Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Montessori is massively overhyped?

231 replies

Sherekhancarolbaskin · 19/01/2022 01:38

Or does it truly have proven pedagogic advantages?

I’m already not a fan of the Waldorf Steiner method at all.

Montessori does seem a lot better to me but after having looked into it a lot of it seems a bit off to me. Besides the fact Maria Montessori did questionable things as a parent herself, abandoning her own son

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
emi1234 · 23/01/2022 19:51

I can't answer your question specifically sorry, but I am wishing to interview some UK based Montessori, private or home-educating parents for my psychology dissertation.

The requirements to participate in my study include having a primary school aged child and you are considering or have already started the education types listed.
If anyone would like to get involved or have some questions you would like to ask about the study - please email me the researcher [email protected] 😁

Thank you in advance!

Curlyreine · 21/01/2022 18:26

@Kanaloa you might also find the study interesting.

serval.unil.ch/resource/serval:BIB_921000E081D3.P002/REF.pdf

Link to an article summarizing the actual study (but in French, sorry I couldn't find an English one).

www.google.ch/amp/s/amp.rts.ch/info/suisse/12211126-la-methode-montessori-favoriserait-la-gestion-de-lechec.html

Curlyreine · 21/01/2022 18:13

@CatJumperTwat

Hi twat! I replied upthread. Good night!

Hi lyre! You posted some contradictory waffle, first backtracking but then saying it was about cooperation vs competition. What does that mean?

Hi Twat, I can only apologise if you read my explanations as ‘waffle’ or contradictory. Not my intention at all. I did backtrack as I was (multitasking and speed reading) and my ‘to adulthood’ response was referring to how far the montessori pedagogy goes, which was not the post I responded to. Of course, I apologise profusely for any misunderstanding.

The Montessori pedagogy goes much further than nursery years, and each plane of development follows on from each other.

You can tell the difference in the children who have attended (certified) Montessori schools, in my experience. Not in terms of the child’s intellect or ambition, but in the expectations the child has of their individual learning, their autonomy and the order in which the child learns. I also stated that (again, IMO) the British system is one of the best for being child centred. I don’t agree with or like the fact that the pedagogy is mostly only available to those who can afford it, but the British system has adopted a lot of aspects towards it, so there is some hope that lots of children can have a part of the experience.

The differences are far too numerous to explain in one post. I came from the usual teaching background and spent quite some time observing Montessori, with many many questions myself. If you wish to have a decent conversation in an attempt to gain some understanding in the differences, then I am happy to do that (preferably via PM). However, if You just want to demand that I justify myself for holding a view that is different to yours, then I prefer not too. I trust you understand that.

Google the principles of montessori. That will help you to understand the differences between cooperation and competition in this context. It will also explain other misunderstandings on this thread such as imagination/fantasy or freedom/responsibility.

The maths materials are just wonderful. This is what first led me to explore this pedagogy, as I noted in my classroom that some children struggled with the abstract concepts. Within the 3-6 classroom, for example, children become familiar with binomial squares, to help develop visual discrimination (shape, color, pattern). It also has an indirect aim, which is to offer sensorial input so that when we used the material in the 6-12 classroom to explain the binomial equation, the material is already known to the child. This is an example of familiarization over memorization, and the children are able to grasp this concept easily. I find watching the children learn in this sensorial way absolutely fascinating. And yes… they are usually ahead of the standard national curriculums (again, in my experience.)

For further reading, I would recommend ‘Montessori speaks to parents’ ‘Educating the human potential’ and ‘The Absorbent Mind’ all written by Maria Montessori. She also has a fascinating life story and it’s worth reading.

As I also previously mentioned, there was an interesting study done by neuroscientist Sophie Dénervaud in the University of Lausanne, demonstrating the benefits of the Montessori pedagogy on the students neural networks and how they approached stress/managed unforeseen circumstances. You can also find this on the internet.

Lyre

pastypirate · 21/01/2022 16:39

Insta-eco huns and Montessori-inspired parents are two completely different breeds.

This. I you want to me the grims rainbow evangelists they are in the limited screen time fb group I'm in. They are loons. And nothing like the Montessori parents from dds nursery.

Kanaloa · 21/01/2022 13:26

*whether

Kanaloa · 21/01/2022 13:26

@mathanxiety

And do you have a very large sample and control group picked from similar home environments? Because otherwise this just isn’t really provable.

I know loads of self starting, hard working kids who have a good self awareness who didn’t go to a Montessori nursery.

And if the adults I know I really don’t know what nurseries they went to. I don’t put mine on my CV and honestly I can’t remember anybody ever asking me where I received my preschool education.

The point of Montessori is to empower the teacher to engage with the children on an individual level and while carefully guiding them through tiers of understanding, empower children to take charge of their own learning.

I have had the experience of observing young adults who have gone all the way through to age 17-18 in Montessori schools.

I am curious as to why you restrict your observations to preschool, and why you brought CVs into the discussion @Kanaloa?

I explained it pretty clearly. I’ve only worked in reception/year 1, and I was giving my experience that there is very little noticeable difference by year 1 in children who have attended different preschool setting.

I then went on to say that in real life very few people know wether someone attended a Montessori nursery or a childminder at the end of the road, because few people put ‘elm road Montessori nursery school’ at the top of their CV.

Realistically the idea that a Montessori nursery is somehow superior and the alumni can be easily spotted 20 years later is daft.

Hope that satisfied your curiosity.

HardbackWriter · 21/01/2022 13:17

My phone selected this article for me - I assume because I've been reading this thread and googled Montessori, as the nursery is nowhere near me! - which I guess shows why a nursery describing itself as Montessori doesn't tell you much at all:
www.essexlive.news/news/essex-news/essex-nursery-rated-inadequate-ofsted-6515099

CatJumperTwat · 21/01/2022 09:26

Hi twat! I replied upthread. Good night!

Hi lyre! You posted some contradictory waffle, first backtracking but then saying it was about cooperation vs competition. What does that mean?

mathanxiety · 21/01/2022 05:01

And do you have a very large sample and control group picked from similar home environments? Because otherwise this just isn’t really provable.

I know loads of self starting, hard working kids who have a good self awareness who didn’t go to a Montessori nursery.

And if the adults I know I really don’t know what nurseries they went to. I don’t put mine on my CV and honestly I can’t remember anybody ever asking me where I received my preschool education.

The point of Montessori is to empower the teacher to engage with the children on an individual level and while carefully guiding them through tiers of understanding, empower children to take charge of their own learning.

I have had the experience of observing young adults who have gone all the way through to age 17-18 in Montessori schools.

I am curious as to why you restrict your observations to preschool, and why you brought CVs into the discussion @Kanaloa?

Curlyreine · 21/01/2022 02:54

@CatJumperTwat

Curlyreine Still waiting to hear how you can tell whether adults went to a Montessori nursery or not.
Hi twat! I replied upthread. Good night!
Kanaloa · 21/01/2022 02:39

@mathanxiety

One difference I have seen between Montessori kids and others when they get older - the Montessori students are much more in touch with themselves, conscious of their feelings, aware of their learning patterns and pace, and tend to be self starters.
And do you have a very large sample and control group picked from similar home environments? Because otherwise this just isn’t really provable.

I know loads of self starting, hard working kids who have a good self awareness who didn’t go to a Montessori nursery.

And if the adults I know I really don’t know what nurseries they went to. I don’t put mine on my CV and honestly I can’t remember anybody ever asking me where I received my preschool education.

In my own experience of reception/year one work you can tell children who’ve always been at home with mum and dad from kids who’ve done preschool, but by late reception/year one they’re all much of a same. Some bright buttons from both categories but generally all of the same standard of learning.

Beowulfthethird · 21/01/2022 02:18

Yes may I also step away from the wool fairies to say that Steiner and Montessori are terribly different to each other. At Steiner it really can be a bit nuts.

Beowulfthethird · 21/01/2022 02:16

Yes math it's like people are confusing an absence of control with absence of direction and authority. They're still educators and there are still expectations which can be if anything a bit higher because the child has more to do with the whole process.

mathanxiety · 21/01/2022 01:53

I'm a bit puzzled that people expect kids to be allowed to drift around Montessori classrooms doing whatever they please - child playing with sand for hours, for instance. Or avoiding art.

Montessori is supposed to involve a good deal of monitoring of children's engagement levels and interests and guidance by the teacher, and the development of self awareness on the part of the children. A Montessori classroom should be unobtrusively structured.

mathanxiety · 21/01/2022 01:44

@SpidersAreShitheads, please don't lump Steiner in with Montessori.

The two approaches could not be more different. They are poles apart in terms of aims, philosophy, and the plane on which they function.

Also, people flog the faceless wool felt fairies and dolls on Etsy for lots of money.

mathanxiety · 21/01/2022 01:37

One difference I have seen between Montessori kids and others when they get older - the Montessori students are much more in touch with themselves, conscious of their feelings, aware of their learning patterns and pace, and tend to be self starters.

unfollowme · 21/01/2022 01:14

My dc is a wild little thing and when picking a nursery I made sure it was a outdoorsy one especially with a huge garden. I also want dc to be exposed to some structure, rules and social cues in a playful engaging way. Of course a nursery is a nursery where they play, create, read, dance, pretend play but to me the nursery that was a right fit for my dc wasn't a Montessori.

He is a lone wolf (only child) and from the tours I have had with Montessori nurseries didn't feel it was a right fit for him because we provide that for him anyway at home when he plays and does his activities we let him lead and I think there are great ideas there where we have been incorporating it for ages but I believe the direct teaching approach is a much more better option for my dc anyway. I can't comment on anyone else though. I just know my child and I know he will thrive at a nursery and learn more with the techniques used in mainstream nurseries rather than Montessori.

BorsetshireBanality · 21/01/2022 00:22

I went to look at a Montessori setting for my DD. It was located in the upmarket naice bit of town with a very gushing brochure and expensive too.

I was disappointed to find it was in a building that looked like uncle Gerry had cobbled it together with bits scavenged from here and there. Inside there was a massive trip hazard.

The woman showing me around made a snide change comment about how my DD was dressed (because of temper tantrum it was shall we say a bit odd!)

But what really put me off was I spotted the DD of an acquaintance looking totally bored and unhappy with nothing to do and being ignored by the staff. So much for engaging with children.

It’s just another thing to squeeze money out of middle-class parents.

CatJumperTwat · 21/01/2022 00:05

Curlyreine Still waiting to hear how you can tell whether adults went to a Montessori nursery or not.

MammaBear18 · 20/01/2022 23:59

@WorkEvent

I have nothing against Montessori principals and tbh a lot of childcare settings have some aspect of these. Our nursery isn’t a ‘Montessori Nursery’ but is very child led, uses a lot of natural and/or ‘found’ resources, learning is ‘discovery led’ etc.

HOWEVER I find the Montessori, Grimms Rainbow owning, Frugi wearing brigade a bit… wanky and devoid of understanding of the real world. It’s like their way of parenting is the best and they can’t fathom how 22 year old Maria who lives in a council flat probably won’t be buying a Pikler Triangle but her child might be just as bright and well cared for.

Insta-eco huns and Montessori-inspired parents are two completely different breeds.
WorkEvent · 20/01/2022 13:30

I have nothing against Montessori principals and tbh a lot of childcare settings have some aspect of these. Our nursery isn’t a ‘Montessori Nursery’ but is very child led, uses a lot of natural and/or ‘found’ resources, learning is ‘discovery led’ etc.

HOWEVER I find the Montessori, Grimms Rainbow owning, Frugi wearing brigade a bit… wanky and devoid of understanding of the real world. It’s like their way of parenting is the best and they can’t fathom how 22 year old Maria who lives in a council flat probably won’t be buying a Pikler Triangle but her child might be just as bright and well cared for.

ancientgran · 20/01/2022 13:28

@3scape

The Nazis were big fans.
I did a bit of googling and I don't know how reliable the source is but according to this news.cision.com/goteborgs-universitet/r/research-sheds-light-on-montessori-s-collaboration-with-mussolini,c2376917 Montessori schools were banned by the Nazi in Germany in 1936. Apparently she collaborated with Mussolini until the war started and her pacifist views didn't sit well with them and they banned her as well.

Not sure which Nazis were big fans. I've never had anything to do with Montessori settings although I've heard of them, Steiner on the other hand I have had contact via a friend who sent her kids there and I can't say one positive thing about them.

Curlyreine · 20/01/2022 13:23

@AnakinthePadawhine

An acquaintance of mine is creating a Montessori nursery back home in France. She lets her baby/toddler poop on the floor because nappies were evil and forbids anybody to say no to him. She is also strongly and vocally anti-vaxx... You may want to see what the person in charge of your children thinks before you enroll them at high expenses...
In every setting. This is not montessori.
AnakinthePadawhine · 20/01/2022 12:36

An acquaintance of mine is creating a Montessori nursery back home in France. She lets her baby/toddler poop on the floor because nappies were evil and forbids anybody to say no to him. She is also strongly and vocally anti-vaxx... You may want to see what the person in charge of your children thinks before you enroll them at high expenses...

Kanaloa · 20/01/2022 12:24

But regardless I still thing balance is the golden word. A good nursery knows that a strict adherence to one form of learning won’t suit all children. That’s why the eyfs is so focused on extending learning based on the individual child’s interests.

Swipe left for the next trending thread