Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not sure how to feel about ExH’s revelation

34 replies

Joined4this · 18/01/2022 12:18

ExH grew up in a slightly neglected area where drugs were rife. When he was a teenager his group of friends were all into drugs and low-level criminal activity. Exh was easily led and could have easily been drawn into this life. Except- his dad offered to pay him not to break the law on condition he didn’t tell his mum. So, basically, Exh was walking around in designer clothes and getting a big allowance to not take drugs/commit crimes. It worked, he’s successful now and is thankful to his parent because at the time he thinks he couldn’t think straight. We were talking about it yesterday and he says if the time ever came he would do the same for his kids. I don’t know if this sends the right message honestly. What ever happened to teaching them to work hard? AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ponoka7 · 18/01/2022 19:02

"What if you try it and the kids just buy drugs with the money?"

It isn't just the cash, his Dad funded what teens see drug dealers having, designer clothes etc, so he never felt tempted by any of it. Teens get shown lives that very few of them can achieve by legitimately working, so they do what they need to, to get by. It worked. The world is changing and we need changing parenting methods.

BurntO · 18/01/2022 18:19

I dunno OP. It worked… I live in a bad area myself and I am fearful for when my kids are teens and I need to give them the freedom to mix with new people and worry about what they could fall into. Sometimes even the best parenting isn’t enough to curb peer pressure. Even “good” kids get caught underage drinking, multiply that by being in a bad area with bad crowds on every corner and the opportunity and extent of fucking up is higher

DysmalRadius · 18/01/2022 18:11

Knowing how much rehab can cost, I'd rather pay that upfront and avoid all the negative outcomes of that kind of lifestyle than watch out happen and have to pick up the pieces.

rrhuth · 18/01/2022 17:56

@Joined4this

It worked with Exh because he could not lie to his dad and was basically a good person if a little stubborn. What if you try it and the kids just buy drugs with the money? Obviously you would stop paying but there would definitely be temptation to take the money and continue the bad behaviour?
I still don't get your issue?

You seem a bit negative about the nature of your children! Your ex was a good person. Your kids will hopefully also be good people.

Isaw3ships · 18/01/2022 14:24

Given the alternative and he turned out alright YABU, but I am kinda with you too! I’m from a rough area but focused on education as my escape.
My parents didn’t have any money to bribe me with! But I was pretty motivated anyway as I loved school.

Mossstitch · 18/01/2022 14:21

I find the idea that we shouldn't pay kids to do things weird, some people call it bribery. We all go to work and are paid 'bribed' to do so!

LondonWolf · 18/01/2022 14:02

@blogbunny

Anything that keeps teenage boys away from trouble and criminal exploitation has got to be worth it. When they’re being offered hundreds of pounds a week to transport and carry drugs, not much can compete with that.

I think his dad did what he needed to do to keep his son out of trouble and it worked. Every credit to your husband too for staying away from that life.

This. My child is given £50 if they bring home an excellent school report or a "present" of their choice - usually cheaper than £50 tbh. They'll get £50 for every GCSE. It's instilling good habits and showing that effort brings rewards. I see nothing wrong with it at all.
FreeFrenchHens · 18/01/2022 14:02

I think you're spot on @CatSpeakForDummies

CatSpeakForDummies · 18/01/2022 13:59

I think that if he had a dad who was intuitive, involved and wealthy enough to propose this course of action, he wasn't really at risk of ending up in a gang/a criminal anyway.

Does he really think that it was the designer clothes that kept him on the straight and narrow? Surely the fact that his dad could understand the situation and the temptation and talk to him about it was a much more important factor, and the real message to take forward.

Beowulfthethird · 18/01/2022 13:57

It's hardly character building. Not ideal parenting.

But I'd pay my dd to eat if she was anorexic.

FreeFrenchHens · 18/01/2022 13:57

It's 2 separate things, paying him to behave and keeping it hidden from his mum. He can do one without the other. The first one's actually quite clever for the right kid.

Incentivising GCSE grades with cash works for some children too, but it would be a disaster for mine. think I'd be encouraging him to be open with you about it, but only decide when you both know what sort of teenager you have on your hands.

blogbunny · 18/01/2022 13:54

Anything that keeps teenage boys away from trouble and criminal exploitation has got to be worth it. When they’re being offered hundreds of pounds a week to transport and carry drugs, not much can compete with that.

I think his dad did what he needed to do to keep his son out of trouble and it worked. Every credit to your husband too for staying away from that life.

Joined4this · 18/01/2022 13:52

His mum would never have gone for it is what I took from the conversation.

OP posts:
Joined4this · 18/01/2022 13:51

It worked with Exh because he could not lie to his dad and was basically a good person if a little stubborn. What if you try it and the kids just buy drugs with the money? Obviously you would stop paying but there would definitely be temptation to take the money and continue the bad behaviour?

OP posts:
MoiraNotRuby · 18/01/2022 13:47

I pay a big chunk of my income on my teenagers hobbies, as well as being good for them mentally and physically, I think it gives them another reason not to be tempted to do drugs. I suppose it's the same sort of thing really.

Skeumorph · 18/01/2022 13:47

The only thing I would point out is is how damaging that simple sentence 'don't tell your mum' has very likely been to him - whether he realises it or not.

To have his father's lack of respect for his mother displayed so clearly. The lack of teamwork.

To teach him lying to your loved ones is ok - end justifies the means.

To instil in him that ultimately, it's ok for a child to be told to keep secrets from a parent like that.

StellaGibson118 · 18/01/2022 13:44

It's unconventional but I guess if it works then it's worth it. It would only be something I'd do out of sheer desperation really.

rrhuth · 18/01/2022 13:44

@Thirtytimesround

I don’t have a problem with the bribery but I think the “on the condition you don’t tell your mum” is awful.
The op's DH is at least not trying to hide it.
Iggly · 18/01/2022 13:43

I would absolutely do the same!

rrhuth · 18/01/2022 13:43

@Joined4this

ExH grew up in a slightly neglected area where drugs were rife. When he was a teenager his group of friends were all into drugs and low-level criminal activity. Exh was easily led and could have easily been drawn into this life. Except- his dad offered to pay him not to break the law on condition he didn’t tell his mum. So, basically, Exh was walking around in designer clothes and getting a big allowance to not take drugs/commit crimes. It worked, he’s successful now and is thankful to his parent because at the time he thinks he couldn’t think straight. We were talking about it yesterday and he says if the time ever came he would do the same for his kids. I don’t know if this sends the right message honestly. What ever happened to teaching them to work hard? AIBU?
But you just said yourself it worked and he is a success Confused
Malbecfan · 18/01/2022 13:41

I don't see a problem. My great grandma did similar with my grandad. She bet him a crown (now 25p) that he couldn't stop smoking. He was in his early 20s so this would have been in the 1920s and he stopped there and then, even though his father and sister both smoked. My grandad lived until he was 90 and told us all about it. None of my cousins smokes although my idiot sister does, but she's always been contrary.

After he died, my dad found the crown in his belongings. Whilst it made my dad emotional, he has kept it for posterity and it's probably worth quite a bit more now.

Thirtytimesround · 18/01/2022 13:21

I don’t have a problem with the bribery but I think the “on the condition you don’t tell your mum” is awful.

YouokHun · 18/01/2022 13:11

Theses strategies don’t work across the board of course but I think the beauty of this strategy is giving a teenage boy agency in his own outcome through choosing not to get involved in the bad stuff because of an immediate benefit as well as a long term benefit which made the right choice immediately more attractive. It’s all very well questioning whether it sends the right message overall, but sometimes we have to do what it takes to keep safe youngsters who are living in the moment and aren’t interested in the long term consequences of negative actions.

emsmar · 18/01/2022 12:56

@Dillydollydingdong

A parent will do whatever they can to ensure the DC take the right path in life. Well done that man if he can afford it.
Absolutely!
Joined4this · 18/01/2022 12:55

I live in the East of England; beautiful yet underfunded. The town centre is a little grotty yet it is popular with the elderly due to aforementioned beauty; young families like the cheap housing and space. There is just a lack of anything to do if you are 16-30. I doubt Exh’s family could afford to move and they also knew lots of people and were happy there.

OP posts: