Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about reaction to gift?

134 replies

giftAIBU · 19/01/2022 10:57

Name changed because it's outing and I don't need my family finding my main account!

For Christmas, I commissioned an artist to do a stylised portrait of my sibling's beloved pet. I knew it was a bit of a risky gift but they are very tough to buy for as they're quite well off and really have everything they need, and I figured that even if they hated the actual picture, they would appreciate the thought that went in to it, and because we don't live near each other they could hide it in a cupboard for most of the year if needs be!

I put a lot of time and effort into it, going back and forth with the artist to get it right, and while it wasn't excessively expensive, it wasn't cheap either.

Anyway, Christmas came and went and I didn't hear anything from my sibling, but that's not massively unusual so I didn't think anything of it. I then came to stay with my Mum and found the picture lying on the side in her house. I remarked that sibling hadn't taken it home, and she said (very defensively) "[Sibling] doesn't think it's very good so wanted to talk to you about it". I was a bit aghast and my mum added that my sibling was "worried" that I had been ripped off and that's why they wanted to speak to me.

In my eyes, this is rude beyond belief - it's clearly a gift that a lot of thought has gone in to, and in my opinion if you get a gift you don't like, you smile and say thank you anyway. Also I don't think it's the receiver's place to worry about whether or not a gift is worth what the giver paid for it.

For my sibling, I'm guessing that it's just good sense to reject the gift considering they don't like it - I'm assuming they think I would be able to get a refund (although of course I can't because it's personalised and I approved it before it was sent out!).

I feel incredibly hurt by both my sibling's actions and my mum's vehement defence of them. We were brought up to always be grateful for gifts, regardless of whether or not we actually liked them, and I can't help but feel if this were the other way around, my mum would be horrified with me.

For background:

  • I lost my spouse last year so it was something of an effort to get Christmas presents sorted
  • Mum, sibling and I have quite a difficult dynamic - sibling is the golden child, regardless of behaviour, and my mum will always take their side, so I am no doubt oversensitive when it happens
  • Sibling didn't get me - or my child, their only nephew - anything for Christmas, but they would say this was deliberate so we could choose something when we next saw them

So I guess my question is - AIBU to be hurt?

OP posts:
oakleaffy · 19/01/2022 13:35

What a horrid ungrateful wretch she sounds
If someone had done that for me, with my dear departed dogs, I’d have been so touched, even if it didn’t look like the dog exactly.
I’m sorry the ungrateful woman has been so rude to you.

Doyourememberthetime · 19/01/2022 13:32

I’m not seeing a floral background?

I would stop exchanging presents.

Firstruleofsoupover · 19/01/2022 13:31

Would it be possible to know please what you bought sister for Christmas the year before? Did she say thank you? If her personality has a tendency towards grabby, and say she might have been expecting expensive perfume or make up say, I can just imagine the pouting rejection of something she may not have the emotional depth to appreciate. Your mum should have put her straight and not pandered when she wanted to leave your “sub-standard” gift behind for you to see with intention you realise you had done a present “fail” aka “get me something I will like next year”. Too many “ “ ses.

Someone in my family buys the strangest gifts, if any, for birthday and Christmas, and has tried to give me back my own xmas gift once, which I refused. I usually make nice noises and always take the presents away even though I don’t keep much. What I buy for them, I never hear about again unless I ask. Dialled it down considerably this year with a carton of the useful and the edible, plus a nice Christmas decoration. Heard not a word.

Staffy1 · 19/01/2022 13:30

If you like the painting keep it at your house. The sibling obviously doesn’t want it and isn’t going to use it.

TonTonMacoute · 19/01/2022 13:28

I don't exchange presents with my DB, an arrangement we are both more than happy with.

Your sibling's reaction was thoughtless and I don't blame you for being hurt, but I would treat it lightly and use this experience to suggest neither of you buy for each other in future.

Buying presents is meant to be fun, not an ordeal, remove this source of stress from your life!

Doyourememberthetime · 19/01/2022 13:27

I think the painting is amazing! So much time and effort has gone into it. I can’t imagine anyone doing something like that for me. A family friend put a printed photo of our dog in a frame recently for Christmas. The picture wasn’t the best but the thought that went into it makes it lovely. So much nicer than the cheap tat we get from other people.

PeonyAndSweetpea · 19/01/2022 13:23

The style isn't to my taste, especially with a floral background (that sounds as if it would detract from the subject). However, I would take it and put it somewhere discreet as it's a picture of my dog......and I love my dogs (their portraits adorn my hall.....and they are a specific style I love, but wouldn't be to everyone's taste)!

You should take it home with you and hang it somewhere as you like it. Stuff your stuck up sibling.....they are just damned rude

Sparklesocks · 19/01/2022 13:20

I'd feel hurt too OP.
Also leaving it at your mum's house and leaving it to her to talk to you about is quite tactless. At least take it home and speak to you about it directly like an adult.

I think it looks nice.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 19/01/2022 13:20

Given that your husband died last year I think it was incredibly rude and entitled.
They could have just shut up and put it in a cupboard.
If I were you I wouldn't bother next year at all.
I wouldn't dream of telling anyone I didn't like their gift. Even if I absolutely hated it.

giftAIBU · 19/01/2022 13:20

@fluffymule I do genuinely love sibling and would have been delighted if they had liked the present - but yes, considering sibling really isn't fussed about getting presents, I do need to look at my motivations for buying them more closely.

OP posts:
confusednotcom · 19/01/2022 13:20

All sounds really wrong to me. "They are the youngest and fondly seen as a bit disorganised etc, so not buying presents is a quirk of their personality. Whereas I am very organised, so not buying a present would be seen as a deliberate snub." I hate this sort of double standard!

I'd say that in light of having got this one so wrong, judging by their reaction, you'll get gifts together in future as they do, to be sure of getting something they'll like. You are NOT being unreasonable!!

Fluffymule · 19/01/2022 13:17

I think they've both been insensitive at best, but I think behaviour like that is rude and unkind.

You've said that you give presents to your sister more to keep your mum happy really, so if you really can't bring yourself to stop perhaps at least consider investing less thought into the gift to protect yourself from any future incidents. A box of chocolates or a generic candle perhaps.

giftAIBU · 19/01/2022 13:16

@saraclara I absolutely get where you're coming from but I know that my mum isn't stirring out of malice. It has definitely been left here by my sibling (not SIL) deliberately, they are in my mum's house several times a week. But you are right that I should wait until sibling speaks to me directly.

@ohmybod I have put a note to this exact effect on my present-buying list for next year - thank you for the suggestion.

OP posts:
giftAIBU · 19/01/2022 13:12

@Chloemol I know that seems like the right course of behaviour but unfortunately that kind of confrontation would be like a bomb going off in my family and wouldn't achieve anything - mum and sibling would double down on their opinion that they were right and that I'm just being oversensitive, and I would be the one left feeling like I'd done something wrong. Additionally, my mum is disabled and her condition is exacerbated by stress/upset, so I would feel guilty for that too. But I will definitely suggest that we no longer buy each other Christmas presents - that's a line I can and should draw.

@Dontbeme It's actually my second Christmas (I said DH died "last year" out of habit, apologies). And in fairness to them, they have been very supportive on a practical level (emotional support not really sibling's strong point!). I do agree though that whether or not the picture is any good sort of isn't relevant because I'm not upset that they didn't like it, but upset about their reaction. Thank you for understanding that.

@ChargingBuck Your posts are so compassionate and helpful - I honestly can't thank you enough. I can't tell you how incredible it is to hear that perhaps this isn't all in my head after all! Also your point about them being good in a crisis - this is sibling to a T! And I'd never really made the association. They have been wonderful at very difficult times in my life, but not at all good for the rest of the time.

@NellieEllie I think your instinct to keep it factual and light is a good one - I'm going to try to do that if they bring it up.

OP posts:
Ohmybod · 19/01/2022 13:11

OP, why are you worried about upsetting your mum by not buying your sibling a Xmas gift? What’s the worst that could happen, especially as you say sibling likely wouldn’t be bothered. I think you need to put a note in your diary for the start of December this year to go back and read this thread and dig deep for your assertive side. Stop buying her a present and just tell your mum the honest truth, in a calm polite manner: it’s never reciprocal and she is difficult to buy for. There is honestly no good reason your DM can give to argue you should continue.

ChargingBuck · 19/01/2022 13:10

It's a pleasure OP, as you have doubtless detected I have experience in this arena!

& crikey, no DON'T read the linked articles while you are still at DM's!
They are for a time of quiet reflection, & I really hope will lead you to some solid help with techniques to help you manage your relatives more easily, & remain more blase & detached from their nonsense.

2pinkginsplease · 19/01/2022 13:10

I think your sister sounds like an ungrateful cow!

Plain rude and selfish, listening to how you describe your mum they sound like 2 peas in a pod.

For me, that would be present buying stopped!

There is no need for her to be rude!

saraclara · 19/01/2022 13:09

instead of just keeping it is it ?

Instead of just keeping quiet!

StellaAndCrow · 19/01/2022 13:08

I'd like that picture and I don't even have a dog :)

I'm very sorry about the loss of your spouse, I'm v impressed you managed to organise presents at all. Take care. xxx

saraclara · 19/01/2022 13:07

how much of this actually came from your sibling? You've had no direct communication from them about it, so is it possible a lot of this is your mother?

I thought it was just me. You and most posters are ranting about how rude SIL has been. But I can't see any reference to her actually saying anything at all to you.

Your mum says that she's planning to, but for all you know she might just have said that to her mum but with no intention of actually doing so. Or just considered doing so but then realised that that would be ungrateful.

So yes, I'd blame your mum for stirring things up instead of just keeping it is it and saying "Oh yes, SIL left it behind, she knows and will pick it up later"

You've said several times that she's at liberty to do what she likes with it. So wait and see what happens before you decide whether she's rude. So far she hasn't done or said anything rude to you, that you haven't acknowledged is okay. She might just pick it up and hide it like you said she can. Or she might confront you on it which would be rude. But neither thing has happened yet.

2022HereWeCome · 19/01/2022 13:07

OP rise above it. Simple text to your sibling saying. 'Mum said you didn't like your Xmas gift. Not to worry - let's just agree not to exchange xmas / birthday gifts any more'. And you could ask for the painting back if you liked as you 'know someone who would like it'
I certainly wouldn't be engaging with your sibling or mum any more than this

ChargingBuck · 19/01/2022 13:05

Oh, how I LOVE this, @AmyDudley!

And personally, even though the picture is of her pet, if you like it, keep it for yourself and hang it in your house (and every time you look at it give it a wink and say 'sod her Rover' grin)

giftAIBU · 19/01/2022 13:03

@AmyDudley I am very sorry for your loss, and I imagine that not having someone to talk this hurtful action over with, has brought home your loss even more. I hope posting on here has helped. This is very, very true, and I was (and am) aware that this additional hurt has made me more sensitive than is possibly reasonable. It's been so helpful getting all the perspectives her.

OP posts:
SalsaLove · 19/01/2022 13:02

I love that! It’s a great painting!

giftAIBU · 19/01/2022 13:01

@chargingbuck Thank you so much for taking the time to write all that out, and sharing those links. I will absolutely read them when I'm able to (still at my mum's at the mo so will probably wait until I'm home!).

OP posts: