Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not feel comfortable using work's unisex toilets

289 replies

Whatafustercluck · 19/01/2022 20:52

My employer is moving offices into a different building. All the toilets are unisex. Most of the men seem fine with this (those who made the decision to move there are men) while the women I've spoken with don't feel comfortable about this for various reasons, from cleanliness to embarrassment about male colleagues knowing they're on their period or whatever. I'm really not happy with this, but feel like it's expected to just get on with it and it's considered somewhat old fashioned to think/ feel this way. Aibu?

OP posts:
emmathedilemma · 20/01/2022 09:41

Our office has switched to these since we returned after lockdown so that people are meant to use the ones nearest to their desk rather than traipsing across the office to the ladies / gents.
I'm not keen and if the office was back to nearly full capacity I think I'd be less keen because I've seen the state the gents toilets used to get in. Our cubicles are floor to ceiling with sinks in them so as private as you can get. But I don't like having to put the seat down after a man has left it up and I usually keep sanitary products in the communal area outside the cubicles and having the men potentially walking in on me accessing those feels like a bit of an invasion of privacy. We've also got the main door into the toilets propped open to reduce "contact points" and this really makes me feel uncomfortable as I have IBS and I'm really conscious of people at the desks outside hearing me poo!

ThePrionOne · 20/01/2022 09:40

@BashStreetKid

I am not one who would be happy for my male colleagues to sit in the cubicle next to me and hear me rustling around with sanitary products, dropping them in the disposal bin etc. I can hear it now "ooh, fustercluck is being very assertive today - mind you, she's on her period which probably explains it"

Seriously, how many people do this? Having, obviously, used women's toilets all my life, I can honestly say I've never sat there thinking about what the person in the next cubicle is doing (apart from the colleague who used to have loud phone conversations). If someone is inclined to do that, they're just as likely to be female as male.

There are many men on record saying they have a fetish for hearing women peeing. Also some men have a fetish for menstruation.

Paraphilias are much more common in men.

journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1079063214525645

Only someone very naive could believe there is no difference between male behaviour in public toilets and women’s behaviour.

SusannaQueen · 20/01/2022 09:37

3scape

The men haters having a good old go again.

I don't hate men at all. I'm married to a perfectly lovely one and have some great male friends. But having worked in a male dominated profession, there is a hard core of deeply unpleasant men who will get a kick out of humiliating women. Other men let them get away with it.

Someone said they had never had experience of men commenting on them having their period - I used to get it frequently, I got to the stage of keeping unwrapped tampons in my bag and flushing, not using the bin. I was actually glad of the fact that my periods weren't regular.

Momicrone · 20/01/2022 09:25

Bit awkward on bring your daughter to work day

Whatwouldscullydo · 20/01/2022 09:22

You think not wanting to share personal space with strange men (and acknowledging that lots of women will find that difficult) equates to hating them? Or is it that you lack the comprehension to form any other argument?

You do have to wonder what they get out of it tbh. If they are male then the men/males who see no need for the boundaries are probably the kind of men/males that the boundaries were meant to keep out.

If they are female, well there's absolutely no benefit to women in mixed sex toilets ( especially in the work place where the needing to take opposite sex child to the toilet isn't an issue)

There's no special protection or appreciation from men/males for assisting them removing women's safe spaces. Once your vote has been cast there's no further need for you. So why do it? When there is no benefit to women. Only risk.

Would they get into a male strangers car if they wanted a lift home ?

Do they open their home toilet up to the public?

Somehow I doubt it

BlaBlaSmthSmth · 20/01/2022 09:10

@3scape

The men haters having a good old go again.
You think not wanting to share personal space with strange men (and acknowledging that lots of women will find that difficult) equates to hating them? Or is it that you lack the comprehension to form any other argument?
BashStreetKid · 20/01/2022 09:01

I am not one who would be happy for my male colleagues to sit in the cubicle next to me and hear me rustling around with sanitary products, dropping them in the disposal bin etc. I can hear it now "ooh, fustercluck is being very assertive today - mind you, she's on her period which probably explains it"

Seriously, how many people do this? Having, obviously, used women's toilets all my life, I can honestly say I've never sat there thinking about what the person in the next cubicle is doing (apart from the colleague who used to have loud phone conversations). If someone is inclined to do that, they're just as likely to be female as male.

newname12345 · 20/01/2022 08:38

[quote offersoverr]YADNBU.

I find this baffling. Why do firms do this?

According to the BBC, it’s unlawful:
“ Since the 1992 Workplace Regulations Act, failing to ensure that men and women employees have separate toilet facilities is unlawful.”
www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-59785477[/quote]
Because they are allowed to? Its not unlawful as long as each convenience is in a separate lockable room.

www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1992/3004/regulation/20/made

"separate rooms containing conveniences are provided for men and women except where and so far as each convenience is in a separate room the door of which is capable of being secured from inside"

C8H10N4O2 · 20/01/2022 08:34

Shared facilities are a cost cutting exercises and come at the cost of women's well being. They should be seen as such.

They can try to mitigate by having fully enclosed cubicles with sinks but that saves less money so organisations will push to fully shared facilities.

OP: ask for the equalities impact assessment on this change - there should be one.

Parents should challenge this in schools where facilities are changed to shared - there is something you can do about it but too many people just accept it as a done deal, especially when the SLT just implement over the holidays (as happened to two schools around here - now reversed).

Ivyonafence · 20/01/2022 08:29

@StopStartStop
'
No man needs to know when my knickers are down, when I piss, shit or bleed. Compelling me to make those things public is a humiliation, a denigration, an abuse, a denial of my right to dignity.'

Do you feel it's 'public' for a woman who works with you to know those things? Or it only feels public is a man you work with does?

Also, I must be missing something. If you're in a cubicle with the door shut how would anyone else notice what you're doing? I've never been in a work bathroom and been conscious of whose knickers were down or who is 'bleeding'. Your privacy is behind the cubicle door, not the whole bathroom.

sadpapercourtesan · 20/01/2022 08:27

It's very clear that some of the "doesn't bother me" brigade are younger women who have never experienced flooding. It really isn't possible to clean yourself up without getting blood on your hands, believe me.

It's disturbing that some posters lack the empathy to see that "I don't mind" doesn't translate into "nobody should mind". You don't actually have the right to sign away someone else's right to privacy and dignity just because you don't personally value it (yet).

ThinWomansBrain · 20/01/2022 08:22

The hotdesk offices whre I work is on two floors, one disabled loo on the ground floor, half a dozen in the basement - everyone uses the one upstairs, apparently without giving it a second thought.
The downstairs ones are all unisex though - but all self contained cubicles too.

I have seen several in restauraunts and theatres recently though where unisex cubicles and shared sinks. Was just appalled that in a longish theatre interval queue, not a single man stopped to wash his hands - grim.Shock
On the plus side, they wouldn't be hanging around the sink area Hmm

BobbinThreadbare123 · 20/01/2022 08:19

What you do at home is irrelevant to public toilets/workplace toilets. The environment is not the same at all.
I work on a site that has 95% male staff. There are separate toilets as per the law, even down on a dockfront. However, those dockfront loos are abused by men - they have decided that they will pee in the block assigned to them but they go for a shit in the one designated as the female loo. There's no way that would occur the other way round. So no, I don't want to share with them. Men always expand to fill any space...

JuergenSchwarzwald · 20/01/2022 08:14

Shared facilities are not ok. Self-contained facilities are fine (in my view).

Your employer needs to rethink this OP.

ThePrionOne · 20/01/2022 08:12

Good idea to find out about the layout. For what it’s worth, I’ve worked in a couple of places with single cubicles and no restrictions on who should use them and there weren’t any problems.

I’ve also used mixed sex toilets with shared sinks and survived, but it is always an uncomfortable experience if I meet someone male at the sink and I suspect the men have also felt uncomfortable.

Hope it is sorted out. The current craze for mixed sex toilets is frustrating and presumably wil eventually go into reverse, as if we didn’t need single sex spaces, they wouldn’t have existed in the first place.

StopStartStop · 20/01/2022 08:10

@user1471453601

How would male colleagues know you were having a period?

And even if they did, for some odd reason, so what? You are all adults. If adult makes don't know that some women have periods, they are v v immature.

Do you share a loo with males at home? I personally don't (all female household), but when I did, it caused no problems. Males are quite capable of hygienic behaviour both in and out of the loo.

To make women share toilets where they can't deal with all their bodily functions in strict privacy is to humiliate them.

No man needs to know when my knickers are down, when I piss, shit or bleed. Compelling me to make those things public is a humiliation, a denigration, an abuse, a denial of my right to dignity.

Whatwouldscullydo · 20/01/2022 08:05

Strange people who criticise others for man hating apparently seen ti think men are so insecure and needy they need women to prove they like them by being happy sharing private spaces where they are vulnerable with them.

Perhaps we can do badges? " then these men can walk around with their little " I'm.so safe " badges and certificates?

Or perhaps we just give everyone , men and women , the privacy safety and dignity they deserve .

Whatafustercluck · 20/01/2022 08:02

Thanks all for your views. I'm going to see what else I can find out today about their layout and challenge it if it's as I suspect - shared facilities, not self contained.

I'm by no means a man hater either. I have a perfectly good husband and 11yo son, as well as a daughter. I asked my son what he thinks about unisex - he says he'd be horrified, having endured unisex toilets (complete with boys, and girls, peeping under doors) on a sports camp once. I am very open with them about periods, they're my family. But sharing with male colleagues is incomparable with sharing in your own home.

I am not one who would be happy for my male colleagues to sit in the cubicle next to me and hear me rustling around with sanitary products, dropping them in the disposal bin etc. I can hear it now "ooh, fustercluck is being very assertive today - mind you, she's on her period which probably explains it". The vast majority of the men I work with would not do this, but there are definitely some. And likewise, periods are messy - I too have had to wash blood from my hands/ clean up after myself.

OP posts:
CityMumma78 · 20/01/2022 07:56

I would HATE to use a unisex toilet!! Of course men made the decision without an iota of consideration for their female employees/colleagues!

TheChemicalMother · 20/01/2022 07:04

@Whatafustercluck

It's a goof point about the set up actually. I'd be far happier if they were all self contained with sinks in them etc. I think they're installing them shortly, so it was just explained on the floor plan as 'unisex toilets'. Maybe I should reserve judgement until I know more.
If they are in progress surely the best time to speak up is now! It will be too late once all installed.

Ask about the details, and get female colleagues to do the same.

pawpatrolneedaunion · 20/01/2022 06:17

No need to stand at the communal sink washing a Mooncup nor do you need to come out of the cubicle with bloodied hands. It's absolutely fine not to wash the cup every single time. It's only for 1 or 2 heavy days that I need to empty my cup at work anyway: most days it easily lasts 8 hrs.

Lucky you @ffscovid I don't actually use a mooncup because on my heaviest days (which are 4-5 every month) I out bleed a mooncup in an hour or two, if I sit on the loo the blood literally pours like I'm having a wee. Flooding is awful, I'm glad you've never experienced it. It involves standing in a toilet cubicle with blood everywhere. I suppose you can just re insert a mooncup but it's very hard to avoid bloodied hands.

nalabae · 20/01/2022 06:11

Would not be okay with this either

echt · 20/01/2022 01:50

wow so many men haters

Really? Who? Have you called the individuals out on it? Thought not.

Hmm
Ivyonafence · 20/01/2022 01:30

I've never 'known' a female colleague was on their period from sharing a bathroom. Do you mean they'll hear the wrapper or the bin?

I honestly don't think men would notice that sound, let alone know what it meant and put it all together.

Most people are in the bathroom to use the toilet and leave, they're not paying attention to what other people are doing .

Ivyonafence · 20/01/2022 01:28

Are people honestly washing mooncups out in their workplace sink? I've never seen anyone do that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread