Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To walk my in season dog? Is it a criminal offence?

306 replies

PollyPurpose · 18/01/2022 11:43

Just that really.

I’ve just been stopped by a local dog walker and she politely but firmly told me it is a “Criminal offence to walk an in season bitch; under a section something…? ”. She stated that if a male dog follows my dog out of the park and gets hit by a car I am legally and criminally liable. She also said I am ruining all dog walks for entire dogs.

I did politely ask what it is owners are meant to do as dogs need walking - she said pavement walks in the dark. As a lone female in london I won’t be doing this.

So yes what are peoples thoughts. Is it actually illegal because I can’t imagine not being able to walk her for three weeks at a time. Twice a year.

She always remains on lead and is small enough for me to carry. She is three years old and I’ve never had an issues - if a male dog has shown interest they’ve usually been called back by an owner.

In response to “have her neutered” I will once I have decided whether Or not to breed from her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pantsville · 12/11/2022 21:57

It’s besides the point, but as lovely as it would be to give homes to rescue animals before breeding, it’s not actually that’s straightforward. The vast majority of rescue dogs seem to have a combination of unknown history/aggression/unpredictable behaviour/anxiety/unsuitable for children/unsuitable for homes with other pets. Cats are usually more straightforward admittedly.

Ukelelele · 12/11/2022 21:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

PinotPony · 05/02/2022 08:12

It's not illegal but it does cause huge problems for owners of entire dogs. Of course the owners should have control of their dogs if they encounter you but it's by no means easy to deal with. And even if you avoid busy areas, your bitch will leave a lovely scent behind her for the whole of your walk. So, when I walk my boy through there a couple of hours later, he's still going berserk because he can smell her. Now imagine how that plays out when lots of in season bitches are all wandering around the place... our peaceful walk goes our the window.

Whilst I agree that animals not being bred should be neutered, my Labrador is a stud dog. I do breed from him. The solution is for responsible bitch owners to keep their girls home when they're in season. A couple of weeks being let out in the garden won't kill them. It's what I've always done when I've owned bitches.

user1481840227 · 22/01/2022 02:20

@XiCi

Every single dog should be spayed/neutered by age 2 unless owned by a licensed breeder unless there's a medical reason not to That's not correct and is outdated advice. It is not recommended any more that male dogs are neutered. Though I hadn't considered that maybe this was because the vetinary world had been infiltrated by the Taliban
Grin Grin Grin
CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 22/01/2022 02:19

So many unwanted dogs and cats, why risk bringing more into the world? Fortunately even in some of the poorest places, there are people doing their best to care for these poor animals:

twitter.com/SulalaSociety/status/1484522959012311041

teamdogs.co.uk/articles/rescue-centre-in-gaza-uses-children-s-toys-to-make-wheelchairs-for-disabled-dogs

BABAHOTEL · 20/01/2022 07:05

@MorningStarling

Good to know dog walkers are inconsiderate or rude to other dog walkers, not just innocent members of the public.
Innocent members of the public? Like people walking their dogs are?
BABAHOTEL · 20/01/2022 06:57

I had someone on a Facebook dog walking group telling me I shouldn't even walk mine at night in a pavement. She said a dog can sense an in season female for up to two miles, that they can then get out of even a secure area, they could get run over, lost etc. I pointed out that therefore she was saying I couldn't even let my dog into the garden, because surely the same thing would happen.

I choose out if the way, quiet places to exercise my in season bitch, she's had one season and will be having two more before she's spayed. It's a bit of a pain, but for her size and breed it's recommended three seasons.

TinyW · 20/01/2022 06:05

My dogs one and only season was a nightmare. She was really poorly and when I did take her out it was very late at night and it set all the local dogs off barking. I got her done almost immediately after.

nalabae · 20/01/2022 06:01

Strange some of the comments
My bitch is in season and no dogs chase her around, only one seemed interested in her but left with his owner. I walk her with my male dog maybe why

nalabae · 20/01/2022 05:59

What an idiot, I have my in season bitch in a park with my male dogs don’t just all jump on her because she’s in season nor is it illegal

People never seem I amaze me

Ghislainedefeligonde · 19/01/2022 16:14

This thread is full of bonkers remarks.
Yabu to take your in season dog to busy places
For those saying that males should be castrated, there is a lot of conflicting evidence about whether this is the right thing regards later health issues, and it certainly can’t be done till they are fully mature or can cause a lot of problems
I came across a woman with her in season dog running loose on the beach with lots of other dogs chasing it, she thought it was hilarious. We’ve had our dog castrated mainly to avoid problems with idiots like that who think it’s so funny to cause distress to lots of dogs. We did wait till he was fully mature though.
There seems to be pretty clear evidence that getting a bitch spayed has health benefits, there is much less evidence for male dogs and certainly some evidence about increased health problems in castrated dogs which is why I think people are less keen to get it done.
It’s certainly not comparable to the fucking taliban Hmm

Emilyontmoor · 19/01/2022 15:29

I have witnessed a normally very obedient neutered male goldie run two miles across a crowded London royal park to get to an in season bitch whilst my entire collie (not neutered on vet’s advice ) ran after him with us and just looked on bemused at the spectacle of him being driven mad by hormones. In fact none of the 6 collies I have owned (not at the same time) has ever shown interest in females in heat. Perhaps the farmers bred it out of them because they couldn’t have them shagging the sheep?

I also know the owner of a neutered male beagle who no longer walks him in the Royal Park because he was constantly sexually harassed by other male (neutered and unneutered) dogs.

All the owners of females I know who waited a season to get them spayed just took it as sensible to stay out of the crowded park.

Hormones are going to do what hormones are going to do and humans complaining they are inconvenient isn’t going to change that.

On breeding do we not now have laws to make sure people who breed for money can only do so if they are registered and monitored to prevent irresponsible people making money by having multiple litters from pets in their homes? There have been a few litters seized and people prosecuted especially during the lockdown madness (when the breeders I know actually stopped breeding and selling their dogs because the market was so chaotic).

crosstalk · 19/01/2022 14:51

I have a 14 y o unspayed terrier bitch who is in season. I walk her in town on lead and in country on lead when in season and am lucky to have open spaces with few dogs which I can see a mile off and dodge.. She doesn't like other dogs anyway after being badly attacked by a male Rottweiler (when not on heat) when she was a 3 y o.

Interestingly when walking in the local park on lead, I haven't seen any male dogs getting hugely frustrated and coming up to us.

Wolfiefan · 19/01/2022 14:39

@EerieSilence I have bitches! I keep them on lead and away from off lead dogs when In season. (Not spayed for health reasons. Not breeding.)
I may get a male in future. I’m not keeping it on lead for years until it can be castrated until people can’t be responsible.

PixieLaLa · 19/01/2022 14:36

My dog weighs under 5kg; if I’ve had an issue with a dog following before I would simply pick her up.

You sound clueless, please do not breed any dogs! 🙈

Whistleforthechoir · 19/01/2022 14:21

@MorningStarling

Good to know dog walkers are inconsiderate or rude to other dog walkers, not just innocent members of the public.
GrinGrinGrin
tabulahrasa · 19/01/2022 14:15

Castrating dogs doesn’t always stop the interest in in season bitches... in fact the odd bitch will also harass in season birches as well.

iBrows · 19/01/2022 14:13

Not getting involved with the ethics of breeding as it isn’t what you were asking.

It’s not illegal and all dogs should be under control, if other dog owners cannot keep control of their male dogs that is their own fault. They don’t have more rights than you or get to dictate when or where you walk.

Blossomtoes · 19/01/2022 14:10

@CoastalWave

Your poor dog. You kept her going through in season just in case you one day feel like making some money off the back of her?

That's basically it. Dress it up how you like.

I would say you're incredibly unkind and irresponsible - the woman was right.

We’ve done the same thing and won’t be making a penny from her one and only litter. In fact, by giving her puppies away, we’ll be significantly out of pocket. Are we wicked and irresponsible?
EerieSilence · 19/01/2022 14:05

@girlmom21 - I certainly don't have an envelope sized garden and my Dobermann gets lots of exercise. I certainly wouldn't let her run on her own in the garden as she digs for cat shit.
@Wolfiefan - if you can't control your male dog and don't castrate him, keep him on the leash. Simple as that. I keep my bitch in season on the leash, keep your hormonal dog on the leash.

CoastalWave · 19/01/2022 13:57

Your poor dog. You kept her going through in season just in case you one day feel like making some money off the back of her?

That's basically it. Dress it up how you like.

I would say you're incredibly unkind and irresponsible - the woman was right.

Thatldo · 19/01/2022 13:56

@AlternativePerspective

This smacks of the Taliban, keep the females in so the males are not bothered say what now?

I am assuming the poster said this for effect. Nobody actually, genuinely thinks there are similarities between a dog in season and the Taliban?

There are similarities indeed!!most people with a female dog will spay their girl by the age of 2 years old,so the pestering from male dogs stop.Owners of male dogs come up with ridiculous comments why they dont castrate their dog(he will loose his manhood🤣).both my girls are spayed and if they get pestered by an uncastrated dog,that dog gets its balls kicked.
SirSniffsAlot · 19/01/2022 13:52

I was sharing anecdotes, not suggesting you - or anyone here - do leave their in season ladies unsupervised Smile

fwiw, I'm in the camp of 'everyone should be taking responsibility for the safety, health and well being of their own dog'. What that really means in practice will vary depending on the dog you've got and the oportunities you have to achieve it.

Ultimately, as someone who always prefers a dog walk in the middle of nowhere with not a soul in sight and miles from civilisation... it's ultimately not a great issue for me. It wasn't even when being stalked by a randy little terrier while my chap cried all the way home "But Mum, WHY can't I shag her?!?!" (I later popped out, caught the madam and returned home to her parents, shamed-faced Grin).

girlmom21 · 19/01/2022 13:48

@EerieSilence maybe you should have considered things properly before getting a Doberman bitch if you only have a small garden...

Wolfiefan · 19/01/2022 13:46

@EerieSilence bitches are in season for days. Males shouldn’t be neutered until they are mature. Why should they be kept on leads at all times for years because owners of bitches aren’t careful for that short period?

Swipe left for the next trending thread