Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Montessori is massively overhyped?

231 replies

Sherekhancarolbaskin · 19/01/2022 01:38

Or does it truly have proven pedagogic advantages?

I’m already not a fan of the Waldorf Steiner method at all.

Montessori does seem a lot better to me but after having looked into it a lot of it seems a bit off to me. Besides the fact Maria Montessori did questionable things as a parent herself, abandoning her own son

OP posts:
Kokeshi123 · 19/01/2022 07:57

Montessori is not a legally protected term, I believe, so pretty much any nursery can call themselves Montessori without breaking any laws. They vary a lot.

kirinm · 19/01/2022 07:56

@Marcipex

There’s a nursery near us which calls itself a Montessori. I never questioned it until on a course where there were several actual Montessori teachers who insisted it was not registered and actually a fake Montessori!

How strange that it’s allowed to continue to use the name.

The woman who runs it hates all parents and won’t engage at all.
It’s quite popular as people think it’s a real Montessori, as I did.

Which area of the UK is this? There have been two references to the women running the nurseries hating all parents which makes me think it's the one near me!
reluctantbrit · 19/01/2022 07:56

With lots of these theories, it always depends on how it is delivered.

We looked at a Montesorri nursery (for a 1 year old) and found the idea too much for a young baby. Our friend's DS went to one from 2 1/2, more a pre-school then nursery, and had a great time as it wasn't childcare but more early learning.

DD would have hated a Montesorri primary school, she thrives on routines (discovered later that she is on the ADHD spectrum) so the whole independent decision what to learn would have been a disaster for her.

I think it is great that it becomes more mainstream so parents have a choice. Not all children fit the same style of teaching.

Steiner is a totally different ideology and after spending 1/2 day in a Steiner Kindergarten/primary school when I did Sociology in 6th form, I knew I wouldn't ever touch that concept.

Marcipex · 19/01/2022 07:53

There’s a nursery near us which calls itself a Montessori. I never questioned it until on a course where there were several actual Montessori teachers who insisted it was not registered and actually a fake Montessori!

How strange that it’s allowed to continue to use the name.

The woman who runs it hates all parents and won’t engage at all.
It’s quite popular as people think it’s a real Montessori, as I did.

HardbackWriter · 19/01/2022 07:53

Lots of children don't really choose things they find hard or boring (drawing and pre writing skills in particular are not popular with some children) if there's anything else on offer. Not all children are naturally eager for knowledge/learning across the board, its limited to their areas of interest. Lots will happily at age 3 or 4 engage in quite repetitive play from which they don't acquire many new skills. To get more from that needs an adult on hand to help/encourage them to extend their play. It can work in a nursery with 6 or 8 kids per adult, in a reception class with 30 kids and only 2 adults, there isnt enough adult contact to get maximum benefit from it.

This is really interesting to hear you say this - DS1 goes to a nursery that isn't branded as Montessori but has an ethos very, very much like people are describing here as Montessori. He pretty much never chooses to do the art activities and is particularly reluctant to draw (he's keener on painting) - he actually rarely seems to choose anything indoors at nursery! He does paint and draw with me at home (where it isn't one of a range of options he's presented with) but he seems to be quite behind with drawing and pen skills. I don't know whether to just agree that he'll be interested when he's interested or whether he needs more of a push - he has a tendency to only like to do things if he can do them well (which is also one of my own worst traits) so I'm worried it's a bit self-reinforcing if he doesn't like to draw and write?

Gatehouse77 · 19/01/2022 07:51

There's a lot of Montessori initiatives that are common place now that you won't realise how much has come from her.

Child size furniture in the classroom.
Learn through play (albeit directed play).
Moving from gross motor skills to fine motor skills.
Helping children to order (make sense) of the world around them.
Sensory learning - isolating senses to focus on refining them.
Phonics.
Home corners - practical life skills.

Are the ones off the top of my head. We owe quite a lot to the Montessori movement in education.

Jobseeker19 · 19/01/2022 07:50

I work for a childcare agency and have worked ina Montessori nursery and found it so boring.
The chikdren did learn how to pour and screw and build but there were no focused activities.
We weren't allowed to say no or stop and had to use positive discipline. However there was more violence than I have seen in the other nursery's I have worked in.
Children smacking glasses off of other children faces when they touched their toy. Children lunging and biting. I was shocked and they weren't.
One particular nursery gave the smallest portion of food ever. It was like a side dish and it was plain.

kirinm · 19/01/2022 07:49

@TheWayTheLightFalls

There is one near me - which everyone in the vicinity will recognise from my description - run by an autocratic Greek woman who absolutely hates parents, all parents, and seems to deal with children under two by strapping them into double/triple buggies and wheeling them round a small yard all day. I'm sure there are some wonderful Montessori nurseries out there but this one has done it for me.
Is this South London?
Totalwasteofpaper · 19/01/2022 07:48

@OfstedOffred

Lots of the principles of child led etc have been incorporated into EYFS.

I think it suits a certain type of child who has a leaning towards independence any - the sort of little girl/boy who insists on getting themselves dressed in their own choice of clothes at 2, rather than the one who still asks their parent to help them at 4. I think it also suits children who are naturally compliant and respond well to subtle prompting/steering from grownups, rather than stubborn children who see things in a more black and white way.

I also think some of the principles aren't always effective if children have available various activities from which they can choose, and are then increasingly judged if they choose repetitively or are never choosing the ones which build the skills the adult would prefer them to build.

Lots of children don't really choose things they find hard or boring (drawing and pre writing skills in particular are not popular with some children) if there's anything else on offer. Not all children are naturally eager for knowledge/learning across the board, its limited to their areas of interest. Lots will happily at age 3 or 4 engage in quite repetitive play from which they don't acquire many new skills. To get more from that needs an adult on hand to help/encourage them to extend their play. It can work in a nursery with 6 or 8 kids per adult, in a reception class with 30 kids and only 2 adults, there isnt enough adult contact to get maximum benefit from it.

This thread is SO interesting. This post in particular makes a lot of sense

My friend had a baby late last year and is obsessed... OBSESSED with montessori.

I told her we were going for the nursery down the road whule £££ it was very convenient and staff seemed nice- She was Shock

To the point where I was almost questioning myself as I didn't get the big deal. when I goggled it our local nursery does EYFS which sounded a logical /sensible approach.
From what I can see montessori is more freestyle... which is fine for a certain type of child but what if you child needs encouragement and structure?

she will also be driving hers to one 15 mins away from hers. then drive back. Then commute. despite having a good nursery literally 3 doors away.
I just like sleep so was like okay .goof for you.. 🤷‍♀️

She is still asking if I am sure sure because montessori is SO amazing Confused

UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 07:48

My DD went to a Montessori influenced nursery in that it had elements of a Montessori and elements of a normal nursery. They had a fully equipped Montessori classroom and trained teachers. The DC would take it in turns to spend some time in there. I have to say my DD loved it and still talks about the things she played with in there. It was particularly good for developing fine motor skills. On the other hand they started teaching her phonics and none of that stuck.

So while I would say it was a positive in the same way she enjoyed yoga at nursery - it's not essential.

SlyAvocado · 19/01/2022 07:47

Ah the Montessori I took my charge to as a nanny was cute. All KIND HANDS! and OUR FRIENDS and SHARING IS CARING!!!

It was a nice set up but I couldn’t get too bogged down in the ethos, they all seem to adapt it differently.

They did take SIC a bit too far though. If a child was nicely playing with something, and another child wanted it there and then, they had to give it up for their ‘friend’ because ‘sharing is caring’. As you can imagine this caused some almighty tantrums and scraps amongst nursery aged children but the nursery persisted with it doggedly.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/01/2022 07:45

My DC went to a nursery that had some sort of Montessori built into their learning.When DS started school his teacher said they could always tell who went to this nursery as they were always ahead of the other children

But is it still noticeable by year two? Year six? I doubt it.

I

TrickyD · 19/01/2022 07:44

It worked for my brother and I and seems to be going well for our kiddo. But also both schools were/are just very well regarded locally, I’m sure there are shit Montessori’s too.

No doubt hot stuff on pouring water neatly and cutting carrots, pity they don't regard grammar and punctuation as worth bothering with.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 19/01/2022 07:44

Not all parents know how to give their kid smart skills.

They spend a lot of time with them and do lots of things. They are good parents, but don't know what makes a good learner and critical thinker. You need a certain mindset and persistence to hold these skills and pass them on with every opportunity and interaction.

Why not spend the extra and outsource this opportunity if you can afford it? It will save a lot of money on private education later on if your kid can get their top grades themselves.

CliffsofMohair · 19/01/2022 07:41

@Thoosa

Besides the fact Maria Montessori did questionable things as a parent herself, abandoning her own son

Don’t worry. Child abandonment wasn’t incorporated into the educational theory. They maintain staffing levels.

🤣
bruffin · 19/01/2022 07:40

@CakeRabbit

It makes no difference once they’re older. You can’t tell which children are Montessori and which aren’t.
My DC went to a nursery that had some sort of Montessori built into their learning. When DS started school his teacher said they could always tell who went to this nursery as they were always ahead of the other children.
MarshaBradyo · 19/01/2022 07:38

We visited a couple of nurseries

One attached to a Montessori fee paying school that started at two,

The other your usual nursery with a Montessori person at a table with some dc

The former had far fewer dc / staff ratio, and time to do loads of stuff during the day - child led etc. We used it for a year and it was really good but different to the other nursery that also had Montessori in the name

BertieBotts · 19/01/2022 07:32

Pedagogically no, I don't think it makes any difference. In terms of the environment being well suited to young children and respectful of them it's great. Although I agree that a lot of the important parts have been brought into other nurseries now too so you don't necessarily need to look for a Montessori specific one.

I can only compare some (10 year out of date) observations of UK nurseries to German nurseries. German nursery staff train for 3 years including a year of placement. The job is paid a living wage, nothing luxurious, similar to a nurse. More than they get paid in the UK. I feel like this makes a huge difference. Many UK nursery staff use it as a stepping stone to get experience working with children before moving on to other things. That means there is a high rate of turnover and the training is much less and requires less education to begin with.

The German nurseries have a very Montessori feel to me. Everything is hands on. The children have a lot of freedom, their day is not obsessively scheduled. Things like art activities are never prescriptive, children are allowed to do their own thing even if there is a suggested theme. They can come and go from the tables. Babies are not strapped into high chairs. If a child does something they are not supposed to do, they do not get shouted at or put in time out, an adult goes to them calmly (unless it's an emergency!) and they talk about what it is and gently redirect them to something else. They don't stop them from or make them nap (this frustrates a lot of UK and US parents who want the nursery to take more control). Reading and writing and maths all wait until school. They might do some colour/shape/number recognition but they don't obsess over it and it's done more passively rather than today we will learn shapes.

Coconuttts · 19/01/2022 07:31

My DS is much older now, but reading this thread and about the ethos of the (better) montessori settings, I know it would have suited him so much better than the awful experience he had in the pre-school and infants school he went to. That was just focused on handwriting, to a degree it was obsessive. When I look back I can't believe how crazy those years were!!

Spellfish · 19/01/2022 07:29

We had a fantastic Montessori around the corner, both DC thrived there. But I knew of some local nurseries that said they were Montessori which were very different and (to my mind) not as good.

The thing that made it great was that my DC were very different - one was all about books and reading (left Montessori at nearly 4 reading simple books, having taught herself with their materials) and one was all about the art and creative play. And it suited both of them. And they both learned to pour water without spilling and other practical things, which made my life easier.

OfstedOffred · 19/01/2022 07:29

Lots of the principles of child led etc have been incorporated into EYFS.

I think it suits a certain type of child who has a leaning towards independence any - the sort of little girl/boy who insists on getting themselves dressed in their own choice of clothes at 2, rather than the one who still asks their parent to help them at 4. I think it also suits children who are naturally compliant and respond well to subtle prompting/steering from grownups, rather than stubborn children who see things in a more black and white way.

I also think some of the principles aren't always effective if children have available various activities from which they can choose, and are then increasingly judged if they choose repetitively or are never choosing the ones which build the skills the adult would prefer them to build.

Lots of children don't really choose things they find hard or boring (drawing and pre writing skills in particular are not popular with some children) if there's anything else on offer. Not all children are naturally eager for knowledge/learning across the board, its limited to their areas of interest. Lots will happily at age 3 or 4 engage in quite repetitive play from which they don't acquire many new skills. To get more from that needs an adult on hand to help/encourage them to extend their play. It can work in a nursery with 6 or 8 kids per adult, in a reception class with 30 kids and only 2 adults, there isnt enough adult contact to get maximum benefit from it.

Notdoingthis · 19/01/2022 07:26

I worked in a Montessori nursery full time for a year and it amazing. The kids really were calm and engaged. I applied a lot of what I learnt to my own kids. My mum thinks it is permissive parenting as she doesn't hear me yelling at them, but actually, in Montessori there are many rules and structures. I love the idea of intrinsic over extrinsic motivations, and not using sanctions and rewards all the time. It may be coincidence, or other factors, but now my three primary aged children really are good at sitting still and concentrataing, and they are much more interested in being creative than using devices.

alphabetsoup1980 · 19/01/2022 07:24

@Thoosa

Besides the fact Maria Montessori did questionable things as a parent herself, abandoning her own son

Don’t worry. Child abandonment wasn’t incorporated into the educational theory. They maintain staffing levels.

Hahaha
MistyElla · 19/01/2022 07:24

Compared to other early years care options on offer over the past 80 years, Montessori has historically been miles ahead. It was certainly revolutionary for the generation who were brought up ‘seen and not heard’. I can imagine there being quite a difference at age 5 between a Montessori child and a child who was sent to a low quality/overcrowded childminder’s where they were being kept safe and alive but received very little stimulation (other than perhaps the tv). There has been a lot of research on the widening gap at reception between kids who receive high quality early years education and those who don’t, which is part of the reason the govt brought in the 30 free hours of childcare. They were trying to give a fighting chance to kids whose parents couldn’t afford programs like expensive Montessori schools.

These days, many early years programs incorporate Montessori principles, so I don’t think it’s necessary to spend loads to send children to a Montessori-specific school as long as the program is a high quality one. That’s especially true if home life is good and offers a lot of hands-on opportunities for children to play, explore, muck in with chores, participate in family life, etc.

AngelicaElizaAndPeggy · 19/01/2022 07:24

Have you looked into the actual pedagogy of it? It's so interesting. However, nowadays, a lot of it is recognised as best practise in any early years setting; promoting independence, the presence of the teacher as a guide or facilitator, the learning from other more experienced peers.

I love Montessori.

Swipe left for the next trending thread