Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to propose this idea for replacing the BBC Licence Fee?

158 replies

BuanoKubiamVej · 19/01/2022 10:10

The BBC is brilliant, and those who are against it are either swallowing the propoganda of media outlets who know they could make more money if the BBC is overthrown, or simply don't realise the huge global benefits that the BBC creates. But that's not my AIBU so please don't vote on the basis of whether or not you believe this.

However, it's true that the current licence fee is effectively a regressive tax - it is a significant amount of money to the poorest households, but is a negligible amount for the comfortably off.

A subscription or opt-in version isn't the solution, because the universal accessibility of BBC services needs to be maintained. The BBC does a huge amount more than just make TV programmes and even those who never watch TV are getting a lot of benefit from it.

So here's my idea for creating a progressive replacement for the TV licence - tie it in to the Council Tax, putting it on the same bill and collecting it at the same time.

There can then be bands for TV licence payments according to the Council Tax band of each residence. Families on a low income occupying a high-band property would get relief under the same structure as normal council tax relief, meaning that broadly those of us with larger and more comfortable homes and lifestyles pay more, and those who are on the lowest incomes pay the least.

The table in the attached image shows in the 4th column the revenue that would be generated if 100% of properties liable for council tax paid the new progressive TV licence fee in the 3rd column. The total raised this way would be significantly more than the amount that is currently generated by the TV licence fee - there would be plenty of flex to (a) use some of the exess income for the reasonable costs of administering the new scheme and (b) have a system for exempting some properties, according to whatever criteria are necessary to ensure that all situations where it would be unfair for the TV Fee.to be applied could be given a zero rate.

Data for the number of properties in each Council Tax band got from here: on gov.uk

Please vote - YANBU = "This is a good idea" (you can vote YANBU if you think it's a good idea but would never be implemented because of the machinations of those who just want the BBC dead - that doesn't stop it from being a good idea)

YABU = "This is seriously flawed and I will post below as to why."

NB this is specifically about how to address the regressive nature of current BBC funding whereby the poor and the rich pay the same. If your gripe is with the existence of the BBC at all, please use a different thread for that.

AIBU to propose this idea for replacing the BBC Licence Fee?
OP posts:
Alayalaya · 19/01/2022 12:42

Council tax is already a faulty system. It assumes the occupiers of expensive houses are rich and can afford to pay more tax, which isn’t always the case! Lots of high earners live alone in small cheap properties, and lots of big families bankrupt themselves to afford expensive houses that offer the space they need. I inherited my house and certainly couldn’t afford to buy it, my household income is very low and I’m sick of being treated like I have loads of money just because I live in an expensive house.

HepzibahGreen · 19/01/2022 12:40

No. I watch BBC a lot. I think the dramas, the nature programmes, science programmes, Bitesize learning, news- are good quality and I like that there’s no adverts. I can’t imagine only watching Netflix. Netflix shows me the same sort of stuff I have watched before, so I stay in my comfort zone which makes my brain lazy!
However, linking to council tax is unfair as you can be renting a Band D place and still be poor. I have always thought the licence fee should be phased though, along with taxes, so if you earn under 20 k or whatever as a household it should be free.

Snugglepumpkin · 19/01/2022 12:37

No it's an awful idea.

There should never be a compulsion to pay for the bloated & bad value BBC - simply scrapping the ability to send people to prison for non payment would save MILLIONS if not more a year on prison costs alone as almost third of all women prisoners are there for not paying for a TV licence.
That's a lot of families no longer split up due to the BBC wanting their slice, some of those children having to be placed in care, or placed with abusive ex partners, pregnant women risking their lives & their babies lives whilst in prison over £150.

Why would it be better if they were in prison for £26?
Food bank users don't have a spare 50p a week.

There is no model which includes the TV licence being compulsory that is good.

Lemonysnicker · 19/01/2022 12:25

It’s not a terrible idea, but does seem a bit unfair. A lone person with a great income might own a small home in a low band.
While a large family on a low income might rent a home in a higher band.

ByGrabtharsHammerWhatASavings · 19/01/2022 11:59

I agree with everyone else I'm afraid OP, your suggestion assumes that everyone not only is using the BBC but also has to use the BBC atm. They don't. I've never had a TV license because it's only in the last 3 years that I've actually had a TV, and even now the only thing we use it for is watching Netflix occasionally. I don't agree with dismantling the BBC, although I would strongly support changes to how they enforce the license fee, but I also don't understand why so many people are acting like it's compulsory to have a TV license. If you don't like the content then you should be able to choose not to pay for it, just like any other optional service. Rolling it up in council tax is completely absurd.

SeeminglyOblivious · 19/01/2022 11:40

No.

Council Tax bands are already ridiculously archaic and unfair. That system itself needs a complete overhaul before you start adding anything else on it.

LuckyMeISeeGhosts · 19/01/2022 11:35

Fuck that.

We never watch live TV in this house, so I won't be paying extra council tax so anyone else can.

TyrannysaurusXXrightshoarder · 19/01/2022 11:35

No. The licence fee is opt in now. In as as you don’t have to pay it if you don’t use the content - the fact you have to periodically ‘prove’ that and the intrusive means by which the BBC are allowed to operate that is a different matter however. How would you opt out of you don’t use the content if it was tied to your council tax? And who would administer the new way of collecting/checking etc? What changes to the IT systems of local authorities would have to be made, and what cost? If you propose local councils would then be responsible for all of that they would need more money, their finances are already ridiculously stretched. How would you raise the money? Make the licence fee more expensive? No, not a viable proposal.

purpleme12 · 19/01/2022 11:31

I'd fisher having to pay for adverts!
While I'm sure we'd all other no adverts in an ideal world
They're not that much of an inconvenience

AwaitingSueGraysInvestigation · 19/01/2022 11:30

I think this whole thing is a great big raspberry being blown by the government to deflect from Johnson's current problems, and will be reasonably surprised if it actually happens.

AwaitingSueGraysInvestigation · 19/01/2022 11:29

I personally don't think the traditional 'ad break' advertising model is a goer either. I work in this industry; ad revenues from 'traditional' TV advertising have been dropping massively for a while now. People simply don't want to sit through four minutes of people flogging yoghurt, discount sofas and aspirational Hyundais when they're watching TV.

Besides, the BBC has all kinds of rules around impartiality which aren't going to go away just because the licence fee does, and are incompatible with an advertiser-funded model.

AwaitingSueGraysInvestigation · 19/01/2022 11:26

Makes no sense. The amount of BBC services you use has nothing to do with the size of your house or its value.

Asdf12345 · 19/01/2022 11:20

I’m against this. We don’t pay as it’s terrible value for money at £150 or whatever it is at present and don’t use the services. There is no way in hell we would pay more than twice that when better value content is available elsewhere at a far more competitive price.

Let the consumer pay for what they value, for us paying for services we neither want or use won’t change with an increase in price, but will put off some marginal cases who currently do pay.

If people are spending hours a day using the services they could reasonably be expected the value it at the cost of a pint each week, if not the market has provided a range of other options at different price points. Why force consumers to chose one particular product if it’s not what the market wants?

Netflix 5.99 a month
Amazon 7.99 a month
Apple TV 4.99 a month
BBC 13.25 a month
ITV online free
Channel 4 online free
Channel 5 free
Many many free web radio stations and other video services
Sky 36+ a month
Etc

FudgeSundae · 19/01/2022 11:19

I think the problem with the license fee is that it’s unclear if it’s a payment for services or a tax.

If it’s a payment for services, you should be able to opt out without threatening letters that people are going to come round to your home and check (imagine netflix coming round to check you aren’t borrowing someone’s password, I mean wtf).

Most of the people who are pro license fee say that it has wider benefits. 7% is on the world service, which by definition is used by people who don’t pay the license fee. Another 23% is for online and radio, which you can use if you pay the fee or not. This is more like a tax - we as a society think these are good things to pay for.

Unfortunately if it’s a tax it’s not working well. It’s completely undemocratic and it’s unclear who controls it. It also has ridiculous costs - 6% in collection (and pension deficit) costs. For context HMRC’s collection cost is about 0.5%.

So OP, I think it’s sensible to acknowledge that it is a tax, put it firmly under the control of the elected representatives, and save collection costs by tying it to another payment. You’d have to fight about the amounts but it’s not a bad idea.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 19/01/2022 11:16

what's the problem with adverts anyway? You can fast-forward through them if you prerecord, even just pause when something begins, go and do the bins and the washing up, then come back, play, and FF as necessary.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 19/01/2022 11:13

We don’t watch much bbc but we are happy enough paying the licence

But we have a higher tax band house and there is no way dh will pay more than we do now

I think its going to have to be some sort of subscription service or adverts unfortunately

kittensinthekitchen · 19/01/2022 11:12

No.

I don't have a TV licence because I don't use their chargeable services. I'm not going to start paying for one with my council tax because I don't use their chargeable services.

If you want to use them, you pay.

TedOnTheBed · 19/01/2022 11:09

So you want to hit first time buyers in new builds? The council tax banding needs to be changed anyway in my opinion because the older house now worth over 1 million in the Surrey area I live in are band A, which makes no sense.

favouritecardigan · 19/01/2022 11:09

@Whammyyammy

I don't understand the love for this biased broadcaster of repeats and Eastenders. If you want to continue to support this shambles that stick by Jimmy Saville and Rolf Harris, that's fine, but the ones of of us that don't shouldn't be forced. I use Spotify a lot, does that mean everyone else should be forced to pay for it too?
Completely agree with this. Cancelled mine a few years ago when the Savile coverup came to light. Quite happy with Netflix and catchup on itv hub now and again. Why should we be forced to pay for these smug, self-satisfied arseholes?
110APiccadilly · 19/01/2022 11:07

@TrickorTreacle Maybe I'm biased because I've not had one for most of my life, but I don't see how you can call it a necessity really.

SouthOfFrance · 19/01/2022 11:07

Love the fact that someone thinks there wouldn't be enough advertising interest to make advertising viable Confused

KiloWhat · 19/01/2022 11:07

No you'll just get rich people complaining about subsidising the poor.

Tanith · 19/01/2022 11:07

"Why can't the BBC just allow adverts like ITV do and pay for it that way?"

It leaves them vulnerable to boycotts and market forces.
Look at how Mumsnet is often targeted by activists contacting their advertisers.

SouthOfFrance · 19/01/2022 11:05

I think a tier system would be the best option. Perhaps a free section with news, radio, and big important national event coverage, and children's programming. Maybe some educational stuff like the science and environment items, the arts etc.

Then another tier which is paid for with the entertainment. This would subsidise the free items. I think it would also be worth reviewing whether adverts could be allowed in this tier, and there would also be income generated from worldwide sales of their content.

TrickorTreacle · 19/01/2022 11:02

@110APiccadilly

I would also add that I think TV is a luxury. It's a good idea to let people stop spending money on luxuries if they want to. In fact, it's downright cruel to make other people pay for your chosen luxury through council tax, even if they don't have to pay much.

I would support the idea of funding a very small part of the BBC through herbal taxation (primarily news services). But do you really think everyone should be forced to pay for The Apprentice? Or Strictly?

Nearly everyone has a TV, so I couldn't call it a luxury. Even prisons with standard status have a TV in their room.

Now if you said a Playstation, then yes I would agree with you. The only prisoners that have access to one are those with enhanced status. You have to work for it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread