Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To walk my in season dog? Is it a criminal offence?

306 replies

PollyPurpose · 18/01/2022 11:43

Just that really.

I’ve just been stopped by a local dog walker and she politely but firmly told me it is a “Criminal offence to walk an in season bitch; under a section something…? ”. She stated that if a male dog follows my dog out of the park and gets hit by a car I am legally and criminally liable. She also said I am ruining all dog walks for entire dogs.

I did politely ask what it is owners are meant to do as dogs need walking - she said pavement walks in the dark. As a lone female in london I won’t be doing this.

So yes what are peoples thoughts. Is it actually illegal because I can’t imagine not being able to walk her for three weeks at a time. Twice a year.

She always remains on lead and is small enough for me to carry. She is three years old and I’ve never had an issues - if a male dog has shown interest they’ve usually been called back by an owner.

In response to “have her neutered” I will once I have decided whether Or not to breed from her.

OP posts:
SirSniffsAlot · 18/01/2022 13:38

The decision to neuter or not should be made after reviewing the specific dog you have, their health, breed and behaviour and the environment and manner in which you keep them.

Neutering has pros and cons and not all pros will apply to all dogs and not all cons will.

e.g. if you have a large dog from a breed with a tendancy towards bones and joint problems you may consider neutering to be too risky (it can have advserse effects on bone and joint health). Alternatively, if you live and walk in places where accidental matings can occur - e.g. your habit is for a relaxed walk in public places where your dog isn't the laser focus of your attention - then you may choose the guaranteed protection that neutering brings against accidental puppies.

The age of neutering is also an important factor and comes with different risks or benefits. As a general, but not exact, rule then the older and more mature the dog, the better. Which means everyone who cares for a dog from puppyhood is likely to find themselves walking a sexually mature, intact animal - at least temporarily.

Which, of course, means anyone walking a dog should EXPECT to come across a sexually mature, intact animal sooner or later...

Isaw3ships · 18/01/2022 13:37

‘ Or, hire a private field.’
😅😅😅

I mean, whom amongst us has not hired private fields for dog walking…

missmoon · 18/01/2022 13:36

My dog ran off after a bitch in heat when he was still a puppy, and too young to be neutered, he pulled on the lead suddenly and I lost my hold. The bitch was being walked off the lead, on a busy path, at a busy time of day. I managed to get him back, but it was a scary moment. The owners just shrugged. I really don't understand why anyone would be so reckless. (My dog is neutered now, as soon as I was able to do it).

Isaw3ships · 18/01/2022 13:36

‘ That's not correct and is outdated advice. It is not recommended any more that male dogs are neutered. Though I hadn't considered that maybe this was because the vetinary world had been infiltrated by the Taliban’

Amazing! If this one doesn’t end up on Mumsnet Madness I’d be stunned. ‘Vetinary’ ( sic) ‘Taliban’
🤣

girlmom21 · 18/01/2022 13:35

Ha, if the answer is obvious

girlmom21 · 18/01/2022 13:35

@Aldinho57

YABU because you are trying to tell me that you have to resort to Mumsnet to find out the answer ? ever heard of GOOGLE ?, or a polite E mail to a local vets etc, so I have to imagine you are a Mumsnet bot making up thick questions just to perpetuate conversation like the vast majority of threads on this site.
Are you ok?

Posting on Mumsnet is going to get a much quicker response than a vet is and it's anonymous so nobody feels silly if the answer is anonymous.

DontWiltMySpinachPlease · 18/01/2022 13:35

You can absolutely still walk her, but you need to be really considerate of other dogs. Walk at the anti social times, walk as far away from other dogs as poss, and ideally always on the lead. Or, hire a private field.

Isaw3ships · 18/01/2022 13:34

What a load of shite! Dogs in season still need to be walked, and we walked ours on the lead with no incident whatsoever.
However - there are too many dogs in the world as it is so do the responsible thing and have your dog spayed.

newnamenewyear · 18/01/2022 13:33

@Aldinho57

YABU because you are trying to tell me that you have to resort to Mumsnet to find out the answer ? ever heard of GOOGLE ?, or a polite E mail to a local vets etc, so I have to imagine you are a Mumsnet bot making up thick questions just to perpetuate conversation like the vast majority of threads on this site.
Wow, that's unnecessarily aggressive!

You seem to have misunderstood the point of Mumsnet.

It's a chat forum. We chat about things. Anything we want. Perhaps you're in the wrong place?

Do I really need to explain that you get a different response here to googling? Not only the answer, but opinion, advice, related facts. And that can be very valuable, sometimes.

FanFckingTastic · 18/01/2022 13:33

Gosh OP, I would have told the dog walker to boil her head (or words to that effect!) It's not illegal to walk your bitch whilst she's in season. Of course you need to be responsible and use common sense, avoid busy times and other dogs where you can but it's not against the law.

On the subject of neutering, there are many reasons why a dog may not yet be neutered. The breed of dog will dictate when is best for them to be neutered from a health perspective. Whilst neutering can be beneficial, there are also risks to the dog if it's done too early and the skeletal frame, ligaments and muscles are not fully mature. Every dog owner should be doing what's right for their dog - so just because someone got their lab done at 9 months does not mean that's right for my Dachshund.

FFSFFSFFS · 18/01/2022 13:32

It's a really selfish thing to not take steps to take into account that she's on heat - even well trained dogs with great recall may put themselves and others in danger trying to get to her.

Amelion · 18/01/2022 13:32

It’s really irresponsible to walk an on heat dog in a park or other area where off-lead dogs are. Male dogs will smell her from a mile off and run away from their owners - even well trained males with usually good recall and so on. I know someone whose dog did this chasing an on heat female - and was hit by a car (big London park with a road inside the park).

Walk her in quiet areas where other dogs are all going to be on lead, it’s really antisocial and irresponsible to walk her in the park.

Aldinho57 · 18/01/2022 13:28

YABU because you are trying to tell me that you have to resort to Mumsnet to find out the answer ? ever heard of GOOGLE ?, or a polite E mail to a local vets etc, so I have to imagine you are a Mumsnet bot making up thick questions just to perpetuate conversation like the vast majority of threads on this site.

SirSniffsAlot · 18/01/2022 13:25

It's more about common sense than rights or wrong, to me. And about working with the specific dog you have.

An in season bitch is more likely to enjoy walking than not, during her season. Provided the walks are safe and comfortable (i.e. she is not being hassled by males). If you and your dog are in a position to walk somewhere like that, then absolutely feel free to do so. Anyone walking an in season bitch - which has included me in the past - would probably do well to try and aim for quiet places and quiet times for the dog's own comfort. If that's not a posibility then perhaps forgo the walks. Again, simply for your own dog's well being because a 'stressy' walk will be less preferable to no walk at all.

Ditto intact males. If you are walking an intact male (or a neutered male you know still reacts to bitches in season) then walking them where it's quieter or walking them with awareness that you may come across an in season bitch is sensible. For your dog's own safety and comfort. Whilst all dogs are different, every intact male I've walked has a 'tell' that he thinks he's sniffed a bitch - giving you precious seconds to get him on a lead. If you're paying attention rather than just having an amble-type walk in which you half expect the dog to keep up with you. I like an amble walk but they are for specific types of dogs only and would never expect one with an intact male unless he'd already proven his obedience around in season bitches. If your dog does not have a tell and will shoot off without even a half second pause, then you need to take even greater care. Not least because bitches can still smell enticing just before or (more likely) just after their season so the chances are high you will come across one sooner or later.

godmum56 · 18/01/2022 13:22

@CayrolBaaaskin

That’s crackers. Not at all illegal to walk a bitch in heat and no reason people shouldn’t breed from their pets provided they do it responsibly. I generally think people who breed from pets are more interested in welfare than breeders.
google back yard breeders to open your eyes!

OP no its not illegal to walk an in season bitch in public but its not a good idea.

I know this is off topic but can I ask.....is your bitch an excellent example of her breed? has she had all the inheritable problems tests recommended for her breed? are you prpared to keep all the puppies if you don't find excellent homes for them? Are you prepared to take back and refund the cost of any puppies if the purchaser can't keep the puppy?

XiCi · 18/01/2022 13:20

Every single dog should be spayed/neutered by age 2 unless owned by a licensed breeder unless there's a medical reason not to
That's not correct and is outdated advice. It is not recommended any more that male dogs are neutered. Though I hadn't considered that maybe this was because the vetinary world had been infiltrated by the Taliban

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 18/01/2022 13:19

Maybe these large intact males should be neutered if they can’t be controlled?

Of course dogs should be under control but as has been said, even neutered males can smell a bitch in heat.

I'm not an advocate of spaying or neutering without good reason but if you own a bitch that's in season it's your responsibility to keep her safe and away from other dogs.

It's only for a few weeks a year so it shouldn't be that difficult to do.

HoppingPavlova · 18/01/2022 13:19

Not illegal, but a male intact dog will do absolutely anything to get to a bitch on heat, and all its training, recall will go out of the window. So its really not ideal, you are likely to get yourself and your dog some unwelcome behaviour.

Exactly, not illegal but really irresponsible and not in dogs best interest.

preperri · 18/01/2022 13:19

If you can't tell at this point wether to breed from her then you should ask a professional and not come to the conclusion yourself
Unless you're wondering wether to breed from her based on other things like if it would suit you at that point in your life

I think @BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz meant that dogs should be bred from responsible breeders, not pet owners in general

HoppingPavlova · 18/01/2022 13:17

Responsible breeders have enough room for breeding stock, to seperate sexes as necessary to avoid distress for bitch and males, and areas to exercise on heat bitches where they are not creating chaos and distress to other dogs and owners in public. I have a family member who breeds and this stuff is important. You don’t sound like a responsible breeder so I’d suggest doing the right thing by your bitch and other dogs and spaying her.

Everafter20 · 18/01/2022 13:16

I have a border collie and she is my first animal ever not to have been neutered at six months due to the lockdown and for various reasons. None of which are to breed from her however she can't be neutered until three months after her last season. As she is such a high energy dog it is unfair not to exercise her especially whilst in season therefore I bought special pants with pads that are to mask the smell. Also use a spray designed to mask the smell. You change the pad before the walk and try to walk at times when it's quieter and luckily we have a huge green at the end of our drive.
Be sensible is the answer and I would of told her to mind her own business!

AuntMargo · 18/01/2022 13:15

Not illegal, but a male intact dog will do absolutely anything to get to a bitch on heat, and all its training, recall will go out of the window. So its really not ideal, you are likely to get yourself and your dog some unwelcome behaviour.

episcomama · 18/01/2022 13:14

Perhaps not criminal, but criminally stupid.

ComtesseDeSpair · 18/01/2022 13:13

Maybe these large intact males should be neutered if they can’t be controlled?

They absolutely should, pet dogs of either sex should be neutered. But the owner of the female shoulders all the risk to their dog and the associated vet bills if she becomes pregnant, if she develops complications (fairly common in accidental breedings where the male is a far larger breed than the female as the puppies can be too large to carry and birth easily) so it’s in the interests of the owners of the female to protect their bitch rather than hope other owners will have neutered their males.

I’ve seen intact male dogs in the park desperately trying to mount a female in heat. Four clueless owners frantically trying to pull their dogs apart, extendable leads all tangled, dogs absolutely driven by the instinct to breed. It’s not pretty. Owners who think they’d simply call their dog over to them or pick it up in that situation are just as clueless.

EerieSilence · 18/01/2022 13:13

It's not illegal.
We are waiting for our dog to be over 2 years old before we have her sterilised as we want her to be fully mature. It's to protect her joints as she's a large breed and the latest advice is to wait.