Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to propose this idea for replacing the BBC Licence Fee?

158 replies

BuanoKubiamVej · 19/01/2022 10:10

The BBC is brilliant, and those who are against it are either swallowing the propoganda of media outlets who know they could make more money if the BBC is overthrown, or simply don't realise the huge global benefits that the BBC creates. But that's not my AIBU so please don't vote on the basis of whether or not you believe this.

However, it's true that the current licence fee is effectively a regressive tax - it is a significant amount of money to the poorest households, but is a negligible amount for the comfortably off.

A subscription or opt-in version isn't the solution, because the universal accessibility of BBC services needs to be maintained. The BBC does a huge amount more than just make TV programmes and even those who never watch TV are getting a lot of benefit from it.

So here's my idea for creating a progressive replacement for the TV licence - tie it in to the Council Tax, putting it on the same bill and collecting it at the same time.

There can then be bands for TV licence payments according to the Council Tax band of each residence. Families on a low income occupying a high-band property would get relief under the same structure as normal council tax relief, meaning that broadly those of us with larger and more comfortable homes and lifestyles pay more, and those who are on the lowest incomes pay the least.

The table in the attached image shows in the 4th column the revenue that would be generated if 100% of properties liable for council tax paid the new progressive TV licence fee in the 3rd column. The total raised this way would be significantly more than the amount that is currently generated by the TV licence fee - there would be plenty of flex to (a) use some of the exess income for the reasonable costs of administering the new scheme and (b) have a system for exempting some properties, according to whatever criteria are necessary to ensure that all situations where it would be unfair for the TV Fee.to be applied could be given a zero rate.

Data for the number of properties in each Council Tax band got from here: on gov.uk

Please vote - YANBU = "This is a good idea" (you can vote YANBU if you think it's a good idea but would never be implemented because of the machinations of those who just want the BBC dead - that doesn't stop it from being a good idea)

YABU = "This is seriously flawed and I will post below as to why."

NB this is specifically about how to address the regressive nature of current BBC funding whereby the poor and the rich pay the same. If your gripe is with the existence of the BBC at all, please use a different thread for that.

AIBU to propose this idea for replacing the BBC Licence Fee?
OP posts:
megletthesecond · 19/01/2022 19:44

I sort of agree.
I don't want adverts on BBC. Horrible things.

lljkk · 19/01/2022 19:39

German public service broadcaster charge system is similar to what OP suggests, afaik.

EddieVeddersfoxymop · 19/01/2022 19:08

Another means tested thing for the squeezed middle. We can't give much more.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 19/01/2022 18:52

OP is like one of those crappy sales videos

"Would you like it in the blue or the green" - brook no argument with the assumed premise you want to buy.

Voting should have said only vote if you love the BBC.

EmmaH2022 · 19/01/2022 18:47

Broblem

Thanks, that's interesting. I don't really watch news so I admit I am not the person to give comparisons. I wonder if watching BBC news and GB news is two separate realities?

However, when I stopped having a TV licence I did have a sense the BBC had a particular agenda.

Some of what I have seen since then (I care for mum so sometimes see it when there) has made me glad I'm not bothering with live TV and BBC.

Mum almost stopped watching news the last two years because, she tells me, there's been so much hysterical non factual stuff. She watches PMQs religiously though.

The issue of compulsory payment is different again.

Also, there's lots of stuff that some would consider a public good, from Fulbright scholarships to the English National Ballet. I'd not be happy with a £150 bill for those either and I see the BBC as similar.

Haven't been to America for ten years so I don't know how their news has changed but I used to like the format of state news first, national news second and international news next.

cptartapp · 19/01/2022 18:39

We pay two bands higher council tax than next door. Only because we bought the house after it had been extended by previous owners (so it was then rebanded) and they extended theirs themselves and have stayed out (so it wasn't).
We already pay more council tax for the same services. I don't see why we should pay more for the TV licence as well.

AtomicSquirrel3 · 19/01/2022 18:34

You don't need a TV licence to listen to the radio so that's irrelevant.

pidgefork · 19/01/2022 18:00

YABU. I don't have any desire to watch or support the BBC so do wish to fund it. At all. We cancelled our licence about 10 years and have somehow survived without it. Those that want it can fund it themselves.

cakewench · 19/01/2022 17:50

No thank you. I already barely watch BBC aside from HIGNFY and the odd animal documentary. I've already been considering dropping it altogether as we're almost never watching broadcast telly and not using iPlayer etc either. The only reason I've kept paying is because I generally appreciate the BBC, but in terms of value for money for us personally, we aren't getting the most out of it. Raising the price would cinch it.

(I wouldn't class us as 'rich' but we're in one of the top bands in our East Midlands council area so I'm responding as such. I realise it's all relative, but just because we're relatively better off than some others doesn't mean we want to sink money into more services we aren't using, ourselves.)

Horst · 19/01/2022 17:42

The only way to go is subscribing and or voluntarily donating.

I don’t watch a single bbc Chanel I don’t listen to any radio at all. Why should I have to pay a broadband tax or increased tax at all to fund it?

Hospitals, schools, police, firemen etc are all needed so of cause we pay via tax. Eastenders isn’t needed. Bargain hunt isn’t needed. Dancing isn’t needed. If they cut all the crap that’s not needed you’d be left with the news and educational shows.

Bbc could save themselves a fortune on all those overpaid idiots and maybe more people would actually care about it again.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 19/01/2022 17:40

@EdithWeston

I would not want to see payment for BBC attached to a mandatory tax. The current licensing system - which made non-payment a criminal offence - was bad enough.

Subscription model is the way ahead I think, so people can choose whether they want it and when

And how do you subscribe to a radio channel?
Saucery · 19/01/2022 17:37

Subscription model is the way to go, for me. There seems to be a lot of people who value the BBC’s output enough to pay it. I might even pay it myself if the standard of programmes went up and the salaries of presenters went down.
Being asked to subscribe to Britbox for programmes we’ve already paid for via the licence fee was the last straw for me. Pretty damn cheeky.

EdithWeston · 19/01/2022 17:31

I would not want to see payment for BBC attached to a mandatory tax. The current licensing system - which made non-payment a criminal offence - was bad enough.

Subscription model is the way ahead I think, so people can choose whether they want it and when

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 19/01/2022 17:23

I'm not sure on a solution but I'd hate to lose the bbc. And I'd HATE adverts in the radio!!!!

Biker47 · 19/01/2022 17:20

You think the TV licence is regressive, but you don't think council tax is regressive? lol.

Broblem · 19/01/2022 17:15

I’m less fussed about the entertainment arm, but I imagine people who work in the arts might have stronger opinions than I.

Broblem · 19/01/2022 17:14

I don’t disagree with you, but if that’s the social good of the bbc then it should be held to an extremely high standard. Any hint of bias should be subject to review and amendment.
I think it is held to an extremely high standard (particularly with references to most other news sources).

And for all the accusations people make of bias on behalf of the BBC, most independent media-monitoring organizations consider it to be pretty much down the middle.

FudgeSundae · 19/01/2022 17:11

@Broblem

I'd be interested to hear more about this if you feel like sharing. Sure.

In the US, most people get their news from the major networks (Fox, CNN, MSNBC et al).

I’d say that every one of those networks is inherently more biased than the BBC. Fox is obviously hugely biased towards the American right, and MSNBC to the left. The divide is so stark that it’s almost like the viewerships are living in two completely separate realities. Not only is there no common ground on opinion, but almost none on basic facts. That in turn helps promote a fractured society.

Also, because channels have to compete for viewership (and therefore money), there’s no real incentive to be factual - instead it’s better to tell your audience what they want to hear. Extreme pandering.

And on top of that, the networks all have presenters who are basically celebrities, and deal in opinion as much as they do fact. Yes the networks do try and pretend that there’s a difference between their news output and opinion output, and use that as an excuse to opt out of basic journalistic integrity, but viewers often don’t do well distinguishing between fact and opinion on those channels (and understandably so).

Basically, it’s the difference between news and partisan news-entertainment.

I don’t disagree with you, but if that’s the social good of the bbc then it should be held to an extremely high standard. Any hint of bias should be subject to review and amendment. And any show that costs more than it makes should have to justify how it fits into that mission of social good. I’m thinking strictly, eastenders, bargain hunters, etc. I realise some of these shows make money, but many cost more than they make.
LethargicActress · 19/01/2022 17:07

There’s plenty of good that the BBC does that we’d get along just fine without, but leaving that aside, no. Too many people have the asset but not the income to match the already ever increasing costs, despite working and through no fault of their own.

Broblem · 19/01/2022 17:01

I'd be interested to hear more about this if you feel like sharing.
Sure.

In the US, most people get their news from the major networks (Fox, CNN, MSNBC et al).

I’d say that every one of those networks is inherently more biased than the BBC. Fox is obviously hugely biased towards the American right, and MSNBC to the left. The divide is so stark that it’s almost like the viewerships are living in two completely separate realities. Not only is there no common ground on opinion, but almost none on basic facts. That in turn helps promote a fractured society.

Also, because channels have to compete for viewership (and therefore money), there’s no real incentive to be factual - instead it’s better to tell your audience what they want to hear. Extreme pandering.

And on top of that, the networks all have presenters who are basically celebrities, and deal in opinion as much as they do fact. Yes the networks do try and pretend that there’s a difference between their news output and opinion output, and use that as an excuse to opt out of basic journalistic integrity, but viewers often don’t do well distinguishing between fact and opinion on those channels (and understandably so).

Basically, it’s the difference between news and partisan news-entertainment.

Hont1986 · 19/01/2022 17:00

Everyone keeps saying it's a social good but not elaborating. What do they actually mean? No-one cares about the World Service any more, BBC1 through 3 are full of shite and 95% repeats. I don't use BBC Bitesize and it sounds like something parents should be paying for if they particularly want it. If I needed to find out about road closures and school snow cancellations then I would use the internet, not the local radio. I'm definitely not seeing £160/yr of value.

LuckyMeISeeGhosts · 19/01/2022 16:59

@Hont1986

So cut the military budget 5% to make up for it then, I'm paying for that and I don't use it.
Oh yeah, that's very similar Hmm.
EmmaH2022 · 19/01/2022 16:50

@Broblem

I used to resent the license (and, by the time i emigrated from the UK, didn’t actually need one and stopped paying).

Having now lived in the US for a few years, I’ve completely flipped. If I was in the UK now, I’d pay for the license even if I didn’t need it, it’s such a social good.

I'd be interested to hear more about this if you feel like sharing.
SpilltheTea · 19/01/2022 16:35

There obviously isn't a fair way to force people to pay for the BBC. If you want it, you pay for it. Feel free to donate for the rest of us who don't care.

Hont1986 · 19/01/2022 16:28

So cut the military budget 5% to make up for it then, I'm paying for that and I don't use it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread