Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have just drained the joint savings account?

389 replies

JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 20:31

Had an argument with DH this evening about money.

We have separate accounts and a joint savings account. I don't feel he contributes enough to the household, he thinks he does.

The joint savings account only I ever pay into. Literally I think he's paid about £30 into it our entire marriage.

However whenever I say we need to pay for X can you send me X for it he'll say "you've got money in the savings account" rather than just contribute himself.

It pisses me off because I guess I see the money in the savings account as mine considering I'm the only one who pays into it so using it just feels like me basically paying for everything still.

So tonight I've drained it. I've put it all in a savings account in my name only and when he says use the savings I'm going to tell him there's none left.

He'll be pissed I'm sure as we were saving up for some stuff but I'm sick of it.

OP posts:
JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 22:24

The argument we had tonight came about because I asked him to send me some money for our sons birthday present. No money left apparently. I can just take it from the savings (my savings).

OP posts:
JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 22:23

He does have money left over yes and he spends it on stupid stuff. Anything he wants he gets. Like I say he thinks his part is paying a few direct debits and that's it.

If it makes any difference the mortgage is £450 so not some staggering amount he then pays a phone contract and the internet.

I pay for everything else. Council tax, gas and electric, water, house insurance, pet insurance, boiler insurance, car finance, all of the shopping, everything for our son bar half the nursery fees, absolutely anything else we need money for in the month comes from me.

He pays his 3 direct debits then swans off acting like nothing else is his problem. He just turns around and says he has nothing left if something comes up. Like it's my job to pay for everything else and not his problem.

I actually did try and do the joint account thing. I set one up and said we needed to set all direct debits to come from it but that was too much work apparently.

OP posts:
Haffiana · 18/01/2022 22:21

@JointAccountBye

You haven't yet said how much more than him you spend, other than it is a small amount, but he IS correct that if you took that small amount from the savings that would equalise things

Then I'd just be equalising it with my own money because he pays absolutely nothing into the savings Confused

But you pay absolutely nothing into the mortgage OP! That is like you saying that the house is his only because it is paid with his own money!

You both spend similar amounts each month. That is the bottom line.

Ugzbugz · 18/01/2022 22:20

I bet he has large savings in a secret account.

Why don't you both put x amount into a joint account and everything comes from that so say for example both put 1k into cover mortgage, bills, nursery fees, food etc. Then what you have left over is yours.

Hes absolutely mugging you off x

NoSquirrels · 18/01/2022 22:20

This set up - man pays fixed bills, woman pays variable bills like shopping, child stuff etc - is ALWAYS ALWAYS unfair on the woman.

Fuck that.

All costs added up over an annual basis, with a budget for car repairs, food shopping, kids clothes and all of the other necessary “etc” stuff. Divide by 12. Divide by 2. You each pay that into a bills/joint account.

JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 22:18

You haven't yet said how much more than him you spend, other than it is a small amount, but he IS correct that if you took that small amount from the savings that would equalise things

Then I'd just be equalising it with my own money because he pays absolutely nothing into the savings Confused

OP posts:
FireworkParrot · 18/01/2022 22:17

I think you ought to repurpose the existing joint account. Add up all your family outgoings eg. £1k per month. Both pay £600 into joint account by standing order. Everything for the household and your child then comes out of that account. Bills, groceries, childcare etc.

If you earn the same, just do this OP. If you earn different amounts then pay the same percentage of your salary into the joint account instead. It's fair, simple and saves all this hassle. The way you have it set up currently sounds ridiculous and of course is going to cause issues.

PurpleThursdays · 18/01/2022 22:16

Do you both have money left over at the end of the month OP? Or is that he is 100% spent up and you - after putting savings to one side - have to budget for the month on what is left? I'm confused without the detail.

The mental load is a separate issue, and whilst it is unfair, a joint account you both pay a set amount into to cover monthly costs would be sensible and would alleviate that burden.

DirtyDancing · 18/01/2022 22:15

Sounds like you are carving it up all wrong. It doesn't make any sense, especially as you earn the same I should be a straightforward conversation.

We have x outgoings.
We have x income
Let's both put x into a joint account each month to cover it and all the bills come out of the account.
Including all random shopping bits.
We both contribute X% into saving account to save up for big things and the rainy day fund eg boiler breaks

The rest is in your own account to do as you so wish. Piece of piece. I don't get why you argue over it

I'd want to be paying half the mortgage too..

FrecklesMalone · 18/01/2022 22:14

[quote Conspiracyornotr]@JointAccountBye men don't think like us women do we think ahead they just happy when they got what need and want and.not bothered about house bills.or food. X[/quote]
Quite a sexist comment! I would say about half the men I know are good at saving and half the women are.

Haffiana · 18/01/2022 22:11

@JointAccountBye

So the issue is mental load OP, not that you spend more than him?

It's both. I 100% spend more than him and literally all of the budgeting to make sure we have enough money for everything we need outside of a few direct debits is all on me too.

The mental load would be helped by having a joint household account.

You haven't yet said how much more than him you spend, other than it is a small amount, but he IS correct that if you took that small amount from the savings that would equalise things.

RedskyThisNight · 18/01/2022 22:10

@JointAccountBye

He can't even use his bank card (forgot the pin years ago). But he never needs to because I pay for everything (other than his direct debits).
It sounds like the system suggested by many on here where you have a joint account which pays all bills, food and incidentals would work for you. (anything left over is split equally between your personal accounts). He gets to make one direct debit into the account and not think about it. You know that everything is covered and can dump some of the mental load.

Have you actually asked him to pay more/suggested such an arrangement. I'm not necessarily getting that he's being unfair deliberately, more that he's never really thought about your arrangement in detail.

RandomMess · 18/01/2022 22:09

How come he doesn't have any money if all he does is pay a fee direct debits and has money left over afterwards?

JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 22:08

So the issue is mental load OP, not that you spend more than him?

It's both. I 100% spend more than him and literally all of the budgeting to make sure we have enough money for everything we need outside of a few direct debits is all on me too.

OP posts:
MyOtherProfile · 18/01/2022 22:08

And have a bank card each for the joint account that you can each use to pay for groceries, kid stuff etc

Haffiana · 18/01/2022 22:07

@JointAccountBye

That's the extent of how much of the load is on me. If I lost my bank card we'd be fucked until a new one turned up.
So the issue is mental load OP, not that you spend more than him?
MyOtherProfile · 18/01/2022 22:07

So you need to open a joint account.
Work out how much he pays in mortgage and bills and pay the same amount into a joint account.

Use this joint account to pay for everything.
If the joint account runs out before the end of the month you can both top it up by the same amount.

JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 22:05

That's the extent of how much of the load is on me. If I lost my bank card we'd be fucked until a new one turned up.

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 18/01/2022 22:05

@HandlebarLadyTash

We have a joint bill account where we both pay in a set amount & all the direct debt & joint costs come out. All other money is separate.
We do the same as HandlebarLady, we both pay into a joint account and all the bills come out of that. We also have a joint credit card that’s used for food shopping, children’s clothes and activities, etc. and that’s paid off with joint money.

Finally, we set a joint savings account that’s fed by a monthly direct debit from our personal accounts. That enables us to jointly save for bigger expenses like household repairs.

JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 22:05

He can't even use his bank card (forgot the pin years ago). But he never needs to because I pay for everything (other than his direct debits).

OP posts:
TinselTitsAndGlitteryBits · 18/01/2022 22:05

[quote Conspiracyornotr]@JointAccountBye men don't think like us women do we think ahead they just happy when they got what need and want and.not bothered about house bills.or food. X[/quote]
This is an absolute load of horseshit. Grown men are not children that need to be mothered, they know bills need to be paid, food needs to be bought, children need clothes...

JointAccountBye · 18/01/2022 22:04

@Gymrats

So you only pay slightly more….well how slight because your post makes it sound like your paying a bit more than slight.

Putting ALL in capital letters doesn’t justify it…you could say he pays ALL the mortgage.

How slight? If it’s under £100 more then the existing arrangement sounds fair

It's impossible to know. Because as I say he literally just pays his direct debits and thinks that's him done. Whereas I'm the one who has to pay for everything else, all the shopping, if our son needs new clothes, if the car needs work etc...

Any time we go in a shop throughout the month it's me that pays. It's not as easy to keep track of when it's not strict direct debits like his but ALL of the mental load of ensuring we still have money left for food, savings, emergencies is on me.

I don't get to just turn around like he does and say sorry I don't have any money left.

OP posts:
Haffiana · 18/01/2022 22:02

Good grief, the numeracy/reading comprehension on this thread is appalling.

He pays: 100% of Mortgage, small bills, half nursery.

OP pays: All other bills, into savings and half nursery.

OP has stated it works out that I pay slightly more than him.

OP also states: The joint savings account only I ever pay into. Literally I think he's paid about £30 into it our entire marriage.

OP also it seems has never paid the mortgage in her entire marriage, not even £30.

Therefore the ONLY difference is the slightly more that OP is spending each month. That is the only bit that needs addressing.

OP's DH reckons that if she takes extra from savings - ie reduces how much she puts in it - then their outgoings will be equal. This is CORRECT.

PurpleThursdays · 18/01/2022 21:59

@MyOtherProfile

So if they earn the same, they should split the difference in outgoings, no??

They pretty much have @PurpleThursdays - this just needs tweaking so that op no longer pays out slightly more than him.

How have they? If he refuses to give her money and tells her to take it from joint savings, she's effectively paying for items herself. He should be going halves with her they have a child together. And he should be putting an agreed matched amount in savings as OP.
Beancounter1 · 18/01/2022 21:57

I should add, if he won't happily agree to a joint current account and a clear and transparent system, then you know you have a big problem!