Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To contact the school about this tomorrow

405 replies

cornbeeflegs · 19/01/2022 22:02

My eldest DD (13) goes swimming with one of her friends on a Wednesday evening, has done since last August, at the local leisure centre. She goes straight from school to her friend's house, has dinner, does homework, etc and then they go to the pool for 8pm, spend an hour in the open swim session, then she gets dropped back here by one of friend's parents.
She came back very subdued this evening, thought maybe she'd had a fallout with friend or something, eventually she opened up and said she'd got into trouble with one of her teachers. Asked her which lesson it was in and what had happened, then she said it was at swimming.
Apparently DD and friend had been waiting for their lift home after swim session when one of their teachers had seen them, recognised them as being from her school because they were in uniform, and then proceeded to tell them off for not wearing it as per school rules, even though they weren't at school they were still "representing the school" by wearing it. She's asked them both to see her first thing tomorrow morning.
Usually I'm supportive of school and if my children transgress the rules then they face the consequences. But surely this is too harsh?

OP posts:
BashStreetKid · 21/01/2022 00:26

"I’d be quite forcefully calling to speak to this teacher and telling her to get stuffed"
And people wonder teachers are leaving the profession in droves and why it's REALLY hard to recruit (and then moan because their child is being taught Maths by someone without a Maths degree etc!).

Teachers who really think this is a sensible use of their time really should be leaving the profession.

Quackpot · 20/01/2022 23:52

@alphabetsoup1980

Oh bore off!
Hello 'mrs x'
andweallsingalong · 20/01/2022 22:09

Just on a practical level would school let her leave her instrument and PE kit there just on swimming day so she has space for a change of clothes?

Stath · 20/01/2022 21:54

D’ya know, with every post I read like this I’m more and more grateful for our High School.

They have a uniform but don’t insist on branded, expensive trousers/skirts (so can be purchased at supermarkets) and the staff seem to have much better things to do with their time than punish kids for wearing an untucked shirt after school.

One of DC has been seriously ill and so has been out of school for large amounts of time. She has facial piercings and, even though they’re not ‘allowed’ in school the HoY asked her to come up with a compromise/solution like flipping her septum ring up to hide it and wear flesh coloured jewellery so it’s not obvious.
The important thing was our child getting back into education and feeling safe.

Is your school an academy? Well done to you for sticking up for your DD. I’m a parent that supports the staff 99.9999% with any sanctions, detention etc that my DC might be given because it’s deserved and I respect the job the teachers are doing. Although, our school isn’t silly about rules about uniform out of school etc.

Also, because our DC was spoken to in a caring way about her piercings and she valued and respected the HoY it meant that she decided to take them out at school.

lanthanum · 20/01/2022 21:39

It does seem a ridiculous rule. Do the staff change out of their work clothes before they go anywhere after school? And they have the luxury of a car to carry a change of clothes in.
It also seems to discriminate against those who live further from the school, for whom it isn't possible to pop home and change.

Perhaps you could request that she be allowed to leave her blazer and tie at school on days when she isn't going straight home, since otherwise the blazer is going to end up crumpled in a bag. Bet that's not allowed either...

harrystylestaylorswift · 20/01/2022 21:32

What a horrible jobsworth. I never used to get changed as soon as I
got home when I was in high school. If we needed shopping etc after school, I would've been in my uniform. I'd have avoided teachers in public like the plague because who wants to awkwardly speak to them outside of school when you're a child but I doubt any of them would've shouted at me in bloody Tesco for not wearing it 'correctly'.

alphabetsoup1980 · 20/01/2022 21:28

Oh bore off!

WakeUpLockie · 20/01/2022 21:26

Oops sorry, missed that the meeting has been and gone!

WakeUpLockie · 20/01/2022 21:24

My kids are preschool and primary but I’m already mad about secondary uniform 😄 I remember eye rolling when I was at school being told about representing the school, keeping blazers on in the July heat etc etc. Totally unrealistic for the workplace - teachers swanning around in floaty summer dresses for example.

So my question is, what happens if you don’t agree to the uniform policy - I assume you have to sign something to say you will ensure your children abide by it? I’m just going to not sign it. Then what? If you don’t have to sign anything then I will stop worrying about it and tell them to get over it, if the need arises 😄

YANBU OP and hope your daughter doesn’t lose any sleep tonight!

cornbeeflegs · 20/01/2022 21:13

@surreygirl1987

"I’d be quite forcefully calling to speak to this teacher and telling her to get stuffed". And people wonder teachers are leaving the profession in droves and why it's REALLY hard to recruit (and then moan because their child is being taught Maths by someone without a Maths degree etc!).

OP, what is the school's policy on uniform? Have you looked? Was the teacher (Assistant Head I think you said?) simply doing her job by sticking to policy, or is she making rules up? If the former, it's the school's policy you need to be addressing. If the latter, it's the teacher's conduct.

I'm intrigued by your daughter choosing to turn up with her shirt untucked to a meeting triggered by allegedly incorrect use of uniform though... rather ironic and not exactly a smart choice!! If you are going to put in a complaint I'd strongly recommend you hearing the teacher's side of it first. I've seen so many parents rush in to full-on complaint mode and then end up really embarrassed because their little darling had actually behaved really badly and told a pack of lies to their parents! Not saying that's what is going to happen here, but definitely worth hearing the other side to the story!

She didn't realise her shirt had come untucked!
OP posts:
cornbeeflegs · 20/01/2022 21:12

When I got home from work, dd had already done half of the lines. I told her not to do any more because she was getting in a stress about not having done her homework. So I told her that was more important, and I would send a note with her lines explaining why they hadn’t been finished.

I have asked her several times whether there was anything else going on that she hasn’t told me about and she assures me not. I have no reason to disbelieve her, she’s always told the truth about good and bad things occurring at school before, so I see no reason for this time to be different.

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 20/01/2022 21:08

OP have you found the school uniform policy yet and seen whether there are any rules about the wearing of uniform outside school?

I don't think you are being unreasonable and it isn't unusual for pupils to go to afterschool activities in uniform nor for that uniform not to be immaculate. The teacher sounds unreasonable. But I think the action you take depends very much on whether the school has an unreasonable policy or whether the teacher is pushing her own agenda.

If there are rules that cover this, I would help DD write the lines and hand them in, tell her you disagree with the rule but sometimes you just have to suck things up and come up with a plan for her for swimming so she doesn't risk it again. Then I would make a complaint to the school about the pettiness of the rule, the lack of consistency in enforcement given that many pupils are in school in a worse state of dress, the additional burden the rule places on students and families given the busy schedules that kids have and point out that such hardline and petty rule enforcement undermines student teacher relationships and trust between the school and parents. I would also consider contacting the parent governors to discuss concerns about the additional impact on families if the school is going to be hardline on this sort of thing and what they can do in a governing role to ensure pupil welfare is paramount.

If there isn't a rule on uniform outside of school I would make an immediate complaint about the teacher - both about intimidating your DC outside of school and about making them miss lessons to try to push her own agenda instead of school policy. And I would give DD a note to give to the teacher saying you have forbidden her completing the lines pending the outcome of your complaint.

NellieWellietheEllie · 20/01/2022 21:08

When I was at school the rule was we had to have full proper uniform or make sure there was no badge on show so the school wasn't identifiable - as it was the badge that made us 'in uniform'. I agree this sounds ridiculous though, no-one I going to care after swimming.

cafedesreves · 20/01/2022 21:06

Ugh soooooooo petty.

surreygirl1987 · 20/01/2022 21:02

"I’d be quite forcefully calling to speak to this teacher and telling her to get stuffed".
And people wonder teachers are leaving the profession in droves and why it's REALLY hard to recruit (and then moan because their child is being taught Maths by someone without a Maths degree etc!).

OP, what is the school's policy on uniform? Have you looked? Was the teacher (Assistant Head I think you said?) simply doing her job by sticking to policy, or is she making rules up? If the former, it's the school's policy you need to be addressing. If the latter, it's the teacher's conduct.

I'm intrigued by your daughter choosing to turn up with her shirt untucked to a meeting triggered by allegedly incorrect use of uniform though... rather ironic and not exactly a smart choice!! If you are going to put in a complaint I'd strongly recommend you hearing the teacher's side of it first. I've seen so many parents rush in to full-on complaint mode and then end up really embarrassed because their little darling had actually behaved really badly and told a pack of lies to their parents! Not saying that's what is going to happen here, but definitely worth hearing the other side to the story!

Sometimeswinning · 20/01/2022 20:58

I would definitely be sending an email questioning this reaction and consequence (punishment!) Im impressed they put their ties back on to be fair!

Ohmycron · 20/01/2022 20:57

Also lines? Really? I haven’t heard of a school setting these since the 90s

And the fact that a teacher allegedly would not only call out the kids and tell of the punishment makes me think this thread is utter bullshit her

Ohmycron · 20/01/2022 20:55

@CrabbyAggie

Parents need to stand up and end this crap.

They are not police officers or in the military where upholding standards of the organisation they are in matters off duty!

Parents are forced to pay for the uniform, the school doesn’t own it. They are CHILDREN.

I’d be quite forcefully calling to speak to this teacher and telling her to get stuffed.

No way would I let her sanction my DC or make them feel they’d done something wrong.

Please don’t recommend that people forcibly call teachers
pointythings · 20/01/2022 20:53

These days I wouldn't assume the school/teacher is always right. This trend for petty nit picking rules that we are currently living with means rationality and proportionality have gone right out of the window. Children are presumed guilty until proven innocent. I am so glad my DDs have aged out of the system. I hope that if they ever have DC the pendulum will have swung back, or failing that they will move to a country that isn't obsessed with appearance over merit.

PugInTheHouse · 20/01/2022 20:43

LemonTreeGrove - IME they do in specific circumstances, I have been in on 2 occasions to discuss detentions and said I did not agree with the reasons behind those 2 specifically, the teachers agreed and removed the detention. If the DD is required to write the lines to take into school then the parent can decide to not allow them to do it presumably.

If the girls were behaving badly, swearing etc then it's a totally different scenario, if they were as the DD described just stood there waiting looking a bit scruffy then nothing should have been said.

CrabbyAggie · 20/01/2022 20:41

Parents need to stand up and end this crap.

They are not police officers or in the military where upholding standards of the organisation they are in matters off duty!

Parents are forced to pay for the uniform, the school doesn’t own it. They are CHILDREN.

I’d be quite forcefully calling to speak to this teacher and telling her to get stuffed.

No way would I let her sanction my DC or make them feel they’d done something wrong.

MajorCarolDanvers · 20/01/2022 20:35

Sorry I've read your update

is DD unusual in staying in her uniform after school, do any of your children do same

no all the kids where I live do the same including my 13 year old

is it really unreasonable that uniform was not 'immaculate' when seen

outside school hours I think its none of the school's business

does the teacher have a point about school image

unless they were behaving badly the teacher is being completely OTT

is teacher just bullying my DD and friend or am I being too sensitive here

bullying is a strong word but you are not being too sensitive. I wouldn't be happy either.

MajorCarolDanvers · 20/01/2022 20:31

Find out the other side of the story. What were they really doing?

Were they bringing the school into disrepute for example?

But if its just a jobsworth and the kids stories are true then yes I would be complaining about it.

Tickledtrout · 20/01/2022 20:30

How ridiculous. What sort of school is this OP?
There's a stupid fixation in uniform in some quarters atm when really relationships, wellbeing and recovery should be the focus.
Teachers don't really help themselves with this kind of nonsense. Why would anyone respect that kind of authoritarian nonsense? Lines even ffs. Too much Mallory Towers read by someone there. They tend to pick on the ones that they know will put up with it. Bullying, really.
Tell your daughter not to let the bastards grind her down.

LemonTreeGrove · 20/01/2022 20:29

I don't think schools let parents decide whether the kids do lines and detention.