Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you complete an 8 mile commute (16 round trip) on an e bike?

57 replies

Hatefreezingweather1 · 19/01/2022 18:10

It's mainly down the East Lancs road if anyone knows it.

Have to take 2 separate buses to get to my job, takes around 45 minutes. However on Monday the morning bus just didn't turn up, no warning, and 3 evening buses failed to turn up, meaning I had to pay for taxis each way which wasn't cheap.

Not sure if it's due to COVID isolation but I can't rely on buses and seeing whether they'll turn up or not.
I did the bike ride yesterday and it took me an hour each way /(even on electric) which is probably quite slow?

Brutal too even if enjoyable in parts, the path is very bumpy and muddy in parts. Not sure I can face that ride every day, does it seem doable to you ?

OP posts:
MrsAvocet · 19/01/2022 19:10

When I was working I used to do 10 miles each way on a regular bike. Going to work was almost all downhill but of course coming home was the opposite - though the time pressure was less on the return journey. I'd drive if it was icy or snowy or really wet and windy though. I used to use cycle path for most of my route as even though it added a mile or so it eas much safer, as the road route included some nasty junctions.
I used to live just off the East Lancs many years ago and I wouldn't have been keen on riding on it to be honest. I doubt it's improved in the intervening years, so I don't blame you for not fancying it, especially if you are not a confident and experienced rider in traffic.
It might be worth exploring other routes. It sounds like the East Lancs is pretty much a straight line from yiur home to work, but sometimescwhen you are cyckung, the most direct route isn't the fastest. For instance, if I ride to the shops, I take a bit of a convoluted route that is part cyclepath, part back roads. I'd never drive that way, but on my bike it is actually quicker and more enjoyable than taking the main roads as there is no traffic to speak of, I don't get held up at junctions, roundabouts or traffic lights and the speed of any passing vehicles is much lower. It took me a bit of exploring to find the best way, so maybe look at a map and try some alternatives out at a weekend? Or ask around at work and see if anyone else rides in from your direction as they'll probably have handy advice and may be willing to ride with you to help boost your confidence.

FlowerPig · 19/01/2022 18:52

Depends which part of the Lancs. My brother rides part of it on his commute which is also an 8 mile ride, he goes the gym 4 nights a week straight from work too. I don't know where he gets his energy but he's done it for 18 months and he says the ride is easy now.
For what it's worth I don't worry about him on the lancs because of the cycle paths, I worry about him on the country lane he comes off the lancs on to.

CourtAndSpark2 · 19/01/2022 18:46

Also, if the weather is bad I have good rain gear. I'm more concerned about gusty winds!

Suzanne999 · 19/01/2022 18:45

Depends how safe you feel. It’s a very busy road, lots of HGVs I seem to remember.

CourtAndSpark2 · 19/01/2022 18:45

I would and do sometimes, but my situation allows it. Firstly, cycle lanes are good, we have OK showers in the office. I do it 3 days per week (one day drive/park, one day public transport and walk)

I actually dislike the drive day most, due to lack of exercise, traffic/parking problems.

I never cycle 2 days in a row. I'd had a few problems with e-bike over the years and have a backup bike (but find that a lot tougher!)

Lonelycrab · 19/01/2022 18:41

It's going to be -2 round here tomorrow morning which is a little concerning so might wait until Friday?

Depends, you mentioned it was rough and muddy, when it’s frozen it’s much nicer to ride, it’s almost like it’s dry again. Ice on tarmac, not so much.

FastFood · 19/01/2022 18:33

I do exactly that, on a non-electric bike, in London, and I love it.

Spectre8 · 19/01/2022 18:33

The crossings are adding your time whereas if you were on the road you would shave some time off as some of the time the lights will be green for you to continue. A crossing can be anywhere from 2-4 mins by time your allowed to go so if you have lots thats where your time is adding up.

Hatefreezingweather1 · 19/01/2022 18:32

It's going to be -2 round here tomorrow morning which is a little concerning so might wait until Friday?

OP posts:
Lonelycrab · 19/01/2022 18:31

Well you’ll certainly get fitSmile

But also don’t underestimate how grim it can be on a really wet, windy day. (I did London cycle commuting all year round, but my distance was half that.)

SituationCritical · 19/01/2022 18:30

Definitely would, if the weather looked terrible for the odd day go on the bus. In Spring and Summer it will be a lot more pleasant too. Lots of benefits with the added exercise and money saved. Like others have said, invest in some decent gear like panniers and waterproofs and it will be fine. I cycled to ride my horse and muck out twice a day for years as a teen/twenties and I generally enjoyed it.

Hatefreezingweather1 · 19/01/2022 18:30

Had to stop at a lot of crossings which added time

OP posts:
Spectre8 · 19/01/2022 18:28

I used to commute 8 miles to work in Birmingham on a road bike, no major hills. Even then I always accounted for an hour for the entire journey. My best speed is doing a mile every 4 minutes so on good days e..g lights almost always green on the road I could do it in 45 mins.

If you have to stop for lights or crossing itll always add time hence why an hour was always what I took into account.

To be honest on an ebike I would of thought you'd do it quicker as it doens't most of the heavy work but I've never used one.

Hatefreezingweather1 · 19/01/2022 18:28

Don't want to do it daily as I had to pay for new brake pads only a month after getting the bike , so don't want to go through anything too quickly but maybe 2 days on the bike and 2 on the bus (I work 4) could be good

OP posts:
CMOTDibbler · 19/01/2022 18:27

Yes, you'll get faster and faster. Maybe tell yourself you'll do it 3 days a week and get the bus if the weather is horrible and see how it goes

Hatefreezingweather1 · 19/01/2022 18:26

It's basically from Salford to Wigan borough

OP posts:
Rollercoaster1920 · 19/01/2022 18:26

I used to do a similar distance and time on a normal bike into central London as my best commute option.
The good news is that you can use the bus if you fancy a day off!

The barriers to cycling (or e-bike or even motorbike / scooter) I found were rain, cold and danger.

On a bicycle if it rains you get wet. Even with waterproofs (get wet with sweat instead). So a shower and change of clothes needed after both directions.

Cold is another challenge, decent clothing that keeps me warm and getting the right clothes for the right day. Often I'd get halfway and take a layer off (so having a pannier on the bike was great). Not expensive stuff, decathlon, lidl are good value, but also normal joggers and ski gloves on a cold day were great.

Danger is multi-faceted, cars, potholes, dodgy areas, pinch points or badly designed roads. I chose routes that were nicer even if not the most direct (often avoiding other cyclists TBH!). Try some routes and see how you feel.
Danger can also be due to weather. My quiet road gets icy and is gritted infrequently, so two wheels are scary on those days. I have used an off-road route on a gravel path on snow / ice days because it is safer (but on a wet day is very muddy so I avoid).

Game changers for me were decent lights to see where you are going on unlit paths, mudguards to keep clothes clean / dry when the roads are wet and pannier bags.

Sounds like you have a bike already so give it a go. If you can commute in January then other months will seem easy!

WhyYesYABU · 19/01/2022 18:26

My husband used to commute 26 miles round trip each day in the hilly Chilterns on a normal bike.

His body was yum at the time. I couldn't do it though, too lazy, but it doesn't sound insane to me.

Hatefreezingweather1 · 19/01/2022 18:26

I feel more motivated to do it now 🙂

OP posts:
Burnt0utMum · 19/01/2022 18:26

Which part of the East lancs is it? No way I'd want to do it on the 60mph parts but would consider it on the 40mph part

BurscoughBooths · 19/01/2022 18:25

Yes, it’ll be fine. All you need for rain is decent waterproofs, and you won’t need a shower after such a short ride on an effortless e bike. I’d expect that journey to take 30 - 40 mins each way

Crimesean · 19/01/2022 18:25

Defo do it! It's loads better than the bus, although I recommend decent waterproofs and bringing a hairbrush/possibly straighteners to work to deal with helmet hair!

purplesequins · 19/01/2022 18:23

8 miles on an ebike sounds like great exercise.
and is alot more reliable than the bus.
get proper locks. a frame lock & chains.
raingear & high vis
a pannier & pannier bags.

you will get a bit quicker with practice.

SandyPanda · 19/01/2022 18:22

No I wouldn't do that unless I really really had to. It'll be horrible in the rain.

Hatefreezingweather1 · 19/01/2022 18:20

Thanks for replies, East Lancs is a busy dual carriageway road, I don't feel confident riding on it yet so I go on the path, which is questionable in parts and also quite hilly (luckily have the electric assistance)

Can do 4 miles in just over 20 minutes with it so hopefully I will get faster as people have said

OP posts: