Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To contact the school about this tomorrow

405 replies

cornbeeflegs · 19/01/2022 22:02

My eldest DD (13) goes swimming with one of her friends on a Wednesday evening, has done since last August, at the local leisure centre. She goes straight from school to her friend's house, has dinner, does homework, etc and then they go to the pool for 8pm, spend an hour in the open swim session, then she gets dropped back here by one of friend's parents.
She came back very subdued this evening, thought maybe she'd had a fallout with friend or something, eventually she opened up and said she'd got into trouble with one of her teachers. Asked her which lesson it was in and what had happened, then she said it was at swimming.
Apparently DD and friend had been waiting for their lift home after swim session when one of their teachers had seen them, recognised them as being from her school because they were in uniform, and then proceeded to tell them off for not wearing it as per school rules, even though they weren't at school they were still "representing the school" by wearing it. She's asked them both to see her first thing tomorrow morning.
Usually I'm supportive of school and if my children transgress the rules then they face the consequences. But surely this is too harsh?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
strawberryapricotpie · 11/02/2022 15:57

@RocketFire7

Tbh I think you’re being unreasonable. I think it’s perfectly fair for the school to expect uniform to be worn correctly outside school.

It reflects badly on the school if you have students walking about in public looking scruffy. The DCs’ school expect uniform to be worn smartly on any occasion- top buttons done up and blazers on.

Detention is fairly given to miscreants.

'miscreants' Grin Grin Grin
Aderyn21 · 29/01/2022 14:27

Uniform is good for avoiding arguments with teenage daughters about what they are going to wear every day. But it's only a leveller if it's affordable, otherwise the poorest kids can't afford to keep up with buying new

Snoozer11 · 29/01/2022 13:49

I don't care about uniform, as long as it's affordable, comfortable and the rules are reasonable.

The problem is the rules aren't reasonable. I went to a strict state school when it came to uniform- top buttons done at all times etc. But in the last 10 years or so, uniform rules have become outrageous and completely inflexible.

There are rules in place now which dictate how short boys can have their hair! I understand rules against tramlines and nom-natural colours, but when did a simple short back and sides become in any way problematic? At one point that was the only style allowed!

I went to school with a lad who used to shave his head because he had MPB even as a teenager. Lord knows what he would have to do nowadays.

Shirt, tie, one colour jumper with iron-on logo, black shoes. This isn't a problem.

Shirt with school logo sold by one supplier costing £££, jumper with logo also costing £££, specific colour trousers that have to be a particular shade of grey, black shoes with a sole no higher than 3/4 of an inch and with laces of a certain length - no Velcro, no slip ons, no hint of colour on the underneath that no one can ever see, grey socks (no black), no belts, black coat with no logos, no hood and NOT a bomber jacket, denim jacket or puffer jacket, two types of trainer for PE, etc etc is not ok.

And as for demanding it's worn a certain way outside of school? Bat shit.

All we hear about is teachers having so much work to do, never any time off, how awful the job is. And yet here we have a teacher in the wild on a school night creating more work for themselves. These people wouldn't last a minute in any other profession.

ldontWanna · 29/01/2022 09:41

@SartresSoul

I think the usual argument against own clothes is bullying, plain and simple. If everyone has to wear the exact same thing then there’s a lot less reason for people to get bullied. If people were to wear their own clothes it would open up children from impoverished backgrounds in particular to all manner of bullying. There’s no reason to create that sort of division as far as I can see.

Anyway, I think this teacher took things too far. I can understand when a child is misbehaving in their school uniform (I remember some boys from my school snowballing houses after school for example) but they were just standing there so yeah, maybe she was on a weird power trip?

Just because it's the usual argument it doesn't mean it's a valid or good argument.

If a school has an issue with bullying, they have an issue with bullying. If it's not clothes it will be something else. Clothes don't suddenly make bullying suddenly appear. And even if they did strict uniform rules will make that worse too. Uniform that is too small, or tatty ,or inappropriate for the weather. School shoes too small, that hurt feet, or with holes in them or soles or other bits hanging off. That can all be avoided when rules are a bit more lax. A kid can wear their trainers or whatever footwear they have (for example) until school shoes can be replaced.

If it was such a big issue , there would no non uniform days or themed days.

If it was such a big issue, you wouldn't have schools where the uniform costs hundreds of pounds just for one set of each.

The division is there regardless, it's simplistic and quite daft to think uniform makes anything better.

pointythings · 29/01/2022 09:21

@SartresSoul

I think the usual argument against own clothes is bullying, plain and simple. If everyone has to wear the exact same thing then there’s a lot less reason for people to get bullied. If people were to wear their own clothes it would open up children from impoverished backgrounds in particular to all manner of bullying. There’s no reason to create that sort of division as far as I can see.

Anyway, I think this teacher took things too far. I can understand when a child is misbehaving in their school uniform (I remember some boys from my school snowballing houses after school for example) but they were just standing there so yeah, maybe she was on a weird power trip?

The bullying argument is nonsense, plain and simple. If it held water, rates of bullying in schools would be lower in the UK than in countries where there is no school uniform, like Germany or the Netherlands. And they're not. You prevent bullying by focusing on behaviour and being tough on bullying where it happens, end of. My DDs were both bullied in their UK uniform wearing school - fortunately the school dealt with it brilliantly. I was also bullied in my Dutch non-uniform school, the school dealt with it brilliantly. Simple.
containsnuts · 29/01/2022 09:00

I can't see how uniform stops bullying. Even if everyone was made the wear the exact same thing from the school shop you can still tell disadvantage by the fading or poor fit of clothes etc. Uniform might require "black shoes" but kids can tell who has Prada from who has Poundland (I don't know if either of these places sell school shoes but hopefully you get my point!)

We had uniform pants at private primary and yes, this was enforced! Blush

Kennykenkencat · 29/01/2022 08:29

I don’t get the thing about having a uniform to stop bullying poorer pupils.

I did go to a primary school without a uniform policy and I was one of the poorer pupils and don’t ever remember getting bullied because of my clothes or for anything else and I can honestly say my clothes were the worst.
Yet at my super strict uniform adhering secondary bullying was rife and I don’t think I spoke to anyone unless I had to for definitely the last 2 or 3 years I was there

Having a uniform doesn’t stop bullying I think it just makes it worse

SartresSoul · 29/01/2022 07:54

I think the usual argument against own clothes is bullying, plain and simple. If everyone has to wear the exact same thing then there’s a lot less reason for people to get bullied. If people were to wear their own clothes it would open up children from impoverished backgrounds in particular to all manner of bullying. There’s no reason to create that sort of division as far as I can see.

Anyway, I think this teacher took things too far. I can understand when a child is misbehaving in their school uniform (I remember some boys from my school snowballing houses after school for example) but they were just standing there so yeah, maybe she was on a weird power trip?

containsnuts · 29/01/2022 06:41

AKASammyScrounge

"I'm in Scotland and uniform rules are more relaxed from what I see on here. It's easy enough to find schools which do not enforce uniform wearing as well as ones that do."

Yes, I've noticed this too although I can't see the point in wearing half a uniform eg, black trousers but with any old jumper, trainers and jacket. Defeats the purpose. Why not just let them wear their own clothes?

AKASammyScrounge · 29/01/2022 01:58

@Aderyn21

Sammy are you saying that you are a teacher in the UK? If so, how can you come out with such twaddle as to tell parents to move their dc to a non uniform school? There are none where I (and the majority of UK parents) live.

It isn't the uniform which is the problem, but the attitude of the teacher. If uniform didn't exist, she'd kick off about something else because that's just how some people are!

I'm in Scotland and uniform rules are more relaxed from what I see on here. It's easy enough to find schools which do not enforce uniform wearing as well as ones that do.
honeyrider · 29/01/2022 01:13

It's a shame so many schools and teachers don't put as much effort into dealing with bullying as they do on school uniforms. Then they wonder why so many people have lost respect for them.

I feel sorry for the decent hardworking teachers who have to work with such unreasonable jobsworths because they all get tarred with the one brush.

Kennykenkencat · 28/01/2022 16:41

The only state secondary school I know that is non uniform and that is in Camden and has an outstanding OFSTED rating.

Maybe the teachers use their energy in teaching and not on uniform inspections

Kennykenkencat · 28/01/2022 16:31

AKASammyScrounge

Where are these non uniform schools

Snoozer11 · 28/01/2022 16:01

@AKASammyScrounge
I think it's really pathetic when you have adults like yourself, who are completely incapable of independent thought and who have no sense of autonomy.

People don't have to do anything just because teacher says so.

It's perfectly possible for a person to respect authority, but not blindly agree with that authority at every moment.

me109f · 28/01/2022 00:57

Some teachers should just grow up ...

BringYourOwnBoris · 27/01/2022 20:40

Well I do hope that Miss X always maintains her impeccable standards outside of school as well, and doesn't swear or post pictures of herself in a bikini all over her FB. Wink

TorringtonDean · 27/01/2022 18:02

Two well-behaved girls in uniform after going for a healthy swim are in fact an advert for the school! Most of us would realise they might not be entirely neat and tidy at that time of day.

AnneWeber · 27/01/2022 11:38

@surreygirl1987

Yeh, I also think that's a fair response and if you follow up further now you're being unreasonable.
Agree
Aderyn21 · 27/01/2022 11:27

Sammy are you saying that you are a teacher in the UK? If so, how can you come out with such twaddle as to tell parents to move their dc to a non uniform school? There are none where I (and the majority of UK parents) live.

It isn't the uniform which is the problem, but the attitude of the teacher. If uniform didn't exist, she'd kick off about something else because that's just how some people are!

DePfeffoff · 27/01/2022 09:37

But really, why don't these people take their children out of uniform schools and put them into non-uniform schools?

Exactly how easy do you imagine this is? How many areas have an equal number of uniform and non-uniform schools?

cornbeeflegs · 27/01/2022 08:25

@AKASammyScrounge

They snigger in the staffroom too. Sometimes Mums are far more ridiculous than they say we are. But really, why don't these people take their children out of uniform schools and put them into non-uniform schools? They clearly have issues with how teachers run schools and cannot cope with authority in action. They would be much happier with a school which has a more relaxed attitude to uniforms and behaviour in general.
I don't have an issue with how the school is run in general, just how this one particular teacher dealt with an isolated out of school situation. Tbh there isn't a large choice of schools in the area anyway, but if I really felt that the school wasn't a 'good' school then I would be prepared to move my eldest to a different one. I've tried to be supportive of the school throughout
OP posts:
Kennykenkencat · 27/01/2022 01:28

@AKASammyScrounge

They snigger in the staffroom too. Sometimes Mums are far more ridiculous than they say we are. But really, why don't these people take their children out of uniform schools and put them into non-uniform schools? They clearly have issues with how teachers run schools and cannot cope with authority in action. They would be much happier with a school which has a more relaxed attitude to uniforms and behaviour in general.
Where are these non inform schools? I would have loved to send my 2 to one but there weren’t any in my area

Do people really judge a school on how neatly a pupil wears a uniform?

It is how the children behave is the fundamental impression. The uniform is just window dressing

AKASammyScrounge · 27/01/2022 00:54

They snigger in the staffroom too. Sometimes Mums are far more ridiculous than they say we are.
But really, why don't these people take their children out of uniform schools and put them into non-uniform schools? They clearly have issues with how teachers run
schools and cannot cope with authority in action. They would be much happier with a school which has a more relaxed
attitude to uniforms and behaviour in general.

Aderyn21 · 26/01/2022 09:51

The school's response is minimising what happened. They know this teacher was way ott and they are hoping you will just drop it and the complaint will go away.
I'm not advocating being aggressive in your response but you do need to be firm, so that they take you seriously and actually take steps to ensure this doesn't happen again to other children. It's really important for children to know their parents will advocate for them and not just allow these things to happen.

LookItsMeAgain · 26/01/2022 09:03

I would agree with @Aderyn21 but I honestly think that the teacher needs to apologise to the students involved, not you. They were the ones caught up in her power drive to improve standards. They were the ones that were punished harshly. They need the apology, in my opinion. I wonder if that teacher will actually apologise to your daughter and her friend for the way she treated them.