Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to propose this idea for replacing the BBC Licence Fee?

158 replies

BuanoKubiamVej · 19/01/2022 10:10

The BBC is brilliant, and those who are against it are either swallowing the propoganda of media outlets who know they could make more money if the BBC is overthrown, or simply don't realise the huge global benefits that the BBC creates. But that's not my AIBU so please don't vote on the basis of whether or not you believe this.

However, it's true that the current licence fee is effectively a regressive tax - it is a significant amount of money to the poorest households, but is a negligible amount for the comfortably off.

A subscription or opt-in version isn't the solution, because the universal accessibility of BBC services needs to be maintained. The BBC does a huge amount more than just make TV programmes and even those who never watch TV are getting a lot of benefit from it.

So here's my idea for creating a progressive replacement for the TV licence - tie it in to the Council Tax, putting it on the same bill and collecting it at the same time.

There can then be bands for TV licence payments according to the Council Tax band of each residence. Families on a low income occupying a high-band property would get relief under the same structure as normal council tax relief, meaning that broadly those of us with larger and more comfortable homes and lifestyles pay more, and those who are on the lowest incomes pay the least.

The table in the attached image shows in the 4th column the revenue that would be generated if 100% of properties liable for council tax paid the new progressive TV licence fee in the 3rd column. The total raised this way would be significantly more than the amount that is currently generated by the TV licence fee - there would be plenty of flex to (a) use some of the exess income for the reasonable costs of administering the new scheme and (b) have a system for exempting some properties, according to whatever criteria are necessary to ensure that all situations where it would be unfair for the TV Fee.to be applied could be given a zero rate.

Data for the number of properties in each Council Tax band got from here: on gov.uk

Please vote - YANBU = "This is a good idea" (you can vote YANBU if you think it's a good idea but would never be implemented because of the machinations of those who just want the BBC dead - that doesn't stop it from being a good idea)

YABU = "This is seriously flawed and I will post below as to why."

NB this is specifically about how to address the regressive nature of current BBC funding whereby the poor and the rich pay the same. If your gripe is with the existence of the BBC at all, please use a different thread for that.

AIBU to propose this idea for replacing the BBC Licence Fee?
OP posts:
purpleme12 · 19/01/2022 11:00

@MorningStarling

I'd rather see a pick 'n' mix subscription service.

Tier 1 - basic access, BBC News, BBC Parliament, website access and limited iPlayer that shows catch-up for seven days, with programmes perhaps being delayed so not available until a month or few after broadcast (except news stuff because you've already paid for that). Perhaps there could be a "BBC catchup" channel like 4seven showing highlights of the week's programming.

Tier 2 - above plus BBC1/2/4/CBBC/Red Button

Tier 3 - above plus full iPlayer which combines the current service plus all available archive programmes, not just the curated selection on ShitBox but everything that has been digitised, with part of the fee going to fund further digitisation.

Tier 1 should be perhaps £40 a year, tier 2 basically the current licence fee cost and tier 3 more expensive at about £200.

It's easy enough to scramble broadcasts even on Freeview so there is no technical reason to prevent this kind of subscription service.

Such a strange suggestion. Tier 3 is more expensive than now!!
girlmom21 · 19/01/2022 10:56

@granny24

Don’t people who say use adverts ever think about things? There is not enough advertising to go round, let alone fund the BBC. Advertising budgets are not endless. The idea of tying it to council taxis basically sound, although need some tweaking.
Where do you get the idea of there not being enough advertising to go around?

Budgets aren't endless but if you had any idea how much companies do pay, you'd know there's plenty of advertising enough to keep the BBC afloat.

mrsm43s · 19/01/2022 10:56

@GreenWhiteViolet

YABU, because I think your first paragraph is utterly wrong and so can't use it as an accepted premise for the rest of the post. There's no need for 'universal accessibility'. Those who like watching the BBC and think it's fantastic can subscribe to it. Those who never watch it (or indeed, never watch TV at all, under your council tax system) should not be forced to subsidise them. If there are enough people in the first category, it'll thrive. If not, it clearly wasn't worth propping up.
^^

This.

I could live quite happily without the BBC or any of its services.

MorningStarling · 19/01/2022 10:55

I'd rather see a pick 'n' mix subscription service.

Tier 1 - basic access, BBC News, BBC Parliament, website access and limited iPlayer that shows catch-up for seven days, with programmes perhaps being delayed so not available until a month or few after broadcast (except news stuff because you've already paid for that). Perhaps there could be a "BBC catchup" channel like 4seven showing highlights of the week's programming.

Tier 2 - above plus BBC1/2/4/CBBC/Red Button

Tier 3 - above plus full iPlayer which combines the current service plus all available archive programmes, not just the curated selection on ShitBox but everything that has been digitised, with part of the fee going to fund further digitisation.

Tier 1 should be perhaps £40 a year, tier 2 basically the current licence fee cost and tier 3 more expensive at about £200.

It's easy enough to scramble broadcasts even on Freeview so there is no technical reason to prevent this kind of subscription service.

SilverDragonfly1 · 19/01/2022 10:47

That's a heck of a jump between B and C (and again between A and B despite them both being single figures). What's the thinking there?

EmmaH2022 · 19/01/2022 10:47

@stitchmaker85

No thanks, I don't watch TV so don't need a TV license but under these rules I'd be forced to pay for it lumped in with council tax
This I don't pay the licence now, legally, because I don't use the services so filled in the relevant paperwork

Your suggestion is literally making it the law to pay the licence if you don't use it.

I live alone, and Council Tax doesn't reflect that either fully either .

You've actually come up with a worse model than the one we have.

And if you think the BBC has "global benefits" what else do you want us to pay for, on that basis? Bizarre.

Narutocrazyfox · 19/01/2022 10:47

I really don't understand why anyone pays it. I stopped watching any kind of live TV a while ago, and stopped paying for the TV licence. I was warned (threatened...?) someone would come round and check but as yet no one has. I'm not sure the BBC could create any content I'd deem to be worth that amount of money.

Also OP linking it yo the council tax banding is a terrible idea. Whilst I'm certainly not against the idea of those on lower incomes paying less, the squeeze on those in the middle would be deeply unpopular.

granny24 · 19/01/2022 10:45

Don’t people who say use adverts ever think about things? There is not enough advertising to go round, let alone fund the BBC. Advertising budgets are not endless. The idea of tying it to council taxis basically sound, although need some tweaking.

GreenWhiteViolet · 19/01/2022 10:45

YABU, because I think your first paragraph is utterly wrong and so can't use it as an accepted premise for the rest of the post. There's no need for 'universal accessibility'. Those who like watching the BBC and think it's fantastic can subscribe to it. Those who never watch it (or indeed, never watch TV at all, under your council tax system) should not be forced to subsidise them. If there are enough people in the first category, it'll thrive. If not, it clearly wasn't worth propping up.

purpleme12 · 19/01/2022 10:44

But they will never please everyone!
There will always be people out there who aren't bothered about watching BBC just like there will be people who aren't bothered about other channels!
It's unrealistic to expect them to produce things that appeal to everyone

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 19/01/2022 10:43

A subscription or opt-in version isn't the solution, because the universal accessibility of BBC services needs to be maintained.
Why?

The BBC does a huge amount more than just make TV programmes and even those who never watch TV are getting a lot of benefit from it.
Could you elaborate on these "benefits" we're all getting OP?

RandomLondoner · 19/01/2022 10:39

No, if it continues it needs to be a simple opt in monthly subscription like Amazon/Netflix. Stop and start when you want, and you can't watch without it.

That's not the same thing though. The point of the BBC should be to bind the nation together with a common experience, that doesn't work if not everyone shares the experience. (I admit it's sort of failing at its job at the moment, because it doesn't produce anything that everyone wants to watch. Maybe what I want from it is no longer possible, in that case the BBC doesn't need to exist, even for subscribers. That doesn't mean abolish it, just that we don't have to discuss it, any more than we discuss whether Disney channel should exist.)

Whammyyammy · 19/01/2022 10:38

I don't understand the love for this biased broadcaster of repeats and Eastenders. If you want to continue to support this shambles that stick by Jimmy Saville and Rolf Harris, that's fine, but the ones of of us that don't shouldn't be forced.
I use Spotify a lot, does that mean everyone else should be forced to pay for it too?

RandomLondoner · 19/01/2022 10:34

I think it would be simplest to have it as a levy/tax on broadband revenues. (Not just broadband, the data part of mobile revenue as well.)

I do think it's a good idea for everyone to pay, so there is no longer an option to opt out. But there needs to be monitoring to make sure everyone is getting some value out of it, so the BBC actively works out who is not using it, and starts producing something that appeals to those people.

Chely · 19/01/2022 10:32

I think people are just fed up of the BBC taking the piss with how they spend the money we have to pay them.

110APiccadilly · 19/01/2022 10:30

Umm, general taxation. I imagine herbal taxation would be a whole different thing!

110APiccadilly · 19/01/2022 10:29

I would also add that I think TV is a luxury. It's a good idea to let people stop spending money on luxuries if they want to. In fact, it's downright cruel to make other people pay for your chosen luxury through council tax, even if they don't have to pay much.

I would support the idea of funding a very small part of the BBC through herbal taxation (primarily news services). But do you really think everyone should be forced to pay for The Apprentice? Or Strictly?

PlanktonsComputerWife · 19/01/2022 10:28

No way. I don't watch British TV and don't want to be charged for it through council taxes. It annoys me enough having to pay money to the council for the police force who have allowed my family member's killer to still be on the streets. (They also stood around in the local park last year while a mob hacked someone's leg off.)

Being forced to pay for Eastenders and Homes under the Hammer would tip me over the edge!

Whammyyammy · 19/01/2022 10:28

Ot we could just abolish it. If you don't watch or want sky, you're not forced to pay it. If you don't watch Netflix, you're not forced to pay it. If you don't watch Disney +, you're it forced.....

However, the BBC.... although I stopped paying years ago and just bin the letters. BBC is outdated and so is the licence fee/tax. .. both need to go

MichelleScarn · 19/01/2022 10:25

@Shitfuckcommaetc

Squeezed middle once again
Yep, as ever!
ginghamstarfish · 19/01/2022 10:25

No, if it continues it needs to be a simple opt in monthly subscription like Amazon/Netflix. Stop and start when you want, and you can't watch without it. We don't watch much TV, so have a month with Amazon, then a month with Netflix, and so on, easy to cancel/renew, and we only need one of them at a time. When we decided to cancel the licence some years back we realised how complicated they deliberately made it, some months paid in advance, but on cancellation however they said they were not able to give refunds for anything less than a full quarter. Thieving bastards. It's an anachronism and well past time it was done away with.

110APiccadilly · 19/01/2022 10:23

Council tax can be pretty regressive though, particularly for renters.

I'd prefer a subscription model, but if you're going to insist everyone has to pay, just take it out of general taxation.

purpleme12 · 19/01/2022 10:23

@girlmom21

Why can't the BBC just allow adverts like ITV do and pay for it that way?
Agree Would rather this I do watch BBC and so does my child so I wouldn't want to lose it personally
girlmom21 · 19/01/2022 10:22

So pensioners who now have to pay tv license and may have a decent house but a low income would now have to pay even more for their tv license?

Very good point.
Work hard all your life. Pay off your massive mortgage. Get a reduction in council tax.

Get screwed over by having to pay your own massive care costs, huge hikes in fuel and now get screwed over by an extortionate TV license too.

stitchmaker85 · 19/01/2022 10:21

No thanks, I don't watch TV so don't need a TV license but under these rules I'd be forced to pay for it lumped in with council tax

Swipe left for the next trending thread