Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that mp’s defecting to another party shouldn’t be allowed?

206 replies

AlternativePerspective · 19/01/2022 13:44

So Christian Wakeford has defected to labour over the whole Boris fiasco.

Fair enough, he wants no part in it and wants out. However, when people vote for an mp they vote for a party, not an individual. Therefore an elected mp defecting to the opposition is essentially giving a seat to that opposition without the vote of his constituents, who hadn’t wanted that party in place Because they didn’t vote for them.

So if he wants out, he should resign from his constituency so that his constituents can decide whether or not they want labour in power or not.

I mean, if you lived in a Labour constituency and your mp became a Tory I presume people might have something to say about that (I would,) so surely it should just be a blanket policy?

OP posts:
Lockheart · 19/01/2022 23:37

If you don't want to be aligned to a particular party and wear their rosette, then stand as an Independent. Don't tie your star to the party who you think will win, get people to vote for you and them and then shift your arse over to the other lot.

That isn't what happened though is it?

He'd always been a member of the Conservative Party. He was a conservative councillor in the constituency for some time before standing as an MP.

He won by 300 votes - Bury South was very tight. It is a seat usually held by a Labour MP but he won by a small majority.

He served the constituency as an MP with the Conservative Party for two years.

Having seen the disgrace the leader of the Conservative Party has made of himself he has decided to leave the Conservative Party.

He wasn't a Labour man in disguise, waiting until the minute he got elected on a landslide Tory manifesto to dramatically fling back his blue cloak (revealing a red lining) whilst cackling about how he fooled them all.

If the leader of your party disgraces himself then it is your democratic right to remove yourself from that party. MPs have this right too.

ErrolTheDragon · 19/01/2022 23:36

@TameDucksAtChatsworth

Oh dear! Try to take your mind out of its pretty narrow "I hate the Tories, Yah Boo cos they're horrid" gauge and see it in a larger context.

What if Corbyn had won a landslide and the next day, all his MPs had crossed over to the Conservatives and he never had the chance to put his manifesto into action.

Wouldn't you think that was a failure of democracy? I would.

.

That scenario is so totally unrealistic that I'm not sure what point you're trying to make.
Blossomtoes · 19/01/2022 23:35

@TameDucksAtChatsworth

Oh dear! Try to take your mind out of its pretty narrow "I hate the Tories, Yah Boo cos they're horrid" gauge and see it in a larger context.

What if Corbyn had won a landslide and the next day, all his MPs had crossed over to the Conservatives and he never had the chance to put his manifesto into action.

Wouldn't you think that was a failure of democracy? I would.

.

Oh dear, try not to be so insulting to someone you don’t know and think about what you’ve posted and how nonsensical it is.

No party is going to defect en masse, is it? I’d think that was a failure of reality.

TameDucksAtChatsworth · 19/01/2022 23:28

Oh dear! Try to take your mind out of its pretty narrow "I hate the Tories, Yah Boo cos they're horrid" gauge and see it in a larger context.

What if Corbyn had won a landslide and the next day, all his MPs had crossed over to the Conservatives and he never had the chance to put his manifesto into action.

Wouldn't you think that was a failure of democracy? I would.

.

Blossomtoes · 19/01/2022 23:17

⬆️ There’s so much nonsense in this post I don’t know where to start with it. Let’s start with all the manifesto promises the Tories have already broken. Manifestos aren’t worth the paper they’re printed on.

TameDucksAtChatsworth · 19/01/2022 23:02

It's all very well prattling on about the theory of who you're voting for-person or party-but most people assume they are voting for the party they want in power. If not, why have Independents in the first place?

What happens if every Conservative MP crosses over to Labour tomorrow? There will then be a Labour government, despite the Conservatives winning the General Election on their manifesto.

The same could happen if Labour were in power and they all crossed to the Conservative.

So, despite a certain colour winning the election on their manifesto, taking power, they would be put out of power the very next day if all their MPs crossed the floor.

What price democracy then. You might have voted for a Labour/Conservative government and then end up with the losing party calling the shots.

So, balls to democracy.

If you don't want to be aligned to a particular party and wear their rosette, then stand as an Independent. Don't tie your star to the party who you think will win, get people to vote for you and them and then shift your arse over to the other lot.

Personally, I think it's a quisling trick and I wouldn't trust the oath of any turncoat of any political colour who did it. He should have stood down and no Jesuitical musing, political angels on pinheads and word salads can make it right.

OperationRinka · 19/01/2022 23:00

..no longer a Conservative MP I should say

Lockheart · 19/01/2022 22:59

@Jjjayfee

You vote for party and candidate. I think there should be a bielection. I also think this mp could have sent a letter to support removing Johnson.
No, you vote for a candidate. Your chosen candidate may be aligned with a political party or may be independent. You do not vote for a political party in a general election, and if you believe you are doing so then you are misinformed.
OperationRinka · 19/01/2022 22:58

He did send a letter requesting Johnson to stand down, but it no longer counts towards the 54 letter target as he's no longer an MP

Jjjayfee · 19/01/2022 22:53

You vote for party and candidate. I think there should be a bielection. I also think this mp could have sent a letter to support removing Johnson.

ErrolTheDragon · 19/01/2022 22:52

@mumda

You vote for a party represented by the person that party has chosen.

I think they should resign and re-stand and let the electorate decide.

No, you vote for an individual who at the time of the election is standing for a particular party (or as an independent). Whether you realise it or not, that's what you're doing.
mumda · 19/01/2022 22:49

You vote for a party represented by the person that party has chosen.

I think they should resign and re-stand and let the electorate decide.

ErrolTheDragon · 19/01/2022 22:46

@steff13

Surely this is just a difference of opinion isn't it? Some people vote for the individual candidate that they prefer, other people vote along the party line.
No. Regardless of whether you choose to vote along party lines or not - and a lot do - you are in fact voting for the individual.
toomuchlaundry · 19/01/2022 22:40

We have so many threads on here berating Tory voters. How would the people feel who are condemning Tories feel if their Labour MP crossed the floor?

VonHaus · 19/01/2022 22:29

There seems to be a lack of understanding that Boris Johnson is only Prime Minister because he’s leader of the party with a majority in the House of Commons. You didn’t vote for him unless you live in Uxbridge and voted Conservative and even then you only voted for him to be your MP, not Prime Minister. It’s not like electing the US President.

nancy75 · 19/01/2022 22:25

@TameDucksAtChatsworth

What would happen if Boris Johnson-or any other Prime Minister- said they were "crossing the floor". So, they were still PM-still in power- but were now pushing through policies of the opposition.

Would that be reasonable?

Of course not and nor is it reasonable for any MP to do this.

They obviously wouldn’t remain PM because they would no longer be part of the party with the majority
Itsalmostanaccessory · 19/01/2022 22:08

@Tomeeornottomee

Um... you vote for you MP during the general election. It means you're choosing them, but you're also choosing a seat for the party they are aligned with at that time. So yes, we elect an individual but it means we give a seat to whichever party they are with.

Lockheart · 19/01/2022 22:01

@Hiddenmnetter

This is really quite mad- it doesn’t matter how you feel about how you vote, it matters what the reality is.

If you vote for your local MP because they’re a Tory, or a labour, it doesn’t matter. That is on YOU. You are not voting for the party, or for the leader. You vote for the local constituent. Who they then align themselves with is a matter for how the business of parliament proceeds. Of course how they align themselves will often (significantly) influence how many votes they get- this is why the whip exists. It’s a two way street- the MP essentially gives his/her support to the party and the parties chosen leader, and in return the MP gets the kudos and basically free votes for being that parties MP (being preselected).

In return the MP votes in line with party policy. The threat of “removing the whip” is essentially being expelled from the party. By moving to a US style of politics (party + leader) without actually having a US style political setup (we still just vote for our local MP) we hand extraordinary power to the PM in a way that was never before intended.

This is precisely what crossing the floor is about- it is a “vote of no confidence”. MPs that cross the floor will be threatened with losing the whip, but probably they don’t care if they’re from red wall seats because they’ll be crossing the floor for constituents who have largely voted labour until now.

TL;DR: you vote for the fucking local MP, not the party, not the leader, no matter how you feel or what you think. That is how our Westminster system of parliament works. If you don’t like it, feel free to campaign for change. Don’t pretend it’s something else. Cause it’s not. It doesn’t matter what party is written on the ballot, you vote for the person, not the party.

This. It's a bit mad how many people don't realise this.

You don't vote for a party, you don't vote for a prime minister, you vote for a local member of parliament.

Lots of people may think they're voting Tory / Labour etc but that's not how our political system actually works.

FatOaf · 19/01/2022 21:58

You’re wrong. When you vote you vote for the party who is represented by the candidate.
You don’t tick “mike smith” in the box, you tick the name of the party you’re voting for.

No. You put a cross against "Mike Smith. 1 Sewer Street, Bogtown. The Conservative Party Candidate."

VikingOnTheFridge · 19/01/2022 21:58

@ChocolateDeficitDisorder

Given that CW is one of the 2019 MPs there may be many voters backing him crossing the floor if they have also been disillusioned with Johnson.

This is the most likely explanation - his constituents have turned anti-tory (despite brexit being 'done', or maybe because of) and he's trying to save his skin.

Oh yeah, I don't believe for one second this was solely down to an attack of conscience on his part. He's got a knife edge majority and all the party revelations will easily have cost him well over 400 votes.
steff13 · 19/01/2022 21:55

Surely this is just a difference of opinion isn't it? Some people vote for the individual candidate that they prefer, other people vote along the party line.

Siepie · 19/01/2022 21:47

@Tomeeornottomee

I have voted for my local MP based on what he has done for our area, not by what party he represents. I have never voted for his party in a GE and I never would. Just because you only vote for a certain party doesn’t mean the rest of the voting populace does so too. YABU
You vote for your MP in the General Election.
Hiddenmnetter · 19/01/2022 19:34

This is really quite mad- it doesn’t matter how you feel about how you vote, it matters what the reality is.

If you vote for your local MP because they’re a Tory, or a labour, it doesn’t matter. That is on YOU. You are not voting for the party, or for the leader. You vote for the local constituent. Who they then align themselves with is a matter for how the business of parliament proceeds. Of course how they align themselves will often (significantly) influence how many votes they get- this is why the whip exists. It’s a two way street- the MP essentially gives his/her support to the party and the parties chosen leader, and in return the MP gets the kudos and basically free votes for being that parties MP (being preselected).

In return the MP votes in line with party policy. The threat of “removing the whip” is essentially being expelled from the party. By moving to a US style of politics (party + leader) without actually having a US style political setup (we still just vote for our local MP) we hand extraordinary power to the PM in a way that was never before intended.

This is precisely what crossing the floor is about- it is a “vote of no confidence”. MPs that cross the floor will be threatened with losing the whip, but probably they don’t care if they’re from red wall seats because they’ll be crossing the floor for constituents who have largely voted labour until now.

TL;DR: you vote for the fucking local MP, not the party, not the leader, no matter how you feel or what you think. That is how our Westminster system of parliament works. If you don’t like it, feel free to campaign for change. Don’t pretend it’s something else. Cause it’s not. It doesn’t matter what party is written on the ballot, you vote for the person, not the party.

DGRossetti · 19/01/2022 17:24

This is the most likely explanation - his constituents have turned anti-tory (despite brexit being 'done', or maybe because of)

I think it's because of . That's why the Tories have been turning into Labour these past few months.

In 1971, council voters in Harrow dumped the Tories to bring comprehensive education to the borough with a Labour administration (NOC).

In 1974 they dumped Labour and went back to their Tory ways.

(As Max Boyce used to say: I know, because I was there ...)

Time will tell.

HopefulProcrastinator · 19/01/2022 17:24

The lack of critical thinking on this thread is staggering...and probably explains why we have such a shower of shit acting as government for our country.

First past the post aka Parliamentary elections are based entirely on the votes an individual can amass. If someone chooses not to check if the candidate they are voting for will actually represent them but instead votes on party that's their choice, but they are still giving their vote to an individual who is elected to represent their constituents in the best way possible - part of this can be deciding whether their values continue to align with the party whip or if it becomes impossible to do.

Proportional representation devolved governments in Scotland and Wales use this as part of their elections, NI might too allows you to vote for a party seat for a set of potential candidates.

However, all that being said I don't think an MP should be able to switch party allegiance, I think the most they should be able to do is either resign as an MP triggering a by-election or to resign from their party thereby making themselves an independent candidate for the rest of their term. However, the law clearly allows this...so if you aren't happy - let your MP know!

Swipe left for the next trending thread