Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GCSE grades

193 replies

UndertheCedartree · 18/01/2022 22:25

My DS is studying GCSE Maths and English at college. I'm just trying to figure out if he is doing ok as we haven't had much feedback. In the latest mock tests he got a level 4. He only started in September but will be taking the exams this Summer. What kind of grade could he be expected to get in his GCSE exams?

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:49

@cantkeepawayforever

Entering students for GCSEs repeatedly to get higher and higher grades used to be a thing, used by schools to 'play' the league tables.

Schools stopped doing this because the rules on league tables were changed so that a student's FIRST grade counted, whether or not they retook them later.

This is likely to be different for a college, where the metric is different and where GCSE league tables won't be such a key driver. Thus for your child - almost uniquely - retaking may well be a way forward, as long as next year's teaching is progressive, building on this year, rather than him just restarting the course again with a fresh set of students.

There is definitely a Y10 and Y11 class. I would want to know that it wasn't just a focus on getting a 5 rather than reaching their full potential, though.
OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 19/01/2022 16:47

Many of these 'low grade' students won't get as far as taking the exams, so won't feature in the headline league tables.

Best case scenario for schools is to have them all stay for critical 'counting' days, having completed a long enough 'qualifying period', but then not be entered for or take the exams.

UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:46

@cantkeepawayforever

Why would a 6th form want to take on a student they think will get low grades?

Because if they are on roll on census day and have completed a 'qualifying period', they will get money. Even if the student doesn't complete the course.

Yes, that makes sense and if they drop out the grades won't affect their league tables.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:44

@Comefromaway

Why would a 6th form want to take on a student they think will get low grades?

Funding. Bums on seats means the courses run/the 6th form stays open.

Ah, ok. I didn't think they'd want bad results on their league tables or whatever they are!
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:42

@Dontfuckingsaycheese

I do apologise *@UndertheCedartree*. I think when I read earlier it was a class of year 10s and 11s I assumed that they weren’t a class full of first timers. I didn’t realise your son was in a specific class for home-edders and you weren’t just talking about his circs! I reckon he’ll be golden love. Sounds like you’ve got it covered English wise 🙂 With all your Eng Lit back up from home I reckon that college grade could fly by summer! Similar language analysis skills etc. One of the key issues in the Language GCSE is knowing what is required for each type of question. It’s so blimming specific!! I’m sure they’re covering all that. Hope all goes well 🤗
Thank you! And thank you for all the advice. I think exam technique is going to be key.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:39

[quote Dottyteapot]@UndertheCedartree yes you’re right, I missed that he wanted to do A-levels. Most home educators are just happy with the pass GCSE result and tend to go on to trade/manual work or work for themselves.[/quote]
Really? I didn't know that. My DS's friendship group all want to go to university.

OP posts:
irregularegular · 19/01/2022 16:38

Most home educators are just happy with the pass GCSE result and tend to go on to trade/manual work or work for themselves.

Are you sure about that?? I don't have any data, and my sample may be biased, but none of the home educated that I know have gone onto trade/manual work etc. They've all gone onto A-levels and university.

UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:38

@MrsAvocet

I agree with LadyLazarus40 Where I live, there is effectively a 2 tier 6th form system as the higher performing schools, despite being technically non selective have entry requirements for A level courses which are applied fairly ruthlessly. They can afford to, because they are oversubscribed, with both their own pupils and pupils from other schools competing for 6th form places which are no longer subject to the constraints of catchment areas etc. My son's school requires 5s for maths and english language regardless of the A levels chosen and at least 6, 7 for some courses, in the subjects selected for A level. It is possible to go elsewhere with lower grades and I'm sure some of those pupils do just fine, but the results are generally not as good at the less sought after schools with lower entry requirements. Obviously it won't be the same everywhere, but I doubt we're unique, so I think the advice to look at outcomes for pupils who start A levels with those minimum requirements is very sound, Also, if I recall rightly, when my older son was applying for Universities, most, if not all, required 5s for maths and english language at GCSE, as well as their specific A level requirements. I know that there are often alternatives for students who haven't followed an entirely traditional educational path though so it's probably worth looking at the kind of courses he's interested in and seeing what would be expected. I wonder if exam technique could be an issue? Pupils who have had a traditional schooling to date will be very used (too used perhaps) to sitting exams and there is a definite skill to it, beyond just knowing the content. It might be that, at least to some degree, your DS needs to improve his exam technique to boost his grades rather than that he doesn't know the work well enough. Best of luck to him - I hope everything turns out well.
Thank you so much and thanks for the useful advice.
OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 19/01/2022 16:36

Entering students for GCSEs repeatedly to get higher and higher grades used to be a thing, used by schools to 'play' the league tables.

Schools stopped doing this because the rules on league tables were changed so that a student's FIRST grade counted, whether or not they retook them later.

This is likely to be different for a college, where the metric is different and where GCSE league tables won't be such a key driver. Thus for your child - almost uniquely - retaking may well be a way forward, as long as next year's teaching is progressive, building on this year, rather than him just restarting the course again with a fresh set of students.

UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:35

@cantkeepawayforever

I am fully aware of what subjects/grades he needs for A levels.

I appreciate that you do know about the 'on paper' requirement. Have you also looked at it the other way - what A-level results a pupil with particular GCSE results might expect in each subject? It sounds as if you are possibly pitching your - and his - expectations at a 'basic minimum', rather than aiming for 'the best possible stepping stone for further study'.

I know it on paper but have also spoken to 6th forms and discussed our situation. I think I may have given the impression he is aiming for the minimum just because everyone kept telling me he would need this or that grade to do A levels when that is not the case at our local schools. I hope that he reaches his potential whatever that may be. But, I will definitely be asking that question as it makes a lot of sense to be aware of.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:31

@cantkeepawayforever

Could he also do the English language as an external candidate if you teach him that as well? Or is the college course an important stepping stone to a non home-schooled 6th form, as much for the process as for the results?

(Home-schooled DS when he was quite little, and know that there can be a whole range of reasons for both entering and exiting that particular world)

Yes, the college is a stepping stone for him in that way.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:30

@cantkeepawayforever

It seems odd to me that you think he is on course for a 7+ in English Literature taught at home, but only on a 4 at college for English Language. Have I misunderstood? Is it a question of exam technique, the way he interprets the world as non-NT? Or is it that the college is pitching its course at 'just ticking that basic box' by virtue of this cohort? Is there a straight 2 year option at college which aims for higher grades?
I know what is he is course for at home as obviously I'm fully aware of what is happening at home! As for college I have no idea what he is actually heading for after a years study but his first results tested in September he got a 4 in both. Then in the November test for Eng Lang he got a 4 but almost 5. Not had result for Maths. I was interested to see what sort of progress is expected on a very general level. I'm not sure exactly how the college are pitching things, although I understand they can take the GCSE exams again in Y11. One poster said that was standard at her DC's school so may just be a different approach I need to learn about. In terms of the way he interprets the world - that seems to have an effect with Maths but not so much English.
OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 19/01/2022 16:27

Why would a 6th form want to take on a student they think will get low grades?

Because if they are on roll on census day and have completed a 'qualifying period', they will get money. Even if the student doesn't complete the course.

Comefromaway · 19/01/2022 16:24

Why would a 6th form want to take on a student they think will get low grades?

Funding. Bums on seats means the courses run/the 6th form stays open.

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 19/01/2022 16:21

I do apologise @UndertheCedartree. I think when I read earlier it was a class of year 10s and 11s I assumed that they weren’t a class full of first timers. I didn’t realise your son was in a specific class for home-edders and you weren’t just talking about his circs! I reckon he’ll be golden love. Sounds like you’ve got it covered English wise 🙂 With all your Eng Lit back up from home I reckon that college grade could fly by summer! Similar language analysis skills etc. One of the key issues in the Language GCSE is knowing what is required for each type of question. It’s so blimming specific!! I’m sure they’re covering all that. Hope all goes well 🤗

UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:21

@cantkeepawayforever

IME, requirements like 'Grade 5 in Maths and English' exist because sixth forms want to be able to admit e.g. fantastic English, French and Drama students who won't get more than that minimum in Maths; or conversely Maths, Further Maths and computer science students who just need to 'tick the boxes' in English.

If a student has 5s across the board, including in subjects where the A-level content and skills build on those from GCSE, then as I have said, it is likely that grades obtained at A-level will be very low if a student gets that far.

Why would a 6th form want to take on a student they think will get low grades?
OP posts:
Dottyteapot · 19/01/2022 16:20

@UndertheCedartree yes you’re right, I missed that he wanted to do A-levels. Most home educators are just happy with the pass GCSE result and tend to go on to trade/manual work or work for themselves.

UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:17

@Comefromaway

Very few schools, whether grammar or private, allow students to do 4 A levels since the reforms, unless it is Maths & Further Maths as universities offer on 3 and there is too much risk of dropping a grade.
Schools must differ so much in different areas. When we looked at local 6th forms there are lots offering 4 A levels. Personally, I think 3 is enough.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:15

@Dontfuckingsaycheese

So he’s doing English Lit GCSE with you and just sitting the exam as an external candidate and English Language GCSE at college?? Is that correct *@UndertheCedartree*?
He's doing GCSE English Language, GCSE Maths plus a vocational course at college. He is currently studying GCSE Eng Lit and GCSE Sociology at home plus other home-ed (non- GCSE) classes.
OP posts:
MrsAvocet · 19/01/2022 16:11

I agree with LadyLazarus40
Where I live, there is effectively a 2 tier 6th form system as the higher performing schools, despite being technically non selective have entry requirements for A level courses which are applied fairly ruthlessly. They can afford to, because they are oversubscribed, with both their own pupils and pupils from other schools competing for 6th form places which are no longer subject to the constraints of catchment areas etc. My son's school requires 5s for maths and english language regardless of the A levels chosen and at least 6, 7 for some courses, in the subjects selected for A level. It is possible to go elsewhere with lower grades and I'm sure some of those pupils do just fine, but the results are generally not as good at the less sought after schools with lower entry requirements. Obviously it won't be the same everywhere, but I doubt we're unique, so I think the advice to look at outcomes for pupils who start A levels with those minimum requirements is very sound,
Also, if I recall rightly, when my older son was applying for Universities, most, if not all, required 5s for maths and english language at GCSE, as well as their specific A level requirements. I know that there are often alternatives for students who haven't followed an entirely traditional educational path though so it's probably worth looking at the kind of courses he's interested in and seeing what would be expected.
I wonder if exam technique could be an issue? Pupils who have had a traditional schooling to date will be very used (too used perhaps) to sitting exams and there is a definite skill to it, beyond just knowing the content. It might be that, at least to some degree, your DS needs to improve his exam technique to boost his grades rather than that he doesn't know the work well enough. Best of luck to him - I hope everything turns out well.

UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:10

@LadyLazarus40 - thank you for that information.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:09

@Dontfuckingsaycheese

Yep kind of - gives us a baseline to show later progress and helps inform planning somewhat. Of course all students are different so gaps in knowledge pop up all over the shop!

Some are saying redo next year too. I mentioned funding. You need to check that. Yes it may be possible to pay and redo the exam to improve on a 4. But that would depend on the college being willing to accept as an external candidate. No guarantee. Also, that would mean he doesn’t get another year’s teaching if he has that 4 already. You might have to pay. This does depend on his age though. There may be different funding for under 16s. But FE funding rules for post 16 are incredibly tight.

Oh no - the course is definitely funded for the 2 years and they can retake in the 2nd year if necessary.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:07

@cantkeepawayforever

I think a question you should ask potential sixth forms is 'What A-level grades do students who have the minimum admissions grades at GCSE typically obtain?' [or you could ask for data by subject, so 'What grades do students who arrive with a 5 in this subject typically get at A-level?'

You might find that students who arrive with 5s typically leave with Ds or so at A-level (except in maths, where it will be lower still, if they are allowed to start the subject at all). If that isn't what you see your child as aiming for eventually, you may want to work backwards, thinking 'well, if I think my child is capable of getting a B at A-level, what GCSE grade would put him on target for that?'

It is difficult to predict with a ND, home-educated child, but it is probably a sensible 'reality check' in terms of the grades that an able child should be aiming for at this point to be on track for A-levels sufficient for their next step.

Thank you - that is a good question.
OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 19/01/2022 16:04

[quote toomuchlaundry]@Dontfuckingsaycheese I assume that is how they can have a mock in the first 2 weeks, as it is for students who have already studied the content[/quote]
No, it is not. It is a class for 14-16 yo. I think the 'mock' was actually a baseline test. Of course some of the DC will have done some study at GCSE level as they have the flexibility within home ed - my DS has. However this course presumes no prior knowledge of GCSE content.

OP posts:
cantkeepawayforever · 19/01/2022 16:04

I am fully aware of what subjects/grades he needs for A levels.

I appreciate that you do know about the 'on paper' requirement. Have you also looked at it the other way - what A-level results a pupil with particular GCSE results might expect in each subject? It sounds as if you are possibly pitching your - and his - expectations at a 'basic minimum', rather than aiming for 'the best possible stepping stone for further study'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread