Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Montessori is massively overhyped?

231 replies

Sherekhancarolbaskin · 19/01/2022 01:38

Or does it truly have proven pedagogic advantages?

I’m already not a fan of the Waldorf Steiner method at all.

Montessori does seem a lot better to me but after having looked into it a lot of it seems a bit off to me. Besides the fact Maria Montessori did questionable things as a parent herself, abandoning her own son

OP posts:
ancientgran · 19/01/2022 18:52

@3scape

The Nazis were big fans.
Of Steiner or Montessori? I can imagine them like some of the Steiner beliefs on race.
pastypirate · 19/01/2022 18:16

@feelsobadfeltsogood

All of load of pretentious rubbish with delusional parents and teachers who aren't even qualified teachers

There was one near us it got shut down I don't know why they are allowed to operate to be honest

Please indulge me with what you think Montessori is....
Curlyreine · 19/01/2022 17:37

@3scape

The Nazis were big fans.
Oh for goodness sake. No they weren't.

Can you not use google ?

This thread has turned into a bashing thread where people say stupid things, without grit, back up, experience or information.

If anyone would like to have a healthy discussion and get a serious overview and guidance, I would suggest they contact the AMI institute rather than read the absolute drivel
and untruths that are being posted here.

SantaClawsServiette · 19/01/2022 17:35

I think MM had some great ideas, and others not so great. I would send my child to a school that was using a lot of her ideas, if it was otherwise good, but not a strict one.

Steiner OTOH was a nutter. Some schools that call themselves Steiner schools aren't really, but many of their ideas are silly and even dangerous.

My own favorite historic educator is Charlotte Mason, who was English, though there aren't many, if any, schools using her method now. She was more or less a contemporary of MM, and her Mason's main criticism of her method was that she felt children shouldn't be put into special environments, but really they learned through interacting in normal environments in normal ways with normal things. She also thought stories and imagination were really important for children, without trying to tell them that technology was powered by gnomes like the Steiner people.

3scape · 19/01/2022 17:30

The Nazis were big fans.

sociallydistained · 19/01/2022 17:26

I worked in a Montessori once It was the worst one and I worked in many 🙈

RobinPenguins · 19/01/2022 17:15

The best elements of it have been adopted by most good nurseries anyway, without being totally purist or rigid about it.

ancientgran · 19/01/2022 17:14

I think the changing is a difficult area. Remember Vanessa George who was taking photos of children when she was changing them and sending them to her paedophile friends. I think the photos were described as depraved. It was a few years ago in Plymouth. I would imagine alot of parents got worried about babies and young children being taken off to a private area with one member of staff so maybe a changing table in the corner of the main room was considered a safer alternative.

Curlyreine · 19/01/2022 17:10

@feelsobadfeltsogood

All of load of pretentious rubbish with delusional parents and teachers who aren't even qualified teachers

There was one near us it got shut down I don't know why they are allowed to operate to be honest

Ugh.
Namele · 19/01/2022 17:04

I went to a montessori secondary school (not uk) and do feel that I benefitted a lot from it. It has taught me to work independently and to my strengths. We also did a lot of group based creative things such as theatre plays, art installations etc. Also it really encourages you to try things you're not confident with as you can do it at your own pace and without being on 'show'. That said, my school was excellent in its interpretation of the philosophy. When DC1 was a baby, I went to look around our local montessori nursery (this time uk based) and got really annoyed with the woman showing me round as everything was done "the montessori way" ie, our children play out for at least 30 minutes a day as it's the montessori way, we feed them 3 healthy meals, as it's the montessori way... she really had no clue and I could see no difference from that nursery to any of the other (considerably less expensive) ones we looked round. As pp said there's just no standard applied across the board.

feelsobadfeltsogood · 19/01/2022 17:04

All of load of pretentious rubbish with delusional parents and teachers who aren't even qualified teachers

There was one near us it got shut down I don't know why they are allowed to operate to be honest

hibbledibble · 19/01/2022 16:49

Montessori is not a regulated name, so any nursery or school can call themselves Montessori. As a result there are a lot of terrible ones.

My daughter went to one and I had to withdraw her for her safety. Basic measures were not adhered to (like staffing ratios, dietary needs due to allergies) which made the environment dangerous. The Montessori aspect seemed very loosely, if at all applied as well. It was just a shit nursery. (Feel free to pm if you are in West London and want to know where to avoid)

purpleme12 · 19/01/2022 16:40

When my child was in the baby room at nursery, 7 years ago, the changing table was in the corner of the baby room.

busyeatingbiscuits · 19/01/2022 16:35

[quote JeshusHChr]@Kanaloa

Read my post again.

I did not comment on, nor defend, the changing on an activity table, just to the being changed where others can see the change taking place ( as OP objected to the change taking place where others can see it. I have been in top rated nurseries where I as a parent have been able to see babies and toddlers being changed. They are changed in a specific changing place, but its observable by others in the nursery). I was solely commenting on the fact that being changed where others can see it is a safeguarding protection.[/quote]
It might be a top rated nursery but that definitely isn't good practice. Even babies deserve to be treated with dignity.

It's also pretty normal for nappy changing/toileting to be carried out by one adult in early years, and it's a bit of a myth that there needs to be 2 adults present.

trumpisagit · 19/01/2022 16:25

@Thousso
"Don’t worry. Child abandonment wasn’t incorporated into the educational theory. They maintain staffing levels."
😅
My DS friend went to a Montessori nursery it didn't sound very "fun".
Lots of individual stations, and self learning....

Kanaloa · 19/01/2022 16:06

[quote JeshusHChr]@Kanaloa

Read my post again.

I did not comment on, nor defend, the changing on an activity table, just to the being changed where others can see the change taking place ( as OP objected to the change taking place where others can see it. I have been in top rated nurseries where I as a parent have been able to see babies and toddlers being changed. They are changed in a specific changing place, but its observable by others in the nursery). I was solely commenting on the fact that being changed where others can see it is a safeguarding protection.[/quote]
I read your post, and still disagree with you. While changing areas need to be accessible and not hidden away and staff shouldn’t be alone with the child there is no need for a child to be changed out in a common area with all the other children (and those children’s parents, who are strangers to them) able to see.

pawpatrolneedaunion · 19/01/2022 16:05

I find some pareting trends like 'sensory activities' are just ways of making mums feel guilty. You don't need to spend 3 hours in the evening dying rice Hmm

JeshusHChr · 19/01/2022 16:02

@Kanaloa

Read my post again.

I did not comment on, nor defend, the changing on an activity table, just to the being changed where others can see the change taking place ( as OP objected to the change taking place where others can see it. I have been in top rated nurseries where I as a parent have been able to see babies and toddlers being changed. They are changed in a specific changing place, but its observable by others in the nursery). I was solely commenting on the fact that being changed where others can see it is a safeguarding protection.

JeshusHChr · 19/01/2022 16:01

Read my post again.

I did not comment on, nor defend, the changing on an activity table, just to the being changed where others can see the change taking place ( as OP objected to the change taking place where others can see it. I have been in top rated nurseries where I as a parent have been able to see babies and toddlers being changed. They are changed in a specific changing place, but its observable by others in the nursery). I was solely commenting on the fact that being changed where others can see it is a safeguarding protection.

ritalinda · 19/01/2022 15:30

They're all so different to each other even though they claim to be Montessori. I think it's nonsense really although for sure some of them are great schools that offer children a lovely environment to learn.

HelloFrostyMorning · 19/01/2022 15:13

NGL. No idea what Montessori is.

JaneDoe7 · 19/01/2022 15:08

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Kanaloa · 19/01/2022 13:52

@JeshusHChr

That means open access bathrooms with more than one member of staff present, not changing a child on an activity table in the middle of a common area.

That really shouldn’t need saying. I’ve worked in so many nurseries and genuinely have never ever seen a child being changed on the crafts table and wouldn’t like it if I did.

JeshusHChr · 19/01/2022 13:33

I suspect this is the reality in many reception classrooms, where it is intended to be free flow, child led etc, but in reality the majority of the acquisition and consolidation of new skills and knowledge happens in shorter periods of direct teaching through the day

Yes. I now live in a country where playbased learning has been in place for some time (years) but the practice is very poor from the classrooms I have spent time in. And the inspectors don't recognise it as poor. And the target framework means teachers inevitably focus on direct learning as they have literacy and numeracy targets to meet that their inspections and careers depend on.

Curlyreine · 19/01/2022 13:24

Montessori encourages cooperation rather than competition, and has the fundamental principle that children learn at different paces, and not every person will learn the same way.

Therefore, we have select materials, specifically designed to isolate one difficulty, which we present to the child and they then repeat and repeat until they have mastered this particular thing. By doing it in this way, the child is encouraged to satisfy their own curiosity, before moving onto the next step.
There are strict boundaries in place with Montessori, and children are not allowed to touch materials that have not been presented to them. But once they have received the appropriate presentation, they are able to use that material.
The materials have subtle continuities that go through the first and the second plane, into the cosmic educational classroom.

It is true that we do not encourage fantasy play before the age of 6. The reasons for this are a) Dr Montessori noted that children preferred the real things rather than imitation toys. Because of this, practical life skills (such as pouring, wiping, folding napkins) were integrated to the curriculum. Whilst some PP’s might not value this, there are many children who have a great sense of achievement when they develop the skills they have observed through watching adults around them, and are able to actively participate in the daily routines.
b) Dr Montessori also noted that fantasy (which during her lifetime often revolved around fairytales) were too much for children under the age of 6. From the age of children are more able to distinguish fantasy from reality. (On a personal note, I feel that today, fantasy play is much more child friendly. Of course my Dc were exposed to Pixar/Disney etc. but I am happy from them to have a break from this during school, and they can live out fantasies at home.)

Montessori appears to have become a buzz word over the last decade and used in marketing without any real knowledge of the pedagogy, sustenance or connections. Sadly there is nothing that can be done about that, but the result is that a lot of opinions form, as this thread has demonstrated.

Imagination is a very important part of Montessori, as children have to be very well informed with solid experiences to understand the world of dinosaurs, for example. Children are not barred from using their imagination but fantasy is kept out of 3-6. 6-12 does incorporate it actually, my classroom is full of Lord of the Rings, Star Wars and Harry Potter fans, which of course, I incorporate into the classroom when appropriate.

“Imagination relies on a solid foundation of real-life experiences, accompanied by ample opportunity for exploration and experimentation- this includes exploration and experimentation through pretending or imagining alternative outcomes. “
– Sarah Werner Andrews, “The Development of Imagination and the Role of Pretend Play”, 27th International Montessori Congress

It is true that a Montessori accredited teacher does not have to have a formal teaching qualification. Just as state teachers don’t have montessori training. They are too separate pedagogical approaches, so different qualifications. There are MANY staff who have dual though, globally, IME.

In a correct Montessori setting, children should have access to outside at all times. This includes as they get older. The 12-15 year olds in my school are very interested in permaculture, and have a garden section dedicated to them, for this, for example. 3-6 have a section to grow vegetables. The 6-12 did not want one this year, but they are very focused on stones and generally digging (and all that goes alongside it) at the moment.

If the adult finds the settings boring, that’s ok. They are not in place to appease the adult. They are there for the child. But more and more places are moving away from
bright information boards, and to calmer, neutral environments.

And no, you cannot quantify the influence of nursery in an adult. Apologies for my quick post before I started work, without any clarification! I am not referring solely to a nursery setting, but I am referring to the entire Montessori pedagogy, which covers the four planes, from 0-24 years. It’s incredibly fascinating and I would encourage you to read more about it. It is not purely academic targets but on developing the person as a whole, which does impact upon a persons outlook in life. As I said earlier, cooperation rather than competition. History, for example is taught from an angle of appreciation and gratitude for all of those who went before us, rather than wars/dates to be analyzed and remembered.

I am AMI accredited, and their website is an interesting place to start.
montessori-ami.org/resource-library/presentations

Sophie Denervaud did an excellent study in 2019, for those who are interested.

It is noted that sadly montessori practices are often privatized and out of the reach of everybody. I cannot believe that this would have been Maria Montessori’s wishes. But as I said up thread, in the UK, you have a wonderful child led education.

I also did the curiosity approach training, and that is just wonderful for Early Years, as well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread