Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should block porn as they do in France...

193 replies

jobhunter7 · 18/01/2022 10:17

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10349501/Major-porn-sites-BLOCKED-France-unless-ensure-users-18.html

OP posts:
toastofthetown · 19/01/2022 11:18

@Muminabun

28% of people on a parenting site think that it is ok for children and anyone else to have unfettered access to watching women, children, animals and men and boys be raped and abused for entertainment and sexual gratification and for it to stay on the web for ever nice 👍 I feel comforted for the future……
That’s a straw man and a half! The thread is a about whether France’s age verification is a good thing. I can’t imagine anyone who voted No wants teenagers viewing violent pornography. What they are saying is this law is pointless, trivial for a teen to work around and gives parents a false sense of security for their teen’s online safety.
Silverswirl · 19/01/2022 11:16

Yes some teens will get around this. But it’s something. Something is better than nothing which is what it currently is.
Currently, my 10 year old walking to school with a friend - If the friend felt like it and has safari on their phone and 4g, They type in porn hub and literally click a box saying I am 18 to view the most horrific porn, which now my child has looked at via the friends phone.
Peer pressure to conform is everything to young people. What’s going to be more prevalent in their minds- me last week saying ‘it’s a really bad idea to look at this’ or his ‘mate’ telling him to look at this funny video - and taunting him if he won’t?
My 10 year old and his mates don’t know how to access VPN’s. They have basic phones and a PlayStation. But currently they can still freely visit these big porn sites.

GlacindaTheTroll · 19/01/2022 11:01

No-one needs to 'engineer a way round it' as there are readily available ways to do that already

It won't stop 'a lot of people' as it applies to only 5 sites, and is introduction of age verification not complete barring. And even if it were, it would be very easy to get round that

astorsback · 19/01/2022 11:01

@AwaitingSueGraysInvestigation

Its because men need an ever increasing level of stimulus to get the same dopamine hit and are therefore served up more and more outrageous, unusual and violent content. It's a bit like men not being able to get turned on by seeing a real woman's legs - they're now wired to see much more graphic images for pleasure so the legs just dont register.

Muminabun · 19/01/2022 10:58

28% of people on a parenting site think that it is ok for children and anyone else to have unfettered access to watching women, children, animals and men and boys be raped and abused for entertainment and sexual gratification and for it to stay on the web for ever nice 👍 I feel comforted for the future……

astorsback · 19/01/2022 10:55

Excellent news but I'm sure some will engineer a way around it.

Depressing fact: Ex used to work for a major web hosting business in the North West. He said 95% of sites hosted were porn related, the remaining 5% were normal/mainstream businesses. The owner was so rich, he bought an island. Sickening.

LessTime · 19/01/2022 10:51

I would support this. I think it's easy to get around but I suspect it would stop a lot of people accessing porn.

Even if it just stops the casual users that can't be a bad thing.

cherryonthecakes · 18/01/2022 14:39

@Thirtytimesround
Had a quick read online and it sounds like people in the ME use VPNs to get around the blocks. Google "Middle East VPN" and there's loads of sites offering recommendations.

The figures will probably be even higher than in 2018

To think we should block porn as they do in France...
cherryonthecakes · 18/01/2022 14:30

@Thirtytimesround

Lots of people say “but it’s hard to do technically.” I don’t understand that. I used to work in middle east and if you tried to access any remotely dodgy website, it got blocked and a message popped up saying “you may not access this website because it is inconsistent with our country’s values.” (I was trying to order a nose ring, apparently they didn’t like body piercing 🤷‍♀️). If they could achieve that technology 10 yrs ago I don’t see what’s so hard about it.

Also… I think it would be a very interesting social experiment to ban violent / degrading porn, but allow porn that presents the woman is happy and free and generally having a great time. In my area the teenage boys who commute 40 mins to school spend the entire bus journey watching violent porn. It must be incredibly harmful in terms of shaping what arouses them in later life.

A major problem is that over 18s can legally watch porn if they want and devices don't know how old the user is. An under 18 interested in porn will already know that it's easy to fake a birthdate to access what they want and what a VPN is.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 18/01/2022 13:42

@Thirtytimesround

Lots of people say “but it’s hard to do technically.” I don’t understand that. I used to work in middle east and if you tried to access any remotely dodgy website, it got blocked and a message popped up saying “you may not access this website because it is inconsistent with our country’s values.” (I was trying to order a nose ring, apparently they didn’t like body piercing 🤷‍♀️). If they could achieve that technology 10 yrs ago I don’t see what’s so hard about it.

Also… I think it would be a very interesting social experiment to ban violent / degrading porn, but allow porn that presents the woman is happy and free and generally having a great time. In my area the teenage boys who commute 40 mins to school spend the entire bus journey watching violent porn. It must be incredibly harmful in terms of shaping what arouses them in later life.

If they could achieve that technology 10 yrs ago I don’t see what’s so hard about it.

Mainly the issue is that we don't live in a totalitarian state with a government department devoted to safeguarding our values.

Technically it's possible in countries like China and so on where the internet is censored and access is tracked.

Here where people are generally free to search for stuff like nose rings, it is very hard to implement because in a non-totalitarian state it can be easily circumvented.

Bowwowwowoh · 18/01/2022 13:35

Yes. Porn addiction destroys marriages.

nothingcanhurtmewithmyeyesshut · 18/01/2022 13:32

I really think it's down to parents to protect children, not the websites. Porn doesn't just pop up. You have to go looking for it. If you don't have parental controls or don't watch what your child is doing online, that's your fault. It's just lazy parenting. What's going to be next, you want the government to feed them for you too?

rifling · 18/01/2022 13:30

In my area the teenage boys who commute 40 mins to school spend the entire bus journey watching violent porn. It must be incredibly harmful in terms of shaping what arouses them in later life.
Eurgh. Grim.

GlacindaTheTroll · 18/01/2022 13:29

Exactly. This is a measure to try and control, not eliminate. What's the problem?

That there is no proposal for any effective control.

The French initiative is as much use as a chocolate fireguard

The best controls are:
a) education
b) supervision
c) use of device based filters - not a full solution, but will do way, way more than this French proposal which is limited to 5 sites and even easier to get round

D0lphine · 18/01/2022 13:27

@InCahootswithOrwell

Does it actually work? Or could your average teen get round the block in a couple of minutes?
It won't work. You can set up a free VPN to get around the block in minutes.
Thirtytimesround · 18/01/2022 13:26

Lots of people say “but it’s hard to do technically.” I don’t understand that. I used to work in middle east and if you tried to access any remotely dodgy website, it got blocked and a message popped up saying “you may not access this website because it is inconsistent with our country’s values.” (I was trying to order a nose ring, apparently they didn’t like body piercing 🤷‍♀️). If they could achieve that technology 10 yrs ago I don’t see what’s so hard about it.

Also… I think it would be a very interesting social experiment to ban violent / degrading porn, but allow porn that presents the woman is happy and free and generally having a great time. In my area the teenage boys who commute 40 mins to school spend the entire bus journey watching violent porn. It must be incredibly harmful in terms of shaping what arouses them in later life.

Isaw3ships · 18/01/2022 13:25

‘ Lots of things are harmful for some people but harmless for others, such as alcohol, smoking, drugs, etc. That's why we have rules/laws and enforcement, to CONTROL rather than eliminate.’

Yes, and this is a suggestion to do exactly that, in the same way we don’t allow children to buy cigarettes. There’ll always be those who get round it and do but restrictions definitely help stop casual users.

rifling · 18/01/2022 13:11

Lots of things are harmful for some people but harmless for others, such as alcohol, smoking, drugs, etc. That's why we have rules/laws and enforcement, to CONTROL rather than eliminate.

Exactly. This is a measure to try and control, not eliminate. What's the problem?

toastofthetown · 18/01/2022 13:09

@Deadringer

Could it be set up so that you need a credit card to access sites, even when they are free? I think you need to be 18 in most countries to have a credit card. I am not techy, so don't know if this is practical.
As long as that isn’t the law globally, there will always be countries where porn is freely accessible. And given that a VPN takes less than a minute to set up, it’s like trying to put out a forest fire with a water pistol.
user1497207191 · 18/01/2022 13:04

@Deadringer

Could it be set up so that you need a credit card to access sites, even when they are free? I think you need to be 18 in most countries to have a credit card. I am not techy, so don't know if this is practical.
Children can "borrow" their parent's credit cards, more so if there's no charge, so the parent would never know their card had been used.
user1497207191 · 18/01/2022 13:03

@rifling

*I have no real side to this argument, if people get off on it crack on I say, not for me personally but lot of my female friends enjoy it as part of their healthy sex life.

There is plenty of evidence unfortunately that porn is harmful. Why do you think there has been such an upsurge in prosecutions for murder where the defendant claims it happened during sex? Is it just coincidence that more and more porn presents choking as part of normal sex?

Lots of things are harmful for some people but harmless for others, such as alcohol, smoking, drugs, etc. That's why we have rules/laws and enforcement, to CONTROL rather than eliminate.
Deadringer · 18/01/2022 13:00

Could it be set up so that you need a credit card to access sites, even when they are free? I think you need to be 18 in most countries to have a credit card. I am not techy, so don't know if this is practical.

HereticFanjo · 18/01/2022 13:00

@HereticFanjo

Based on a career working with young men and women through to their adulthood. Based on significant online interactions in gaming and other communities. Based on therapeutic work. The language many young men use to talk about their relationships and desires when safely anonymous would horrify most people. I used to think like you too. I don't anymore. I think we are creating a generation of young men whose first sexual interactions with women are not in their own imaginations but on screen. In a significant percentage of these, women are degraded or at best treated like receptacles. They are dehumanised. There has been significant research and therapists have been ringing alarm bells for the last decade or more at the number of young men coming to them in distress because they are unable to have a sexual relationship with any physical woman in front of them because they don't look like the pornstars they are used to viewing.

And what is the impact on women? You're only attractive if your body is hairless, fake tanned and your lips are stuffed with fillers. You're vanilla unless you're willing to do anal, be choked, be slapped. Young women are growing up being told this is what a normal sex life looks like. This is their baseline. And then we wonder at the massive rise in the number of young women wanting to identify as men. To no longer face the pressure of being walking sex dolls or prey animals.

Your female friends may, like me, be old enough to have grown up in a time when porn existed in magazines up on high shelves. It is a very different world for our 12 to 20s now. I know because I've worked with them for twenty plus years. Believe it's all harmless fun if you choose. I did once upon a time. I don't anymore. I don't know how we put the genie back in the bottle though.

This post was a response to @fromdownwest for some reason it didn't quote.
AwaitingSueGraysInvestigation · 18/01/2022 12:56

I guess what I'm saying is; does the porn beget the culture, or does the culture beget the porn?

Mouseonmychair · 18/01/2022 12:55

Stupid idea have people never heard of vpns? Also pushes towards the home made porn which isn't available on the big sites of which there is no regulation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread