Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have just drained the joint savings account?

389 replies

JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 20:31

Had an argument with DH this evening about money.

We have separate accounts and a joint savings account. I don't feel he contributes enough to the household, he thinks he does.

The joint savings account only I ever pay into. Literally I think he's paid about £30 into it our entire marriage.

However whenever I say we need to pay for X can you send me X for it he'll say "you've got money in the savings account" rather than just contribute himself.

It pisses me off because I guess I see the money in the savings account as mine considering I'm the only one who pays into it so using it just feels like me basically paying for everything still.

So tonight I've drained it. I've put it all in a savings account in my name only and when he says use the savings I'm going to tell him there's none left.

He'll be pissed I'm sure as we were saving up for some stuff but I'm sick of it.

OP posts:
sunnybunnyy · 20/01/2022 14:10

Why doesn't he set up a direct debit for a certain amount each month to go into the savings account, just make him do it then it's done

Itsalmostanaccessory · 20/01/2022 13:47

@ToffeeMamma

I'd be very careful because divorce wise he's paying the main one, the mortgage on the house. My brother was main bread winner paid all bills etc only bill his wife paid was mortgage which was like you only between £400-£500 however despite both names being on the mortgage and him showing he paid all the other bills equaling over £1500 a month and he was left with two kids to look after because her priorities stank. Because she had paid all the mortgage they couldn't let him have the house. They even apologised about it in court and explained that it's always recommended mortgage payments are paid in from joint accounts or two halves because a house legally belongs to the person who has paid if there is any disoute. They can only force sale of house if the other person has paid at least 40% or something. So she got the house, he ended up living with friends with two kids until he found somewhere. I'd say your husband knows his contributions amount to more than yours in law and won't make others because he has always prepared for divorce. You either need to show you are paying something towards the mortgage fast or consult a solicitor maybe draw up some sort of legal agreement in the case of a later divorce, or if it ends in divorce you are going to lose it. You may need your savings if that's the case so thankfully you have sorted them out. Now they can't be taken into account but get that mortgage sorted.
This is really unusual. If they were legally married then this is... unusual.
Sceptre86 · 20/01/2022 13:43

You're having a rant, that's good, so you should. However, what do you intend to do about this, now in the short term, what is the plan? What's the goal longterm? Would you leave him over being a lazy, selfish arse or not?

I'd not be happy with this. My dh works full time and I part time. we do keep.our money separate in that no joint accounts. He pays the mortgage and food, plus everything to do with his car. I pay all other bills. If there is a child's birthday coming up one of us will pay for the cake and decorations and some little presents, the other will buy the bigger present, food and for a day out. Dh usually pays more because he earns more but its usually proportionate. We go halves on things like clothes and shoes.

You'd probably be better off, financially at least on your own.

frazzledasarock · 20/01/2022 13:35

I would get legal advice about finances OP.

My experience with regards money and assets during a divorce the starting point was 50:50 for everything and then need was taken into consideration.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 20/01/2022 13:32

@Itsalmostanaccessory

If he gets annoyed or says no, ask him why he thinks you should pay for everything your child needs and everything to feed the family as well as your share of the bills. Get him to explain in great detail why you are required to spend all that money and he is refusing to pay his half. Why is that fair?

You need to make him explain it. He wont be able to. That's your first step. Either he will accept how wrong he is, or he will accept it is unfair but he will want to keep it that way. Then you know whether you stay or leave.

This...

Im also concerned that he will present it as HIS house as he pays the mortgage (leavibf out you pay for everything else).

If youre intending being together... You need to put a large amount of money from both of uou into the account and EVERYTHING is paid frkm it... Including the mortgage

ToffeeMamma · 20/01/2022 13:28

I'd be very careful because divorce wise he's paying the main one, the mortgage on the house. My brother was main bread winner paid all bills etc only bill his wife paid was mortgage which was like you only between £400-£500 however despite both names being on the mortgage and him showing he paid all the other bills equaling over £1500 a month and he was left with two kids to look after because her priorities stank. Because she had paid all the mortgage they couldn't let him have the house. They even apologised about it in court and explained that it's always recommended mortgage payments are paid in from joint accounts or two halves because a house legally belongs to the person who has paid if there is any disoute. They can only force sale of house if the other person has paid at least 40% or something. So she got the house, he ended up living with friends with two kids until he found somewhere. I'd say your husband knows his contributions amount to more than yours in law and won't make others because he has always prepared for divorce. You either need to show you are paying something towards the mortgage fast or consult a solicitor maybe draw up some sort of legal agreement in the case of a later divorce, or if it ends in divorce you are going to lose it. You may need your savings if that's the case so thankfully you have sorted them out. Now they can't be taken into account but get that mortgage sorted.

thirdfiddle · 20/01/2022 13:24

I'm finding the 'I don't understand' a bit tedious when several of us have explained why it works for us. We have separate accounts for all sorts of things. One to save for children's uni/other training course fees for example. Why not one for personal spending separate from family spending?

Maybe it depends how you use your money. If you do everything together and have similar spending habits, no need. If one partner wants to go to the pub every weekend and the other wants to save up for a designer coat, how do you make sure they both get a fair allocation of fun spends? How does the coat ever get saved for if the attitude is "it's there so fair play to spend it"?

ReadySteadyTwins · 20/01/2022 13:06

OP has gone.

I suspect the freeloader she's married has now discovered the freeloading has stopped.

And there are now huge arguments as he tries to make her out to be the bad guy, as she's stopped enabling his parasitic ways.

Hope you're ok OP. It's utterly shit to realise someone is there because it's cheap and they can spend at your expense. I've had that. Many of us have. They're charming, and because we aren't thieving, lying shites, we don't expect others to be, and so we don't see it coming. As other PP, mine is now an ex

littlesos · 20/01/2022 11:07

@CoastalWave

I'm so confused by how people manage their household finances.

Surely - you get married, you pool the lot?! Who cares who earns what?! It's about being a team. Whole lot in - all the bills out. By all means split what's left accordingly IF one person is a substantially higher earner but christ - I couldn't be arsed with all the working out.

The way myself and DH look at it - if one of us makes some money, great we've both got money to play with. If we're skint, we're skint.

Genuinely don't think you should marry someone if you can't play it like this!

Im with you @CoastalWave and @D0lphine We only have one current account. I just don't understand separate accounts. One family, one account.
BillMasen · 20/01/2022 10:51

@thirdfiddle

I don't believe the "slightly more". I think if OP adds up the groceries and incidentals as well as all the rest of the DDs she will find it's more like a "lot more". Food, nappies, Council tax, car costs, energy bills, water bills, insurance - so many regular things even without all the gifts and one-offs going on OP's account.
Without op giving numbers we’re all speculating
Belladonna12 · 20/01/2022 10:47

This is what happens when people keep their money separate. It might be fine for high earners but for anyone else it's always leads to arguments. The easiest thing for you would be to set up a joint current account from which all wages and direct debits come out of. When you switch the banks change all the direct debits etc for you. You can set up direct debits from this into two individual savings accounts so you both have your own money still. I suspect he will be more proactive about making sure money goes into his account compared with going out,

trickytimes · 20/01/2022 10:42

Do a spreadsheet. Earnings for each of you plus every single thing that gets paid for. Look at your expenses over the last 3 months. Add your earnings together then minus all the expenses. Half the remaining amount. That’s what each of you should have left over each month. See if that’s different to what you do have. Have you done those numbers? Who has how much left over? If you are short he should be doing another direct debit into your account. Look at those numbers now

BluebellsGreenbells · 20/01/2022 10:35

Surely he need to set up a direct debit into the savings account

The problem is he knows what he should be doing, he’s choosing not too.

Ddot · 20/01/2022 10:32

Surely he need to set up a direct debit into the savings account. Work out how much your bill come to and I mean to the penny, then tell him, he may get a shock

UnexpectedItemInShaggingArea · 20/01/2022 10:25

YANBU. And your OH needs a serious kick up the arse. He's not even adulting if he doesn't know his PINs. You have two children, not one.

thirdfiddle · 20/01/2022 10:03

I don't believe the "slightly more". I think if OP adds up the groceries and incidentals as well as all the rest of the DDs she will find it's more like a "lot more". Food, nappies, Council tax, car costs, energy bills, water bills, insurance - so many regular things even without all the gifts and one-offs going on OP's account.

BillMasen · 20/01/2022 10:03

“ The savings are definitely hers bar £30, so clearly they should go on her and not on the joint thing they both want to buy.”

The savings are joint, they’re paid for out of her (broadly) fair contribution to joint expenses. Would you say the house is his as he pays the mortgage, or the food is hers because she pays for it?

It’s all joint!

BookishKitten · 20/01/2022 09:56

I find more women complaining of this in my circle of relations.
Riding food costs, energy bills, and fuel have meant that arrangements that in the past may have been fair because the amounts involved in paying for different things were equal are no longer equal !
My better half and I split every bill down the middle. At the start of the month we each pay into a dedicated account where direct debits like mortgage, nursery, energy and internet/subscriptions come out of. Then any additional bills we each pay we note down in a magnetic board on the fridge (typically food shopping, clothes for our child and any added extras) and then over the weekend we to the sums for each, divide down the middle and whoever has spent less has to pay the difference to the other person. So if I’ve spent £60 and my husband has paid £40, then he will pay me £20.
We do not include there things like personal items, eg I would buy a perfume for me and ask my husband to pay for it! But I will note down presents for family members or family treats like meals out.
The one thing we do not share bills on is my travel costs which are significantly more than my husband’s because our salary difference is precisely that amount.
Any leftover money stays in each person’s account. My husband has a current account but I have a savings account. It works for us and doing the household accounting once a week means that no one is out of pocket and we can keep an eye on costs and outgoing bills.
This has worked for us and there’s no grudges.

You have a shit deal and I think you need to have a sit down with your husband. Keep it factual and objective, point out the monetary difference and the fact that you’re outgoings are significantly higher - do not bring emotions into the discussion.

dexterslockedintheshedagain · 20/01/2022 09:51

And that helps the OP how exactly?
She'd love to do that but HE WON'T!!!

SparkleTwinkle101 · 20/01/2022 09:25

I find these posts really weird. When we got married DH and I literally decided that any money earned was 'ours' rather than his or mine and we tuck along nicely. We both still have separate accounts as well as a joint account but we just pay as and when it's not scheduled. My parents did the same

frazzledasarock · 20/01/2022 08:41

@BillMasen

This thread is full of people making up their own numbers then claiming the partner is abusive, hiding money or just generally taking the piss. Op has given no figures and has only said they pay “slightly” more.

Let me make up some figures (based on what the op has actually said!)

Partner pays mortgage and some bills. Say 550
Op pays bills, food, joint savings. Slightly more, say 600

Our of her 600 say 1000 is joint savings. She said this was included!

The savings are part of her share! Ok both should pay the same but she can’t just decide they are hers

Made up numbers I know but lots are ignoring what the op is actually saying and making things up so they can assume the partner is wrong

So why is the H refusing to contribute half towards the £50 OP is over paying then? and expecting OP to absorb it? Over a year OP is then paying £600 more than her H etc. Why is she having to shoulder the extra £50 when they both earn the same?

The savings are definitely hers bar £30, so clearly they should go on her and not on the joint thing they both want to buy.

frazzledasarock · 20/01/2022 08:36

You need to sit down work out all your household outgoings and then tell your H that he needs to transfer x% of his salary to the joint account each month, you both transfer all DD's to the joint account.

It really doesn't take long to change DD's. Most of our bills are managed online ,you go in and change the bank details on your DD instructions, I did it with the TV license and water bills.

If he refuses, I'd seriously revaluate your marriage.

In the meantime, stop paying for anything for him. pay out exactly the amount he does in his DD's on bills and then stop and point blank refuse, you have no money.

He sounds awful

InaccurateDream · 20/01/2022 08:32

You must be spending minimum twice as much as him if the mortgage is that low. Food is expensive. I’d work out what you both spend and spell it out to him. He should care if he’s a decent person. Or just do as you have but you will still be spending more I’m sure.

We didn’t have joint account when we first got married as had old student debts and accounts. We split bills in a similar way to you and my DH is laidback and thought it was all fine. Once I spelled out how unequal it was he was horrified. We now have a joint account, wages go in there, everything comes out of there, and we both take out the exact same money to our own accounts to spend on personal/random things. He can save or spend it and it doesn’t affect me.

BillMasen · 20/01/2022 08:29

*I meant 100 could be joint savings. Bloody phone!

Whattochoosenow · 20/01/2022 08:26

I think you need to completely change what you do.
You should have a joint account that you both pay a set amount into to cover bills only plus whatever you’ve agreed to save (everything else remains in your own accounts for personal spending) . All direct debits come off this and each month a standing order transfers to a joint savings account.
If he won’t agree to this or something similar I’d be questioning why.