Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have just drained the joint savings account?

389 replies

JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 20:31

Had an argument with DH this evening about money.

We have separate accounts and a joint savings account. I don't feel he contributes enough to the household, he thinks he does.

The joint savings account only I ever pay into. Literally I think he's paid about £30 into it our entire marriage.

However whenever I say we need to pay for X can you send me X for it he'll say "you've got money in the savings account" rather than just contribute himself.

It pisses me off because I guess I see the money in the savings account as mine considering I'm the only one who pays into it so using it just feels like me basically paying for everything still.

So tonight I've drained it. I've put it all in a savings account in my name only and when he says use the savings I'm going to tell him there's none left.

He'll be pissed I'm sure as we were saving up for some stuff but I'm sick of it.

OP posts:
Lifeisforalimitedperiodonly · 19/01/2022 19:48

If he won't open a joint account and pay his salary into it, just swap. You pay the mortgage and the few direct debits. Then organise everything else, all the insurances, car finance, council tax etc to come out of his.

Thehop · 19/01/2022 19:48

@Ohsugarhoneyicetea

OP you need to work it out properly, write it down. He's paying what £525 /month (mortgage plus internet & mobile) and you are paying (as a general guess)

council tax (£150?), gas and electric (£160?), water (30) house insurance (30), pet insurance (15), boiler insurance (20), car finance (180), all shopping (450), everything for our son (50), absolutely anything else (50). I guess all household replacements repairs etc too?

So based on those pretty average costs for a 3 bed semi you're paying £1100 per month, more than double him.

Stick the actual figures under his nose & unless he apologises, refunds you and changes things to be fair immediately- you are with an abusive tosser who needs to be given marching orders.

This
Treacletoots · 19/01/2022 19:41

People don't ever "not realise" they're not paying their way. They know full well they're taking advantage of the very person they're supposed to care about.

Think about that. It sounds like sadly you've married my exH and if so, you'd be better looking whether long term you'd rather be with someone who doesn't think it's ok to take advantage of you.

BillMasen · 19/01/2022 19:41

@Tigger1895

Open a new account in your name only and direct the savings there. It won’t take long before you have drained the other account and then where will he be. Keep records of everything you pay for and after 3 months have another discussion. If he can’t be swayed you have a big problem in the future.
The savings that are joint and paid from the op’s equal contribution? So you’re saying she takes those and therefore contributes less than her share?
Purplepussycat · 19/01/2022 19:28

I always find these threads bizarre. Me and husband have a one joint account since we were 18. Anything we have both earned over the course of marriage is ours regardless of who ‘earns’ it.

Harmonypuss · 19/01/2022 19:25

I used to be in a similar situation, we earned approx the same but he also had some private work he did on the side and didn't declare, so he actually had almost half again.
We had our separate accounts and a bills account but he only paid approx 1/3 and I paid the other 2/3 of all the household bills, purely because he wouldn't have things like childcare, food, petrol connected with the bills account. I always paid for the food and childcare, we filled our own cars but if ever we went anywhere together, he would insist on us using my car and my petrol.
Fortunately, I came to my senses about 14yrs ago and now all my bills are mine but I have no-one to argue over them with, life may be more expensive for me but it's sooo much better.

Tigger1895 · 19/01/2022 19:12

Open a new account in your name only and direct the savings there. It won’t take long before you have drained the other account and then where will he be.
Keep records of everything you pay for and after 3 months have another discussion. If he can’t be swayed you have a big problem in the future.

Eggshausted · 19/01/2022 19:11

How much are you talking about? £500? £5000?

Darbs76 · 19/01/2022 19:01

Make him use a joint account, all he needs to do is tell his employer and the 2 companies. That’s not going to take long, just do it for him if needs be

keeptheaspidistra · 19/01/2022 18:59

[quote Conspiracyornotr]@JointAccountBye men don't think like us women do we think ahead they just happy when they got what need and want and.not bothered about house bills.or food. X[/quote]
Thank goodness this is sexist nonsense otherwise how on earth would gay couples cope without a woman to plan their lives

littlenickyy61 · 19/01/2022 18:56

If he feels he is paying more than you, offer to swap - you just pay the mortgage , internet and phone bill and he can do all the rest like you have been doing. A reluctance on his part to do this will show that he recognizes he is paying less but doesn't really care

Leedsfan247 · 19/01/2022 18:56

100%

Kaboomba · 19/01/2022 18:53

I think you need to sit down and set out all your bills and for one month keep all your receipts to calculate how much your actually paying out.

If you both earn the same surely it makes sense to split everything evenly and then anything left over is split between you both to share out. This way you treat savings as a bill and you don't feel like your the scape goat for everything!

MammaMacgill87 · 19/01/2022 18:53

I think you're probably unreasonable to have drained it rather than, sitting down reasonably and proving that the ingoings and out goings of the house are unequal. You say you think you pay more he thinks he pays more. Get the actual bills/expenses and actually prove your point. Then say regardless dear I'm not happy with how we are dealing with money right now we need to come up with a solution together. What you've actually done is have an argument then a kneejerk reaction of draining and renaming an account with the idea that you'll 'just tell him it's empty' next time something comes up. When something does come up you are definitely going to be the one paying because you absolutely have that spare money squirreled away in your name. Not only that you're going to have another row about how and why that's the case. This man is your partner and as much as he's being a pain you both deserve honesty especially when it comes to money because it does nothing but cause arguments and suspicion. If this is the way it's always been and it's only now you are finally bringing in it up because you feel it's unjust - this is the first he's hearing of it and in his mind it's all been ticking along nicely why is she all of a sudden making a fuss.
So get him sat down get all the evidence you need to prove your point and have an honest adult conversation, because otherwise I can see you needing that money an awful lot sooner than you thought when you have a massive row over finance's and one of you storms off 🤷🏻‍♀️

PuzzledObserver · 19/01/2022 18:51

My money is my money. We share a joint account for household bills and savings, but what I spend beyond that is up to me. I’m not having to explain to my husband what I bought on Amazon this week.

We both manage to buy things from Amazon, or elsewhere, from our joint account without feeling we need to account to each other for every penny. We have a similar attitude to money, so we both know that the other would not spend large sums on just themselves without checking it out first.

I have my own savings account for if anything happens, and I could walk away happy that my and my daughter’s future is secure if I needed to. Why on earth would I tie myself financially to someone else when no-one knows what might happen down the road?

I think you’ll find you did that when you got married.

If you did walk away, your DH could potentially go after whatever is in your account, as you could potentially go after any sole savings he’s got. That’s the law.

MrsOk · 19/01/2022 18:49

@BoredZelda

To be honest, this His and Her money gives me the ick, There should be one single household income

And here, I thought we had moved on from the 1950s.

My money is my money. We share a joint account for household bills and savings, but what I spend beyond that is up to me. I’m not having to explain to my husband what I bought on Amazon this week. I have my own savings account for if anything happens, and I could walk away happy that my and my daughter’s future is secure if I needed to. Why on earth would I tie myself financially to someone else when nobody knows what can happen down the road? How many times do women on here find themselves in a situation where they can’t walk away. Anyone who can build up their own account and chooses not to is putting themselves at risk.

This is what everyone should have. My husband and I have a joint current account and a joint savings account. We each contribute the same percentage of our take home pay into each account. This helps as sometimes he's earned more and sometimes I've earned more. Every single household bill and kids bill comes from the joint account. And some joint savings as well comes from the joint current account (if there is any money left unspent at the end of a month).

The balance is left in our personal accounts to do as we see fit. I save some into my personal savings and he does the same. The rest of the money is to spend however we please. If we have a big household expense that the joint account cannot cater to, like a big holiday, we each contribute half of the amount. Extra unexpected household expenses are also paid from the joint as we tend to fund it over the usual amount needed.

I think this way, a couple can do things jointly but also have the independence and freedom to spend their money on whatever they wish and how they wish without any questions.

Dramaticwithgoodreason · 19/01/2022 18:48

@Freecuthbert

In our house, every bit of income from both of us goes into one pot, which is then split into various pots including fair and equal spending money for each of us. There is a card for joint household purchases, food shopping, anything for our child etc. I don't understand being married and operating your finances in a way where you have to ask for a share of money towards this and that and for just the one partner to put money into joint savings while the other presumably spends all money on himself as he sees fit. YABU for putting up with this for so long, but YANBU for taking action now.
We do this. He earns FAR more than me, but also has debt to pay off from "before". EVERYTHING goes in one pot, then everything comes out of there too, we both have access to the accounts. We each then have a standing order back into our individual accounts (for the same amount as each other) which is ours to spend however we choose: clothes, lunches, nights out, coffee's, birthdays. Works well. & no, I don't think YABU, but I think a conversation instead of passive aggressive actions would help (although I can absolutely see why you'd want to try and see make him see where you're coming from and I'd probably have done the same thing a few years ago!)
Paradisaeidae · 19/01/2022 18:41

Please add up ALL your direct debits and total them.

Then go back over the last 12 months and add up additional costs like clothes for ds, activities for him, repairs, car costs, petrol, etc etc. Basically everything else that you've forked out for in the last year that should have been a shared bill. Divide it by 12 as an average you've spent every month that he should have contributed to.

Are you married?
Are you on the mortgage?

The mental load thing - to me the main thing with this issue is it shows an underlying level of misogyny and a huge lack of general respect for you. Not what you want from someone you share a child with.

Also - I'm confused. You say he can't buy stuff as no bank card. But also say he spends in random stuff. How is he doing that with no bank card??

Walkaround · 19/01/2022 18:36

Better for you both to have your salaries paid into a joint current account and take all family expenses from there. Money left over an agreed amount can subsequently be transferred to separate savings accounts if you don’t want joint savings, or a mix of joint savings and separate accounts, the amount taken out of the joint current account by each of you for this by mutual agreement. The alternative is actually having bugger all idea of each other’s earnings or the real cost of running a household, both massive failings whether you stay together forever or separate.

Twonka · 19/01/2022 18:33

I find this very strange
If you are trying to split the bills why not just have a joint account where the mortgage and nursery bills and food etc come out of.. with a monthly direct debit?
Anything leftover can go into the joint savings account

maltesers99 · 19/01/2022 18:33

This sounds barmy and so unhealthy!
He has no pin for his card?! He just expects you to pay for everything?
I propose:

  • new joint bank acc. Both of you transfer half the mortgage payment, any dd payments and all other small payments to that from your personal accounts each month. Work out your average food spend and put half that in too.

That way, he cant refuse to pay anything else as what is joint has been split.
I have to say, i couldn't live like that especially with a baby. We share an account and don't forensically monitor each other's spending. It sounds exhausting.
You must sort something out as it feels likr he is taking advantage of you.
Make him get a pin for his card. Or 'lose' yours!

dementedmummy · 19/01/2022 18:31

I am raging on your behalf!
Question - what happened when you went on mat leave? Were you still paying for everything then? Just trying to ascertain what time of man you have got yourself in tow with!
Go through your bank statements for the last 3 months and put down all your bills paid plus the rest. Then show him what he has contributed. It will be so unequal it will shock him. Either he will sort the situation or you will realise he is a complete selfish toad and you can dump his sorry ass as it will make no odds to you as you are already paying for everything AND still managing to save.
Also consider whether he has a gambling problem - not having any money/refusing to engage financially/ every excuse under the sun for not making a logical financial decision like changing bank accounts is a classic sign.
Feel for you - just had the same conversation over birthday and Christmas contributions with childrens father. Some men are just dickheads and should be treated accordingly where shock and awe tactics don't work. Good luck 🍀

Whatamess582 · 19/01/2022 18:25

YANBU

at all.

TheCatterall · 19/01/2022 18:13

Tell him he needs to set up a standing order to you to chip in with food, child costs, annual costs towards Christmas and birthdays etc.

Tell him he needs to agree to a percentage going into a fund that is for emergencies/holidays etc.

If he can’t or won’t do this… then what use is he?

You’d have less expenses if he left.
Less food costs. 25% discount on council tax. Access to further financial assistance. Less stress.

He pays more to you so you can continue meeting the additional costs of two adults life’s. Or he leaves. He isn’t going to get better on his own.

Pky45 · 19/01/2022 18:12

[quote Conspiracyornotr]@JointAccountBye men don't think like us women do we think ahead they just happy when they got what need and want and.not bothered about house bills.or food. X[/quote]
This is, of course, bollocks