Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have just drained the joint savings account?

389 replies

JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 20:31

Had an argument with DH this evening about money.

We have separate accounts and a joint savings account. I don't feel he contributes enough to the household, he thinks he does.

The joint savings account only I ever pay into. Literally I think he's paid about £30 into it our entire marriage.

However whenever I say we need to pay for X can you send me X for it he'll say "you've got money in the savings account" rather than just contribute himself.

It pisses me off because I guess I see the money in the savings account as mine considering I'm the only one who pays into it so using it just feels like me basically paying for everything still.

So tonight I've drained it. I've put it all in a savings account in my name only and when he says use the savings I'm going to tell him there's none left.

He'll be pissed I'm sure as we were saving up for some stuff but I'm sick of it.

OP posts:
BillMasen · 19/01/2022 07:59

I think a lot of people aren’t reading properly

Each pays roughly the same (yes op a bit more but we don’t know how much)

One of the ops costs in this calc is the joint savings, so it’s par of her “the same” costs

She thinks of it as her savings when in fact, it is joint. It’s been part of her responsibility to pay (an overall equal amount) and so using it to pay for things is right.

Fwiw I do agree that one paying fixed bills and the other variable isn’t really fair, I’d go down the joint “bills account “ route tbh, but those posters calling him tight, a cocklodger etc are either not understanding the money, or don’t care

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 19/01/2022 07:59

DH-our funding of our lives is unfair. We earn the same but I pay … more than you. I have no money left for anything extras each month-unlike you, who has … left. We either sort things properly with the joint account with both putting equal amounts in to pay for everything and you step up with this or we will have bigger problems and you will have more to sort out when you are looking for somewhere else to live

ThinkingtheUnthinkable · 19/01/2022 07:58

You need to get this sorted a.s.a.p. as energy bills will shoot up very shortly.

The savings are already yours, you're not draining the joint savings.

Do a projected budget (include the anticipated rise in gas/electricity prices). Insist that each of you pays an identical monthly amount in to the joint account (hopefully it's still open even if unused).

How is he spending on himself if he has no PIN number for his card. Is it all online purchases and contactless ? How does he get cash ?

If he's paying the mortgage, are you sure your name is on the mortgage/deeds ?

Starting point is a household expenditure budget including everything, mortgage, childcare, pension payments, life insurance, utilities, TV licence/broadband/landline/sky/virgin/netflix etc, shopping, pet costs (if applicable). It might be a smart move to draw it up yourself and then ask him to "Look it over to see if I've missed anything" but don't let him minimise/reduce any of the projected costs. Prices are are the way up inflation wise so add 3% to everything in anticipation of that.

When it's there in black and white, insist on a sit down discussion over a glass of wine/nice meal and do not be diverted from reaching a conclusion that £X amount is needing to be put in to the joint account each month to cover joint expenses.

Right now he's financially abusing you and it won't get any better unless you nip it in the bud.

PersonaNonGarter · 19/01/2022 07:58

It’s so weird how women don’t get more angry.

stuntbubbles · 19/01/2022 07:57

If you have a joint account why aren’t both your incomes going into it and all bills being payed out of it?
OP has explained this: her DH literally won’t do it. She can’t force him to tell his work the joint account details and get his income paid into it. She could update the mortgage direct debit and other household bills to the joint account, but that would only screw her over if he literally won’t budge and send one (1) email to HR updating where his income should land.

I think it’s really telling that you have to nag him and remind him every month for his half of the nursery fees; he should have a standing order to you for his half. He is hoarding money.

Not actually against separate finances over here: it works for us! I came into the relationship with a lot more assets than DP, so we’re not married and have a deed of trust on the house to protect my deposit. We pay proportionally based on income split. And I’m much tighter than he is. But the key is trust and generosity and honesty: the idea of DP begrudging our child a birthday present and telling me to take it from savings! We both know exactly what the other has and where we as a family stand financially. It sounds like OP has no idea what her DH has.

I’m glad you retrieved your savings, OP. I’d be stashing them into a S&S ISA to grow and create a LTB fund for the future should you eventually need it. Maybe not yet, maybe not if DH sorts this out, but potentially.

RedskyThisNight · 19/01/2022 07:54

@thedarkling

How does he actually spend any money if he doesn't have a bank card?
OP says he's "forgotten the PIN", so he is probably using it for online shopping and has his details saved.
thedarkling · 19/01/2022 07:52

@knittingaddict doesn't matter if not married either if the house is in joint names. If it's just in his name and they're not married it's a problem whoever pays it!

coodawoodashooda · 19/01/2022 07:52

@Matbest

If your relationship is otherwise good and this is a financial situation, I think you need a new set up.

Sit down together and list all bills and outgoings for each month including grocery budget and a small buffer for unexpected things. If you get child benefit for your 1 year old that should be enough to cover if they need a new coat or shoes or whatever. Divide it by 2.

Open a joint current account and each of you pay 50% of the family outgoings into it on pay day. All direct debits, bills and grocery money comes out of the joint account. Anything that is left in your individual accounts is yours to do what you want with.

When it comes to savings, you need to agree on an amount and set up a direct debit that is the same as each others. Keep your own savings account for you, and start a fresh with the joint one.

How csn any relationship be good when you are being so disrespected? Op you wouldn't keep overinvesting in anything else that kept letting you down. Why do the same with him?
GoodnightGrandma · 19/01/2022 07:49

He doesn’t sound like a keeper, I’d be chucking him back in.

MintyGreenDream · 19/01/2022 07:47

What does he spend his spare money on?

BarbaraofSeville · 19/01/2022 07:47

^don't know how people exist like this!*
In this house, his money AND my money is our money. One pot. No arguments^

This is fine if you're both on the same page with spending and sensible with money.

Not so much if either of you see an account with money in and thinks 'what can I buy' because then you've got one person buying nice things for themselves, while the other is struggling to buy underwear and watching the mortgage payment bounce.

Frazzled2207 · 19/01/2022 07:45

He sounds like a petulant child tbh.

He pays for literally three things plus half the nursery fees? You can estimate that really easily

List all the things you have paid for in the last month. Obviously will be a lot more. Spell it out to him how much more.

If he still “can’t be arsed” to switch his direct debits to a joint account so that everything is fairer then I’d be leaving him tbh.

As for not being able to use his bank card because he’s lost the pin. Lazy idiot.

You do need to have a proper discussion with him though rather than just pocketing the savings.

Matbest · 19/01/2022 07:40

If your relationship is otherwise good and this is a financial situation, I think you need a new set up.

Sit down together and list all bills and outgoings for each month including grocery budget and a small buffer for unexpected things. If you get child benefit for your 1 year old that should be enough to cover if they need a new coat or shoes or whatever. Divide it by 2.

Open a joint current account and each of you pay 50% of the family outgoings into it on pay day. All direct debits, bills and grocery money comes out of the joint account. Anything that is left in your individual accounts is yours to do what you want with.

When it comes to savings, you need to agree on an amount and set up a direct debit that is the same as each others. Keep your own savings account for you, and start a fresh with the joint one.

sHREDDIES19 · 19/01/2022 07:40

I think separate and joint finances can both work but this set up doesn’t work for you as you feel resentful. My dh and I have never had a joint account, didn’t really feel the need. Over the years circumstances have changed where he earned more, then me but we’ve just taken various direct debits each and bought stuff as and when needed. Although we have separate accounts the key point is we see ourselves as a unit and the monies belong to us both. There is no resentment.

JustDanceAddict · 19/01/2022 07:39

@StoneofDestiny

I don't know how people exist like this! In this house, his money AND my money is our money. One pot. No arguments

Likewise

Same - we have separate savings but don’t really use them. Dh is a bit more ‘with it’ as far as financial planning is concerned but we both know exactly what we have. Whatever our job/financial situation we pay in/out of it together.
1AngelicFruitCake · 19/01/2022 07:37

@k1233

I'd be non negotiable on him transferring a set amount to the joint account monthly. If it's too hard for him, get him to open his bank app and do it for him.

Work out all costs, including mortgage and what he pays for now. You pay an amount to match his direct debit to the joint account. Divide the rest by two and that's what you both put in to the joint account.

Only shop etc using that account and when there's no funds, don't proffer your own if he won't step up.

This is what I think you should do.

We do this so once the joint account is empty we start splitting the excess spending e.g. meals out, stuff for the house.
I also used to get really annoyed that I was the only one saving so now we both have a standing order to our savings account each month.

knittingaddict · 19/01/2022 07:37

@helenabonhamfarter

I'm worried by the comment that he pays the mortgage. I hope that doesn't put you in a precarious position in the future.
Shouldn't make the slightest bit of difference if the op is married, which I assume she is because she used "dh". It's a marital asset and who pays wouldn't matter.
middleeasternpromise · 19/01/2022 07:33

But you haven't drained the joint savings account because it was never joint. You've just stopped showing him one aspect of where your money goes. It is a good signal that you do not want to work with the current arrangement. The next step depends on how much you are prepared to allow the real picture to emerge if you decide to balance the contributions. One option is to match your husbands contributions - what ever they are, and put the rest of your income elsewhere. When its spent its spent. Then you both have to top up.

Having been in this situation, I suspect your small act of resistance will not bring about a resolution as fundamentally you are dealing with someone who has not signed up to the family responsibility. He is keeping his life simple and passing on the family work to you. Is this apparent in other non monetary aspects of the relationship? eg the child care, the house work, the property maintenance; the management of social and family engagements??

eldora · 19/01/2022 07:33

He can't even use his bank card (forgot the pin years ago). But he never needs to because I pay for everything (other than his direct debits).

OP, you just know this I isn’t out of laziness but a deliberate ploy to make you pay for everything?

Presumably he goes to the bank to withdraw cash? It would take 2 minutes to order a new PIN.

JustDanceAddict · 19/01/2022 07:32

Yuck all round.
I don’t get this separate account thing if you’re married - are you? I feel it’s a real control thing when the husband gives the wife ‘an allowance’ - are we in the 1950s or 2020s?
If you’re not married then I would sit down with your dh and work out an even 50/50 split if you both earn the same (and I bet you do most of the childcare & housework too). If he’s resistant to this I’d be thinking wtf.

Good luck.

eldora · 19/01/2022 07:31

@thedarkling

If it's a joint mortgage (and so the house is in joint names) it really doesn't matter which account the money's coming from.
It can matter actually.

Should they divorce, the husband has an established history of paying a mortgage solely from his account. This will help him get a new mortgage approved in his name only.

OP has no history of paying the mortgage from her own account.

OP, I would strongly urge you to get a joint account set up, have his transfer money there every ninth, and you pay the mortgage from your own account.

ohthejoys · 19/01/2022 07:29

Definitely sounds like you need a new financial plan as a couple. Joint account for all household bills is a must. Then a savings account you both contribute to for bigger items that take time to fund, like new sofas or holidays. Then an account for your child’s needs, to cover all his clothes, toys, gifts etc, with whatever’s left building up as a small ‘savings’ towards higher costs as he grows, like school uniforms and first bikes etc. Whatever is left after that is your own! That way you both know where you stand and contribute equally and your child is protected too.

thedarkling · 19/01/2022 07:28

If it's a joint mortgage (and so the house is in joint names) it really doesn't matter which account the money's coming from.

thedarkling · 19/01/2022 07:27

How does he actually spend any money if he doesn't have a bank card?

eldora · 19/01/2022 07:20

OP, here is what we do:

  • £1,000 automatically transfers from my account and £1,000 from DH’s account on the 27th of each month to a joint account
  • mortgage, council tax, all bills, food shopping is taken from that account joint account each month
  • the account has also built up some extra (£2,000 +) so it also pays for any emergencies

DH pays for his own car insurance, road tax etc

I pay for my own car insurance road tax etc

I have my own savings, DH has his own savings

If we want to make a big purchase (holiday etc), we each pay half.

I think a similar model would work for our whilst you are both earning the same.

What happened when you were on maternity leave? I’m guessing he still expected you to pay the bills?