Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that mp’s defecting to another party shouldn’t be allowed?

206 replies

AlternativePerspective · 19/01/2022 13:44

So Christian Wakeford has defected to labour over the whole Boris fiasco.

Fair enough, he wants no part in it and wants out. However, when people vote for an mp they vote for a party, not an individual. Therefore an elected mp defecting to the opposition is essentially giving a seat to that opposition without the vote of his constituents, who hadn’t wanted that party in place Because they didn’t vote for them.

So if he wants out, he should resign from his constituency so that his constituents can decide whether or not they want labour in power or not.

I mean, if you lived in a Labour constituency and your mp became a Tory I presume people might have something to say about that (I would,) so surely it should just be a blanket policy?

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 20/01/2022 10:05

@CreamFirstThenJamOnTop

I vote on the individual….. if my preferred party is represented by a complete moron then I certainly wouldn’t vote for them.

I would think that if a candidate decides to change party then it would be fair if it triggered a bi-election to give constituents the choice of whether to keep them in office. But politics don’t often feel fair….

Is it usually for the same party or have you switched due to local MP running

And do your views on local MP generally align with whether you like the leader or would you prioritise liking local over leader

Legoninjago1 · 20/01/2022 10:05

@WindyState

It's true that individuals are elected rather than parties.

But let's be realistic here. Most people know the sum of absolutely nothing about their local MP. You'll be lucky if most people could name their MP, let alone pick them out of a crowd.

Plus, the whipping system is a thing. Regardless of what your local MP claims to stand for personally, on most matters that people actually care about when it comes to how an MP votes they do as they are told. So, if you vote for an MP on the basis of say a manifesto to "get brexit done" they will be whipped accordingly to vote through brexit legislation. If they cross the floor to an anti-brexit party, they are whipped to vote the other way.

So given the actual reality of the UK political system and given that electoral reform is not going to happen soon it's understandable that people feel like a byelection should be triggered when an MP changes party, and I'm inclinded to agree with that.

I absolutely agree with this. In addition, to my mind, anyone who can suddenly swing so markedly - in either direction - is in it to promote themselves and can't really have had much belief in their own stated convictions.
DGRossetti · 20/01/2022 09:59

So, for consistency (aka "fairness") when an MP dies, they should be replaced by whoever their party thinks should do the job ? No election needed ?

CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 20/01/2022 09:50

I vote on the individual….. if my preferred party is represented by a complete moron then I certainly wouldn’t vote for them.

I would think that if a candidate decides to change party then it would be fair if it triggered a bi-election to give constituents the choice of whether to keep them in office. But politics don’t often feel fair….

maddy68 · 20/01/2022 09:49

When you vote for an MP you vote for that individual not the party. That's why they can switch sides

3scape · 20/01/2022 09:47

Everyone should be able to develop their opinions and change their minds. If an MP never budges on any stance they have a closed mind and probably are shit at problem solving, listening and reflecting in the world.

montysma1 · 20/01/2022 09:44

Realistically people vote for a party.
In a strong Tory constituency they could stand a monkey as a Candidate and they would still be elected. Look at Boris.
Convesrsley I could be presented with a Tory candidate with amazing credentials, great charisma, kind to animals, a novel prize and looks like George Clooney.
I wouldn't vote for a Tory.

Perhaps in local elections people will give a personal vote for a candidate that's done good things for their area.
National elections..... you vote for the party. Because that determines the direction for the whole county.

MarshaBradyo · 20/01/2022 09:44

CW rather

MarshaBradyo · 20/01/2022 09:44

@WindyState

It's true that individuals are elected rather than parties.

But let's be realistic here. Most people know the sum of absolutely nothing about their local MP. You'll be lucky if most people could name their MP, let alone pick them out of a crowd.

Plus, the whipping system is a thing. Regardless of what your local MP claims to stand for personally, on most matters that people actually care about when it comes to how an MP votes they do as they are told. So, if you vote for an MP on the basis of say a manifesto to "get brexit done" they will be whipped accordingly to vote through brexit legislation. If they cross the floor to an anti-brexit party, they are whipped to vote the other way.

So given the actual reality of the UK political system and given that electoral reform is not going to happen soon it's understandable that people feel like a byelection should be triggered when an MP changes party, and I'm inclinded to agree with that.

Well put

Talk this morning of CE voting according to Cons whip who will then change

ErrolTheDragon · 20/01/2022 09:43

Which he’d win because his majority as a Tory was miniscule. It would be a complete waste of time and money.

Not necessarily- he wouldn't necessarily be adopted as the Labour candidate would he?

Tbh although I think it's completely right that MPs should be able to leave a party if they believe it no longer represents their constituents' best interests, and I don't think this should automatically trigger a by election, it would probably be better if they had to serve the remainder of their term as an independent. They could then seek to be adopted by another party as their candidate, or stand as an independent.

DGRossetti · 20/01/2022 09:42

For people that think the system should change, your first challenge appears to be to get your MP to give a toss ....

To think that mp’s defecting to another party shouldn’t be allowed?
WindyState · 20/01/2022 09:42

It's true that individuals are elected rather than parties.

But let's be realistic here. Most people know the sum of absolutely nothing about their local MP. You'll be lucky if most people could name their MP, let alone pick them out of a crowd.

Plus, the whipping system is a thing. Regardless of what your local MP claims to stand for personally, on most matters that people actually care about when it comes to how an MP votes they do as they are told. So, if you vote for an MP on the basis of say a manifesto to "get brexit done" they will be whipped accordingly to vote through brexit legislation. If they cross the floor to an anti-brexit party, they are whipped to vote the other way.

So given the actual reality of the UK political system and given that electoral reform is not going to happen soon it's understandable that people feel like a byelection should be triggered when an MP changes party, and I'm inclinded to agree with that.

Tomeeornottomee · 20/01/2022 09:41

@Itsalmostanaccessory no. I was talking about the by-elections. I vote for the PARTY in a GE, not in a local 🙄 thanks for your input though. Really helpful 😂

Regularsizedrudy · 20/01/2022 09:37

Found out you were wrong on page 1 and not come back lol

Blossomtoes · 20/01/2022 09:33

@Viviennemary

I agree. It's cheeky. They should force a re-election of the MP.
Which he’d win because his majority as a Tory was miniscule. It would be a complete waste of time and money.
Viviennemary · 20/01/2022 09:22

I agree. It's cheeky. They should force a re-election of the MP.

MarshaBradyo · 20/01/2022 09:19

poppycock about people "voting for parties"

Of course it is…

‘Frothing’ yep from people getting angry over the reality of people voting for parties or leaders. When the questions were asked after Labour’s defeat it was - was it more Corbyn or policies not how about your local MP

As for this site if it went the other way ha at this same posters being so magnanimous

DGRossetti · 20/01/2022 09:15

A lot of inconsistent frothing here, surely.

If we accept this poppycock about people "voting for parties" (and that's their lookout) then what should happen when the party changes ?

I was awake in 2019, and can recall Tory manifesto pledges (so not some bloke spouting off outside a pub, but official policy) about not raising NI (for example).

Why aren't people clamouring for a fresh election over that ?

Besides. Unless you are a Bury constituent, why should any of this worry you ? Your MP hasn't crossed the floor. Maybe concentrate on holding them to their promises before you fret over someone elses ?

MarshaBradyo · 20/01/2022 09:02

Technically people can talk about what happens but if people dismiss the leader and manifesto for preferring their local MP I’d say they are an outlier and can’t understand why they would

But I guess if they’re a stickler for process and it’s that important to them it’s up to them how they vote

crazyjinglist · 20/01/2022 09:00

Confused You vote for a candidate who is a representative of a party (unless they are an independent). And obviously in many cases you vote for that candidate precisely because they are representing that party.

The fact that the OP was wrong to say that you vote for the party and not the candidate (you effectively vote for both really), doesn't mean her point about candidates defecting is unreasonable.

Dillidalli · 20/01/2022 08:48

@DGRossetti well we have a conservative government and useless mps so I guess we are already there.

DGRossetti · 20/01/2022 08:46

A lot of people believing a wrong thing doesn't make it right.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 20/01/2022 08:37

@HirplesWithHaggis

You don't vote for a party though, you elect the candidate. So many people don't seem to understand this.
Yes, in theory, but in practice the vast majority of people do vote for a candidate because s/he represents the party they prefer.

I agree with a pp that it should trigger a by-election.

MarshaBradyo · 20/01/2022 08:35

Jesus, no matter this country Is fucked, people are voting for the party rather than the candidate. That means the candidate could be utter utter shite and they’d still vote for them!

So the policies and leader for the party mean nothing over the local candidate? Crazy

DGRossetti · 20/01/2022 08:31

@Dillidalli

Jesus, no matter this country Is fucked, people are voting for the party rather than the candidate. That means the candidate could be utter utter shite and they’d still vote for them!
(looks around parliament)

You think there's a real danger that might happen in future ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread