Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that mp’s defecting to another party shouldn’t be allowed?

206 replies

AlternativePerspective · 19/01/2022 13:44

So Christian Wakeford has defected to labour over the whole Boris fiasco.

Fair enough, he wants no part in it and wants out. However, when people vote for an mp they vote for a party, not an individual. Therefore an elected mp defecting to the opposition is essentially giving a seat to that opposition without the vote of his constituents, who hadn’t wanted that party in place Because they didn’t vote for them.

So if he wants out, he should resign from his constituency so that his constituents can decide whether or not they want labour in power or not.

I mean, if you lived in a Labour constituency and your mp became a Tory I presume people might have something to say about that (I would,) so surely it should just be a blanket policy?

OP posts:
AwaitingSueGraysInvestigation · 19/01/2022 14:00

@DGRossetti

How about when a Prime Minister is replaced ? Should that trigger a general election ?
It almost always does in practice. The exception I can think of from memory is Gordon Brown, who stayed in Number 10 for three years before going to the country. Other 'drop-in' PMs John Major, Theresa May, and Boris Johnson have gone to the country pretty soon after being elected leader by their party. Because there's a tacit understanding, I think, that if you didn't get there through winning a general election you're there on someone else's mandate.
Kitkat151 · 19/01/2022 14:00

@AlternativePerspective

You’re wrong. When you vote you vote for the party who is represented by the candidate.

You don’t tick “mike smith” in the box, you tick the name of the party you’re voting for.

No, you are wrong
girlmom21 · 19/01/2022 13:59

@CorrBlimeyGG

What happens to the current Labour candidate for the constituency?

There isn't a local Labour candidate. They're not selected until close to the next election.

Oh I didn't realise. I just assumed the candidates remained the same. Thanks!
Unescorted · 19/01/2022 13:59

@AlternativePerspective

You’re wrong. When you vote you vote for the party who is represented by the candidate.

You don’t tick “mike smith” in the box, you tick the name of the party you’re voting for.

a guide to ballot slips for you
ZenNudist · 19/01/2022 13:58

Considering all the mumsnetters who have justified voting tory on the grounds they have voted for their MP then YABVU.

I've been voting Labour in the last few elections not because I wanted Corbyn for PM but because of my excellent MP.

Shiningpath · 19/01/2022 13:58

OP you’re totally wrong, please just accept it. I’m our current system electors vote for candidates. If an individual elector chooses to base their vote on party, leader or what their elderly auntie had for lunch last Tuesday, that is a matter for them. And more fool them if they don’t understand the consequences.

Papyrus · 19/01/2022 13:57

Of course you vote for the candidate. That's why independent candidates can stand without the backing of a party.

Hont1986 · 19/01/2022 13:57

You do elect the individual. The party they are a member of is prominently featured, but you elect the individual.

To think that mp’s defecting to another party shouldn’t be allowed?
Nanny0gg · 19/01/2022 13:57

@HirplesWithHaggis

You don't vote for a party though, you elect the candidate. So many people don't seem to understand this.
True, But the party's policies are usually part of that.
Justcallmebebes · 19/01/2022 13:56

You don’t tick “mike smith” in the box, you tick the name of the party you’re voting for.

You do though. A ballot paper will offer the options:
Mike Smith - Labour
John Jones - Conservative etc

You are voting for your local candidates not the party as a whole. I am in this predicament because I am not a fan of the Tories and don't want to vote for Boris, but my MP is a Tory and a very good MP

Itsalmostanaccessory · 19/01/2022 13:56

@DGRossetti

How about when a Prime Minister is replaced ? Should that trigger a general election ?
The public dont elect the prime minister. The party with the majority do.
musicalfrog · 19/01/2022 13:55

You're so wrong OP!

I usually vote for a particular party but since I moved constituency I won't because my candidate here is such a wrong un! I don't believe everyone in a given party is cut from the same cloth. Humans just don't work like that.

MitheredAndFrazzled · 19/01/2022 13:54

@CorrBlimeyGG

You don’t tick “mike smith” in the box, you tick the name of the party you’re voting for.

The paper lists the name of the candidate, with the party name in smaller letters underneath. You do vote for the candidate.

Imagine the issues you'd have in a constituency with more than one independent candidate will if you had no names!
WhatdoImean · 19/01/2022 13:54

The heart of a Parliamentary Democracy is that you elect an individual who will act in the best interests of their constituents - as they perceive that to be. This can mean that they shift party allegiance, as and when they think that a different allegiance would serve their constituents better.

Effectively, the current system is working as designed. Now... whether I think that is a GOOD design is a different question!!! I have a whole view on what electoral reform should be!!

Itsalmostanaccessory · 19/01/2022 13:54

@AlternativePerspective

You’re wrong. When you vote you vote for the party who is represented by the candidate.

You don’t tick “mike smith” in the box, you tick the name of the party you’re voting for.

No, you're wrong. The name is first. The party is additional info.

We dont elect the party. We elect the individual.

That's why, if the individual dies or leaves the job, it triggers a by-election. The party cannot just replace them with another party member because the party isnt elected. It is the individual.

Sartre · 19/01/2022 13:53

You’re supposed to vote for the candidate rather than party so if he’s a decent MP it shouldn’t matter which party he represents.

CorrBlimeyGG · 19/01/2022 13:53

What happens to the current Labour candidate for the constituency?

There isn't a local Labour candidate. They're not selected until close to the next election.

DGRossetti · 19/01/2022 13:53

How about when a Prime Minister is replaced ? Should that trigger a general election ?

Octomore · 19/01/2022 13:52

@AlternativePerspective

You’re wrong. When you vote you vote for the party who is represented by the candidate.

You don’t tick “mike smith” in the box, you tick the name of the party you’re voting for.

Are you quite sure about that?

Because you're wrong.

CorrBlimeyGG · 19/01/2022 13:52

And at the top of the paper, it states "vote for only one candidate", not party.

girlmom21 · 19/01/2022 13:51

What happens to the current Labour candidate for the constituency?

I agree it should trigger a by-election.

CorrBlimeyGG · 19/01/2022 13:51

You don’t tick “mike smith” in the box, you tick the name of the party you’re voting for.

The paper lists the name of the candidate, with the party name in smaller letters underneath. You do vote for the candidate.

Cornettoninja · 19/01/2022 13:51

I agree it should trigger a by-election but I wouldn’t agree that a sitting MP is unable to defect.

My local MP is a Tory (very safe seat) and although I have never voted for him he objectively does a good job and I agree with a lot of his parliament voting history; he does have a tendency to go against the Tory line. If local candidates from other parties were abhorrent to me I would cast my vote for him. I’d welcome his defection.

Unescorted · 19/01/2022 13:50

You elect the person. If you want an elect the party type of selection start campaigning for proportional representation or another type of electoral reform.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 19/01/2022 13:50

But you dont vote for the party. You vote for the individual. That's how our elections work. You choose an individual. They are a party member usually, but they wont always line up with the party politics. You're voting for them with their specific views/promises, not just a blanket conservative policy or labour policy.

So, because we vote for individuals, they can swap around and you've still got the person you voted for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread