Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it fair to say that 36C, 34D, 32E, 30F bras are all pretty much the same size?

137 replies

Shinydiscoballs1 · 19/01/2022 13:32

Just that really, I just did a bra calculator and I've put my measurements in. It says I would be a 34D, 32E or 30F
I also have a bra here which is 36C which fits well too.
What actual bra size do I go for?

OP posts:
Cbtb · 20/01/2022 09:50

Also complicated by some manufacturers not actually making the bands to the actual inches size. A 34” bra should measure 34” along the bottom of the band when gently stretched - that’s what the band test is measuring. If a tape measure at 34” goes around your chest a piece of fabric of that length must also do so. If it dosent it’s usually because the bra is not made right.

(History or the reason M and S can’t measure bras - Pre the invention of elastic material it was needed to add some “give” to the band measurements to allow people to breathe as the band couldn’t stretch with your breathing. This lead to the adding on of inches to the band measurement. Now bands stretch though this is unhelpful as it makes the bands to big but lots of places continue to do this. Some manufactures try and compensate by making the band smaller assuming that women are looking for a band that is 2 inches too big - their 34” is actually only 32” long because they assume that the customer actually measures 32” and has added on 2” so of course it dosent actually fit an actual 34” chest )

womaninatightspot · 20/01/2022 09:48

I hate a tight band too but I'm going to take this thread onboard next time I go bra shopping!

MaybeHeIsMyCat · 20/01/2022 09:47

Posted before but this is me, a fat size 16/18 in a 34 band that was too big as it had stretched over time
It's not tight at all, my fist is under it. The band should be level all the way round and not ride up at all, I can feel mine is there when I breathe out. As in I'm aware I'm wearing it but I can sleep in it and not be uncomfortable
Different styles matter a lot as well, I find Elomi fits me, curvy Kate doesn't

dementedpixie · 20/01/2022 09:45

@stingofthebutterfly

Bra sizes confuse me. I'm wearing a 36E, size 16/18ish. According to my actual measurements, I should be in a 44AA. My 14 year old daughter thought it was very amusing that I should be in a smaller cup size than her.
Do you measure 44 under your bust? If not, then that's not your back size
MaybeHeIsMyCat · 20/01/2022 09:44

You are likely to get some back fat/skin because well, you're human
Like sock tops sometimes dig in
You can look for longline bras which are more smoothing but if you have a supportive firm band, it's going to show back fat/skin folds

stingofthebutterfly · 20/01/2022 09:43

Bra sizes confuse me. I'm wearing a 36E, size 16/18ish. According to my actual measurements, I should be in a 44AA. My 14 year old daughter thought it was very amusing that I should be in a smaller cup size than her.

Cbtb · 20/01/2022 09:39

The easiest way I find to think about it is that the cup size is the difference between your ribcage and your boobs

So you measure below your boobs snug but not tight and then this is the size band you need

You then measure around your boobs at the widest part and subtract the band measurement from this and that’s how much your boobs stick out from your body =cup size
1’’ A
2’’ B
Etc

Example
34 below your boobs and 38 across them
Your boobs stick out 4 inches

So you need a 34 band and a D cup

That’s simple enough. The issue is that as the cups and the band are joined together (duh) then they interact and bigger cups make band length longer as well as bigger bands making cups larger. If you think about the construction of a bra you have essentially a long rectangle of fabric - the band and two cones/circles - the cups (plus some shoulder straps).

_
OO

The strap is cut up to add the cups so it goes strap - cup- strap- cup - strap

—o-o—
—O-O— this one is bigger though the band is the same size

so the bigger the size of the cup/circle the bigger the overall length of the band will get!

It works the other way round as well

—o-o—
—-o-o—- this one is bigger as the band is longer although they cups are the same size

Which means that
—O-O—
—-o-o—-
These too are roughly the same size in actual length (though not exactly as I’m doing this with o/- not actual material)

MrsPnut · 20/01/2022 09:31

@TommyShelby

Bob method was rubbish for me. Didn’t work at all. They put me in a 30DD. It didn’t even go round me to fasten!
Did the 30 back fit when you did the band test?
TommyShelby · 20/01/2022 09:17

Bob method was rubbish for me. Didn’t work at all. They put me in a 30DD. It didn’t even go round me to fasten!

Bitbloweyoutthere · 20/01/2022 09:08

Non cup-size bras are my big bug bear. I love the sloggi zero feel bras for lounging, but while a medium fits my boobs, it's too slack. A small is perfect, but my boobs are too big for it and the non adjustable straps are too short, so I end up with underboob.

My sports bras are shockabsorber and a size up in the band and down in the cup. But then, the latest shock absorber, the fly, isn't secure enough. Ffs, why do that? I thought I had it sorted.

JustFrustrated · 20/01/2022 08:23

None of the methods work for me.

Have implants so it's almost like I sit between cup sizes and band sizes.

And no one has answered how to stop the unsightly under band roll, when wearing a tighter back. I'm not fat, but as soon as i drop a back size there's a roll below the bra line?

whowhywhenwhat · 20/01/2022 08:18

Apart from my running bra which is a 34C.

whowhywhenwhat · 20/01/2022 08:15

And I am size 8 and wear a S.Smile

whowhywhenwhat · 20/01/2022 08:14

They've similar size cups but the strap at the base is different lengths - which also affects how far apart the cups sit at their fullest. I can't wear anything too tight as I've had a mastectomy (one side) and have scars which make it uncomfortable. Can't wear underwires either. So I go up a back-size. But my favourite bras are the stretchy comfort bra crop top style (they've got pockets to add padding in too). Those ones generally only come in in SML and support me just fine.🤷‍♀️

dementedpixie · 20/01/2022 08:00

Maybe try a 30 back if you have less padding on your ribs. And play about with cup sizes. 28F sister size would be 30E so maybe try that and 30DD.

pawpatrolneedaunion · 20/01/2022 07:55

[quote dementedpixie]@pawpatrolneedaunion Could be a style issue. I can't wear full cup bras as the top section would be empty. I wear balconette bras instead. If the 28 back fits then try different sizes and cup styles. Try M&S bras if you like but just don't get measured by them[/quote]
I've tried half cup and balconette, they are still huge up top and after five years wearing nursing bras I also find the wires sit on my ribs and feel awful. I wonder if there is a miracle non wired bra out there for me somewhere.

Shinydiscoballs1 · 20/01/2022 07:53

There seems to be such a range here!!
I've ordered a bra from vinted for £1 (it's nice too) 32DD as a start point.
Will update when it arrives.
30 just seems like it would be far too tight for me. But I won't dismiss till I've actually tried with the bigger cups.
So weird as my breasts don't look big! No one would say I've got big breasts, a large handful maybe, but I guess the ratio to back measurement means the bigger cup size!!

OP posts:
dementedpixie · 20/01/2022 07:43

@pawpatrolneedaunion Could be a style issue. I can't wear full cup bras as the top section would be empty. I wear balconette bras instead. If the 28 back fits then try different sizes and cup styles. Try M&S bras if you like but just don't get measured by them

pawpatrolneedaunion · 20/01/2022 06:32

I don't understand all of it. BOB has me at a 28F but I've lost all volume through breastfeeding so when I wear that there's enough room to fit at least 3 hamsters into the cups on each size (I suppose it'd be warm!)

I have no idea what size to look for and everywhere that used to do fitting here has closed. We only have m&s left and I'm wary of them for sizing.

EishetChayil · 20/01/2022 06:22

How can there be that much discrepancy? Surely your chest measurement is what it is.

User6397254 · 20/01/2022 06:18

I think if you a quite small chested as I am it really doesn't matter and just wear what is comfortable and looks OK

LemonSwan · 20/01/2022 02:04

This thread has confused me beyond belief.

I am a 32/34 band and a size 8/10.

hellobabyyy · 20/01/2022 01:21

@Blahblahblah21

I got measured in Victorias Secret. Measure 30” under boobs and was sized as 34” bra. The fit is great and no way could I go down a band width without feeling extremely uncomfortable. Guess they use the old way of sizing too as in if you’re an odd number measurement add 5, even measurement add 4.🤷🏻‍♀️
They don’t even do that. I worked at Victorias Secret for a year before I went to work at a ‘proper’ underwear shop and I couldn’t believe the difference.

VS very much enforce the idea of fitting the bra to the customer not the customer in the bra. It doesn’t matter what size they are, you don’t let them leave without a bra if that’s what they want. They only stock up to a DDD (equivalent to an E) but we would fit women with much bigger boobs in this and just put a huge back size on them even if they were a size 8 they could still end up leaving with a 36 DDD if they really needed a 32G.

Polestar50 · 20/01/2022 00:50

Stravaig, who posted yesterday, is spot on:

"Sounds like you've decided what a reasonable cup size is and are forcing the band to provide the extra space, which makes for a terribly fitting bra. Too large band/too small cup is apparently typical for most of us. The comfort and support from a smaller band with generous cups is a revelation!"

I wore a 36C for years as that's the cup size that fitted me best when self-fitting in a high street shop with limited range. As Stravaig says - I had decided what a reasonable bra size is and thought a C-cup sounded "about right" for my size.

Finally went for a proper fitting and discovered I was actually a 32E.

Revelation is not too strong a word. A correctly sized bra is more comfortable and infinitely more flattering. I felt held and lifted for the first time ever. My boobs looked much smaller and perkier under clothes.

It took me a while to get over the fact the bra had 'E' written in the label and looked massive, like 2 hats sewn together in my eyes. This was because the cup to band ratio was so different to what I was used to. I basically thought it looked like a comedy bra. But once on me it fitted like a glove and made a huge difference to my self-image.

Best of luck OP. Please do come back and tell us what you discover!

Voice0fReason · 19/01/2022 21:41

@Mollysocks

I’m a 36C but I did one of those bra sizes quizzes and put in all my measurements and apparently I’m a 32F!!

A 36 band bra just fits me I’d no way get into a 32 so I’m confused too OP!!

I used to wear a 36B and often wore an extender as the band felt so tight. When I discovered Boob or Bust it put me in a 32F. I laughed and completely dismissed it as ridiculous. Then I went and tried on a few bras and I was a convert! I have thrown out all of my old bras and only wear 30G/32FF depending on the style

When you try on a 32, make sure it is the right cup size.
If you try on a 32C it will be tiny and you'll never get it on.

The test on the band is to put the bra on backward. That will tell you if the band fits.
Remember that if a tape measure shows 32 inches then a bra that measures 32 inches when stretched will fit you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread