Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to propose this idea for replacing the BBC Licence Fee?

158 replies

BuanoKubiamVej · 19/01/2022 10:10

The BBC is brilliant, and those who are against it are either swallowing the propoganda of media outlets who know they could make more money if the BBC is overthrown, or simply don't realise the huge global benefits that the BBC creates. But that's not my AIBU so please don't vote on the basis of whether or not you believe this.

However, it's true that the current licence fee is effectively a regressive tax - it is a significant amount of money to the poorest households, but is a negligible amount for the comfortably off.

A subscription or opt-in version isn't the solution, because the universal accessibility of BBC services needs to be maintained. The BBC does a huge amount more than just make TV programmes and even those who never watch TV are getting a lot of benefit from it.

So here's my idea for creating a progressive replacement for the TV licence - tie it in to the Council Tax, putting it on the same bill and collecting it at the same time.

There can then be bands for TV licence payments according to the Council Tax band of each residence. Families on a low income occupying a high-band property would get relief under the same structure as normal council tax relief, meaning that broadly those of us with larger and more comfortable homes and lifestyles pay more, and those who are on the lowest incomes pay the least.

The table in the attached image shows in the 4th column the revenue that would be generated if 100% of properties liable for council tax paid the new progressive TV licence fee in the 3rd column. The total raised this way would be significantly more than the amount that is currently generated by the TV licence fee - there would be plenty of flex to (a) use some of the exess income for the reasonable costs of administering the new scheme and (b) have a system for exempting some properties, according to whatever criteria are necessary to ensure that all situations where it would be unfair for the TV Fee.to be applied could be given a zero rate.

Data for the number of properties in each Council Tax band got from here: on gov.uk

Please vote - YANBU = "This is a good idea" (you can vote YANBU if you think it's a good idea but would never be implemented because of the machinations of those who just want the BBC dead - that doesn't stop it from being a good idea)

YABU = "This is seriously flawed and I will post below as to why."

NB this is specifically about how to address the regressive nature of current BBC funding whereby the poor and the rich pay the same. If your gripe is with the existence of the BBC at all, please use a different thread for that.

AIBU to propose this idea for replacing the BBC Licence Fee?
OP posts:
girlmom21 · 19/01/2022 16:23

@Hont1986

Better idea: scrap the license fee entirely and fund it through normal tax. The Track and Trace system cost £22 billion, we can't find £3 billion for the BBC budget?
But then taxes rise and it's still the lower and mid-level earners who are most impacted, and it still means everyone's paying for a service that not everyone uses.
lonelyapple · 19/01/2022 16:23

No. Just make it subscription and pay it yourself OP. Why should other people subsidise your likes! I think Netflix is great but I don't expect you to pay towards it because I like it. Why do people who love the BBC not want to pay for it themselves and expect others who don't like it/don't watch to sub them? Just make it subscription only and if it's as popular as all the BBC employees make out then it will be fine.

Broblem · 19/01/2022 16:21

I used to resent the license (and, by the time i emigrated from the UK, didn’t actually need one and stopped paying).

Having now lived in the US for a few years, I’ve completely flipped. If I was in the UK now, I’d pay for the license even if I didn’t need it, it’s such a social good.

Hont1986 · 19/01/2022 16:19

Better idea: scrap the license fee entirely and fund it through normal tax. The Track and Trace system cost £22 billion, we can't find £3 billion for the BBC budget?

PlanktonsComputerWife · 19/01/2022 16:18

I mean it's quite a lovely map, but it's not what you would call up-to-date.

AIBU to propose this idea for replacing the BBC Licence Fee?
PlanktonsComputerWife · 19/01/2022 16:13

Soft power projection, World Service.

I do believe a certain sun has set.

girlmom21 · 19/01/2022 16:11

Advertising is not a solution. The private businesses that pay for advertising are not going to suddenly increase their advertising budget by £250million a year

They don't need to increase their budget. They'd stop advertising on channels like Gold and Watch. They'd happily stop advertising across 5 lesser watched channels for a prime time spot on BBC One.

The World Cup finals half time advertising spots are about £500,000 for 20 seconds.

BuanoKubiamVej · 19/01/2022 16:05

Thanks @VeniVidiWeeWee that's a great few examples, but some people don't seem to be able to cope with the idea that this thread is specifically for pondering how to fairly dubd the bbc in the context of accepting that it is a genuine public good. Anyone who takes issue with that concept is welcome to start a different thread on that topic, not derail this one. Its not lazy to refuse to be derailed onto an entirely different question.

Advertising is not a solution. The private businesses that pay for advertising are not going to suddenly increase their advertising budget by £250million a year to replace the funding lost from licence fees, any funding the bbc got from advertising would just be taking money away from the existing commercial broadcasters. The money does need to come from the general public somehow. We need a hook to identify how to fairly apportion the cost among the public which I would like to be based on something that is proportional to the level of luxury in general in a household lifestyle. I recognise that council tax isn't a good candidate for that but I don't think income tax does the job either as I've seen too many people who are allegedly on the breadline for income but yet manage to drive expensive cars and have big houses and nice holidays due to clever accounting.

The idea of a tax on broadband provision might work, possibly. Might also need to apply to unlimited data mobile plans.

OP posts:
GrolliffetheDragon · 19/01/2022 16:00

@Alayalaya

‘ You have assets, even if you don't have cash. You could sell the house and downsize if you really think you're so poor in your big house.’

If we downsized then we’d be cramped. The space is worth more than a chunk of cash that will be quickly spent. We do without other things to afford the upkeep of the house. My point is that a big house doesn’t correlate to a higher income or more disposable income. Also some people (not me personally) are benefits claimants so if they downsized the government would just stop their benefits until they spent the money from downsizing. It’s not that simple.

Agreed, I'm in a similar situation. It's a pretty average semi though, and moving anywhere cheaper would bring its own raft of problems - my transport costs here are practically zero for example, and I can fit work round school drop offs for DS - it's also an excellent school, so I'd rather not move him.

And the sort of places where we'd have to move, any money left over would probably have to be spent doing work on the house to get it acceptable.

As for the OP - I couldn't afford the amount added to the Council Tax right now, and certainly not if the proposed 7% CT rise goes ahead alongside the looming increases in gas & electric. I'm already sitting here bundled up in a duvet and blankets to avoid having the heating on for more than an hour and a half a day.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 19/01/2022 15:42

What benefits other than tv?

Serious journalism, mainly on radio 4.

World class orchestra and choirs. The Proms.

New comedy commissions, new writers competitions.

Soft power projection, World Service.

Chloemol · 19/01/2022 15:29

Nope. I end up paying more when I can only just about afford to live now

There is no reason at all they can’t obtain sponsorship via commercials, sponsorship of programmes or anything else just like ITV, Channel 4 etc. And the ‘universal accessibility of BBC services’ can be maintained

And your response to the question @daimbarsatemydogsbone is just lazy as smacks of not being able to answer which makes your question void

Alayalaya · 19/01/2022 14:40

‘ You have assets, even if you don't have cash. You could sell the house and downsize if you really think you're so poor in your big house.’

If we downsized then we’d be cramped. The space is worth more than a chunk of cash that will be quickly spent. We do without other things to afford the upkeep of the house. My point is that a big house doesn’t correlate to a higher income or more disposable income. Also some people (not me personally) are benefits claimants so if they downsized the government would just stop their benefits until they spent the money from downsizing. It’s not that simple.

twosticksandanapple · 19/01/2022 14:23

I think it needs to be slimmed down. Elements which are for the 'good of the nation' e.g. world service (important reputational benefit) or educational value (e.g BBC Bitesize) should come out of general taxation. Drama, comedy etc needs to be commercially funded.

Council tax is highly regressive and needs reform so should not have additional elements included under it.

Sartre · 19/01/2022 13:56

Bonkers. The main issue is the fact lots of people don’t watch/listen to BBC content yet they’re still forced to pay for it. My DC like CBeebies and I like radio 4 so I pay for it but it’s expensive compared to Netflix and prime. It should just be an optional subscription service.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 19/01/2022 13:55

@BuanoKubiamVej
So you make an assertion and the aren't prepared to offer even a single suggestion in support of it?
YABVU.

Butchyrestingface · 19/01/2022 13:52

@BuanoKubiamVej You haven't even touched on why you think people who don't use the BBC's services should pay for it in their council tax - thus making them WORSE off than they are currently.

girlmom21 · 19/01/2022 13:44

I did actually address that in my OP, there is plenty of flex in the system for there to be numerous exemptions for those on a lower income to pay less or nothing if the system places them in a band they can't easily afford.

But these exemptions never work well enough to help everybody.

It's always the people who earn slightly too much who suffer most.

BuanoKubiamVej · 19/01/2022 13:23

[quote daimbarsatemydogsbone]@BuanoKubiamVej

The BBC does a huge amount more than just make TV programmes and even those who never watch TV are getting a lot of benefit from it.
Please tell us about these benefits OP?[/quote]
Nope.

I specifically laid out in the OP that this thread is specifically about how to fairly fund the BBC given that it is a good thing. If you want to snipe about the BBC then this isn't the thread for that, and I have no intention of engaging in that debate. not my job.

Thanks to those who have contributed thoughtfully. I don't think I had appreciated the extent to which the Council Tax banding system is urgently in need of an overhaul - I thought it was basically an existing reasonably good measure of how comfortable a lifestyle one has, with basic and modest homes generally being band A and luxurious mansions being band H and everything else being categorised evenly along the scale. But if that's not the case then yes this idea won't work until the council tax scale is fixed. It should be that the average family in a fairly bog-standard home and with an average sort of income pay about the same as now, but there are steep discounts for the least well off and a gradual hike up for those who enjoy more comfortable lifestyles for whom the extra is relatively negligible.

But the various objections on the basis of specific examples where someone is a low income but in a higher band property for good reasons - I did actually address that in my OP, there is plenty of flex in the system for there to be numerous exemptions for those on a lower income to pay less or nothing if the system places them in a band they can't easily afford.

OP posts:
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 19/01/2022 13:07

@BuanoKubiamVej

The BBC does a huge amount more than just make TV programmes and even those who never watch TV are getting a lot of benefit from it.
Please tell us about these benefits OP?

Darley368 · 19/01/2022 13:03

No thanks. I have not watched live TV for years. I boycotted the BBC when all the information started to emerge about the regressive TV licence and how prosecutions tend to unfairly impact on women. It has not been a loss.

A subscription model is the only fair route. They could ditch some of the channels and radio stations too.

Bazinga007 · 19/01/2022 13:02

Awful idea, why would I want to pay even more money for something that I don't use.

Gwenhwyfar · 19/01/2022 13:01

@Lillyhatesjaz

I think that if it is to continue as a public broadcasting service it should be funded out of income tax. Not council tax which is for local authorities. If it is to be paid by licence or subscription I am happy to pay for the bbc as I watch it. I think that people shouldn't automatically get it free due to age as some older people have a lot of money and some young people have little money and often don't even watch it.
The problem with that is people who don't use it isn't it? I know people on social media have been saying thinks like 'I don't have children, but pay for education, I'm not ill, but pay for health', but TV really isn't the same kind of thing.
Gwenhwyfar · 19/01/2022 12:59

@Alayalaya

Council tax is already a faulty system. It assumes the occupiers of expensive houses are rich and can afford to pay more tax, which isn’t always the case! Lots of high earners live alone in small cheap properties, and lots of big families bankrupt themselves to afford expensive houses that offer the space they need. I inherited my house and certainly couldn’t afford to buy it, my household income is very low and I’m sick of being treated like I have loads of money just because I live in an expensive house.
You have assets, even if you don't have cash. You could sell the house and downsize if you really think you're so poor in your big house.
Lillyhatesjaz · 19/01/2022 12:59

I think that if it is to continue as a public broadcasting service it should be funded out of income tax. Not council tax which is for local authorities.
If it is to be paid by licence or subscription I am happy to pay for the bbc as I watch it. I think that people shouldn't automatically get it free due to age as some older people have a lot of money and some young people have little money and often don't even watch it.

Gwenhwyfar · 19/01/2022 12:49

@Narutocrazyfox

I really don't understand why anyone pays it. I stopped watching any kind of live TV a while ago, and stopped paying for the TV licence. I was warned (threatened...?) someone would come round and check but as yet no one has. I'm not sure the BBC could create any content I'd deem to be worth that amount of money.

Also OP linking it yo the council tax banding is a terrible idea. Whilst I'm certainly not against the idea of those on lower incomes paying less, the squeeze on those in the middle would be deeply unpopular.

You have to pay for it to watch i player now, not just live TV. I only had a laptop, but still paid to access i player.
Swipe left for the next trending thread