Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Montessori is massively overhyped?

231 replies

Sherekhancarolbaskin · 19/01/2022 01:38

Or does it truly have proven pedagogic advantages?

I’m already not a fan of the Waldorf Steiner method at all.

Montessori does seem a lot better to me but after having looked into it a lot of it seems a bit off to me. Besides the fact Maria Montessori did questionable things as a parent herself, abandoning her own son

OP posts:
busyeatingbiscuits · 19/01/2022 13:15

I’ve worked in several nurseries (and my children have been to 3 others between them) and I have never seen nappy changing/intimate care happening in a playroom.
Always in a bathroom or changing area.
Door open or windows in the door, yes - but stripping a baby or child off in front of everyone is really poor practice and Ofsted certainly wouldn’t find it ideal.

OfstedOffred · 19/01/2022 13:11

Even though the curriculum says it was child led learning through play and the teacher would say it was, it just wasn't. You have to have time to observe children to use their play to extend their learning and the staff simply did not have time for that. Instead the children play by themselves for short periods and then the teacher interrupts and ends their play to draw them together for the set learning for that day.

I suspect this is the reality in many reception classrooms, where it is intended to be free flow, child led etc, but in reality the majority of the acquisition and consolidation of new skills and knowledge happens in shorter periods of direct teaching through the day.

kirinm · 19/01/2022 13:01

[quote TheWayTheLightFalls]@kirinm that’s the one Grin[/quote]
She is off putting!

JeshusHChr · 19/01/2022 12:52

@OfstedOffred

Froebel is another one where true application needs a lot of adult support/input. I just think most western education settings can't offer enough adults beyond the ages where max ratio is 8 to 1, for very very free, child led approaches to actually consistently result in acquisition of wide ranging knowledge and skills.
Absolutely. My kids went to a stonkingly brilliant Froebel nursery but they had excellent staff ratios and very highly educated and well paid staff ( starting pay similar to starting pay for a teacher).

Compare that to when my kids went to school, and the ratios are just not there. Even though the curriculum says it was child led learning through play and the teacher would say it was, it just wasn't. You have to have time to observe children to use their play to extend their learning and the staff simply did not have time for that. Instead the children play by themselves for short periods and then the teacher interrupts and ends their play to draw them together for the set learning for that day.

CorpusCallosum · 19/01/2022 12:41

A Montessori approach hands down got us through lockdown with a 1yo and I'm about to do it from birth with number 2. The bits about adapting their environment for little ones really appealed to me as an OT and it's worked so well.

Tiny bits of independence like DD being able to hang her coat up on a hook at her level is brilliant for all of us and I don't think we'd have thought to do it otherwise.

I'm in a FB group and people are often worried about 'not being 100% Montessori'. I struggle with this attitude. It's a family at the end of the day, take and use what works for you from every resource, Montessori or not, and leave the rest - no big deal right?!

I agree with many PP, Montessori education settings are poorly regulated so views will be shewed by what they've experienced whether or not it's 100% Montessori 😉

HardbackWriter · 19/01/2022 12:36

Nappies are meant to be changed in places where others can see. Its for safeguarding, to stop the risk of children being abused at nappy changes.

Every nursery I've ever seen has indeed placed the nappy changing station somewhere that's line of sight for other staff - which sometimes means it's a separate area of the room but not a separate room - but that has never meant changing the nappy in front of other children on an activity table! That's weird and gross and I'm surprised that anyone is defending it.

N0N4M3 · 19/01/2022 12:29

I think part of the problem is that there's no regulation / standardisation over what is and isn't 'Montessori'. So anyone can set up a nursery, run it however they wish, and call it 'Montessori'. Having the name on the door doesn't actually mean that a place will incorporate any of Maria Montessori's ideology. If the staff are AMI trained then there's more likelihood that they will adhere to what she wrote about, but there are still lots of different interpretations of her ideas even amongst those.
There's also this weird misconception that it's all about (expensive) wooden materials and making kids do housework. It's not. The movement was intended to make a high standard of education accessible to poor and disabled children, so it's a shame that it's become this culty middle-class money-making thing.
I wouldn't pay for a 'Montessori' nursery, but I have read Montessori's books and incorporate her ideas at home because I think the ideas are beautiful, when you strip away all the snobbishness and exclusivity that's grown up around it more recently.

ancientgran · 19/01/2022 12:28

@HardbackWriter

I think it's also worth noting that 'nurseries' and EYFS cover a wide range of provision, and I do think that you wouldn't necessarily want the same approach in a school hours' preschool as somewhere where they might spend 10 hours a day and has them from babies. I might have chosen somewhere different - more structured, more 'academic', a bit more like school - if I were looking for the former, but I needed the latter so that wasn't what I wanted at all.
That is very true.
JeshusHChr · 19/01/2022 12:27

@BarrowInFurnessRailwayStation

We looked round one for ds1, but the worker changing a toddler's nappy on an activity table in full view of anyone and everyone and seeing lots of sharp tacks on the floor - amongst other debris - somewhat put me off. The manager was an idiot as well.
Nappies are meant to be changed in places where others can see. Its for safeguarding, to stop the risk of children being abused at nappy changes.
ancientgran · 19/01/2022 12:26

@Yumperwumpee

somewhere, right in the cross section, is the perfect blend of them, but I don't think anyone has actually located it yet.

They never will because it looks different for every child.

And also different with every practitioner/teacher. I think if you have an adult who loves what they are doing and do it well the children are much more likely to be happy, enjoy it and do well.
Ellie1209 · 19/01/2022 12:19

I agree @OfstedOffred. But I'd definitely say that's where the focus seems to be these days.
When I done my training it was all about Vygotsky and Piaget. It just goes through stages, I don't know where the recent Montessori attention is coming from (I've heard it's tiktok?)
I'm not particularly a fan but maybe it's because we incorporate elements without really thinking about it.

BertieBotts · 19/01/2022 12:15

Er, not really? Every nursery I have been in has a changing area/room often with child sized toilets in it. That way the area can be easily wiped down and caregivers can immediately wash hands.

Mysterian · 19/01/2022 12:15

Good nurseries are good nurseries. Doesn't matter about the labels. Do they put children first? Can they justify everything they do? Are the children's experienced varied, fun, and learnful? (Not well today so can't think of the proper word for "learnful". Are the children busy, happy, safe getting along?

OfstedOffred · 19/01/2022 12:10

Froebel is another one where true application needs a lot of adult support/input. I just think most western education settings can't offer enough adults beyond the ages where max ratio is 8 to 1, for very very free, child led approaches to actually consistently result in acquisition of wide ranging knowledge and skills.

Ellie1209 · 19/01/2022 12:02

I work in early years, I'd say it's all about Froebel, particularly outdoor theory, in recent years.

greenmarlin · 19/01/2022 11:50

goldbar you are well within your rights, I don't like dolls without faces either.

OfstedOffred · 19/01/2022 11:47

There is also a big tendency for those teaching Year 1 and above with Targets to reach to want the Reception class to prepare children for this Target rather than assessing where the children are and progressing from this point.

This can be true but conversely the reverse can also happen where EYFS teachers see EYFS goals as being a maximum level for the end of reception, when actually there's quite a gap between that and what's expected to be covered in year one. Failure to prepare gradually through reception leaves the y1 teacher having to try and bridge the gap AND cover the y1 curriculum, it's too much and is a short sharp shock to kids who aren't ready.

ItsSunnyOutside · 19/01/2022 11:40

I think some elements of Montessori are reallly good and they work for my DD, but there are also some other elements I don't like/agree with, so we don't do those. DD goes to Forest school for 1 afternoon a week and loves it, they use a similar hands on, child led way of learning to Montessori, but also encourage children to use their imagination through fantasy story telling.

I don't think there is a one size fits all approach.

OfstedOffred · 19/01/2022 11:39

But I think the jump from a mostly play-based approach in reception to one that is mostly based on didactic instruction in Y1 is a bit sad.

Good schools manage the jump well with a gradual progression through yr. It shouldnt be a massive shift over night on entering year 1.

CaptainMyCaptain · 19/01/2022 11:27

[quote Goldbar]@OfstedOffred. I don't disagree with you. It's effectively a question of resources. But I think the jump from a mostly play-based approach in reception to one that is mostly based on didactic instruction in Y1 is a bit sad.[/quote]
I agree. There is also a big tendency for those teaching Year 1 and above with Targets to reach to want the Reception class to prepare children for this Target rather than assessing where the children are and progressing from this point. Head teachers with no Early Years experience are, in my experience, terrible at wanting this. Sorry, this is a digression.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 19/01/2022 11:26

@kirinm that’s the one Grin

Goldbar · 19/01/2022 11:23

@OfstedOffred. I don't disagree with you. It's effectively a question of resources. But I think the jump from a mostly play-based approach in reception to one that is mostly based on didactic instruction in Y1 is a bit sad.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 19/01/2022 11:22

All the way to adulthood, actually.

Do you have evidence to prove that @Curlyreine? And if so, how do these studies prove it was the Montessori nursery that made the difference and not a million other influences like wealth, location, parental education, whether there's SAHP, general intelligence etc.?

CatJumperTwat · 19/01/2022 11:22

Curlyreine Please explain how you can tell if an adult went to a Montessori nursery.

OfstedOffred · 19/01/2022 11:19

On another note, I love the emphasis in the EYFS on 'free-flow' play and movement between outdoor and indoor learning environments. I think it's sad that this can only be offered to children until the end of reception and there is such a change in learning approach between reception and year 1.

The problem is it depends what your objective is. Fundamentally, children are at school to learn primarily academic skills - reading, writing, maths, science etc. Continuous provision/play based learning/ free flow etc is great where you have high numbers of adults to gently guide children to extend out of their comfort zone and learn new things that initially they may find harder. It basically doesn't work with 30 kids and 1 adult. Lots of 5 year olds given genuinely free choices of what to do, without enough adult guidance, will repetitively play in a home corner or with construction and won't extend that into say, pre-reading/writing or connecting into maths concepts, because it's fun simply pretending to be a pirate without feeling the need to label anything or count the treasure or notice that something is a rectangle or whatever. You need an adult on hand to gently question, suggest, guide and help a child learn from that sort of play, you can't do it effectively throughout a school year with 30 children to one adult.

Swipe left for the next trending thread