Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if you have an infectious disease, you should stay home?

177 replies

Notcontent · 20/01/2022 09:17

So apparently the need to isolate if you have COVID will end in March. To me that seems to be sending an odd message… I am all for COVID restrictions being lifted - but surely if someone knows they have a virus, they should just stay at home??

I always thought it was pretty selfish for people with the flu or a stomach virus etc to just go out and spread their virus on public transport, to colleagues at work, etc.

I thought that a positive to come out of COVID might be that people will be more mindful about not spreading illness but it seems the message being given is that it’s fine to expose others!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Xiaoxiong · 20/01/2022 22:41

@Sugarplumfairy65 they can't, unfortunately. I'm not CEV but I get invited for a flu jab on the NHS every year following lung damage as a result of almost dying from pneumonia in 2015. It's shit, but I do my preventer puffers, get my flu jabs every year, avoid people who I know are sick, and changed jobs to one that allowed me to work from home on a regular basis. I hope that one outcome of this whole pandemic is that sickness norms can be changed and sick pay is available for all so that people don't drag themselves into work sick to keep the roof over their heads. I don't think we can keep everyone safe though, even if there was unlimited paid sick leave for all.

SweetFelicityArkright · 20/01/2022 21:44

Ignoreamor

I used to work in a carehome and the only "acceptable" illness to them was diarrhea and vomiting, unless you got a doctor's note there was no paid sickness as I worked 3 nights a week so generally would feel better by net night shift.

I would have actually been okay with it if they recommended that we wore masks if sick with like a cold. I needed the money desperately but it really feels horrible feeling knowing you might make vulnerable

Depressingly, I came on to say a similar thing about my experiences working in social care, I have also been through a disciplinary because of sickness - in an industry where care and protection of the vulnerable is supposed to be paramount, apparently that doesn't apply to the providers who employ people to do the hands on care and they can and do insist you work with anything from a cold onwards which they are very well aware can kill their clients - and discipline you for making the "right" decision by staying away from work - and that's before you get to the trying to live on no income because if you don't work, then you don't get paid for the first week, and then you get a 1/4 of your income after that.

Why do you think that things like local councils paying for care assistants to isolate and the isolation grant had to happen during covid? Because they knew fine well that people would just be left to hang, faced with the choice of going to work with covid and possibly killing someone or putting themselves in debt and risking their homes and essential living.
What a lovely choice that is to be facing, and one with the announcement of SI ending soon and no clarification on what will happen in care homes, not one that I want to have to be in a position to choose. If you want people to do the right thing in terms of protecting those most vulnerable from illness like covid etc then you need to make it a viable choice, not one that ruins their lives or makes them responsible for ending or ruining others.

Has anyone saying that we should just do it ever faced the threat of eviction because they have been too ill to work and had no income? I have.

Have they faced bailiffs at the door because the council couldn't care less that you can't pay your council tax because you were ill? I have.

Have they had utilities put PAYG meters in because you've been ill and take a % of what little you can afford to pay back your debt leaving you for a couple of days without heat and light? I have.

Have they spent years paying off debts that have been added to because they got ill and ruined any credit rating? I have.

Going to work with something infectious, for so many is a symptom of a system that doesn't give a shit about anything but productivity and money and watches as we squabble among ourselves about who's selfish and who's vulnerability is the most worthy and who should get the blame - look up.

RichTeaRichTea · 20/01/2022 21:01

My brother has had to try to avoid catching colds for decades, since he first became CEV due to the long term effects of a virus which for most people is very mild. Colds can put him in hospital very easily - he often doesn’t react like he has a cold either - and he is of course very vulnerable to covid. It is really shit for him living with that, and we have had to change our behaviour as a family in terms of contact with him since well before covid. I don’t know what the answer is re covid right now but the world didn’t protect people like him two decades ago by stopping people going out to work with cold symptoms, and unfortunately unless new sickness policies come into play (which I would support), then I don’t think covid will change that.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 20/01/2022 20:30

@Xiaoxiong

Lots of people have infectious viruses and are out and about even now - colds, herpes simplex, shingles...

Generally I think if people feel too sick to work or go to school, they should feel empowered to stay home and rest. This is why a civilised country should have sick pay, and social norms to say that you wear a mask if you yourself are sick, and you don't drag yourself into work feeling like death. However, once they are back on their feet they can go back - for some people this will be a day, for others this will be longer but it should be for them to decide not the government.

Having legally enforced isolation has to end at some point, generally when scientists and doctors are telling us that it is affecting the majority of the population no worse than a cold. We have always had and will always have the CEV in the population to whom even a cold is a serious illness but they have to take their own precautions and make their own risk assessments, as they always have done in the past.

For most who are cev it doesn't work like a cold. It attacks the blood and organs. How are the cev supposed to keep themselves safe? We are just normal people who have to go out to work, mix with other people, use public transport etc
MeredithGreyishblue · 20/01/2022 19:53

What does "protect the vulnerable " actually mean?

Because the longer it goes on for, the less potent it's becoming, the fewer people seem to be extremely vulnerable to it, any more than another similar virus. And as that number shrinks, it becomes less feasible to protect the vulnerable in the ways we have been. But I'm sure that would be much less easy to say if I was vulnerable.

Arguably, people on lower wage with keys sick pay are also vulnerable

Ignoreamor · 20/01/2022 19:51

I would have actually been okay with it if they recommended that we wore masks if sick with like a cold. I needed the money desperately but it really feels horrible feeling knowing you might make vulnerable people sick or lead to a earlier death

Ignoreamor · 20/01/2022 19:49

I used to work in a carehome and the only "acceptable" illness to them was diarrhea and vomiting, unless you got a doctor's note there was no paid sickness as I worked 3 nights a week so generally would feel better by net night shift.

HerculesMulligann · 20/01/2022 19:40

We seem to be in some kind of vulnerability top trumps situation. Whose vulnerability is more important??

And I think now covid has evolved and generally become a lot milder it doesn’t necessarily win at vulnerability top trumps in every instance. As already mentioned by previous posters vulnerability to poverty, homelessness, mental health problems, domestic violence etc are all important considerations.

We as a society need to be able to have sensible and realistic conversations about these sometimes difficult trade-offs. Simply repeating ā€œBut it’s covid! Some people are clinically vulnerable!ā€ is way too simplistic.

Butteredtoast55 · 20/01/2022 19:35

I think what has happened in the last two years has made people more mindful of not being in work when ill but I hope it's also made them more mindful of washing their hands properly, cleaning up shared spaces and good respiratory hygiene (using tissues and throwing them away for instance). That, and staying at home when unwell, makes a huge difference.
Having said that, Covid is not just a cold. It's unpredictable and can make healthy, vaccinated people very sick. I'm not thrilled by the idea of people 'pushing through' and spreading it around once we get to March and that will definitely happen especially amongst those who can't afford to be penalised for taking time off work.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 20/01/2022 19:34

@AndAnotherNewOne

Yes it is, if they don't get paid for it. It is absolutely asking too much. You're being completely obtuse and refusing to acknowledge these issues.

Not ignoring. Just don't think they matter as much as the lives of the vulnerable. It isn't obtuse to value human life. It really isn't.

How would a person feel if their decision to ignore the infection led to another person's death? I cannot imagine trying to live with that.

It's obtuse to think only Covid kills people.
OperationRinka · 20/01/2022 19:33

@positivevibesonly22

Anyone with actual flu would not be in a position to be out and about. If they are out and about saying they have flu they just have a bad cold and if everyone stayed off work with a cold the country would grind to a halt. Never really know why people say it's a 'disease' either. It's a coronavirus. A common cold is a coronavirus. Obviously when it first appeared it was severe like a disease could be, but now, with vaccines and boosters for most it's a virus, a coronavirus, like a cold.
So what you're saying is that people who have symptomatic Covid can easily be out and about and going to work, despite this disease killing millions in the last two years but nobody with any strain of influenza could possibly be capable of leaving the house?
RichTeaRichTea · 20/01/2022 19:32

@AndAnotherNewOne

It isn't asking too much to expect those infected with Covid to stay indoors until they are no longer infectious.

It's the least we can all do.

The OP isn’t talking just about covid here - and nor are most people on the thread - this is about all infectious diseases including colds.

I can guarantee that you have passed on an infectious disease that caused someone’s death somewhere along the line.

I am completely on board with better sickness policies and protections for people who can’t work from home if they have a cold. In the meantime, I can’t ask someone to forgo their livelihood to protect my CEV relative. I wouldn’t be able to live with myself

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 20/01/2022 19:30

Anyone with actual flu would not be in a position to be out and about

Why do people keep repeating this? You can have flu and be completely asymptomatic.

positivevibesonly22 · 20/01/2022 19:30

@UnbeatenMum šŸ‘šŸ¼šŸ‘šŸ¼ I agree. I never usually suffer with colds but have been non stop for the last five months or so. Isolating and hiding away is so bad for general immunity.

FanGirlX · 20/01/2022 19:30

My employer is moving to hybrid working. I think this will also mean "WFH if you can" when you have flu/cold/bug. For those that can't work from home and / or aren't eligible for sick pay, then I think they will return to pre COVID standards, in that they will struggle in to work. I can't really blame those who don't get sick pay for going into work when sick.

positivevibesonly22 · 20/01/2022 19:27

Anyone with actual flu would not be in a position to be out and about. If they are out and about saying they have flu they just have a bad cold and if everyone stayed off work with a cold the country would grind to a halt. Never really know why people say it's a 'disease' either. It's a coronavirus. A common cold is a coronavirus. Obviously when it first appeared it was severe like a disease could be, but now, with vaccines and boosters for most it's a virus, a coronavirus, like a cold.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/01/2022 19:25

@AndAnotherNewOne

Yes it is, if they don't get paid for it. It is absolutely asking too much. You're being completely obtuse and refusing to acknowledge these issues.

Not ignoring. Just don't think they matter as much as the lives of the vulnerable. It isn't obtuse to value human life. It really isn't.

How would a person feel if their decision to ignore the infection led to another person's death? I cannot imagine trying to live with that.

Dear god almighty. You're a lost cause
AndAnotherNewOne · 20/01/2022 19:24

Yes it is, if they don't get paid for it. It is absolutely asking too much. You're being completely obtuse and refusing to acknowledge these issues.

Not ignoring. Just don't think they matter as much as the lives of the vulnerable. It isn't obtuse to value human life. It really isn't.

How would a person feel if their decision to ignore the infection led to another person's death? I cannot imagine trying to live with that.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 20/01/2022 19:23

I have read the full thread. I still think we need to protect the vulnerable, not sure why people take exception to that.

What are children if not vulnerable?

They can't feed themselves, pay the rent, pay the bills, keep the house warm - they need their parents to go to work and do it for them!

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 20/01/2022 19:22

@AndAnotherNewOne

It isn't asking too much to expect those infected with Covid to stay indoors until they are no longer infectious.

It's the least we can all do.

Yes, it is too much to ask when those people aren't bloody getting paid.

For the millionth time, campaign for better sick pay instead of trying to guilt trip people who are just trying to pay their bills.

Exhausteddog · 20/01/2022 19:18

We had it at Christmas. I had about 3 or 4 days where it felt a bit like a horrible cold. DH felt similarly (albeit with slightly different symptoms) . I might have considered taking a day or 2 off but felt fine after day 5 or 6. We were both still testing positive on day 9 so did the full 10 day isolation.
DH is self employed and wouldn't have taken more than one or 2 days off, in any other circumstances.(and definitely not 10 days)

Waxonwaxoff0 · 20/01/2022 19:09

@AndAnotherNewOne

It isn't asking too much to expect those infected with Covid to stay indoors until they are no longer infectious.

It's the least we can all do.

Yes it is, if they don't get paid for it. It is absolutely asking too much. You're being completely obtuse and refusing to acknowledge these issues.
AllThingsServeTheBeam · 20/01/2022 19:09

@AndAnotherNewOne

It isn't asking too much to expect those infected with Covid to stay indoors until they are no longer infectious.

It's the least we can all do.

'We'. Royal we if I ever saw one.
AndAnotherNewOne · 20/01/2022 19:08

It isn't asking too much to expect those infected with Covid to stay indoors until they are no longer infectious.

It's the least we can all do.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 20/01/2022 18:52

@AndAnotherNewOne

People will put the needs of their loved ones over the needs of people they don't know. Being able to keep a roof over my child's head and feed him is more important to me than a faceless stranger.

That is so depressing to read.

A shame the government aren't caring for the vulnerable since so many here think they don't matter. I thought that's what we had government for - to look after those least able to look after themselves.

I have read the full thread. I still think we need to protect the vulnerable, not sure why people take exception to that.

Children are vulnerable. My 8 year old cannot look after himself. He needs me to provide for him.

I don't think people vulnerable to Covid don't matter. But they're not my priority. You are suggesting that people should be fine with potentially losing their homes, incomes, and leaving their children hungry. I think THAT is depressing.