Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Montessori is massively overhyped?

231 replies

Sherekhancarolbaskin · 19/01/2022 01:38

Or does it truly have proven pedagogic advantages?

I’m already not a fan of the Waldorf Steiner method at all.

Montessori does seem a lot better to me but after having looked into it a lot of it seems a bit off to me. Besides the fact Maria Montessori did questionable things as a parent herself, abandoning her own son

OP posts:
aweebitlost · 19/01/2022 10:57

On another note, I love the emphasis in the EYFS on 'free-flow' play and movement between outdoor and indoor learning environments. I think it's sad that this can only be offered to children until the end of reception and there is such a change in learning approach between reception and year 1.

Oh I couldn’t agree more with this!

Onlyhuman123 · 19/01/2022 10:51

@EishetChayil

Everyone I know who sends their children to a Montessori nursery are absolute knobs.
wow; judgemental much!

OP: my kids went to a montessori nursery...we picked it because it had a nice 'feel' about it, staff were fantastic and it being near to our work place so if anything happened, we could be there quickly. Kids thrived, made friends and enjoyed their hours there. When the kids went into reception year at our local school, the teachers said they could always tell when a child had been to a montessori nursery as they displayed more independent play and knew how to share with others. It was a positive experience for us but yes, expensive. Not sure it was much more expensive than 'normal' nurseries though...

purpleme12 · 19/01/2022 10:47

I agree that it should carry on beyond reception @goldbar

Goldbar · 19/01/2022 10:41

@SpidersAreShitheads

This is completely off topic really but I've been holding it in for ages and this feels like an appropriate place to vent.

I love crafting, and specifically needle felting. There's been a trend for people to make needle felted fairies - there's tons of them around. That's all fine but none of the bastard things have faces! None of them!

And if you ever ask why, they tell you it's because it's a Waldorf/Steiner approach. No it bloody isn't! It's because the faces are the hardest bit to do!! 😅 Yes, I know Waldorf/Steiner dolls don't have faces - but people are jumping on the bandwagon as an excuse not to do the difficult bit without having a clue about what the philosophy is.

Generally, needle felting is a very generous place and there are many felters who are more talented than I am. I love seeing people compliment each other's work. But it's just the pompous lies, and sanctimonious explanation.....I've tried asking people more about the "Waldorf/Steiner" approach and as suspected, they know fuck all. Just say, "faces are too complicated and I end up making my fairy look like a drunk demon". We'll all sympathise and move on. It's the fakery which pisses me right off. I am also well aware it's a) none of my business and b) a first world problem. I can't help it though. It's like an itch every time I see one.....

And breathe 😅

Back on topic, there are lots of really positive elements to Montessori/Waldorf/Steiner - it's not all wafting around in kaftans. It might not be completely for everyone but especially for children who struggle to cope in a traditional setting, or need help developing life skills, they have real value. There's some controversial stuff relating to the original Steiner beliefs but modern schools have moved on from that.

I love the randomness of this!

Having never done needle felting, I defer to you on the face issue Grin.

On the Montessori issue, while it's valuable particularly at nursery level to encourage children to explore for themselves and take an independent approach to learning, I think the EYFS means that all good nurseries take this approach nowardays - it's all about learning independently through play. So I'm not quite sure what Montessori adds beyond that though I think it was revolutionary before early years education started taking this approach.

Having visited a few when choosing a nursery for my DC, they seemed quieter and more structured with a greater emphasis on natural materials and limited toys. There seemed less noisy play and children playing games together than in other settings and more emphasis on focusing on a particular activity. And small world play and pretend play did not seem to be emphasised in the same way as in other settings.

On another note, I love the emphasis in the EYFS on 'free-flow' play and movement between outdoor and indoor learning environments. I think it's sad that this can only be offered to children until the end of reception and there is such a change in learning approach between reception and year 1.

Sweetleftfood · 19/01/2022 10:39

Oh for goodness sake, just take a look at a Scandinavian nursery or school, it's just common sense, let kids be kids, not sure why it has to be a "philosophy" ? Just the fact that the British (not trying to be anti-British) saw kids as 'little adults' and the thing to aspire to was the wealthy aristocracy. Steiner takes it too far in my opinion, you have to have some sort of order and timetabling

aweebitlost · 19/01/2022 10:38

Why are people talking about Steiner and Montessori as if they’re the same? They’re very different!

I have one of those constantly moving, not at all interested in arts and crafts kids. He’s at a fully outdoor nursery which is perfect for him. But when he was a bit younger we used to attend a Montessori group and he was like a different person in that room.
You would see these toddlers come in for their first session, running around a bit and making a lot of noise like a normal toddler group, and very quickly find an activity to settle to and there they would often stay for the whole two hours.
I actually stopped going to any other toddler groups because I found them too busy and noisy after the heaven of the peaceful, calm Montessori group!

daisyjgrey · 19/01/2022 10:37

@Yumperwumpee

somewhere, right in the cross section, is the perfect blend of them, but I don't think anyone has actually located it yet.

They never will because it looks different for every child.

Exactly. Everyone is searching for something that doesn't exist.

HardbackWriter · 19/01/2022 10:15

I think it's also worth noting that 'nurseries' and EYFS cover a wide range of provision, and I do think that you wouldn't necessarily want the same approach in a school hours' preschool as somewhere where they might spend 10 hours a day and has them from babies. I might have chosen somewhere different - more structured, more 'academic', a bit more like school - if I were looking for the former, but I needed the latter so that wasn't what I wanted at all.

elbea · 19/01/2022 10:14

We looked at a Montessori too but we didn’t like the look of it, definitely not for a one year old anyway.

We went without an outdoor nursery with acres of land and animals. They come home covered head to toe in mud and paint everyday but seem to absolutely love it. That’s what we are much more interested in, we do plenty of learning activities at home. We just wanted somewhere that she had a nice time!

Yumperwumpee · 19/01/2022 10:13

somewhere, right in the cross section, is the perfect blend of them, but I don't think anyone has actually located it yet.

They never will because it looks different for every child.

daisyjgrey · 19/01/2022 10:11

Like most things where there are multiple 'approaches', there is generally a venn diagram of all the educational approaches, and somewhere, right in the cross section, is the perfect blend of them, but I don't think anyone has actually located it yet.

FruitToast · 19/01/2022 10:02

I looked into it when my eldest went to nursery and decided that the 'normal' nurseries offering EYFS were a better choice than a true Montessori nursery. I wouldn't say it's rubbish. Some of the concepts are fantastic but most of the revolutionary stuff from the early 1900s is now incorporated into the curriculum without the bits that I find a bit strange! EYFS also takes best practices from all methods of learning so I feel children are more rounded. My DCs both thrived/are thriving at the nursery they went to. DD loves art and reading. We got a daily barrage of paintings and crafts and she was reading very well by the time she left nursery and is an avid reader now. DS hates sitting still. He has spent most of this week so far outside building a pirate ship with his friends. Nursery staff recognised their skills and interests and worked them into their themes and had activities that suit both of them. They were both independent at a young age. They learned to cut fruit, bake cakes, put their own coats on etc just as they would at a Montessori nursery. I don't believe a true Montessori nursery would have catered well for either of them. DD wouldn't have had access to her beloved fairy/unicorn/princess books and role play and DS wouldn't have sat still long enough to do any activities!

Yumperwumpee · 19/01/2022 09:56

Bear in mind lots of colour can be really overwhelming for children with sensory issues as well.

Gonnagetgoing · 19/01/2022 09:52

@SmellyOldOwls

My son went to a Reggio Emilia place. Tbh I don't really know or care what most of it means, I just wanted him to go somewhere they would be nice to him and let him run around outside.
@SmellyOldOwls - DNephew and his cousin went to a place exactly like this - a Barnardos nursery in Hackney.
HardbackWriter · 19/01/2022 09:52

To me though, the environment is too fucking bland. I was looking into them when creating a Montessori themed nursery in Animal Crossing and the more I read the more fucking boring and grey everything looked and even seemed in the curriculum.

I think that's very much the current fashion, though. Our nursery just did a big refurb and now everything is grey and black and white and wood and maybe some pale green and it is very soothing (and looks lovely on instagram!) but I also agree I prefer more colour and vibrancy. But the refurb has massively improved the space overall and we love the nursery in general so I can live with it being a bit colourless in its decor - but I do think it's a fashion, and it'll change. Right now everything is neutral and natural but give it long enough and nurseries will be ripping that out and making everything primary colours again.

Gonnagetgoing · 19/01/2022 09:51

My DM wanted both me and DB to go to either a Montessori or Steiner school - for whatever reasons probably finance we didn't go.

Friend of family's 2 DCs go to Montessori school and actually really like it and are happy there.

I agree though most nursery schools from what friends kids and relatives kids who go to nursery they have a lot of Montessori elements and teachings in them nowadays.

SmellyOldOwls · 19/01/2022 09:43

My son went to a Reggio Emilia place. Tbh I don't really know or care what most of it means, I just wanted him to go somewhere they would be nice to him and let him run around outside.

Staryflight445 · 19/01/2022 09:43

I’ve had to stop following an instagrammer who is into this with her children.

She’s posted stuff about feeling guilty for going on days out with her daughter when knowing her daughter wasn’t in the right frame of mind to enjoy it for example- child literally the centre of everything.

It’s not realistic is it? I watched a story of her allowing said older child to ‘play fight’ with her baby sister. Kid was throwing her all over the place, touching her neck and all sorts.

Some of it seems nice but I do worry a lot of these kids will struggle as adults when not everyone puts their feelings at the centre of everything, that isn’t real life.

Blackberrybunnet · 19/01/2022 09:41

Whether it's "better" than a regular education is dependant on what you are looking for. However, it's worth noting that Montessori "teachers" do not have to have state-recognised qualifications (which is, in fact, the case for all private schools). That said, many of them do. It's up to the consumer to do their homework.

Kanaloa · 19/01/2022 09:39

@SlyAvocado

Well that’s news to me, when I worked in a baby room at nursery we changed nappies in the table right there! Not the activity table obviously, but on a changing table in the room.
Gosh I’ve never seen that in my experience at any nursery. Wouldn’t like it either. However, a changing table at the corner is still very different to stripping a kid down on the table where his friends are painting. I doubt OFSTED would appreciate a child being changed right over the sticking and gluing activity.
purpleme12 · 19/01/2022 09:38

@MollyQueenOfSocks

I absolutely get the child led learning concept of it and that it doesn't work for some children.

To me though, the environment is too fucking bland. I was looking into them when creating a Montessori themed nursery in Animal Crossing and the more I read the more fucking boring and grey everything looked and even seemed in the curriculum.

I always think this too! I gather that's the point of them but it's not what appeals to me
SlyAvocado · 19/01/2022 09:37

Well that’s news to me, when I worked in a baby room at nursery we changed nappies in the table right there! Not the activity table obviously, but on a changing table in the room.

toconclude · 19/01/2022 09:36

@Curlyreine That's a nice change from the usual Mumsnet " EVERYTHING in Britain is the worst in the world". Thanks Smile

newnamenewyear · 19/01/2022 09:34

@MollyQueenOfSocks

It also seemed very insular in that children seemed to be expected to entertain themselves and play alone, which to me seemed not only pretty lonely but also detrimental to forming bonds and relationships with other children.

Every child just seemed so separate from each other, the teachers and the environment around them, like they were being taught they were this abstract concept rather than a human with social needs.

Yes, this.

I felt the teacher jumped on any play the children tried to do together and stopped it. Nicely, gently, subtly, with a smile - but still wrong IMO. It felt insidious.

Kanaloa · 19/01/2022 09:34

Where are they supposed to change nappies confused that bit sounds normal for a nursery.

It’s absolutely not normal. An activity table is where the children are playing. No child (for reasons of both hygiene and dignity) should be having their nappy changed in the okay area in full view of the other children/teachers/parents. They should be being changed in the bathroom/nappy change area where staff can wash their hands up after disposing of the nappies and wipes and the child can have privacy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread