

I don’t think you could or should stop people leaving their house with a cold.

Mainly because I can recall many, many times when I’ve caught a cold but caught it so mildly so barely notice. Often our family will all come down with the same cold to varying degrees. Presumably we are all carrying the same cold and are all infectious.

At the moment my DD has a stocker of a cold - mainly sneezing and pouring nose (LFTs negative). I myself am sneezing once or twice every few hours. My LFTs also negative. I clearly have whatever she has and as I’m sneezing I could potentially infect someone else but is sneezing about ten times a day a good enough reason for me to hypothetically miss work or school? If it is I don’t honestly see how anyone would ever get anything done.

1/3 people who have the flu are asymptomatic just like Covid. Yes if you have the flu and are suffering from it you’re unlikely to be leaving your bed but people will have it asymptomatically or with very mild symptoms and it would seem odd to try and lock up those people.

Colderthanever · 20/01/2022 11:31

I honestly think people should stay off work with a cold

This is such a privileged view point and has no concept of the hundreds of thousands, if not millions of people who would lose their jobs or not get paid if they stayed off for a cold.

It would be lovely if everyone could stay at home if the had a cold, get paid, be able to pay their bills, not risk their jobs, but that’s not the real world.

The sentance should read everyone should be able to stay home if they have the cold, collect their full wage and not risk unemployment.

Socialcarenope · 20/01/2022 11:30

I'm not a martyr but if I feel well enough to work, I go to work. I don't think COVID now should be any different.

If someone feels like crap and is dragging themselves out of bed to go to work then they should stay home, rest and recover. But just because I'm bunged up and sneezing doesn't mean I can't work. My kids wouldn't have been in school or nursery for the whole of October and November if I kept them off for every sniffle. The fact that they could bounce and run around, concentrate on lessons and eat all their meals told me they were well enough to go to school.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/01/2022 11:30

@hugr that just isn't a viable option for most. Office workers who work from home yes. Everyone else? No

HerculesMulligann · 20/01/2022 11:29

I think the common sense approach of staying at home if you feel ill and only going out when you feel better is the way to go. Within a comprehensive system of less precarious employment and decent sick pay so people aren’t forced to leave their homes when they’re not well.

It’s time to end the constant testing & isolation for people with covid. I’ve been really annoyed by misleading headlines over the past couple of months along the lines of ā€œBusinesses struggling with staffing due to covidā€ when actually the businesses are struggling due to the response to covid i.e telling people who feel basically fine to isolate for a week. Which is a completely different scenario.

PattyPan · 20/01/2022 11:26

If I called in sick to work every day for a week, I'd probably be in trouble.

Honestly, change jobs. Your employer is awful and there are loads of jobs out there at the moment.

PartyOnKale · 20/01/2022 11:24

The well office idea makes sense where wfh is viable.

hugr · 20/01/2022 11:24

@Seeline

The cold is a virus, and for most people, Covid now seems to appear as a cold. Did you go to work with a cold?
I honestly think people should stay off work with a cold.
PartyOnKale · 20/01/2022 11:23

Every now and again as it evolves and / or your immunity is lowered you catch a rough one.

MoirasWigStand · 20/01/2022 11:23

If you don't get sick pay, or are on a zero hours contract, what choice do people have?

PartyOnKale · 20/01/2022 11:21

@GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER

I don’t think it’d be possible for people to self isolate every time they have any sort of cold - some people get a lot.

As for flu, IMO anyone who says they have flu and is still going about fairly normally, almost certainly just has a bad cold instead.

Anyone who’s had real flu will know that it’s not something you can treat with Lemsip and just carry on as usual!

Flu does circulate mildly among the majority though. 🤷
ImInACage · 20/01/2022 11:21

Believe me I wish I could stay home when I feel unwell, but on a zero hour minimum wage job with no entitlement to sick pay, it's not even remotely possible for me to. Plus if I do take time off, I'm less likely to be given more hours.