Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should block porn as they do in France...

193 replies

jobhunter7 · 18/01/2022 10:17

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10349501/Major-porn-sites-BLOCKED-France-unless-ensure-users-18.html

OP posts:
fizzypop100 · 20/01/2022 09:55

For kids, a good parent control app will block private VPN access !

cherryonthecakes · 20/01/2022 09:48

@WinterDeWinter

Oh man, so many excuses. There will never be a perfect way - you have to be really invested in porn one way or another to keep pushing this 'it's not a full solution' line.
Blocking the 5 sites will just divert traffic to other places. Mastercard and Visa stopping use of their cards on Pornhub in 2020 because of child abuse content was probably the best tactic so far to trying to tackle the issue. It didn't solve the issue but I believe it triggered policy changes at Pornhub.
nalabae · 20/01/2022 06:12

Agree

AutomaticMoon · 20/01/2022 02:14

VPN would void this measure, unfortunately. There’s a problem with the violence in the thumbnails and titles, when I checked a mainstream one last year, the titles were extremely vile and hateful.

Dissimilitude · 19/01/2022 23:45

Completely unenforceable.

Free VPNs are a Google search away, and once activated your internet traffic is essentially completely hidden from your ISP.

GlacindaTheTroll · 19/01/2022 23:40

@WinterDeWinter

Oh man, so many excuses. There will never be a perfect way - you have to be really invested in porn one way or another to keep pushing this 'it's not a full solution' line.
It's not that it's not a 'full solution'

It's that it is no solution at all, and you will get better protection for your DC by using device-based blockers.

Mischance · 19/01/2022 22:38

No-one is suggesting that it is easy to keep porn away from young people and children - that does not mean that we should not try.

The principle of the damaging effect on children and the need to keep them safe should inspire us all to be contacting our MPs and wanting to know what they are doing about it. We need to keep the topic alive and not let the legislators sweep it under the carpet because it is difficult to do.

WinterDeWinter · 19/01/2022 21:31

Oh man, so many excuses.
There will never be a perfect way - you have to be really invested in porn one way or another to keep pushing this 'it's not a full solution' line.

D0lphine · 19/01/2022 21:00

If you make it difficult to access mainstream porn (on porn hub for example) it may mean teens download Tor and look for porn on the dark web instead. Obviously all sorts of illegal dangerous shit on there.

Lockheart · 19/01/2022 20:43

@WinterDeWinter PornHub removed something like 80% of their content because of possible child abuse. Eighty per cent.

That isn't quite true. PH removed all content from unverified users (about 80%) following criticism from processors like MasterCard that their checks weren't stringent enough and that lack of checks was allowing dodgy content through.

It isn't the case that 80% of their content was possible child abuse.

Beautiful3 · 19/01/2022 20:24

Yes, agreed. Could you start an online petition? I'd sign it.

MorganKitten · 19/01/2022 20:05

Kids will find away around this and will probably end up finding worse.

fizzypop100 · 19/01/2022 19:50

As for adults, they should have to prove identity That would stop a lot of addictions

Norgie · 19/01/2022 19:45

Unfortunately there's no real way to ban is because as others have already said, kids can get round it by using a VPN or by using their phones and a ' warm ' connection. Kids are more techno savvy than we give them credit for.
The other problem is with the age verification, shy of someone having to verify their age with photographic proof, such as a passport or driving licence, then it's just a fake birth year, which is no proof at all, and again kids are savvy.
The problem with porn itself today is twofold. One is the content, which varies from mild straight vanilla sex to degrading violent stuff, with 'teens', paedophillia, forced sex, anal and god knows what, and it's everywhere! Even mainstream TV doesn't escape it.
The second problem is the accessibility to this stuff. Yes, once upon not so long ago it would have been a mucky mag from the top shelf or a blue movie from the bloke in the pub, which in comparison to today's stuff was pretty tame.
Now we have the other problem of young girls being coerced into sexual acts because, due to porn they think what they're seeing is normal as they have nothing to compare it to, as it's all they've seen.
Not too many years ago, anal sex was literally unheard of among a straight couple, mainly because it was illegal and because no one owned up to doing it, even if they were. Now it's in literally every porn clip and so has become 'normal'.
The same applies to boys, but with the addition of them pressuring the girls into certain acts, because again, they have nothing to compare it to. Therefore he will pressure a girl into doing anal because it's 'normal' and everyone does it, in his mind.
It's damaging and dangerous, very much so to a young impressionable mind.
That said, I have no idea what the answer is to stem the tide and turn things around, except keep talking to your kids.

Brogues · 19/01/2022 19:07

I’ve said no because I just don’t think it’s workable and it’s not a ban on porn, it’s a ban on porn for those under 18 only. Just as in the olden days with magazines and videos it’ll just be forwarded on my older brothers etc.

LosingMySh1t · 19/01/2022 19:01

I watch porn. I would be happy with this ban. Bring it on.

When my kids are old enough to be on the Internet I will put a blocker on, so we all can't watch it.

Loveismyfoodanddrink · 19/01/2022 18:58

100% yes, we should.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 19/01/2022 18:49

Where does most of the porn originate?

WinterDeWinter · 19/01/2022 18:45

I agree that there is - of course - a parental obligation. Why isn't it statutory? We have laws about car seats at one end of the spectrum, and no-one thinks that's a step too far (now). At the other end of the spectrum, I bet every single one of us would agree that social services should get involved if a parent exposed their child to other people having sex (which is against the law). Why not a statutory obligation to take reasonable measures - blockers at device-level and household level?

There's also no reason why phone companies shouldn't shoulder the responsibility for establishing new phones (without device-level blockers) are going to adults only, like supermarkets selling alcohol or cigarettes. Of course there will be shit parents who lie, but many many more will not.

What's required is a system of measures that change the culture and make it harder (though not impossible - of course) for children to slip through the net. But this is a good first step.

The trouble is that third-wave feminists have been persuaded by men that porn is empowering/a right, and those men themselves don't give a fuck about women or children, as evidenced by the fact that they consistently push away the evidence of widespread trafficking, lack of meaningful consent, and child abuse. PornHub removed something like 80% of their content because of possible child abuse. Eighty per cent. Men know this, but they don't give a fuck. There are endless excuses, but the bottom line is that if men gave a fuck whether their porn was consensual or not, whether a girl was under-age or not, the front page of PornHub wouldn't look how it looks. They don't care.

So there's no outcry for governments to respond to, and in any case the governments themselves are broadly constituted of men/intersectional feminists. It amazes me that we can look each other in the eye to be honest - it's astonishing what we've allowed to be done to our children.

GlacindaTheTroll · 19/01/2022 15:21

[quote MilduraS]They tried it already then suddenly dropped the plan at the last second. I guess they got too busy with Covid after that.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/culture/2019/oct/16/uk-drops-plans-for-online-pornography-age-verification-system[/quote]
I think they dropped it because they realised it was bollocks.

If parents won't use blockers, supervise their DC whenever possible, and above all educate their DC on the dangers of the Internet and the harm of porn, then those DC will be at risk and thus kind of measure will do nothing to mitigate it, and can make it worse because it offers an illusion

GlacindaTheTroll · 19/01/2022 15:19

Even if it stopped some children stumbling upon it (quite a large percentage of first exposures iirc) it would be worth it

If the parents installed a blocker on the device, it would prevent access to sites such as these. Thus measure is not required for that. The 5 sites in question are large and well known and will be covered by blockers, as will scores more.

Of course blockers have their limitations. Not all objectionable content (whether porn, violent/graphic, rexi or whatever) will be identified and blocked. That is why both education and supervision are also needed

MilduraS · 19/01/2022 13:45

They tried it already then suddenly dropped the plan at the last second. I guess they got too busy with Covid after that.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/culture/2019/oct/16/uk-drops-plans-for-online-pornography-age-verification-system

WinterDeWinter · 19/01/2022 13:14

Even if it stopped some children stumbling upon it (quite a large percentage of first exposures iirc) it would be worth it.

It's not only about children's exposure to sex but about what they learn about men and women's roles and relative value through porn - about the fact that, from their perspective, these roles and functions are endorsed by 'the grown-ups' because we don't appear to care whether they access it or not.

Libertarians who care more about their freedom to wank (or even just the 'principle of freedom') than actual children's freedom to be children, to be safe from content which cannot be unseen, are pretty repulsive in my view.

As for the argument that this is an imperfect policy - that's bollocks. Until there is a better way, this is the only way. If you're prepared to stand by and watch a generation be damaged while you wait for a better way to present itself, you're either being dishonest about your true motivations or what we might call 'rigid in your thinking'.

user1497207191 · 19/01/2022 11:44

@Silverswirl

My 10 year old and his mates don’t know how to access VPN’s

They soon will when they need to access things they want to see. A very quick google explains it in a few seconds. When one works it out (or their elder sibling tells them how), it'll spread over your son's friend group like wildfire.

My son was about that age when all his friends started watching illegal streams of live premier league football matches. Within a few days, they were all doing it, my son included. All via a VPN which was free and very easy to set up.

user1497207191 · 19/01/2022 11:40

@Muminabun

28% of people on a parenting site think that it is ok for children and anyone else to have unfettered access to watching women, children, animals and men and boys be raped and abused for entertainment and sexual gratification and for it to stay on the web for ever nice 👍 I feel comforted for the future……
No, that's not the case at all.

28% think that a half hearted "block" without enforcement that is easily and quickly avoided by a VPN is pointless.

What is needed is a proper, Worldwide clamp down, that may actually work, not a toothless measure that makes politicians look as if they're doing something when in reality they're doing beggar all!

Swipe left for the next trending thread