Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that mp’s defecting to another party shouldn’t be allowed?

206 replies

AlternativePerspective · 19/01/2022 13:44

So Christian Wakeford has defected to labour over the whole Boris fiasco.

Fair enough, he wants no part in it and wants out. However, when people vote for an mp they vote for a party, not an individual. Therefore an elected mp defecting to the opposition is essentially giving a seat to that opposition without the vote of his constituents, who hadn’t wanted that party in place Because they didn’t vote for them.

So if he wants out, he should resign from his constituency so that his constituents can decide whether or not they want labour in power or not.

I mean, if you lived in a Labour constituency and your mp became a Tory I presume people might have something to say about that (I would,) so surely it should just be a blanket policy?

OP posts:
SantaClawsServiette · 19/01/2022 17:19

I would really object to changing to where we vote for the party. In fact I think being too much under the party thumb is a real issue for MPs and in many cases means they cannot do their job of representing people effectively.

The vote is for a person, someone you could potentially have a real relationship with, rather than an abstract set of policies. This is a good thing - abstract sets of policies can't think and in the end, it would give more power to the few people who have a real hand in setting the policies of the party. You would have even more centralization of power within the parties and within the PMO.

As it is now, even the PM knows that even they play too fast and loose, they could loose MPs. The ability of MPs to really balk over bad legislation would be seriously eroded.

ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 19/01/2022 17:09

Given that CW is one of the 2019 MPs there may be many voters backing him crossing the floor if they have also been disillusioned with Johnson.

This is the most likely explanation - his constituents have turned anti-tory (despite brexit being 'done', or maybe because of) and he's trying to save his skin.

DrFoxtrot · 19/01/2022 17:01

I voted for the candidate I wanted, who happens to be a Labour MP. I'm usually a Tory voter but I wanted this candidate to continue as our MP as I've been impressed with the work she has done. YABU

Iggly · 19/01/2022 16:59

@DGRossetti

We need a better voting system

The problem is our existing voting system consistently delivers around 500 people who really don't want to see a better voting system. And will continue to do so.

This is how revolutions happen. When "the system" is so geared to feeding "the system" that it becomes sclerotic and eventually corrupt and oppressive.

Look how hard it was to abolish slavery. And even when we did we (that is the British taxpayer until 2011) had to pay back the slave owners for the loss of their property.

And as we know, women would never have got the vote if they had solely relied on "the system" as it was.

There are a lot of things that could be done to vastly improve the UKs electoral system. Some form of PR, for a start, and getting rid of hereditary privilege and cronyism for a finish. I humbly suggest worrying about what rossette an MP might identify with at any given moment is really small beer in comparison.

I know. Doesn’t stop me wishing for a better system though.
WhatScratch · 19/01/2022 16:59

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_elected_British_politicians_who_have_changed_party_affiliation

It’s a tradition that goes back hundreds of years. We vote for the individual, not the party, when we elect an MP.

DGRossetti · 19/01/2022 16:57

@Unescorted

There will always be conflict where there are competing views. I would however expect my MP to vote in a way that does not cause detriment or hardship to his own constituents. I may not agree with that majority view but I would expect an elected representative to vote to uphold those views. What you don't want is one that is whipped so hard they have only voted against govt once even where it has been at the cost (environmental, socially and economically) for the majority of his constituents.
I would however expect my MP to vote in a way that does not cause detriment or hardship to his own constituents

But if all 650 did that, you'd never get anything passed.

What you don't want is one that is whipped so hard

Ah - well that's another issue.

Personally I like the idea of "primaries" (and whatever happened to the Conservative initiative over that ??????) where constituents can have an input into candidate selection as well as the central party machine. But I guess that runs counter to the "principle"* that an MP is a representative and not a delegate. And the problem with that "principle" is (a) it's a crock of shit, (b) it's a crock of shit, and (c) it's been superseded by the new normal of getting the electorate to do the job and blaming them.

*There are a lot of "principles" in the UK that none of us have ever been asked about. Which makes the concept of a social contract key to avoiding heads-on-spikes reforms.

sunshinesupermum · 19/01/2022 16:57

I have always voted for the best candidate to serve my local constituency. Last time it was a Labour candidate (who won) even though I did not want Corbyn as PM under any circumstances. The other candidates were all woeful.

Good for Christian.

gogohm · 19/01/2022 16:53

You vote for the individual. You are not unreasonable to think it's wrong for them to switch sides but you are wrong about who you vote for

Unescorted · 19/01/2022 16:50

There will always be conflict where there are competing views. I would however expect my MP to vote in a way that does not cause detriment or hardship to his own constituents. I may not agree with that majority view but I would expect an elected representative to vote to uphold those views. What you don't want is one that is whipped so hard they have only voted against govt once even where it has been at the cost (environmental, socially and economically) for the majority of his constituents.

DGRossetti · 19/01/2022 16:19

@Unescorted

I want my local councillor - borough and county to deal with the local problems and my MP to influence national policy in a way that benefits their local constituents.
But what when that is at the detriment to another MPs constituents ?
Unescorted · 19/01/2022 16:14

I want my local councillor - borough and county to deal with the local problems and my MP to influence national policy in a way that benefits their local constituents.

DGRossetti · 19/01/2022 16:13

We need a better voting system

The problem is our existing voting system consistently delivers around 500 people who really don't want to see a better voting system. And will continue to do so.

This is how revolutions happen. When "the system" is so geared to feeding "the system" that it becomes sclerotic and eventually corrupt and oppressive.

Look how hard it was to abolish slavery. And even when we did we (that is the British taxpayer until 2011) had to pay back the slave owners for the loss of their property.

And as we know, women would never have got the vote if they had solely relied on "the system" as it was.

There are a lot of things that could be done to vastly improve the UKs electoral system. Some form of PR, for a start, and getting rid of hereditary privilege and cronyism for a finish. I humbly suggest worrying about what rossette an MP might identify with at any given moment is really small beer in comparison.

puffyisgood · 19/01/2022 16:11

OP's post isn't by any means ridiculous, but it's unreasonable on balance, for the reasons already given by others.

Iggly · 19/01/2022 16:08

@Tomeeornottomee

I have voted for my local MP based on what he has done for our area, not by what party he represents. I have never voted for his party in a GE and I never would. Just because you only vote for a certain party doesn’t mean the rest of the voting populace does so too. YABU
Which I understand but it means that the ruling party ends up being one that you don’t support?

I wonder how many other voters have a similar dilemma and how our governments would look if they reflected actual voter party preferences.

We effectively have no choice really if we want a decent local MP vs a decent national government when the two don’t align.

Tomeeornottomee · 19/01/2022 16:06

I have voted for my local MP based on what he has done for our area, not by what party he represents. I have never voted for his party in a GE and I never would.
Just because you only vote for a certain party doesn’t mean the rest of the voting populace does so too. YABU

Iggly · 19/01/2022 16:03

I always voted for the party candidate for the simple reason that our MP vote has a bearing on who runs the country.

We need a better voting system - if, for example, I had a really competent Conservative candidate, I’d never vote for them because I don’t want the conservatives running the country. But locally that isn’t much of an issue - I want my local MP to deal with local issues. We see it a lot where MPs vote along party lines that go against local views.

Better to decouple the two.

I wonder if other countries manage it!

DGRossetti · 19/01/2022 15:53

Personally, I've always voted for the person first, and party second, hence why my recent voting pattern (not in date order) is Con, Con, Lab, Lab, Lib. All down to the person for me, ie. I only vote for a local candidate who has either lived or worked in the area and who has a real interest in local issues. I've never voted for anyone parachuted in from Central Office of any party.

+1

It's funny you need to sign more forms saying you have understood something to take out a direct debit than you need to vote.

(Now thinking of an Abraham Lincoln quote) ...

user1497207191 · 19/01/2022 15:41

YABU. People DON'T vote for a party, they vote for an individual. Have you ever looked at a ballot slip??

It may not be right, but it's how elections work.

Personally, I've always voted for the person first, and party second, hence why my recent voting pattern (not in date order) is Con, Con, Lab, Lab, Lib. All down to the person for me, ie. I only vote for a local candidate who has either lived or worked in the area and who has a real interest in local issues. I've never voted for anyone parachuted in from Central Office of any party.

RoseAndRose · 19/01/2022 15:37

I think there should be a bye-election when there is such a dramatic change of allegiance.

powershowerforanhour · 19/01/2022 15:33

"What would be more representative of what is actually happening is for an MP to be able to leave their Parliamentary party - because they no longer feel able to belong to that 'group' who have agreed on a common manifesto - and then sit as an independent or cross-bencher [like in the Lords].

Then in the next election they can stand as an Independent against a newly-appointed candidate OR return to their original party f in the meantime the manifesto had changed to one they again supported.

The 'two tribes' mentality gets in the way in some ways."

Lady Sylvia Hermon did this and won her seat at the next general election:
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sylvia_Hermon

although it helped that the Alliance party withdrew their candidate to support her.

VonHaus · 19/01/2022 15:04

Under the political system you vote for the candidate not their party, so no. However, in reality, people are voting for who they want to be the next government, so I take your point.

ThereIsNoSuchThingAsRoadTax · 19/01/2022 15:01

@Grantanow

I think this is a really marginal issue because it happens so infrequently so why waste space on it? Of course, Churchill crossed the floor twice which is partly why the Tories never trusted him as PM until the success at El Alamein and he went on to be our greatest wartime PM. If he had lost his seat in a compulsory by-election we might have lost WW2.
You think the Russians and, later, Americans wouldn't have bothered fighting if Churchill hadn't be our PM?
EmpressCixi · 19/01/2022 15:00

YABU
You vote for the person, not the party. And an MP can switch parties as much as any other citizen if they feel the party no longer adheres to their sense of ethics or purpose.

Iggly · 19/01/2022 14:55

@Grantanow

I think this is a really marginal issue because it happens so infrequently so why waste space on it? Of course, Churchill crossed the floor twice which is partly why the Tories never trusted him as PM until the success at El Alamein and he went on to be our greatest wartime PM. If he had lost his seat in a compulsory by-election we might have lost WW2.
Ok that’s a stretch.
Coldilox · 19/01/2022 14:55

I’m a Labour voter in Christian Wakeford’s constituency.

He can fuck off, I still wouldn’t vote for him, he’s an awful man.

But the way it works in this country is we elect individuals to represent in in parliament, they may or may not be aligned to a political party. They can then vote whichever way they please in the commons - they don’t have to follow the party line.

Therefore if they want to defect they can.

I just hope Labour don’t put him up at the next election.

Swipe left for the next trending thread