Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have just drained the joint savings account?

389 replies

JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 20:31

Had an argument with DH this evening about money.

We have separate accounts and a joint savings account. I don't feel he contributes enough to the household, he thinks he does.

The joint savings account only I ever pay into. Literally I think he's paid about £30 into it our entire marriage.

However whenever I say we need to pay for X can you send me X for it he'll say "you've got money in the savings account" rather than just contribute himself.

It pisses me off because I guess I see the money in the savings account as mine considering I'm the only one who pays into it so using it just feels like me basically paying for everything still.

So tonight I've drained it. I've put it all in a savings account in my name only and when he says use the savings I'm going to tell him there's none left.

He'll be pissed I'm sure as we were saving up for some stuff but I'm sick of it.

OP posts:
RandomLondoner · 19/01/2022 09:04

Being married means you own all assets and money together. You're one financial unit. That's what being married sodding well means! It's a contract between two people to share all their assets

I can see why anyone who has listened to wedding vows would think this, but it's not true at all, in England anyway. Any money that's in an account in your own name is 100% yours to do with as you like. Also, you are not legally responsible for your partners debts.

RebeccasoldercousinSusie · 19/01/2022 09:04

You need to write a list of your outgoings and work out a fair system. If you are paying significantly more you can highlight this. Right now you aren’t able to quantify it.

If his direct debits add up to more than you pay, then you paying into savings makes sense. If they don’t, then he also needs to contribute.

BridStar · 19/01/2022 08:57

Never combine finances. Never pay for a freeloader. Don't marry them either.

Skeumorph · 19/01/2022 08:56

Well if he's not contributed, they're your savings. So you can put them where you like. You have this cash, he has whatever he spunked his wages on, eh?

Now comes the change.

Tell him from now on, it's a joint account, which you both move the majority of your wages to, on standing order, same amount. Everything comes out of this - bills, food, child stuff, everyday expenses. EVERYTHING.

Then pack a bag, get your child and tell him you're going to stay with family and you'll be back when it is done, because the time for pissing around and snaking about to pay less is OVER.

That really is the only way you are going to get across that you won't take it - by NOT TAKING IT.

You and your bank account are elsewhere and you won't be paying for jack shit until it's fair.

cleocleo81 · 19/01/2022 08:55

Why don't you ask him to set up a standing order for half the nursery fees so they always come out and a standing order for x amount to go into the savings account as soon as he is paid?

AChocolateCoin · 19/01/2022 08:53

I thought that now it was very easy to transfer all direct debits to a new account, don't the bank do it all for you? So simple.

I would definitely look into transferring all his direct debits into the joint account and also sit down and show him all the money you spend throughout every month. Completely unfair of him to have money for just him whilst you are funding everyone.

RandomLondoner · 19/01/2022 08:52

This set up - man pays fixed bills, woman pays variable bills like shopping, child stuff etc - is ALWAYS ALWAYS unfair on the woman.

I am the man in such an arrangement. Over a long marriage, DW has paid just under a quarter of joint outgoings. (I pay her back for half of shopping, which is why I have records of how much it is.)

jackstini · 19/01/2022 08:52

You seriously need to sit down and do a spreadsheet to work out what you are spending

List all direct debits
Go through bank/credit card statements for food/clothes etc.
Consider annual costs like insurance and holidays

Work out the current amounts for you both

Do you have access to all the accounts?
Tell him you are moving everything into one account
It's a bit of a pain I know, but not that difficult and will be 100% worth it to avoid all the issues you have now

I would be tearing my hair out!

CeceBerry · 19/01/2022 08:51

A lot of posters are giving the OP really great advice about how to change things......but they are not reading what she has been posting. The ‘D’h doesn’t want to change.

I honestly don’t know how you’re going to fix this - tally up both monthly expenses but will he actually go into his account and tell you how much he’s spent on the bills? Seems like he can’t be arsed. Or as you said start acting like him and say you don’t have money.

oviraptor21 · 19/01/2022 08:41

Yep - echoing PP.
Do a spreadsheet for all the outgoings and show him.
Then insist on a joint account. Agree an amount each.
He then has to do two things - he can manage this, he's a big boy - set up standing order into the joint account, and transfer the mortgage DD to it.
If he refused to do this or didn't offer a satisfactory alternative (not sure there is one but you may be) it would be a deal breaker for me as it would show how little respect he has for you.

Dontwanttolivewithmylover · 19/01/2022 08:39

Good on yer, girl.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 19/01/2022 08:37

What does he spend his spare money on?

Yes I'd like to know this as well.

I think different systems work for different relationships and providing neither party feels hard done by it's fine. But this situation sounds mad to me. Being unwilling to change things when one person is pissed off with it is either lazy or showing you exactly how they feel about you, only the OP can answer that.

But the card pin number issue would drive me mad. How does he pay for stuff when he's out and about and you're not with him OP? Petrol? The odd coffee or snack? A takeaway? I'd be suspicious that he hasn't forgotten it at all and is just using it as an excuse to get you to pay. Maybe he's spent all his money on other stuff and his account is almost empty? Have you actually seen his bank statements lately?

user1471538283 · 19/01/2022 08:37

The bit that annoys me is that he sees it as your responsibility. He pays what he thinks is his bit and everything else is for you. You have to make sure there is money for bread and milk.

I'd suggest swapping if he is feeling so hard done by. I would also only save into my account and when something needs doing/paying tell him there is no money.

What is he spending his money on?

mogschristmascalamity · 19/01/2022 08:35

Joint account for all bills. Both people get paid into own account and have SO set up to transfer a set amount each month leaving the same amount in own personal accounts (we have £250 in our own accounts, rest goes to joint).

Any surplus from joint goes to savings at end of month.

Its the only way to do it fairly.

JohnnyEyebrows · 19/01/2022 08:33

You've had previous threads about this haven't you? Is this the bloke with the older child who you were posting about earlier?

You know it's not a fair split but you've got bigger issues than just the money. The advice is the same no matter how often you post about the situation,

Mix56 · 19/01/2022 08:31

The joint account isn't joint, its yours. Bar £30,
You are perfectly entitled to keep it, in the same way he keeps the remainder after his direct debits.
So in future when you need something extra you will both have to share the cost
I had this happen to me, I used my birthday money from my parents to keep the housekeeping afloat, while he squirreled away his savings.
He is happy to build up his nest egg, while you spend all your money on the family. Time for you to have your own savings. You may need them

Jumpingintomenopause · 19/01/2022 08:28

@JointAccountBye

He can't even use his bank card (forgot the pin years ago). But he never needs to because I pay for everything (other than his direct debits).
I’m confused, if he can’t withdraw money/use his pin, does he have quite a bit saved in his account or does he literally earn enough to cover his direct debits?
BillMasen · 19/01/2022 08:27

@NoSquirrels op says it’s about even. She pays slightly more

She’s given no figures but says that, and her share includes the savings payment. Hence it’s joint.

You’re betting it’s different based on what? Op has said it’s the same so why disregard that?

TheChemicalMother · 19/01/2022 08:26

Change the way you manage your joint household expenses.

Have a joint account from which ALL household and family expenses are paid. From mortgage to meals out. Pay in an equal amount, to easily cover your monthly costs, plus a good contingency. Have a household savings account for annual costs (e.g boiler service) and emergencies (new boiler).

Set up a standing order from each of your accounts to transfer money to the joint household account the day after payday.

Set up a joint savings account with an agreed amount to be saved each month and sound by standing order either from the household accounts or your sole accounts.

Money leftover; yours to spend / save as you each wish.

Sort out a better money management system like this, rather than seethe and take to passive aggressive war fare. Your current system supports his general obliviousness and your martyrdom.

NoSquirrels · 19/01/2022 08:14

@BillMasen

I think a lot of people aren’t reading properly

Each pays roughly the same (yes op a bit more but we don’t know how much)

One of the ops costs in this calc is the joint savings, so it’s par of her “the same” costs

She thinks of it as her savings when in fact, it is joint. It’s been part of her responsibility to pay (an overall equal amount) and so using it to pay for things is right.

Fwiw I do agree that one paying fixed bills and the other variable isn’t really fair, I’d go down the joint “bills account “ route tbh, but those posters calling him tight, a cocklodger etc are either not understanding the money, or don’t care

I don’t know how this could possibly be true that their monetary contribution is roughly equal if he pays only £450 mortgage plus one or two other small bills.

We earn the same.

They aren't split 100% evenly but it works out that I pay slightly more than him. He pays the mortgage and a couple of small bills from his, I pay the rest of the bills and ALL of the shopping and ALL of our sons costs like clothes etc .. and put money in the savings.

£450 plus, generously, £100 extra.
If the whole household costs, including clothes for growing baby etc are £1,000, that’s fine.

But I bet it’s not.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 19/01/2022 08:12

If I have understood correctly you earn around the same so the joint account should be about 50-50 with some extra to cover unforeseen items.

Work out what you need for food and bills and then add eg an extra £100 a month on each. So if you need £2000 a month you each pay in £1000.

I prefer a joint account for bills and my own account for my own spending and so does DH, we don't have a problem with separate finances as far as that goes. But joint things need to be paid for jointly and in proportion with earnings.

alwayswrighty · 19/01/2022 08:07

@eldora

Should they divorce, the husband has an established history of paying a mortgage solely from his account. This will help him get a new mortgage approved in his name only

Being a mortgage adviser I can categorically tell you that is bullshit. Lenders go off credit files. If the OP is on the mortgage and its being paid in full monthly they won't look further. If in relation to divorce the starting stance is 50/50 now and if OP is not on the property and mortgage she can get a matrimonial home rights added legally to land registry.

Guineapigssweak · 19/01/2022 08:05

From your post it looks like you are paying a lot more out . Sit down and work it all out and I bet your be sadly surprised at how unequal your finances are. Sounds like you need to rethink your future.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 19/01/2022 08:03

[quote Conspiracyornotr]@JointAccountBye men don't think like us women do we think ahead they just happy when they got what need and want and.not bothered about house bills.or food. X[/quote]
It's the same as cats and dogs, if they had access to their own bank accounts, cats would just buy catnip and rubber mice to play with, whilst dogs would buy chocolate and make themselves sick, and a big bag of tennis balls.

This is why banks do not allow cats or dogs to open bank accounts.

BillMasen · 19/01/2022 08:02

@BarbaraofSeville

^don't know how people exist like this!* In this house, his money AND my money is our money. One pot. No arguments^

This is fine if you're both on the same page with spending and sensible with money.

Not so much if either of you see an account with money in and thinks 'what can I buy' because then you've got one person buying nice things for themselves, while the other is struggling to buy underwear and watching the mortgage payment bounce.

I do agree with this

Joint everything isn’t the way for me. The saver saves, the spender spends then relies on the savings for emergencies. Not fair